HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adamsea

554 karma · joined September 24, 2015

software engineer. interested in things. have opinions, mostly lurk & listen.
submissionscomments
adamsea··on Being kind to others is good for your health
Our bodies are composed of information too.

LOL basically you have to accept that our current scientific understanding is that our minds are embodied constructs (your mind doesn’t exist in any meaningful way without your brain, which is a physical organ and fundamentally and essentially integrated with the body).

Thought itself is embodied.

Your argument proves the necessity of physical contact for human health.

Our biologies - our brains and bodies - require the information (chemical impulses, electrical impulses, etc) provided by our senses when embodied physical touch, sight, sound, the body heat of another person, etc, occur.

Unless a perfect simulacra of physical human interaction (including the ability for us to move our own physical bodies) was created, there will always be a lack of the information (consider the chemicals released by exercise, by a hug, and impact of said chemicals on the brain, the combination of chemicals from eating with the chemicals of being close to someone you like) which our embodied minds require for health.

You’d have to put a brain in a vat and feed it every single electrical impulse and chemical it would normally receive from being part of the body.

Otherwise you lose information and god knows what happens.

I don’t deny the value of interaction via the Internet, etc.

To imply it is anywhere near replacing the information density of embodied physical contact is just a sign of a lack of information - education - about all this stuff.

adamsea··on Being kind to others is good for your health
> This is accurate. More often than not, trying to do something good for others will end up making you feel like an idiot. For the person on the receiving end, you are a jackpot. Instead of being shown gratitude, you're likely to be exploited.

Helping others doesn’t mean you have to set yourself up to be a sucker. Which you kinda point out when you about volunteering. But IMHO in any space our own judgement is still required and essential.

adamsea··on Being kind to others is good for your health
> Being helpful and kind to others also requires that you be kind to yourself. You can only give when it is healthy to do so.

Agreed. We all deserve the same fundamental measure of respect. It’s equally important to be kind to myself and to others. The two are the same thing in disguise.

It can take reflection to parse out each situation, but if a “helping” act of mine is actually damaging to me in a way I resent or would prefer to avoid, then am I really being kind to the other person? I’d argue that often I’m actually acting out of an unhealthy impulse of guilt, some sense of social-obligation, self-identity, etc, which is really just about myself.

Sometimes helping another person - even if they want said help - actually doesn’t help them at all, and that’s not really kindness in my opinion. It requires judgement.

True kindness includes more than the “soft and mushy” feelings a lot of us look on with suspicion. Authentic kindness and care can be hard as fuck because it means saying no or not helping someone when your natural impulse is to do so.

See: parenting, family members/friends with addictions, letting go an employee who’s well-intentioned, breaking up with someone who’s nice, etc.

IMHO Buddhist thought is a great tool for thinking about this kind of stuff.

adamsea··on Tensions in Google's ethical AI group increase as it sends demands to CEO
good point!
adamsea··on Who Gets to Breathe Clean Air in New Delhi?
Excellent article.
adamsea··on Tensions in Google's ethical AI group increase as it sends demands to CEO
> but this has gone too far.

Honest question - which part has gone too far?

Feel like there are currently a lot of parts.

adamsea··on Tensions in Google's ethical AI group increase as it sends demands to CEO
> She sounds like too much of a headache to deal with.

Yeah and your average software engineer is roses.

Difference is engineers positively impact the bottom line and society is less tolerant (empirically researched fact) of pushback from women or people of color.

For sure there may be complications on both sides of this issue but let’s not pretend that this shit isn’t real.

adamsea··on Tensions in Google's ethical AI group increase as it sends demands to CEO
Do you really mean that?
adamsea··on Creative Code-Generated Art
Art? Gain?
adamsea··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
Thank you for your response - much appreciated! And for pointing out the Carnegie Mellon program.

What is the academic job market like this days for CS Phd's, if I may ask?

adamsea··on Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year
Fair enough. I appreciate your response. I had gotten a very different impression from your previous comment, FYI. Maybe I was too angry when I was writing myself.

While some journalists in Portland may be actively engaged as you describe, I think it's inaccurate and unfair to expand that into a generalization of most journalists in Portland.

adamsea··on Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year
"... the predominant liberal party" ??? Who talks like that?

I feel like you're not saying what you really mean. IMHO you are making noise to distract from what actually matters. From the Black Lives Matter website:

https://blacklivesmatter.com/herstory/

"In 2013, three radical Black organizers — Alicia Garza, Patrisse Cullors, and Opal Tometi — created a Black-centered political will and movement building project called #BlackLivesMatter. It was in response to the acquittal of Trayvon Martin’s murderer, George Zimmerman. The project is now a member-led global network of more than 40 chapters. Our members organize and build local power to intervene in violence inflicted on Black communities by the state and vigilantes.

Black Lives Matter is an ideological and political intervention in a world where Black lives are systematically and intentionally targeted for demise. It is an affirmation of Black folks’ humanity, our contributions to this society, and our resilience in the face of deadly oppression.

As organizers who work with everyday people, BLM members see and understand significant gaps in movement spaces and leadership. Black liberation movements in this country have created room, space, and leadership mostly for Black heterosexual, cisgender men — leaving women, queer and transgender people, and others either out of the movement or in the background to move the work forward with little or no recognition. As a network, we have always recognized the need to center the leadership of women and queer and trans people. To maximize our movement muscle, and to be intentional about not replicating harmful practices that excluded so many in past movements for liberation, we made a commitment to placing those at the margins closer to the center.

As #BlackLivesMatter developed throughout 2013 and 2014, we utilized it as a platform and organizing tool. Other groups, organizations, and individuals used it to amplify anti-Black racism across the country, in all the ways it showed up. Tamir Rice, Tanisha Anderson, Mya Hall, Walter Scott, Sandra Bland — these names are inherently important. The space that #BlackLivesMatter held and continues to hold helped propel the conversation around the state-sanctioned violence they experienced. We particularly highlighted the egregious ways in which Black women, specifically Black trans women, are violated. #BlackLivesMatter was developed in support of all Black lives.

In 2014, Mike Brown was murdered by Ferguson police officer Darren Wilson. It was a guttural response to be with our people, our family — in support of the brave and courageous community of Ferguson and St. Louis as they were being brutalized by law enforcement, criticized by media, tear gassed, and pepper sprayed night after night. Darnell Moore and Patrisse Cullors organized a national ride during Labor Day weekend that year. We called it the Black Life Matters Ride. In 15 days, we developed a plan of action to head to the occupied territory to support our brothers and sisters. Over 600 people gathered. We made two commitments: to support the team on the ground in St. Louis, and to go back home and do the work there. We understood Ferguson was not an aberration, but in fact, a clear point of reference for what was happening to Black communities everywhere.

When it was time for us to leave, inspired by our friends in Ferguson, organizers from 18 different cities went back home and developed Black Lives Matter chapters in their communities and towns — broadening the political will and movement building reach catalyzed by the #BlackLivesMatter project and the work on the ground in Ferguson.

It became clear that we needed to continue organizing and building Black power across the country. People were hungry to galvanize their communities to end state-sanctioned violence against Black people, the way Ferguson organizers and allies were doing. Soon we created the Black Lives Matter Global Network infrastructure. It is adaptive and decentralized, with a set of guiding principles. Our goal is to support the development of new Black leaders, as well as create a network where Black people feel empowered to determine our destinies in our communities.

The Black Lives Matter Global Network would not be recognized worldwide if it weren’t for the folks in St. Louis and Ferguson who put their bodies on the line day in and day out, and who continue to show up for Black lives."

adamsea··on Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year
Are you saying all the people in question were simultaneously committing crimes?

Because otherwise your analogy makes no sense. Since, you know, you said you would be committing a crime.

The real question is, is this an honest question - are you really asking what other people think, or, are you deliberately implying all the folks in question were somehow criminal?

adamsea··on Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year
Does it actually matter?

If you believe it does, why?

adamsea··on Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year
> I am not saying that they are better or worse than traditional press, which I have a strong aversion to, I am just saying ...

So you’re saying you just don’t like the press, basically.

Except maybe the press that says what you like?

Because tbh everything you wrote just sounds like a lot of authoritatively-stated opinion.

Which tells me that you’re either uneducated about facts-, or, looking to shift the conversation away from facts.

For that matter, what’s wrong with activism? And activism against what, specifically?

You don’t even mention that. Just “activists”.

LOL I watch twitter too and didn’t see what you saw. Here:

https://www.opb.org/news/article/aclu-sues-portland-oregon-p...

https://www.wweek.com/news/city/2020/06/07/portland-reporter...

“ Video taken from a helicopter by WW's news partner KATU-TV around 11:45 pm on June 6 shows a person filming police in Chapman Square, until an officer turns to him, hits him with a baton and twice pepper-sprays him in the face.

... “‘As the man sputtered and spit and gasped, I, for reasons that I'm sure are clear, shouted to get the fuck off his neck,’ Farley recalls. ‘This is the moment a fourth officer approached, reaching for his baton.’

Farley says he believes officers targeted him because he was filming the arrest.“

Press-activists indeed.

adamsea··on Record Breaking Number of Journalists Arrested in the U.S. This Year
Reading history is the honest answer.

You read enough good books and articles about current events and history and then are able to make reasonable inferences.

Suppressing, or evening worse distorting historical knowledge is always a tool of authoritarians and oppressors.

Which is imho part of why so many folks here in the U.S. are so historically illiterate :/ :(.

adamsea··on Welcome Yari: MDN Web Docs has a new platform
Agreed. Plus why name the thing / use the icon of a lance, anyway? So confusing.
adamsea··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
Good point. And I just want to throw on to that (not saying folks are disagreeing w/this) that IMHO some amount of technical expertise is necessary but not sufficient for the kind of socially responsible decision-making we are talking about.

JFK (or whomever) didn't need to be a physicist, but he did need to understand a little physics. And math, etc.

adamsea··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
Do you think there is room for various kinds philosophical thought within Computer Science itself? Honest question.

As an undergrad studying Comp Sci and also taking philosophy/literature classes it struck me just how rich the Computer Science metaphors are, and how much creativity seemed to go into coming up with a lot of the fundamental ideas of Computer Science.

But of course it's also possible that I was applying my own bias; I know most of the Comp Sci folks from the 50s/60s/70s were pretty heavy math folks.

But pursuing a graduate Comp Sci degree is something I've considered on and off. Alan Kay has always been especially inspiring.

TBH I've also felt like there's some unexplored areas where Computer Science and Poetics, or Literary Theory, could make a really interesting combination. Again it's a question of rich metaphors and investing meaning into use-of-language in a very comprehensive and granular way (grammar, one verb or adjective versus another, theories of narrative, etc.

adamsea··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
> Were the Greeks that original in some definite way that later stuff is derivative but they aren't?

I believe some folks are interested in if Indian thought and philosophy, or other Asian philosophies / schools of thought had any influence on Ancient Greek thought, as there was communication, trade, Alexander the Great conquering stuff, etc. But I believe it's an open question and probably one difficult to answer.

Schopenhaur, Nietzsche, and others, were aware of and admirers of Buddhism.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buddhism_and_Western_philosoph...

IMHO there's generally more cross-pollination, in multiple directions, than is generally realized or credited.

adamsea··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
Very good point. And, this algorithm would totally fail in my country! As the U.S. has a wide variety of citizens of various skin tones. Which I'm very happy about : ).

Which I think supports what you're saying; not only do algorithms have biases, but we also can't assume they are universally applicable across a domain (in this case that a single facial recognition algorithm will have the same degree of accuracy in all places across the globe).

adamsea··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
I just want to point out a few question-able statements about history made in the article:

> Does it ever strike you as just a teeny bit odd that after a brief period where philosophy flourished, from maybe 400 B.C.E. to ~100 C.E., we went through a follow-on period of well over one thousand five hundred years during which the Roman Catholic Church enslaved everyone's minds and killed anyone who dared think differently?

First, let's not forget that it was the Athenians (the Greeks) who put Socrates to death! So it's not like Ancient Greece was all about this philosophy stuff and we can just go blame the Christians ...

I don't know why we saw an 'end' to the golden age of ancient Greek philosophy. BUT .... the Greeks were conquered by the Romans. Christianity developed in the Holy Land and spread through Rome. Early Christianity was highly influenced by Platonism (Plato). So in some ways Christianity is an outgrowth of Greek Philosophy. Or at least not orthogonal to it. And if anything, maybe blame the Romans for the end of Greek philosophy? Though the

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_Greek_philosophy#Helle...

> It was philosophers that got us out of that Dark Ages mess, and no small number of them lost their lives in doing so.

The Dark Ages weren't really "dark"

"As the accomplishments of the era came to be better understood in the 19th and 20th centuries, scholars began restricting the "Dark Ages" appellation to the Early Middle Ages (c. 5th–10th century),[3][7][8] and now scholars also reject its usage in this period.[9] The majority of modern scholars avoid the term altogether due to its negative connotations, finding it misleading and inaccurate.[10][11][12] Petrarch's pejorative meaning remains in use,[1][2][13] typically in popular culture which often mischaracterises the Middle Ages as a time of violence and backwardness."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_Ages_(historiography)

Since Steve's article uses this history as an analogy for the state of Computer Science / Programming, and then draws on it as an argument for why we need "philosophers" (IMHO philosophers of computer science might well do something completely unexpected and not what is suggested here), I think it's important to address the historical inaccuracies.

If anything I think more Science & Technology Studies folks / Philosophy of Computer Science, or anthropology folks studying the culture and implicit biases of computer scientists and software engineers would be useful & kinda awesome.

adamsea··on U.S. Treasury breached by hackers backed by foreign government – sources
Good question :).

Maybe layers? For government agencies, the government could manage procurement.

For non-government organizations, realistically, maybe some sort of public-private/foundation partnership, if the NSA is willing to bend a little. Which at this point might be in their best interest.

adamsea··on Earnestness
You must be from Europe or something ;)
adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
Let’s do it - I love a good intellectual conversation!

Examining what facts we have it’s very clear that the Republican Party has put forth a number of specious lawsuits with no grounds - all of which have been vehemently rejected by every court in the land - and that the goal of these lawsuits is either to overturn the legitimate election results and/or undermine people’s faith in the election.

Many or most Republican politicians know the lawsuits will fail and are on board because they know they have to keep their base riled up in Georgia to win those Senate runoff elections.

And also because Trump still has a vise-grip on the Republican base, so these politicians have made the calculation that they’d rather do what Trump wants (so they can win re-election) than reaffirm what is America’s most fundamental small-d democratic process: voting for our president, having our leader be elected by the people.

Considering how fundamental voting is to a democracy, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to call an attempt to undermine the electoral process itself seditious.

It’s not very patriotic to put the success of your own political party ahead of the good of the country. Both sides do it a lot but in this specific case it’s clearly the Republicans and it’s a pretty egregious breach of faith of our social contract. In America we expect our elected officials to respect the rules of the game, and acknowledge an electoral loss.

Do you agree that these lawsuits are un-patriotic and seditious? If not, why?

I look forward to your reasoned, cogent, and rational response so we can have a nice intellectual discussion about policy.

Please don’t share evidence or whatnot which the courts have already examined and rejected - it doesn’t seem like a very good use of time to cover old ground, unless of course you wish to disagree with the decision of the courts.

Be careful what you wish for - you just might get it! ;)

———-

My point, of course, is that not all of our political conflict is blind “tribal warfare” where blame can be equally distributed between the two sides. There really are some important issues where one side is wrong, and where it’s important to fight for what’s right.

That’s not to say all partisan conflict is good and necessary. But I do think the facts show that (and I don’t deny the many flaws of the Democratic Party) the Republican Party has embraced obstruction as a technique to achieve and maintain power and continues to inch closer to “If I can’t have it, well then nobody can.”

And that they’ve embraced a figure who is very comfortable with undermining democracy itself and would love to become an authoritarian leader.

adamsea··on Earnestness
Agreed! :)
adamsea··on Earnestness
Cool : ). Yeah I honestly wasn't sure and appreciate your response : ). And I agree.

Just for fun I'll throw out Ursula le Guin as one of my favorite science fiction authors because she explores issues of human nature via anthropology and such.

adamsea··on Employees are leaving Facebook and torching the company in departure notes
Thank you for such an honest and thoughtful response, and forgive my delay.

We probably agree on a lot of politics. I do believe in a national healthcare system (socialized medicine?), because our current approach is so unjust, and because I fundamentally believe that a democratic government is the tool that people use to collectively better themselves. I also believe in free higher education for the same reason. I think both would pay for themselves.

That said, I know actually doing those things (especially healthcare) in the U.S. would be quite tricky and that the practical implementation of something matters as much as what should ideally be.

In general I believe in intellectual honesty, integrity in public services, treating everyone with the same level of respect, and that people generally do better when they work together. Which is why I think the Trump Administration and the current crop of Republicans enabling him (note that I'm not saying all!) are such pieces of shit. I didn’t used to be so crude but at some point you have to make clear what’s not acceptable in the kind of society I believe in.

I'm also a huge fan of the arts, the liberal arts, and so a big believer in freedom of expression.

So I can be a bit of a political idealist. At the same time I've read a lot of history and think I understand that the world is a rough place and that people in power often have to make shitty choices between bad and worse.

TBH I think one of the biggest positive changes, both in this country and in the world, could be in the field of mental health. Consider how revolutionary modern medicine has been in terms of the physical health of the individual and all the positive good and realization of human potential that has come from that.

Mental health is (at least in Western science) still a very young field and only beginning to be socially accepted. Also consider just how much damage a troubled individual - especially someone in a position of power - can do. Even just a shitty manager can really fuck up other people's lives.

We also have to acknowledge that no one can have good mental health when they have constant economic insecurity, or lack a way to meaningfully contribute to their community/to society.

I believe that if we keep fucking over our planet, it's gonna be real shitty for the human race. Pollution plays a big role in mental health as well (nature is actually critical for good mental health, plus pollution causes myriad physical and mental health issues in the population).

So I tend to be a pretty strong critic of capitalism as it is today, and how it just makes things like polluting the environment "externalities". I see markets as a financial tool and not inherently good or bad (and definitely not magical!), and, I think regulated capitalism can have it's role, but, the system we see today sucks. The national and global wealth disparity as it exists today is unjust, unethical, and, even if it's legal, criminal. It's shameful that the richest country in the world is so poor (poor civic infrastructure, poor citizens, poor quality of life, etc).

That said , while there are so many positive reforms we can make, I don't know what's out there to replace capitalism as a whole. We've yet to see some other sort of economic system really be tried (I don't count the USSR and most 'socialist' countries; tbh most of those governments were fucked up or, undermined by the US). So who knows what a better system is.

I do like the United States; what I like about it is that criticizing it is part of our civic duty.

Lastly I believe people really don't like to be uncomfortable, or change, or question themselves, which is why we see so much resistance to acknwoledging things like the patriarchy or white supremacy; no one likes to think that maybe their own friends, family, or themselves, have behaved in ways which have been harmful to other people. No one likes to question the unspoken assumptions of their world. Which goes back to my point about mental health.

And I think this discomfort with change has been a big part of the terrible response to the pandemic; people would rather stay comfortable with what they know and die, or play a role in the deaths of others, than deal with the discomfort of change.

This in part comes from my own perspective from having done a lot of therapy and dealing with mental health issues.

adamsea··on Earnestness
I can’t tell if you are being serious or sarcastic.

FWIW I think all of those things sound interesting and cool.

Here’s the abstract from the ‘Saga’s Sorrow’ paper:

“This article examines the construction of gender roles in contemporary white nationalist music. Grounded in extensive and ethnographic fieldwork, the article traces the rise of leading Swedish singer Saga and argues that her music frames women as besieged embodiments of racial and national essence dependent on men for deliverance. The discussion of Saga’s music draws from a review of recent social and ideological shifts in radical white nationalism, insider interviews, performance observations, and structural and textual analyses.”

For some reason I’m reminded of the Zack Snyder film ‘300’.

adamsea··on Earnestness
He’s a great man indeed.
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →