HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adamsea

554 karma · joined September 24, 2015

software engineer. interested in things. have opinions, mostly lurk & listen.
submissionscomments
adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
Indeed. I miss when it was turtles all the way down :):).
adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
Facts are being discussed. They’re being discussed on CNN. The New York Times. Fox News. In courts of law.

And actually, when the facts are discussed in courts of law what we find every time is that there is no evidence of fraud in any meaningful way. And, that the legal arguments being made don’t make any sense and may actually be asking for something illegal.

The question of a private company choosing to censor right wing anti-democratic propaganda (I think that’s a precise description even if it’s an unpalatable one to you) at the urging of some politicians is a different and tricky question.

I think it’s important to note that there have been threats of violence against state-level civil servants and their families. Threats which YouTube videos like the ones we are discussing foment.

But to say it’s not being discussed is just another lie.

adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
You’re missing my point. A Russian influence operation to support the Trump campaign actually happened. This is a fact supported by evidence which bears up under examination.

There is no evidence of electoral fraud or whatever nonsense is currently being claimed. It did not happen. It is, in fact, a deliberate lie.

Someone saying stuff on CNN is not reliable information. Are you really going to compare that to the Mueller report?

In fact, what is reliable right now is how courts have been deciding these ridiculous claims. And they’ve all been universally rejected because the claims have no evidence, make no sense, and are basically asking for something that’s actually illegal.

So we are talking about two completely different things. Something that really happened, based on evidence, and something that is a bunch of lies and distortions. That is my point.

And, I’d really encourage you to learn how to better judge things. Or, to stop participating in this anti-democratic bullshit.

adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
You're assuming equivalence between the two.

What matters is evidence. Facts. Logic. Reason.

The two simply are not equivalent. Check out what Wikipedia says about the Mueller Report:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mueller_report

I'm not claiming the Democrats are perfect or that there aren't mixed motives.

But it's obvious to any thinking person not living in a poisoned media ecosystem that all of these election fraud claims are baseless and ridiculous.

The same is not true about Russian influence operations during the 2016 election and the Trump campaigns, let's say, benign support of them.

adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
You're assuming equivalence between the two.

What matters is evidence. Facts. Logic. Reason.

The two simply are not equivalent. Check out what Wikipedia says about the Mueller Report:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mueller_report

I'm not claiming the Democrats are perfect or that there aren't mixed motives.

But it's obvious to any thinking person not living in a poisoned media ecosystem that all of these election fraud claims are baseless and ridiculous.

The same is not true about Russian influence operations during the 2016 election and the Trump campaigns, let's say, benign support of them.

adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
> Politics requesting censorship is always partisan.

Extremely general statements are always applicable.

adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
It's a tricky area. The challenge is how to deal with bad actors who use the rules of the game to undermine the game itself.

We also have to acknowledge the context in which this is occurring; the people claiming fraud are also threatening violence against civil servants and their children.

"Georgia officials were similarly reticent until last week, when threats online targeted a young contract worker for Dominion Voting Systems, whose voting machines were used in the state. One post on Twitter included a swinging noose.

That day, Gabriel Sterling, the Republican in charge of the voting machines, walked to a podium visibly angry and demanded that Trump “stop inspiring people to commit potential acts of violence.”

In an interview with Reuters, Sterling said that he personally had received a message calling him a him “traitor” that included his home address. Someone else wished him a happy birthday in a tweet saying it would be his last."

https://www.reuters.com/article/usa-election-threats/electio...

Just like it's difficult when and what content to censor when it comes to things like the ISIS recruiting pipeline, it's hard to know where the line is with what is basically a far-right ideology which bleeds into domestic terrorism.

adamsea··on YouTube to remove content that alleges widespread election fraud
[EDIT: I choose to use strong language because it's important to speak the truth. Simplicity and clarity, combined with honesty, always are friends of truth. Sometimes you gotta say that the emperor has no clothes, and that shit does indeed stink. And this is shit that stinks.]

> In fact, there is a case brought to the Supreme Court by Texas and 17 other states ...

