HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

abannin

155 karma · joined September 12, 2014

submissionscomments
abannin··on San Francisco Progressives Declare War on Affordable Housing
"Below Market Rate" is in reference to a specific program in the City of San Francisco that subsidizes housing for qualifying residents based on income. New developments have to provide 30% of units for the program, but have a buy out option.

http://sfmohcd.org/current-listings-below-market-rate-owners...

abannin··on Disrupting Uber
Downvoted with no comment! Oh, the irony.
abannin··on Disrupting Uber
Correct, but the article is advocating that full time drivers capture rents from the market. This is justified by implying (without evidence) that Uber is engaged in rent seeking against the drivers.
abannin··on Disrupting Uber
1) There is an assumption that Uber is not only profitable, but wildly profitable. There is no data to support this claim outside of Uber's press releases (obviously biased) stating "oh, yeah we just raised another billion but I promise we're profitable in a few markets". To argue that Uber is withholding profit from drivers, one would first have to prove that Uber is making profit, not just a positive contribution margin.

2) The high liquidity of drivers would imply a functioning market (not to say that it's perfect). The most obvious solution for drivers who are unhappy with the pay would be to get a different driving job, right?

3) The core issue is that the barrier of entry to driving for Uber is very low, increasing labor competition. This also keeps the price of a ride low. The wage of the driver is the agreement between the rider and the driver for the service, Uber is acting as a mediator. There is nothing in this article that comes close to proving that Uber is not fulfilling it's role as a mediator.

4) It will be interesting to see if the app works, but the strategy seems flawed. The constrained variable are the riders; there are already plenty of options. Paying drivers more doesn't seem to be a very compelling reason for riders to choose a different service.

abannin··on Disrupting Uber
It's much easier to down vote something you don't want to be true than to engage in intelligent discussion.

And to answer your question: everyone wants the benefits of economic efficiency but none of the costs. It's much easier to say "low skilled labor should be paid more" rather than "let's increase the value of labor". Also, an easy counter argument is that Uber is engaging in rent seeking against it's drivers. I don't think this has very much merit given the liquidity of driving labor.

abannin··on Ask HN: Avoid Tax hit from vesting of shares?
This is a wonderful question for a lawyer.
abannin··on GM paid less for Cruise Automation than was reported
Surely $500M of retention incentives would be considered 'material' and require disclosure
abannin··on Dollar Shave Club and the Disruption of Everything
Great questions!

Let's see if I can rephrase this: A company that is unable to generate a profit long-term has proven incapable of creating value for all stakeholders. So a company may be able to sell a product with a margin, but if that margin is not enough to compensate labor, landlords, supply chain, shareholders, etc; the the net value creation is negative. So a company that is not generating a profit is not creating value, but one cannot measure the amount of value created by just measuring profit.

Open Source: I think that the incentives and economics of open source get pretty complex. There are multiple reasons for a company to open source their code, but I think it's pretty safe to say that companies are not in the habit of open sourcing valuable trade secrets. Two ways a company can realize more value by open sourcing are 1) utilize "unpaid" labor (contributors are not paid by the company, but presumably are compensated through some other means) and 2) recruitment and PR boost (by open sourcing projects, the company has improved reputation giving it leverage in hiring and other practices). So, to answer your question, open sourcing code restructures the value calculation. Presumably, an open source project that provides no value is an orphaned project.

Comcast is a beneficiary of monopoly provisions. In order to incentivize the creation of infrastructure, telecoms were granted monopolies. For example, I can only purchase Comcast cable, not TimeWarner or any other provider. I suspect that your point is correct as regulating ISPs like utilities could decrease rent-seeking actions by the ISP. In this scenario, lower margins would generate more value (shareholders realize lower value but consumers realize greater value in the form of decreased prices). Rent seeking, like coercion, is a sign of a market failure.

Thanks for the response!

abannin··on Dollar Shave Club and the Disruption of Everything
Great points, thanks for bringing clarity to a rushed comment.

You're very right that increased competition could lead to losses. However, this is a short term destabilization with a maximum duration of capital reserves. It is the net profit of the firm that determines it's long term viability.

abannin··on Dollar Shave Club and the Disruption of Everything
Thanks for the response, vkou.

Since the article was discussing a specific industry and company, and the OP responded by the incentives of companies, I figured it was safe to assume that the discussion did not involve coercion or charitable actions as they are very different actions with different reward structures. Within a marketplace for commodities, an actor is rewarded with profits for providing goods or services.

Mugging would be coercion, and doesn't seem to fit within the context. Charitable actions can obviously create and transfer value, but it also seems outside the scope of a discussion of commoditization of goods.

abannin··on Dollar Shave Club and the Disruption of Everything
"A company that makes products for $5 and sells them for $5 may have a negligible stock price while creating an enormous amount of value" No profit means no value creation, the company is doing nothing. Profit isn't inefficiency, it is the incentive to remove inefficiency.
abannin··on Santa Monica convicts its first Airbnb host under tough home-sharing laws
SF has a day limit (within certain conditions) but has no way to enforce it. Hence the recent actions to hold the platform accountable & AirBnB suing the city.
abannin··on My best employee quit because I wouldn’t let her go to college graduation
The best managers learn what is important to their employees and figure out how to deliver it. Those employees will pay you back many times over. Invest in others, and they will invest in you.
abannin··on Universal Basic Income – Poll Results from IGM Economic Experts Panel
It looks like I don't fully understand the system. I suspect there is a need based system that supplements Social Security benefits if the recipient is below the poverty line?
abannin··on Universal Basic Income – Poll Results from IGM Economic Experts Panel
The data is misleading; many of comments reject the context of the question not UBI itself. Take Thaler's response: "This is a dumb question. We are not going to eliminate Social Security and Medicare etc." The survey is not an expert review of UBI, but rather a specific implementation of UBI.
abannin··on Universal Basic Income – Poll Results from IGM Economic Experts Panel
Isn't Social Security just age restricted basic income? It seems strange to have UBI and then give citizens another check after they hit retirement age.
abannin··on Airbnb Is Suing San Francisco to Block Rental Rules
Yes, but there is a tactical decision at play here. AirBnB seems to believe that it has a better chance of winning on privacy and user-generated content issues then state/local laws.
abannin··on Airbnb Is Suing San Francisco to Block Rental Rules
In SF, 32 days or more is effectively long term.
abannin··on Airbnb Is Suing San Francisco to Block Rental Rules
Ah, yes! Decreased property values are an externality! However, judging based on police dispatch or crime rates seems to rely a bit more on correlation than causation. It's pretty easy to argue that hotels are typically built in areas with increased police dispatch rates, not hotels causing the dispatches. Unless you have data that shows that the hotel itself has a higher rate than surrounding areas? Furthermore, there are plenty of examples of short term rentals (typically in the form of hotels or resorts) that are tied to increased property values.

Once again, your arguments support better inspections and code enforcement for health issues not banning short term rentals.

I'm not sure why you assume my history with bedbugs. You are correct that I have never had to deal with a bedbug infestation, but I've helped friends who have. I have lived through multiple other infestation of other insects and rodents because of my neighbors. I've also had neighbors who felt the need to party all night every weekend, and have lived across the street from meth houses and drug dens multiple times. However, all of these experiences were dealing with long term tenants, not short term rentals. I am not discounting the inconvenience of these situations, just questioning why we conclude that they are unique to short term rentals.

It seems that you're confusing the impacts of property values with short term rentals. Long term rentals can occur in very wealthy neighborhoods as well as economically depressed areas. I'm no fan of slum lords, but a slum lord can have long term or short term tenants! Furthermore, they tend to set up shop in economically depressed areas if for no other reason than the overhead is too great in nicer neighborhoods.

Regarding criminal activity, I fail to see how 1) this is isolated to or increased activity from short term vs long term rentals and 2) it assumes that the landlord/host does not care about the activity. While same may not care, it seems quite presumptuous to conclude that all AirBnB hosts will encourage criminal activity. But this presents a really interesting question: why hasn't the city of San Francisco taken steps to train hosts on potential threats if this is a concern?

abannin··on Airbnb Is Suing San Francisco to Block Rental Rules
Wonderful point. Student housing is a great example of long term rentals with tenants that don't always respect the property or neighbors.
abannin··on Airbnb Is Suing San Francisco to Block Rental Rules
Kinda surprised that no one is debating jurisdiction here. Why federal and not state courts? Are federal judges more friendly to this type of case?
abannin··on Airbnb Is Suing San Francisco to Block Rental Rules
See my post above
abannin··on Airbnb Is Suing San Francisco to Block Rental Rules
The analogy would imply that hosts should verify that guests have a license to rent. Last I checked, there is no license to rent.

A much better analogy would be a franchisor has a responsibility to ensure a franchisee has appropriate business licensure. However, I do not know where the liability lies in this scenario.

abannin··on Airbnb Is Suing San Francisco to Block Rental Rules
I'm surprised that this argument gets so much traction without any supporting data. It just plays on fear.

First, nothing you listed is an externality but rather direct results of poor behavior. An externality would be something like 'decreases property values of neighboring properties' or 'increased rents due to lower supply'.

Second, what data do you have that proves these scenarios are more likely in an AirBnB than a long term tenant? You're only supporting evidence is inference; if people are going to behave poorly then it makes sense for them to rent an AirBnB away from home. But there's an easy counter argument: pressure from neighbors will keep these incidents to a minimum. Sure, there will always be hosts are not sensitive to neighborhood pressure, but that same logic can be applied to long term tenants who have bedbugs, throw parties with loud music, litter, engage in criminal activity, etc. Simply put, all of negative scenarios you outline can occur with long term or short term tenants, and there is no evidence that these behaviors are more common from short term tenants.

Third, comparing all AirBnB's to skeezy motels is like saying all restaurants are roach-infested mold-filled 50-point scoring health hazards. This is a classic straw man argument. What about Marriot or Hilton? Embassy Suites or DoubleTree? Do they fulfill the reputation of "skeezy/short term motels"? This is an argument for better inspections and code enforcement, not prohibiting AirBnB.

No one expects neighbors to file daily lawsuits, but neighbors can notify the police if there is a noise violation, etc. Once again, there is no difference here between long term and short term rentals. AirBnB requires more identification than any hotel I've stayed at, so this argument actually supports AirBnB as a platform.

Lastly, your bank analogy is frightfully off base. First, a bank's intrinsic motivation for monitoring large transactions is fraud and not criminal activity. Second, banks are compelled by law to monitor and report specific types of activities that are likely to be criminal activity, but this is defined by organizations like the FBI, not the banks themselves. Third, you still have yet to prove, beyond casual inference, that AirBnB promotes criminal activity any more than long term tenancy.

abannin··on Ask HN: How do you build an activity/news feed with Firebase for iOS?
The tutorials from Firebase are helpful, and Ray Wenderlich has some good content.
abannin··on Ask HN: Where VC money comes from?
It's not a question of where does the money come from, but rather how much. VC as an asset class is pretty small compared to stocks, bonds, etc and vehicles like mutual funds.
abannin··on GiveDirectly Planning to Give $30M in Basic Income to East Africa
If people choose to donate, isn't that just the market working?
abannin··on The FBI faked an entire field of forensic science (2015)
Thanks for posting this. I'm shocked at the lack of response to this issue.
abannin··on Fantasy Math Is Helping Companies Spin Losses into Profits
Does there need to be one? Yes, there is IFRS.
abannin··on Fantasy Math Is Helping Companies Spin Losses into Profits
Another interpretation of the same data is that GAAP is so bad at representing a company's operations that both investors and firms choose to not make decisions off the statements. I don't know of any company who, internally, lives and dies by GAAP reporting. Sophisticated investors know this.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →