HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adamsmith143

701 karma · joined February 10, 2022

submissionscomments
adamsmith143··on France’s Mistral AI raises a $113M seed round to take on OpenAI
You should throw all your money in then. Meanwhile teams with good people who also have a good product are going to eat them for lunch.
adamsmith143··on Stochastic Parrot
Yoshua Bengio, Andrew Ng, Anrej Karpathy, and many other of the top researchers in the field do not believe these models are stochastic parrots, they believe they have internal world models and prompts are methods to probe those world models. Stochastic parrots is one of the dumbest takes in AI/ML.
adamsmith143··on Show HN: 10xjobs.net, High paying tech jobs directory
>Any source for that claim?

Similarweb

>And the post will remain in other regions peak hour when they visit it, not to mention it still peak hour for Canada, S.America and even parts of Europe too.

It's not a particularly popular post and probably fell of the front page after a few hours.

>If you mean the job site, then it should be specified in the title, if you mean HN, then that’s irrelevant.

Of course it's relevant. You haven't really made any arguments. The fact is that a post made in the US' morning, on a US website primarily frequented by US techies is not required to cater to random engineers viewing the page at odd hours of the night across the world. Are you also upset that it's not translated into Bantu? God forbid we exclude Tanzanian developers.

adamsmith143··on Google doesn’t want employees working remotely anymore
I don't think referencing the value of consultants is going to help your argument lol.
adamsmith143··on Show HN: 10xjobs.net, High paying tech jobs directory
A plurality of visitors to HN are from the US, the next largest source is 10x smaller. This post is during peak US hours. This website is owned and operated by a US based company.

Its not absurd to imagine most post are going to be US focused. In fact it's pretty silly to imagine otherwise.

adamsmith143··on US SEC sues Coinbase, one day after suing Binance
? Bitcoin is down 5% since Binance was sued...
adamsmith143··on First impressions: Yes, Apple Vision Pro works and yes, it’s good
What percentage of people worldwide use smartphones with no voice service at all? Including voip.
adamsmith143··on First impressions: Yes, Apple Vision Pro works and yes, it’s good
Isn't the actual killer app for Advertisers? "Glue this thing to peoples faces and you now have the most effective most intrusive way to slam ads in front of people ever created!" Don't see why any consumer would buy this for 3500 though.
adamsmith143··on US SEC sues Coinbase, one day after suing Binance
Always interesting how crypto prices tank after legal action is announced against exchanges. Isn't the whole point to be decentralized in the first place? Hard to believe the whole dip is due to people wanting to get their tokens off the exchanges.
adamsmith143··on Tips for better coding with ChatGPT
Strong "Just read the manual" vibes.
adamsmith143··on The newest college admissions ploy: paying to make your teen “peer-reviewed”
>Seems ridiculous to me, why would teens even have peer-reviewed papers, or even papers, to their name?

Pretty much only because of this scam - so an automatic 'fraud' signal IMHO.

For reference the comment I was responding to implied that the ONLY way for a teen to be an author on a paper was because of this scam. I was pointing out that that is obviously not the case.

adamsmith143··on The newest college admissions ploy: paying to make your teen “peer-reviewed”
Plenty of teens have legitimate papers. Probably not first author but it's not hard to believe that an IOM Medalist could contribute to a Mathematics paper or an Intel Science winner would contribute to a Biology paper e.g.
adamsmith143··on The newest college admissions ploy: paying to make your teen “peer-reviewed”
Plenty of jobs check your credentials before hiring already. It's not a significant burden.
adamsmith143··on Measuring the productivity impact of generative AI
ChatGPT is free to use. Stable Diffusion is free to use. Those are two of the largest if not the largest generative models out there.
adamsmith143··on Lisa Su saved AMD – Now she wants Nvidia's AI crown
This is a cute headline but let's see AMD put out some software to actually run DNN training on their hardware. Currently either impossible or too onerous to be worth the trouble.
adamsmith143··on Measuring the productivity impact of generative AI
Why would this be scary? You've upgraded the productivity of maybe hundreds of millions of people.
adamsmith143··on Measuring the productivity impact of generative AI
>In other words, if you're skilled, there's nothing AI can do for you…

Yet...

adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
I think discounting future lives because you can't precisely count them is immoral at best and actively evil at worst.
adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
The last gas I passed had 10^23 entropy fluctuations in it. So you're saying those are more important than the 100 Billion human lives that came before them?
adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
Exactly. Taken to the limit if you extrapolate how many future human lives could be extinguished by a runaway AI you get extremely unsettling answers. Like the expected value of a .01% change of extinction from AI might be Trillions of quality Human lives. (This could in fact be on the very very conservative side, e.g. Nick Bostrom has speculated that there could be 10^35 human lives to be lived in the far future which is itself a conservative estimate). With these numbers even setting AI risk to be absurdly low, say 1/10^20, we might still expect to lose 10 billion lives. (I'd argue even the most optimistic person in the world couldn't assign a probability that low) So the stakes are extraordinarily high.

https://globalprioritiesinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/Tob...

adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
The problem is that even with N years until we reach that point it seems likely that it would take 2*N years to build the proper safety mechanisms because at least currently capabilities research is racing far ahead of safety research. Of course we have no way to know how big N really is and recent results like GPT-4, Llama, Gato, etc. have shifted peoples timelines significantly. So even if 5 years ago people like Geoff Hinton though this might be 30-50 years away there are now believable arguments to make that it might be more like 3-10 years.
adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
No man, the future of trillions of humans is obviously much less important than 1 person getting insulted on the internet.
adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
>She's the first author of the stochastic parrots paper,

That alone is enough to disqualify any of her opinions on AI.

adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
Particularly ironic given this isn't actually what the focus on...

https://www.safe.ai/ai-risk

adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
If AI improves by 0.0001% per year on your favorite intelligence metric there will eventually be a point where it surpasses human performance and another point where it surpasses all humans combined on that metric. There is danger in that scenario.
adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
>Real risks are more in the category of systemic racism and sexism, deep fakes, over reliance on AI etc.

This is a really bad take and risks missing the forest for the trees in a major way. The risks of today pale in comparison to the risks of tomorrow in this case. It's like being worried about birds dying in wind turbines while the world ecosystem collapses due to climate change. The larger risk is further away in time but far more important.

Theres a real risk that people get fooled by this idea that LLMs saying bad words is more important than human extinction. Though it seems like the public is already moving on and correctly focusing on the real issues.

adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
>As far as a pandemic or nuclear war, though, I'd probably put it on more of the level of a K-T extinction event. Humans are doing some work on asteroid redirection, but I don't think it is a global priority.

I think it's better to frame AI risks in terms of probability. I think the really bad case for humans is full extinction or something worse. What you should be doing is putting a probability distribution over that possibility instead of trying to guess how bad it could be, it's safe to assume it would be maximally bad.

adamsmith143··on Statement on AI Risk
This is a bad take. The statement is signed by dozens of Academics who don't have much profit motive at all. If they did they wouldn't be academics, they could easily cash in by starting a company or joining one of the big players.
adamsmith143··on Yoshua Bengio: How Rogue AIs May Arise
It's very clear that a strong AI/AGI would vastly surpass all humans combined. We've already seen shades of this with Chess AIs(all humans combined still can't beat a 3000 elo chess engine e.g.), hell even Kasparov vs the world showed showed us that the rest of the world combined can't even match a single high end human.

>I think going forward we're going to need much more clarity about what "superintelligence" really means.

This was already well defined by Bostrom in 1997: "An intellect that is much smarter than the best human brains in practically every field, including scientific creativity, general wisdom and social skills"

>Currently it seems like AI is essentially mimicking collective human intelligence, which means it is probably constrained at that level, as that level is the source.

There are no indications at all that it is constrained to that level.

adamsmith143··on Sam Altman goes before US Congress to propose licenses for building AI
>It can't translate whale song, or an extraterrestrial language, though it may opine on how to do so.

Ok guys pack it up, LLM's can't be intelligent because they can't translate Whale Song. GG.

I mean of all the AI Goalposts to be moved this one really takes the cake.

← PreviousPage 3 of 31Next →