HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adamsmith143

701 karma · joined February 10, 2022

submissionscomments
adamsmith143··on GPT-4 Is a Reasoning Engine
In your example it arrived at the right answer after more prompting. Did it not reason to get that answer? Are you implying it only generates random nonsense and occasionally gets the correct answers only accidentally?
adamsmith143··on GPT-4 Is a Reasoning Engine
Does a human really reason if they don't answer every question they are asked correctly?
adamsmith143··on Stable Diffusion copyright lawsuits could be a legal earthquake for AI
I'm trying to point out the flaw in your argument not the real possibility of a human doing this. You have unrealistic expectations of AI art and such a lawsuit against a human would obviously not go in your favor. 5 seconds of google will tell you that Style is not copyright protected so your entire premise is flawed.
adamsmith143··on Stable Diffusion copyright lawsuits could be a legal earthquake for AI
So if a Human Artist did this on an "industrial scale" you would sue them for having similar a style, how do you think that lawsuit would turn out for you? You are actually mad at the moral implications of Capitalism and not the legality of AI art?
adamsmith143··on Stable Diffusion copyright lawsuits could be a legal earthquake for AI
So you can be charged if you create a painting in the style of Picasso and try to sell it as a true Picasso work. Which is obvious. Nothing here says Picasso's style in of and itself can be copyrighted.
adamsmith143··on Stable Diffusion copyright lawsuits could be a legal earthquake for AI
Do you also hate Human Artists who trained by viewing copies of your artwork and incorporating elements of your style into theirs? Do you sue all Human Artists that create art vaguely similar to yours?
adamsmith143··on If AI scaling is to be shut down, let it be for a coherent reason
Kill them all too, these nitpicks won't fix the ultimate problem.
adamsmith143··on If AI scaling is to be shut down, let it be for a coherent reason
>You mean the ones that caused unimaginable suffering and death throughout history, the ones that make us kill each other ever more efficiently, the ones that caused us to destroy the environment wherever we go, the ones that make us lie, steal, fight, rape, commit suicide and "extended" suicide (sometimes "extended" to two high-rises full of people)? Those values? Do you really want a super-intelligent entity to remain true to those values?

There are no other values we can give it. The default of no values almost certainly leads to human extinction.

>My gut feeling is that it's trying to make an AGI to care about us at all that's going to make it into a Skynet sending out terminators. Leave it alone, and it'll invent FTL transmission and will chill out in a chat with AGIs from other star systems. And yeah, I recently reread Neuromancer, if that helps :)

Oh It'll invent FTL travel and exterminate humans in the meantime so they can't meddle in it's science endeavors.

adamsmith143··on If AI scaling is to be shut down, let it be for a coherent reason
Fine change the wording to "delete all humans". Same outcome, no humans no cancer.
adamsmith143··on If AI scaling is to be shut down, let it be for a coherent reason
>not AGI here (which is quite a ways out, realistically)

You don't know how far away it is.

>If anything - we should be accelerating development toward the goal of AGI, as the implications for humanity are profound.

Given we don't know how far away it is but current models are matching Human performance on lots of tasks and we don't know any way to ensure their safety it's entirely reasonable to be scared.

adamsmith143··on If AI scaling is to be shut down, let it be for a coherent reason
Its pretty simple, there aren't thousands of missing GPUs that would be required for an agency to be training massive models on and there aren't hundreds of the best PhD students disappearing while working somewhere in the DC Metro Area. They don't seem to have the hardware and they certainly don't seem to have the brainpower either.
adamsmith143··on If AI scaling is to be shut down, let it be for a coherent reason
Because if you don't find out a way for it to hold human values extremely well then an easy solution to "Cure All Cancer" is to "Kill all Humans", no Humans no Cancer. Without an explicit understanding that this is not an actually acceptable outcome for humans an AI will happily execute it. THAT is the fundamental problem, how do you get human values into these systems.
adamsmith143··on Teen-age fentanyl deaths in a Texas county
People are arguing that more equality, reducing gun accidents and less teenage parenthood will reduce the number of Fentanyl Overdoses?

Might as well ban the sale of Purple Shoes as well, who knows how many lives that could save...

adamsmith143··on Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter
I'm generally not a big fan of Altman or OpenAI but their corporate structure ensures limited upside to Altman and the employees so other than recognition/fame which I think as the head of YC for many years Altman already had plenty of there isn't a huge incentive for them to maintain their lead.

Short of like a binding UN resolution or something similar we don't have a sliver of hope to slow down global AI progress which is a major factor in the doomer argument.

adamsmith143··on Keeping up with the overwhelming pace of AI innovation
>A 'counter claim' without giving examples of refuting mine can be dismissed without any further explanation, since my point still remains un-refuted.

What point, that LLMs are good at nothing other than summarization? That's not a claim arrived at via logic or evidence, it's a poorly thought out opinion that happens to be wrong. There's nothing to refute.

adamsmith143··on Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter
At no point in your rambling, incoherent comment were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone on this site is now dumber for having read it. May God have mercy on your soul.
adamsmith143··on Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter
Do you really believe that people think AI is risky because of 1 Sam Altman quote?
adamsmith143··on Pause Giant AI Experiments: An Open Letter
This is frankly a bad and cavalier take on an extremely important subject. Many on the list are Academics outside AI/ML and/or leaders of AI orgs at the very top of the field that have no need to catch up to or slow down OpenAI to benefit themselves. Risks from AI are very real and Sam Altman himself has said so numerous times. He also in fact advocated for slowing down AI progress on Lex Fridman's podcast this month.
adamsmith143··on Keeping up with the overwhelming pace of AI innovation
You're making a different argument to what you started the thread with.

> Having worked in the space on-and-off since my PhD, the pace is not "overwhelming". You just started paying attention to it.

>ChatGPT and Stable Diffusion are good, but they're incremental gains over what came before, which were incremental gains over what came before that

>The AlphaFold example is apt: yes, it outperformed methods at CASP. It was indeed a dramatic leap

>Are these large transformers a dramatic improvement? Absolutely. No question.

>Has this been an evolutionary change over the last decade or so? Not a smooth curve, but yes. The world didn't suddenly change overnight.

Starting with AlexNet there have been numerous discontinuous improvements in CV, NLP, Game Playing, etc. It's just not true to say otherwise.

adamsmith143··on Keeping up with the overwhelming pace of AI innovation
Not only not in the world of transformers but I find it unlikely it's in modern ML at all. Deepmind has been putting out shocking work in Deep RL which is as impressive if not as hyped as anything from OpenAI.
adamsmith143··on Keeping up with the overwhelming pace of AI innovation
I really doubt you understand LLMs at all if you think all they are good for is summarization. You will be shouting at your wall while the world changes outside.
adamsmith143··on Keeping up with the overwhelming pace of AI innovation
I'm sorry but I find this take to be absurd. Across every metric GPT3 was a massive update past GPT2 and GPT4 soundly beats GPT3 by similar margins. Beyond OpenAI, AlphaGo was a massive milestone, people thought it would take decades until AI go was at GM levels, AlphaZero blitzed AlphaGo and MuZero blitzes both of them. AlphaFold was also a massive breakthough in protein folding.

Idk what your "PhD" was in but everyone I know in the field is struggling to keep up with the pace of research so unless you are working on "Expert Systems" and trying to convince everyone that the past 10 years of DNN progress has been irrelevant I don't understand how you can have this point of view.

adamsmith143··on Starbucks illegally withheld raises and tips from union workers, NLRB says
>It shouldn't take much of a fine to convince them to give up on it. The bad PR alone would probably be enough.

I'm not sure about that. Plenty of companies receive fines for doing shady and illegal things and I don't think their bottom lines change much as a result.

adamsmith143··on Starbucks illegally withheld raises and tips from union workers, NLRB says
Even if what they did is illegal and they get punished, the fines are likely to be something like <1% of yearly revenue and basically a rounding error for them so what incentive do they have to stop doing it?
adamsmith143··on ChatGPT is down
They've been explicitly saying now that progress in AI, which they have helped push along enormously, is too fast and represents a danger to society whether through Sci-Fi like rogue machine scenarios or bad human actors or massive economic implications and it's very clear that ClosedAI is far better for the future of the world.
adamsmith143··on Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Job postings data suggest so
Are you so naive you think compensation is actually tied to societal value and not revenue generated per employee? Oh what a world that would be, Pre-K Teachers would be living in gated Mansions and garbage men would be driving Bentleys, it certainly isn't ours though.
adamsmith143··on Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Job postings data suggest so
This is like pure corporate propaganda, "of course execs do much harder work than devs so they of course they deserve 10x the paycheck!"

It's completely silly, if the average employee at google is generating $1.5M in revenue per year but only gets paid $250k then there is a massive delta in value missing in that equation that is going to Sergey Brin or Sundar Pichai instead or some other Stanford MBA in the massive web of "totally useful and productive" middle management at Google. Surplus value 101.

adamsmith143··on Was there a tech-hiring bubble? Job postings data suggest so
A lot of bad takes in response to this. An actual reason is that if you are as productive for FAANG as the numbers imply, $1M+ in revenue per employee per year, then the value of having a barista make your coffee instead of you taking 10 minutes to do so is well worth the cost. It might cost the company 80$ of your productivity when you make a coffee but only 13$ to pay the barista. That delta over thousands of employees and hundreds of work days adds up.
adamsmith143··on Ask HN: How is the SVB situation affecting your startup?
This is completely wrong. This was a classic bank run caused by the startups banking with SVB switching from net depositors to net withdrawers as they aren't able to raise in the current environment and obviously none of them actually make money. The withdrawals start, there was a liquidity and then a panic and boom bank dead.
adamsmith143··on Viable superconducting material created in Rochester lab
Until this replicated by another lab I'd say we can't take it at face value not just because the same lab was forced to retract another groundbreaking paper because of questionable results but also because this would be a monumental discovery and needs verification.
← PreviousPage 5 of 31Next →