HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adam_arthur

4,090 karma · joined December 23, 2020

Worked for a Silicon Valley startup from early days through successful acquisition.
submissionscomments
adam_arthur··on Giving Up a $250k Salary to Retire Early Is Hard
Are you trying to retire with stable cash flow, or grow your wealth?

For many, retirement is first and foremost about generating a stable income. A guaranteed lower rate of return is usually desirable over a speculative higher rate of return.

adam_arthur··on Giving Up a $250k Salary to Retire Early Is Hard
You can lock in cash flowing assets today yielding 6%+ with very low risk. Think REITs with conservative portfolios and strong balance sheets.

You can lock in today's treasury rates for 30 years by buying a 30Y treasury bond.

So, yes, they will last if you understand where to put your money. The options are extremely numerous and plentiful now in cash flowing assets, and you don't have to deal with the uncertainty of selling off principal in down markets to finance your retirement

adam_arthur··on Giving Up a $250k Salary to Retire Early Is Hard
Sad to see people still parroting the 4% rule when you can get "risk free" US Treasuries, today, paying more than that. Not to speak of the numerous, still conservative, investments paying far higher.

This isn't the 2010s era with ultra low fixed income yields. If you intend to retire early, please educate yourself on the state of the market

adam_arthur··on Apple files emergency motion to become defendant in US vs. Google [pdf]
And how much of Apple's services revenue comes from Google?

When's the last time you paid Microsoft 15% to download an exe?

adam_arthur··on Apple files emergency motion to become defendant in US vs. Google [pdf]
It is entirely relevant to the parent comment.

As to the second part, it requires a bit of reading comprehension and contextual awareness, unfortunately.

adam_arthur··on Apple files emergency motion to become defendant in US vs. Google [pdf]
Why would Apple be allowed to partner with Microsoft, which is even larger than Google?
adam_arthur··on Apple files emergency motion to become defendant in US vs. Google [pdf]
Honestly it's the only logical conclusion.

Otherwise the terms of the deal are terrible for Google

adam_arthur··on Apple files emergency motion to become defendant in US vs. Google [pdf]
I seriously doubt Apple would move to Bing by default, even if there were some short term monetary gain. Using a subpar/cluttered search interface is so far off from their brand image.

I find it 10x more likely Apple would suddenly find the motivation to make their own search engine if forced to end their deal with Google.

(They say they wouldn't under any circumstance, but seems to be posturing to me)

Regardless, it's clear getting paid Billions to give people the default they'd choose anyway is a good deal for them.

I wonder who at Google negotiated this, because the terms seem very bad for them. They only make sense if the premise was to prevent Apple from starting a competitor

adam_arthur··on Apple files emergency motion to become defendant in US vs. Google [pdf]
Some issues are (largely) bipartisan.

Over time the sentiment towards concentration of power in small number of big tech firms has rubbed both the Democrats and Republicans the wrong way.

Somewhat for different reasons initially, but the end result/agreement converges.

adam_arthur··on Apple files emergency motion to become defendant in US vs. Google [pdf]
It is funny and a bit sad that many root for anticompetitive behavior by these companies out of what appears to be largely simply due to fanboyism.

Making markets highly competitive and open to new entrants/innovation is far better for society in the long run.

Is society better off if Visa can take 5% of every Transaction? Apple/Google 30%? Clearly not.

In a competitive market, margins will trend towards marginal value add of the player. Margins well in excess of the add are signs a market is not competitive.

Open protocols for payments, storefronts, Identity/Auth, messaging etc can solve most of these inefficiencies.

Eventually government will get smarter on technology. (Maybe on the cusp?)

adam_arthur··on OpenAI says it has evidence DeepSeek used its model to train competitor
Who cares?

They did the exact same thing with public information. Their model just synthesizes and puts out the same information in a slightly different form.

Next we should sue students for repeating the words of their teachers

adam_arthur··on Jevons paradox
"Induced Demand" is often, incorrectly, talked about as a shift in the demand curve in response to increase in supply.

There is no shift. I am addressing this common misunderstanding, not debating the wording in the Wikipedia article.

"Induced Demand" is a misnomer, as the demand was always there at the given price. It is not induced, just realized. If I offer you a gold bar for $0, did I induce your demand to accept it?

Most people will always have demand for goods offered below their perceived intrinsic value.

Ultimately it's semantics around definitions, but the thinking of lay people around this concept is typically more of the shifting demand curve, not realization along the existing curve

adam_arthur··on Jevons paradox
Induced Demand is a poorly conceived mental model.

The concept of "Induced Demand" is easily explained by the default state of the downward sloping demand curve, and upward sloping supply curve.

In basic economic theory, if you reduce the cost of a good, more people will consume it.

e.g. the classic building a highway example; there was always demand for cheap housing with accessibility to downtowns, but the supply of cheap housing with accessibility to downtowns did not exist prior to building the highway there. The "demand curve" doesn't shift at all, you're just moving along it as perception of cost changes.

Has there ever been a case where a highway was run through the middle of nowhere and traffic didn't increase? It's intuitive why

adam_arthur··on Amazon removed statements advocating for LGBTQ rights and racial equity
Assuming equal skill distribution among subgroups, an unbiased hiring process would end up with employee demographics matching 1:1 with the demographic make of the talent pool.

What do you think is the gender split in the tech hiring pool?

What do you think is the racial split?

adam_arthur··on Amazon removed statements advocating for LGBTQ rights and racial equity
There's an easy legal argument to make that discrimination in hiring, or otherwise, on the basis of race is illegal.

So I'm not surprised that companies with policies promoting specific subgroups are worried about legal consequences.

e.g. from the article

[Amazon] "The deletion of previous statements pledging to commit to “equity for Black people”"

adam_arthur··on Bun 1.2 Is Released
I respect the area Bun is trying to carve out, but if you follow the creator on Twitter, you'll see the decision making process is very focused on short-term wins/convenience and very light on the deeper implications of the "magic"

I was initially excited about the project, but have no faith in the long term direction given the spurious (and often poor IMO) design decisions. At least as it's publicized on socials.

It would have been fine if they kept it v0.x, but releasing 1.0 should have significantly raised the bar for increasing API surface area

adam_arthur··on Nvidia's Project Digits is a 'personal AI supercomputer'
Finally!

First product that directly competes on price with Macs for local inferencing of large LLMs (higher RAM). And likely outperforms them substantially.

Definitely will upgrade my home LLM server if specs bear out.

adam_arthur··on I Run LLMs Locally
Whether performance or cost is more important depends on your use case. Some tasks that an LLM can do very well may not need to be done often, or even particularly quickly (as in my case).

e.g. LLM as one step of an ETL-style pipeline

Latency of the response really only matters if that response is user facing and is being actively awaited by the user

adam_arthur··on I Run LLMs Locally
It's reasonable in a "working professional who gets substantial value from" or "building an LLM driven startup project" kind of way.

It's not for the casual user, but for somebody who derives significant value from running it locally.

Personally I use the MacMini as a hub for a project I'm working on as it gives me full control and is simply much cheaper operationally. A one time ~$2000 cost isn't so bad for replacing tasks that a human would have to do. e.g. In my case I'm parsing loosely organized financial documents where structured data isn't available.

I suspect the hardware costs will continue to decline rapidly as they have in the past though, so that $5k for 128GB will likely be $5k for 256GB in a year or two, and so on.

We're almost at the inflection point where really powerful models are able to be inferenced locally for cheap

adam_arthur··on How I run LLMs locally
A Mac Mini with 24GB is ~$800 at the cheapest configuration. I can respect wanting to do a single part upgrade, but if you're using these LLMs for serious work, the price/perf for inferencing is far in favor of using Macs at the moment.

You can easily use the MacMini as a hub for running the LLM while you do work on your main computer (and it won't eat up your system resources or turn your primary computer into a heater)

I hope that more non-mac PCs come out optimized for high RAM SoC, I'm personally not a huge Apple fan but use them begrudgingly.

Also your $900 quote is a used/refurbished GPU. I've had plenty of GPUs burn out on me in the old days, not sure how it is nowadays, but that's a lot to pay for a used part IMO

adam_arthur··on How I run LLMs locally
Inferencing does not require Nvidia GPUs at all, and its almost criminal to be recommending dedicated GPUs with only 12GB of RAM.

Buy a MacMini or MacbookPro with RAM maxed out.

I just bought an M4 mac mini for exactly this use case that has 64GB for ~2k. You can get 128GB on the MBP for ~5k. These will run much larger (and more useful) models.

EDIT: Since the request was for < $1600, you can still get a 32GB mac mini for $1200 or 24GB for $800

adam_arthur··on The Weeds Are Winning
I think the future of pesticides and weed control in food production will be robots manually removing pests. No chemicals required.

The technology we have today isn't too far off from this... weeds are certainly easier than bugs, but both should be feasible.

adam_arthur··on The Electoral College was nearly abolished in 1970 (2020)
People should consider that campaigning, platforms and candidates would be entirely different in a world run by popular vote.

It may or may not ultimately be better, but it certainly wouldn't be a simple one variable change from the current political climate to the benefit of one party today.

I'm largely in favor of popular vote over the EC, but it would not usher in a huge change to the status quo, more likely a slightly different flavor of what we have today.

The stances of both parties has drastically changed over time under the EC model, and would continue to do so under the popular vote model

adam_arthur··on Life expectancy rise in rich countries slows down: took 30 years to prove
This was and is part of their goal, yes.

https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Technology/Beijing-asks-Ten...

"Beijing asks Tencent to lower WeChat's mobile payment market share"

https://www.forbes.com/sites/zennonkapron/2022/11/09/chinas-...

https://www.business-standard.com/world-news/china-may-impos...

"China is planning to introduce a new mobile payment regulation aimed at reducing the market share of Tencent Holdings' WeChat app, similar to efforts made by the National Payments Corporation of India to curb Google Pay and Phone's growing dominance in the market"

China's methods are more authoritarian than are viable in the west. But the general premise of a competitive market being better for society than dominance by a small number of firms is supported well by history

adam_arthur··on Life expectancy rise in rich countries slows down: took 30 years to prove
You would expect market cap of the largest players to decline if the market becomes more competitive... which was China's primary goal with their recent crackdown.

They proactively forced interconnectivity and limited the ability for companies to make "walled-garden peudo-monopolies", as we have in the US with Apple and Google.

If the same happens here (through act of congress, or legal outcomes), you can expect their market caps to decline as well. A decline in market cap doesn't speak at all to whether it's beneficial to the industry or consumers

adam_arthur··on US weighs Google break-up in landmark antitrust case
Competition usually leads to higher wealth creation and GDP, not less.

If you use real life examples and history as a benchmark

adam_arthur··on Windows 11 vs. Ubuntu 24.10 Performance For Intel Core Ultra 7 Lunar Lake
I switched to Ubuntu recently on a Thinkpad Z16 and had some compatibility and battery life issues.

I think Linux is great for more mainstream models that have already been out for a few years, but unfortunately I can't recommend if you're buying a new or more niche machine.

It's really a shame, as I absolutely don't like the direction either Microsoft or Apple is going. I keep ending up back at MBP due to overall polish/hardware quality, but I prefer linux to MacOS. I hope Asahi Linux can get fully up-to-date with latest models and resolve the various QoL issues

adam_arthur··on Google must open Android for third-party stores, rules Epic judge
They aren't direct competitors.

You have two walled gardens and two monopoly-esque distribution platforms within those walls.

Nobody with an iPhone can use Google Play, and nobody with an Android can use the app store.

Which is why disallowing, or hindering, competing app stores within one walled garden is clearly anti-competitive.

It's not reasonable to expect consumers in one ecosystem to completely leave the ecosystem for one specific app, just like it's not reasonable to expect a homeowner to sell their house and move somewhere just so they can pay a lower utility bill.

Is the utility company serving your house a competitor with the utility company across the street if I have to move houses to switch between them?

Yes, if you look at the market as a whole. Clearly not if you use a reasonable interpretation and consider costs of switching.

If Apple and Google are truly providing unique value to developers and consumers, then they have nothing to fear from alternative app stores. Their profits won't be affected.

adam_arthur··on US antitrust case against Amazon to move forward
(Compelled) Open standards isn't an argument, it's an act of congress.

Unfortunately Congress is largely old and non-technical so the problems present aren't very well recognized or understood.

History will look at walled gardens as bad for competition and thus broader society.

adam_arthur··on US antitrust case against Amazon to move forward
Competition is the core tenant that makes capitalism beneficial to broader society.

Consolidation over the past few decades has limited the capacity for firms to compete in many sectors.

So I appreciate the sentiment of what the FTC is trying to do, but they really come across as amateurs bringing far too many lawsuits and often with weak legal reasoning/argumentation.

In many of the cases they've brought there exists alternative, yet stronger arguments that could have been made.

I'd support congress legislating towards more competition (e.g. forcing open standards for things like APIs/chat clients/smart watches etc), or a more active FTC.

But the current approach is far too disorganized and weak.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →