HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

activescott

107 karma · joined May 2, 2013

More about me at https://scott.willeke.com
submissionscomments
activescott··on Mazda slaps developer with cease-and-desist for DIY smart home integration
I just happen to read about DMCA exemptions legalities recently (which I submitted at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37961007). Turns out that exemptions to DMCA are recommended every three years. I noticed one especially relevant to this one under the section category of "Proposed New or Expanded Exemptions":

> Proposed Class 7: Computer Programs— Vehicle Operational Data > MEMA petitions for a new exemption to ‘‘access, store, and share vehicle operational data, including diagnostic and telematics data’’ from ‘‘a lawfully acquired motorized land vehicle or marine vessel such as a personal automobile or boat, commercial vehicle or vessel, or mechanized agricultural vehicle or vessel.’’ 182 The petition limits circumvention to ‘‘lawful vehicle owners and lessees, or those acting on their behalf.’’ > The Office encourages proponents to develop the legal and factual administrative record in their initial submissions, including describing with specificity the relevant TPMs and whether their presence is adversely affecting noninfringing uses, whether eligible users may access such data through alternate channels that do not require circumvention, and the legal basis for concluding that the proposed uses are likely to be noninfringing. In general, the Office seeks comment on whether the proposed exemption should be adopted, including any proposed regulatory language.

- From Page 14, of October 19, 2023 – Notice of Proposed Rulemaking at https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2023-10-19/pdf/2023-2...

The US Copyright Office goes on to say *they want feedback on this potential exemption*:

> The Office encourages proponents to develop the legal and factual administrative record in their initial submissions, including describing with specificity the relevant TPMs and whether their presence is adversely affecting noninfringing uses, whether eligible users may access such data through alternate channels that do not require circumvention, and the legal basis for concluding that the proposed uses are likely to be noninfringing. In general, the Office seeks comment on whether the proposed exemption should be adopted, including any proposed regulatory language.

Note that final sentence!

activescott··on Uber migrates microservices to multi-cloud platform running Kubernetes and Mesos
> In preparation for the move to the cloud, the company spent two years working towards making all stateless microservices portable so that their placement in zones and regions can be managed centrally without any involvement from the service engineers

I'd like to hear more about how Uber organized the engineering teams over two years to make "stateless microservices portable".

How many teams? What were the requirements to each team? What was the timeline? How did they know it was completed? How was it prioritized along other business priorities of the teams? How long did they think it would take originally? Was it worth it?

activescott··on Who profits most from America's baffling health-care system?
I think worth clarifying. The comment ends with

> If you want to criticize colleges on their cost, the data to use is expenditure data, which is much cleaner.

As if the opaque pricing of colleges isn't just as baffling as the healthcare system's resulting cost situation.

activescott··on Who profits most from America's baffling health-care system?
The OP article provides clear evidence that for-profit companies is not limited to Pharma:

> ...insurers, chemists, drug distributors and pharmacy-benefit managers (PBMs)—sitting between patients and their treatments. In 2022 the combined revenue of the nine biggest middlemen—call them big health—equated to nearly 45% of America’s health-care bill, up from 25% in 2013. Big health accounts for eight of the top 25 companies by revenue in the S&P 500 index of America’s leading stocks, compared with four for big tech and none for big pharma.

It goes on to detail their profit relative to the S&P as well.

activescott··on Who profits most from America's baffling health-care system?
Are you arguing that the opaque pricing is effective?
activescott··on Scaling to 15000 Functions and Beyond
Your relentless customer service is commendable. Good work. Serverless works well in many scenarios and being able to run it on any k8s cluster without proprietary platform hooks is a good thing for all of us to have an option for.
activescott··on Scaling to 15000 Functions and Beyond
"you better have the configuration defined in code" - you better do that anyway for anything that is used and will be around for a while :)
activescott··on DMCA Excemptions to "Copyright Protection Systems" Being Reconsidered
What a great point. Why is it that the peoples' rights require renewal every three years, rather than the restrictions of the peoples' rights that require renewal?
activescott··on Web Summit CEO Paddy Cosgrave Resigns After Israel-Hamas War Comments – AP News
Paddy Cosgrave's apology (https://websummit.com/blog/apology-from-paddy-cosgrave-ceo) seemed to me to be balanced, sincere and thoughtful. Although apparently it is not enough to appease the likes of Google, Meta, Intel, Siemens who are boycotting Web Summit because of what his views on a social issue (https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/meta-google-and-stripe...).

Should public technology business leaders refrain from all opinions related to social issues, or just those that are not popular? Given the number of public figures that have expressed unconditional support for one side of an ongoing violent conflict, it appears that it is just unpopular views that are not welcome in the technology business community.

activescott··on DMCA Excemptions to "Copyright Protection Systems" Being Reconsidered
My understanding is that the exemptions are made every three years and only for a three year period. So while the LOC isn't necessarily _intending_ to take back exemptions, their is not necessarily an intention to leave them in place for another three years. As you noted, this time around an exemption that existed previously is no longer granted. I certainly didn't mean to make your heart skip a beat, but we also shouldn't take the exemptions there for granted.
activescott··on DMCA Excemptions to "Copyright Protection Systems" Being Reconsidered
Lol. I’m so classy
activescott··on DMCA Excemptions to "Copyright Protection Systems" Being Reconsidered
Every three years the Librarian of Congress publishes exceptions to the copy protection circumvention. The public can comment in support for renewing existing exemptions or adding new ones. Copyright holders or other can also lobby to remove exemptions. This covers fundamental access control technology such as encryption on everything from software to video to music to books.

This is also is more interesting as copyright holders consider the impact of allowing generative AI to train on their copyrighted works. Discuss!

← PreviousPage 2 of 2