How do I put this delicately?

That case is bullshit.

Texas knows it, those 17 states know it, the Supreme Court knows it, and every single lawyer in the United States knows it.

And now you know it.

The Supreme Court will probably, like it did to the Pennsylvania Republicans, issue an order consisting of a single sentence rejecting their application:

"The application for injunctive relief presented to Justice Alito and by him referred to the Court is denied."

https://www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/120820zr_bq7...

adamsea··on Microdosing: Improving performance enhancement in intelligence analysis (2019) [pdf]
Love it - only half-joking. Take advantage of a large population of healthy young men under close medical supervision and government access to good LSD in order to run a good experiment to see if micro dosing has positive cognitive effects.
adamsea··on AI researcher Timnit Gebru resigns from Google
> The worst part is that there was a path for you to be professional and achieve your goals, but then I guess you don't get to bask in Twitter's righteous indignation that way.

IMHO we don’t really know if that part (achieving your goals) is true, or not true.

adamsea··on AI researcher Timnit Gebru resigns from Google
IMHO she is saying it’s reasonable to believe that social and systemic issues have an impact on creating ML models (as the teams designing, building, and deploying said models are members of society) in ways in addition to the data sets.

I don’t know what the right answer is but plenty of institutions come up with ways they attempt to deal with systemic biases. For example, blind auditions for positions in orchestras (you only hear the person auditioning, you can’t see them). Used to not be a thing. Now it is.

Point being that when people are motivated they are able to come up with stuff.

adamsea··on AI researcher Timnit Gebru resigns from Google
> Many other rhetorical moves have a lot of politics to muddle through / implicit assumptions that can be disavowed in bad faith, etc. I don't like to engage in that kind of discussion at all.

But isn’t what you described so vague and subjective, that you can apply it to pretty much anything?

IMHO it’s more honest to say “I sit out of conversations I don’t like”, which is an entirely fair and understandable decision to make :).

adamsea··on AI researcher Timnit Gebru resigns from Google
“People like me,” not referring to her privilege, but to women and people of color, I would guess. Since there are serious culture and systemic biases / prejudices against women and PoC.
adamsea··on AI researcher Timnit Gebru resigns from Google
I dunno. Consider that when Google found that a sexual harassment claim against Andy Rubin was valid, and so Google asked him to leave, they also paid him 90 million bucks when they didn’t have to.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nytimes.com/2018/10/25/tech...

“ Google could have fired Mr. Rubin and paid him little to nothing on the way out. Instead, the company handed him a $90 million exit package, paid in installments of about $2 million a month for four years, said two people with knowledge of the terms.”

Let’s assume that’s true. What is worse behavior? Obviously his. Yet he gets paid.

It’s not an apples to apples comparison but if google was to say to anyone, “goodbye and don’t let the door hit you on the way out”, shouldn’t it be this guy and the other dudes mentioned in the article?

And IMHO the fact that they didn’t is a great example of systemic sexism in action. So it’s not unreasonable to wonder if similar forces played a role in this situation.

It’s not surprising that companies function like this but that doesn’t make it right, and, it doesn’t mean that (even though change is slow) it isn’t possible to change norms.

We don’t know the full details; Googles firing of her may be valid.

But to be as dismissive of her being a representative of marginalized groups, and facing prejudice (conscious or unconscious) herself, is wrong. IMHO.

adamsea··on Deep Frozen Arctic Microbes Are Waking Up
“Based on science” means using science as a core part of the decision making process.

It sounds like you actually agree with what I said, but also misunderstood.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
If the effects are systemic it doesn’t matter if there is an “organized system”.

In fact we have a word for that and that word is “culture”. No one explicitly organizes it.

You use knowledge and reason, not to seek truth, but to occlude it for your own ends, driven by your own insecurities and fear.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
Yeah I looked at that language:

'We disrupt the Western-prescribed nuclear family structure requirement by supporting each other as extended families and “villages” that collectively care for one another, especially our children, to the degree that mothers, parents, and children are comfortable.'

So what? There are tons of cultures in which child raising is communal. Including various parts of Western cultures at various times.

They're not saying "nuclear families suck." They're saying, "nuclear families are one approach among many which humanity uses to raise children, and it's not necessarily always the best."

'Disrupt' doesn't mean 'Destroy'.

They also said 'to the degree that mothers, parents, and children are comfortable.' Meaning, IMHO, 'folks should make their own choices for their own families.'

Considering how incredibly destructive slavery was to any form of family institution (father sold or killed, mother sold, child not, etc), and how that has echoed down to the present day in the black community, I can understand why black folks would want to have that discussion.

Which is not just a discussion being had by black people, either.

What exactly is your beef here?

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
> It's anti-scientific to deny the possibility that biological gender can influence desired career paths.

IMHO what is actually being claimed, and which there is academic consensus based on facts around, is that sexism has been such a pervasive cultural force, to such a degree that it's difficult to parse nature versus nurture.

Plus science is still working on nature vs nature - it's complex.

So. Simpler to start with the known, empirically verified problem in front of our eyes.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
> The argument against affirmative action is that it is very hard to remove preferential treatment once it is in place even if it no longer required.

Once you educate yourself with fact-based historical information to understand how unfair the system has been, this actually is an argument in favor of affirmative action.

Point being that until very recently the biases has been extreme, so that despite positive changes in both culture and law, equality will not happen over night (as you said, things persist), and thus affirmative action is important even after the most pernicious source of discrimination has been removed.

Affirmative action is complex, no question, but your particular point is more of an argument for it than one against it.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
> You seem to be arguing for laws that treat people differently based on their immutable characteristics - i.e. gender. I think that's wrong and people should be treated equally.

That's not what I am arguing. What I am saying is, if people were currently being treated equally then we would not have to have this conversation. The truth is that they are not.

I mean come on, have you ever heard of the Bedchel test?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bechdel_test

"It asks whether a work features at least two women who talk to each other about something other than a man. The requirement that the two women must be named is sometimes added."

You have to exercise a lot of mental energy to not see all the ways in which there is systemic sexism in our society and workplace.

You also have to decide that all these women must be, making this shit up?

You also have to be pretty ignorant, either deliberately or through circumstance having placed you in an unhealthy media environment. These days there are a lot of fact-based, data-supported history books, studies, etc, talking about systemic sexism both past and present.

To sum up, however good your tech knowledge may be, your knowledge - current, best-practices knowledge, so to speak, of history is weak. Or, you don't want to acknowledge the truth.

Those are facts.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
Look. Culture doesn't change overnight.

If you are unwilling to understand the significance of it taking until 1920 for women to receive the right to vote, and the variety of reasons for resistance to the ERA, then, I don't know what to say.

If you haven't, talk with the women in your life you are friends with about sexism and discrimination in the work place.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
Do what everyone else is doing - put up a sign that says "Black Lives Matter".

The issue is big enough where it's OK to use the slogan - everyone will know what you mean.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
> Techies are less suspectible to feelings (they are deaf in some sense)

I'd argue "deaf to feelings" actually means more susceptible, just unconsciously so, and to different feelings.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
The link you shared - from the Post-Millenial - is troubling.

First, when reading it, to me, the language from the BLM site the article discussed did not line up w/what the article was accusing it of.

Second, the very beginning of the Wikipedia page about The Post-Millenial says this (and cites decent-looking sources for each point):

"The Post Millennial is a conservative Canadian online news magazine started in 2017. It publishes national and local news and has a large amount of opinion content. It has been criticized for releasing misinformation and articles written by fake personas,[1] for having unknowingly employed an editor with ties to white supremacist-platforming and pro-Kremlin media outlets,[2] and for opaque funding and political connections.[3][4]"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Post_Millennial

IMHO that invalidates your critique.

Simply put, Black Lives Matter, or BLM, is fundamentally about racist police violence and systemic racism in the justice system. That's at the core of it.

IMHO most critiques such as the one you raise seem to mainly be an attempt to obfuscate that simple fact.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
> Systemic sexism would imply there is an organized system to disadvantage women.

1. Women couldn't vote until the 1920s in the U.S. The 1940's in France.

2. In the U.S., the Equal Rights constitutional amendment, guaranteeing legal equality between men and women, still hasn't been fully ratified/passed: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Rights_Amendment

That's the tip of the legal iceberg.

If those aren't examples of a system, i.e., the U.S. government, granting less legal rights to women than to men, i.e., systemic sexism, then what is?

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
> I get that these things are all because women are underrepresented in tech and surely there are challenges for women and sexism against women. However, the examples above still feel like sexism to me.

These two sentences contradict each other.

You also say "I am not all men", but, sadly, the issue with systemic biases (racism, sexism, etc), is that it's not about individuals.

You seem smart enough to be able to theorize about ways in which, as a man, you may have unknowningly benefited from systemic biases over the course of your education / career.

For one thing you don't have to worry about being sexually harassed or raped by a friend/coworker - the numbers are pretty bad.

We're supposed to be rational, work with numbers, etc - so even if we can't prove the effect of a systemic bias on an individual, our knowledge of the data and basic statistics should lead us to be able to make reasonable inferences about general cases, etc.

I guess what I'm saying is, be the bigger man, in both ways in which that phrase can be read. It's not all about you.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
How in any possible reality is BLM not a civil rights issue? Did you read about the murder of George Floyd?

You're totally wrong.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
> Why not encourage employees to represent their beliefs individually, and off company time, by giving them more vacation and flexible working hours instead? Empower the employees to participate in politics without the company taking a side itself?

IMHO it's about power and the profits power leads to, and the desire of large companies to maintain their power and their profit.

IMHO on some level large corporations know that if they did this employees would get politically active and push more for their own interests to be represented in government over that of the large companies, resulting in less profit for said companies because government is investing in civil society and public infrastructure instead.

IMHO part of the reason the George Floyd protests were as big as they were is that folks had time on their hands, which is not the normal case for most folks in our system as it is today.

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
For sure. But right now we're in an era of change. Should addressing the existential threat of climate change be a goal for every company, or not? That's one example.

The Expensify CEO believed that democracy itself was on the line in the 2020 election, and that supporting democracy was relevant to the company's goal.

We can disagree with him but I respect him for exercising his judgement about the situation.

EDIT: I'd like to add, IMHO, workers should have more control over their own labor and see more of the profits of their labor, so, actually I'd like to see companies evolve to become less hierarchial institutions and thus decide priorities in a more democratic / consensus-based fashion.

I don't know how we'd do this. But I know we collectively are smart enough to figure out how to get closer than we are now : ).

adamsea··on To do politics or not do politics? Tech startups are divided
If the workplace did not have its own issues I would agree. But, since, to take one example, sexism is a known problem in tech - and throughout corporate America and society, to be fair - in order to not have a sexist workplace, one would need to be proactive.

Broadly speaking. Point being, it's easy to not want "politics" in the workplace when the workplace works well for you. If you're someone whom the workplace doesn't work well for, like a person of color, a pregnant woman, new mother, or new father, for that matter, well, then it's a different story.

If you yourself believe that sexism/systemic racism aren't issues that show up (even inadvertently or despite the best intentions of individuals) in the workplace, well, then that's a different conversation entirely.

I think this is different from someone in a position of power promoting a particular candidate in the workplace. That is more complex and problematic. The 2020 election was obviously an extreme example, and, tbh, with things like global warming, I think we'll be seeing more politics like that in the workplace, not less.

Which, to me, means it's not an easy or one-size-fits all solution, but rather, a challenge which requires each of us to exercise care and our own judgement.

For example, personally, I would have liked to see Hacker News take even a small explicit step of endorsing the Black Lives Matter movement (such as putting 'Black lives matter' on the top of the homepage), seeing as how it's one of the major civil rights issues of our present moment. I can also understand their concerns around doing so, even though I disagree with them.

IMHO it's too easy for those of us doing well and making money to forget that the institutions we work for have a social impact and are a part of society.

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →