HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adamtaylor_13

1,277 karma · joined February 5, 2024

submissionscomments
adamtaylor_13··on Born Against, or why hobby programming communities are against LLM usage
You can summarize this roughly by comparing art for its own sake versus art for a purpose. If I need software for a purpose, I don't care how it is crafted, only that it is crafted well. But if I care about the art of code done well, then obviously the means matter.

I find that a lot of "pro-AI" folks are very much doing software for the ends (myself included) and in the past, we were happy with the "means" primarily because there was no other way. The "anti-AI" folks are, as mentioned, mostly in the camp of caring about the means equally with the ends.

Lots of nuance here, but those buckets seem to generalize pretty well (so far) in my experience.

adamtaylor_13··on Karpathy’s Pelican
You literally did not read the article.
adamtaylor_13··on Cookware Got Worse on Purpose: Who Owns Pyrex and All-Clad Now
I'm glad to have found this site. Though it's obviously AI-generated, the research itself is solid (I've checked).

I'm using it to avoid enshittified brands in the future.

adamtaylor_13··on Kimi K3-256k
Why stop there? No true developer needs more than 32k!

--

Jesting aside, I cannot think of a single session in recent memory that used less than ~70k tokens, so I presume you are joking.

adamtaylor_13··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
Nature != Good

We miss that much of the time, and it causes all manner of suffering.

adamtaylor_13··on The iPhone Upgrade Program is being replaced by Apple Upgrade
> That’s the entire point. They would have bought a cheaper phone

This kinda sounds like, "We should make it hard for people to make poor financial decisions." Which seems like an answer completely orthogonal to the problem at hand.

adamtaylor_13··on What AI developers could learn from Charles Bukowski?
"There is way that seems right to a man, but the end thereof is death." Proverbs 14:12

By my own admission, I often place importance on the wrong things. I am building the discipline of putting the truly important things first.

adamtaylor_13··on What AI developers could learn from Charles Bukowski?
Is this a comment toward the author?

Surely the irony isn't lost upon you that they literally are advocating for getting a life.

adamtaylor_13··on What AI developers could learn from Charles Bukowski?
I think it boils down to most of these folks don't have anything better to do. Or worse (the bucket I find myself in) this type of work is the most mentally stimulating thing I have, so I do it willfully at the expense of my wife and cats.

I'm still building the discipline to put the important stuff first!

adamtaylor_13··on I'm 38 and I Can't Support Myself Anymore
I think part of the lie is that we live for and unto ourselves. We instinctively know it's not true, yet for much of our lives we live as if it is. Until one day we find out what we knew all along.

When you suddenly become unable to "give anything" to others and become the one who must be given to, you feel a disconcerting sense of loss and powerlessness.

I don't think it really has anything to do with capitalism.

adamtaylor_13··on Benchmarking Opus 5 on SlopCodeBench
I may be crucified for asking this but: is there any proof that slop matters beyond our sensibilities as developers?

If the code is ugly, but defects are low—does it matter?

If the code is hard to read, but clients are happy—should I care?

Genuinely asking. Weird times we live in.

adamtaylor_13··on Show HN: Trylle – The Next-Gen Git Platform for Modern Teams
Or tell me what it explicitly doesn't do. I like marketing that says, "We don't X"

It's very clear and not "clever"

adamtaylor_13··on German Peasants' War
Ours is a religion of submission to God, literally calling upon us to "pick up your cross daily." Which is, to die to yourself in submitting to God's will.

Various books of the Bible were written to very specific peoples at specific times, but at the same time, to all Christians everywhere. It takes wisdom to discern to which group does an instruction apply, and when?

This isn't to say that under no circumstances can you break the law; consider Christians in countries where Christianity is unlawful, they consistently break the law and defy the government because submission to God supersedes submission to government.

This passage specifically establishes that building a "Christian Caliphate" is not a goal of Christianity nor should it be a goal of any individual Christian. In general, the government is an institution put in place by God. The general principle is that God is sovereign, so by resorting to violence to assert yourself and your rights you are in no small way asserting your own will over His.

Books have been written on this, so I'll stop here. If you're interested, you can to much deeper on this.

I just wanted to clarify the drive-by theology indicating Christians are somehow "siding" with the "elite" is a very poor understanding of the scripture and ignores basically all of history.

adamtaylor_13··on Claude Opus 5
If I recall correctly that was a bug, not malicious intent. Hanlon's razor makes me presume that's likely.
adamtaylor_13··on League of Legends designer shares game design field manual
I love AI. I'm just as AI-pilled as the next guy.

But, somewhat ironically, LLMs are unbelievably bad at writing.

I can read thousands of words from my favorite authors without getting annoyed by their tics and their grammar. People like Nikhil Suresh literally make me laugh out loud when I read their writing. But something about AI-slop-prose is just obvious and gross and annoying to read.

adamtaylor_13··on How do we stop vibe coding?
This article wasn't written for folks who just want to "turn it off". If that's you, by all means do so.

New people coming into the field will likely not have the privilege of deciding how much/little to use AI, just like I didn't really get a choice about whether I wanted to use CI or wanted to SSH straight into prod to deploy. As the industry changes, you change with it if you like being a hire-able professional.

This article was written for the folks that are interested in using AI while shaving off some of the sharper corners.

It is unfortunately wasted on people who believe you can just stuff cats back into bags.

adamtaylor_13··on Claude Opus 5
Btw Fable beat Pokémon with just vision.
adamtaylor_13··on Claude Opus 5
I asked Opus 4.8 to help me design an adapter for a 3d printed part and it actually modeled and GAVE ME the part.

That blew my mind. It doesn't surprise me that Opus 5 ups the ante.

adamtaylor_13··on League of Legends designer shares game design field manual
> shares game design field manual written entirely by AI

I fixed the title for you.

adamtaylor_13··on Claude Opus 5
You can opt out of training.

If you don't believe checking the opt-out box actually opts you out, then this sentence could be said about literally any provider.

adamtaylor_13··on Claude Opus 5
This is part of why I switched to Grok 4.5

I don't need more powerful models, I need one that responds fast enough that my attention doesn't wander to other tasks. Grok 4.5 is so fast I can just use it in-band without swapping to other tasks.

Slower than Opus 4.8, which was already miserably slow, is indeed a step in the wrong direction.

adamtaylor_13··on Em dashes are fucking amazing
I never see emdashes squeezed tightly to the word before them.

I only ever see them with an AP-style spacing before and after.

adamtaylor_13··on Why Software Factories Fail (or: harness engineering is not enough)
This has been my experience as well. While not a full "factory", I've got several mature vibed software projects.

More often than not you can "feel" when the quality has degraded. Many of these pieces leave you hanging on the assumption that once it's slopped up that's the game, it's over, you're cooked, straight to jail.

But I've yet to reach that position and be unable to pop the hood, identify the issue, and agentic-ly clean it up.

The post explicitly says it's not a skill issue, but I've yet to see any situation where an average engineer can't unslop their codebase.

adamtaylor_13··on Quality non-fiction books are the antithesis of AI slop
On a related note, I was just noting to my co-founder, as we struggle to write good case studies for our website, that I find LLMs are astoundingly bad at writing good prose.

We all know the "AI-tics" that give away a sloppily AI-written piece, but even if you steer them, they still struggle to write consistently high-quality prose.

Somehow I feel that the work of a good copywriter has never been more noticeable.

adamtaylor_13··on OverpAId – Fire your CEO. Hire the future
Is a company ever really just "ticking along" though? Seems to me like you're always sliding one way or the other, largely due to leadership at the top.
adamtaylor_13··on Advertise in ChatGPT
I don't understand how this will interact with llms.txt files (or if it does/will)

Ideally AI should scrape 400 different competing websites, those that have well-designed llms.txt files based on my query should rise towards the top, no?

I understand this is incredibly oversimplified but something like that should be the goal.

adamtaylor_13··on Xiaomi-Robotics-1
I disagree with your assertion that Trump is somehow committing genocide against Palestinians while also acknowledging that the situation there is awful and I pray it ends soon.

But last I checked the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a few thousand years older than our sitting president.

adamtaylor_13··on Agent swarms and the new model economics
Wouldn't that be in the authors' interest to disclose, if true?
adamtaylor_13··on Ask HN: How do you as a normal swe use AI?
I think you're 100% correct that you need to feel the pain that the agent is supposed to solve. It's like trying to explain to a junior the power of Rails if they've never even built a regular static HTML website. It's going to be very difficult for them to understand why things are the way they are.

I'm very allergic to "solutions just because we can". In fact, one way I use AI that may be slightly not-mainstream is that I use AI to actively pursue subtraction that I couldn't otherwise do: cutting down on all my tools I've built over the years, culling cruft: notes, scripts, comments, etc. until I'm left with a smaller footprint of stuff I know is useful.

adamtaylor_13··on Ask HN: How do you as a normal swe use AI?
Actually I feel like I'm in the goldilocks zone right now. I've tried automating more for the sake of automation, and didn't really feel any more productive. My workflows have grown naturally as I feel like AI can fill certain gaps, and as I watch other people use AI successfully.
← PreviousPage 3 of 20Next →