255 karma · joined June 25, 2008
In other contexts maybe you’re more accepting of public exposure. For example tokenization can be an effective GDPR mitigation, but i don’t think folks are particularly worried about reuse attacks when the information contains a name or email (I’m sure there are instances where they are concerned as well)
But at least when talking about tokenizing actionable information (credit card, bank account, whatever) implementors should be careful to keep them out of their public apis.
Instead the best practice would be to tokenize the data, accept it through one channel (an AttachCard api or whatever) and then return to your api consumer another opaque token to use for actions like authorization or clearing. From here there you can ensure that tokens are never reused etc.
This way if tokens leak they should be “inert” and no actions should be able to be taken with them.
I learned the hard way that I was safer taking the lane and having some angry drivers (I guess OP would be happy to treat me like a car?) than to put myself in poorly designed bike lanes.
This response puts both property and a narrow understanding of the law in front of lives.
First let’s just acknowledge that the article is describing a small change in driver habit to save lives. Not the lives of drivers, but the bicyclists.
Second, while bicyclist are often treated like other vehicles by default there are many exceptions made for bicycles, this is a reasonable one.
Finally this comment seems to demonstrate a deeply fundamental misunderstanding of the design flaw of putting a bunch of parked cars directly next to a bike lane with no safety gap.
There is almost no safe speed to bike next to a car where you can practically avoid a door that could open any second. This is why lanes are given a wide berth of parked cars. This same affordance has not been given to most bike lanes as cities have attempt to squeeze bike lanes into existing roads. It leaves bicyclists a sophie’s choice: ride in the road with the cars, or in the bike lane with the doors.
In the inner most ring, the most readily available, happening almost instantly, we have tools like syntax checking, maybe even LSP calls, linting. Time since writing the code is on the order of ms to a second.
In the outermost ring, the least available we have CICD, these checks happen rarely, often on a push to a central server. Time since writing the code is on the order of 10s of minutes to potentially hours.
I have a really hard time believing that folks are getting so little value out of types, have so few project wide issues, or are so willing to rewrite portions of their work to push type checks into the outer ring of CICD.
I find this idea of throwing away safety for compilation speed to be a non-option.
Given the low interchange rates in Europe I would have guessed that despite some flaws overall reduction in fraud was effective.
Sadly doesn’t look like the spin off company producing the displays went anywhere :(
HCQ - Discussion on HCQ are not being suppressed broadly. We are proving that right now. The drug continues to be studied, I bet we could find recent publications. What's being suppressed is the broadcasting of health missinformation on places like youtube.
If you go on YouTube and tell people that arsenic cures headaches and people subsequently dig out their rat poison and die. We would hold you accountable for that missinformation.
HCQ does not cure Covid-19 based on numerous studies. Videos and posts saying it does poses an urgent health risk to the population in at least two ways. First it's a powerful and potentially dangerous drug that people should not be administering themselves. People who seek out the drug on their own, through the grey market, or via other pathways certainly out themselves at risk. Second, it is actively disruptive to the attempts at corralling this pandemic. People who have followed this advice after infection might reasonably believe they are cured, going on to spread covid-19.
I can't figure out 1: what is the slippery slope that's being applied here? Doctors don't need youtube to figure out real cures. Scientist arent having their work suppressed. All we have is some dangerous medic advice ... Which is exactly the kind of thing youtube can and I say should consider removing. If these folks believe they have great ideas there are many journals to publish them in. Or they could attempt to convince the NIH.
Unrestricted Freedom - Your position seems to imply all freedoms are at play but I just want to make it clear that all rights imply restrictions of freedom on behalf of others to protect those rights. If I have a right to life, we restrict someone's freedom to shoot me, etc. So hopefully we can focus on unrestricted free speech.
Within free speech we have a number of restrictions at the state and federal level. Libel, slander, giving medical advice, etc. And I'll assume this is also not the argument.
Finally we have free speech on platforms like facebook, youtube, and Etsy. These are not protected in the constitution of the united states but I believe we're discussing the ethical choices these platforms make on their own behalf.
What do you currently see as tbe risk? What is the harm being done? Who is suffering from the removal of these messages?
Because I can tell you what I see on the other side, the risks to leaving them up. I outlined the harm with HCQ, that people will believe that HCQ cures covid-19, people with no medical training of their own. That this will potentially harm them and their country people. And that by pushing these conversations to happen in other domains does no harm to their merit as ideas
But I think the much bigger risk right now is that our social platforms are enabling fringe groups to form and grow like a cult. Where the folks inside start to lose perspective and the group think empowers ideas that are dangerous to our society. There is no good evidence of wide spread voter manipulation in this presidential election, HCQ does not cure covid-19. But there is a faction of the United States today getting advice from randoms on the internet, being fed lies from pod cast.
Our new social platforms seem to be enabling a wide spread cult in a way that we don't understand. Where inside the cult there's been a domain sheer from reality. I worry that like successful propaganda campaigns used on other nations this could end up radicalizing enough of our population to cause meaningful and irepareable harm to our society.
How do we respond to that?
I'm not a doctor, I'm not an export, but in my searches I can find no, reputable, peer reviewed studies that support HCQ.
I can't think of any reason there would be to suppress HCQ.
I think that if HCQ was a realistic cure we would have substantial reports of it's deployment in tbe rest of the world.
This seems to me to be largely a fantasy that is being used to attempt to put some pretty paint on the current administrations failures during this pandemic.
Is there something I'm missing? Why is this abuse of platform?
Voultair's works predate successful democracies, large scale propaganda campaigns, and the internet. I choose these three examples because I believe these are at the heart of the current crisis.
Now I can see from your comment that you have a specific viewpoint of our current political climate. I empathise with your experience, and the feeling that the world is moving in a way that seems counter to your own understanding.
But, I worry that you are finding yourself in the position that I'm most concerned for. You are acting in a small way as a network repeater for exactly the kind of missinformation I'm worried about spreading.
And while I think a widespread doctoral conspiracy is far less likely than the possibility that HCQ is a bad drug to combat Covid-19. I'm far more concerned about the harm that we're doing to our democracy by rejecting the outcomes of what, by nearly all accounts, appears to be a successful election. One that again, for it to be a false narrative would require a huge conspiracy including members of both parties across numerous states. And it's not even so much the faith in the election but the deep resentment afterwards that scares me. How do we repair the divide in the country when truth is being questioned as subjective. What is the shared ground we work from?
Libel and slander are easy limitations for us to agree on. It seems pretty clear to me that we should offer protections to individuals on truthfulness of others speech.
What about package labeling? Company's are required to post truthful listings of their ingredients and labels if their products are shown to do harm. Is this an appropriate limitation of speech?
I suspect we could also agree that there are missinformation and disinformations that if distributed at a wide scales can also be seen go cause harm to individuals. Holocaust denial for instance is a fairly obvious rhetorical tool used to discredit the Jewish experience, promote anti-semitism, and recruit people into organizations seeking to do harm to Jewish people.
Anti Vaccine propaganda also does harm to members of our society as it reduces the efficacy of our public health programs and promotes the spread of deadly disease.
So my last question is only to ask what is the appropriate line for us as a society to draw? It appears Etsy has landed on "harmful falsehoods". This seems relatively sane to me, and I would expect most of the argument to lie in the word harmful rather than falsehood. I worry however that you're implying we might also be arguing about falsehoods.
This policy does not seem to make any statements about political slogans unless you're including within that categorization; harmful miss-information such as anti-vaccine claims and holocaust denial.
There was a lawsuit filed by the Trump with regards to the distance requirements for safe viewing of vote counting. The judge overturned a lower court decision on what safe distances would be, and enabled observers to observe from 6 feet instead of 10.
The first source listed corroborates this story (although I haven't found any primary sources or what the exact contents of the complaint were, abcnews seems to be the source that most outlets are referencing https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/pennsylvania-judge-permits-c...).
There doesn't seem to be any truth to observers being removed from any tabulation rooms (or at least I can't find any trustworthy sources). The second source, while claiming this in the headline, is also just referencing the complaint discussed earlier and has twisted that into the headline.
When we hear a claim and the reaction is “that’s incredible and unprecedented”, the reaction we should have should not be to accept that claim but to default to critical thinking.
In this case the public records are available and easy to access. It took me less than 10 minutes to get to primary sources. This an easily falsifiable claim.
The only way we enable the norm to be claims of stolen elections is by failing to access claims like these critically.
Again, I hold you and this community to a higher standard.
This claim started as a tweet by Donal Trump Junior but can be easily fact checked by looking up the voter count for 2020 and the voting population of Wisconsin (3.2M against 4.5M), or in a desperate time a quick Google.
I expect better from the community here and from you personally.
That is. They would then have to ask you permission to spam you.
Finite games like the one invented by the children described by the OP have end states, they have winners, and the goal within them are always framed from that perspective. While infinite games have no winners, have no end, and the goals are often framed around ensuring that the game never ends.
It's easy to think of finite games in our lives, they are everywhere in our society, and the OP does a good job of pointing out some of the less obvious cases. Infinite games are less obvious, the one that I found most illuminating was "language", a game where people actively collude to extend the game to the end of time, and has no winner.
Anyay, it's an interesting read, but a little bit mumbo-jumbo by the middle of the book. I would recommend it.
http://www.amazon.com/Finite-Infinite-Games-Vision-Possibili...
Admittedly the syntax is /unique/ to makefiles, which I think is the biggest downside. There is a huge benefit to not having to learn one more way of doing things. And I think that's the big appeal of tools like rake (as well as the ability to easily leverage, libraries, and other higher order programming concepts). But for the simple tasks of compilation, and minor project management. Give me Make.
I actually have to tip my hat to you, after a couple of books and some google tinkering, the article you linked to is by far the most comprehensive scientific look at the topic that I've found.