HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adamtaylor_13

1,277 karma · joined February 5, 2024

submissionscomments
adamtaylor_13··on Failing grades soar with AI usage, dwindling math skills in Berkeley CS classes
I've also "lost" (or rather, never had) the ability to manually manage memory, and I have no idea what my machine code actually does once my program compiles.

Yet, I'd say my career so far has been very successful and personally enriching for me.

So what am I losing? I still use my intellect day in and day out, so it can't be that I'm not using my intellect at all.

I don't find this argument persuasive.

adamtaylor_13··on Failing grades soar with AI usage, dwindling math skills in Berkeley CS classes
This is a good point! AI can't lift the weights for you.
adamtaylor_13··on Failing grades soar with AI usage, dwindling math skills in Berkeley CS classes
The presumption that we're losing "intelligence" is unproven and widely debated. I'd prefer "capability" over raw intellect any day, and my capability is definitely greater than it was a year ago.
adamtaylor_13··on Failing grades soar with AI usage, dwindling math skills in Berkeley CS classes
I feel like a lot of the lament expressed in the comments is grounded in loss aversion. We really don't like losing things—regardless of the objective (or subjective) value of that loss. We know this intellectually, but we still feel it emotionally.

I'm feeling effects of using LLMs day in and day out, but I am not yet convinced that it's overwhelmingly negative, the way much of HN seems to lean.

I derive a lot of joy from shipping outstanding code for my clients and fixing problems they're experiencing. My joy has only increased as I can now ship better code, faster, with fewer bugs. No, I don't intimately understand the code the way I used to, but I understand it enough to accomplish the end goal.

The premise of this article takes a presumed position that the grades we were posting before really mattered a whole lot. I'm not convinced that's true.

adamtaylor_13··on Meta workers can opt out of being tracked at work up to 30 min
Well I wouldn't consider myself particularly sophisticated, but I run just such a business myself.

So... no! It's not too late!

You can absolutely do that. But you'll have to network hard and find those people.

It's not impossible, and you may have to work some of those less-desirable jobs in the process. I have a theory that you'll actually find more of those companies as AI proliferates because the work that a single good engineer can do is being scaled very quickly.

adamtaylor_13··on Meta workers can opt out of being tracked at work up to 30 min
Leaving tech altogether and working for dystopian companies like Meta are just two choices in a broad band of possibilities. You could also go work for yourself.
adamtaylor_13··on I don't want my search engine to think for me
Your search engine doesn't think for you. It never did. It still doesn't, even with AI summaries. What it does do, is summarize information.

It's up to you, the human, to decide what path you get the information and how to digest it and use it. I use LLMs for 99% of my "querying" these days because 99% of the information I'm looking for is either verifiable (coding) or low-stakes (how to do low-risk DIY house thing).

If I need actual search, I use Kagi. Otherwise, Claude has taken 99.8% of what Google used to do for me and it feels better than ever.

adamtaylor_13··on Microsoft builds MacBook Pro rival with NVIDIA-powered Surface Laptop Ultra
The biggest problem here is the operating system. If they could fix that, this might be enticing.
adamtaylor_13··on Protestware for coding agents
People are free to do exactly that. The problem is very few people actually believe as strongly as they'd like to posture online.

SUVs aren't vandalized because people talk a big game online where there are zero consequences, and shrink down to the level of their actual beliefs in real life.

It's all just posturing to show that you fit in with some crowd. Very few people actually care as much as they want everyone to believe. So, uh, yeah... I guess points to the jqwik crew for being "true believers". Hope that works out as well as it should for them.

adamtaylor_13··on Protestware for coding agents
This is beyond childish. Despite many people saying it's "defensible" it's clearly as defensible as putting bear traps in your front yard beside a "Don't walk on the grass" sign and then chuckling that someone didn't do their due diligence when reading the sign.

I'd also add that this sort of "activism" is more indicative about someone's character than just waving a sign and chanting about something you feel passionately about.

It's a great way to torpedo your own career simply because you couldn't regulate your emotions.

adamtaylor_13··on Cloudflare Turnstile requiring fingerprintable WebGL
So if you need to prevent bot abuse, but also don't want an ugly captcha every time someone goes to sign up, is there a better option?
adamtaylor_13··on Anthropic surpasses OpenAI to become most valuable AI startup
That's... that's not how social perception works at all.
adamtaylor_13··on We should be more tired than the model
I'll point out that this presupposes that skill retention is necessary, as opposed to something like "taste" retention. I'm not arguing against this, just pointing out that it carries a supposition that may or may not be true.

I am not yet convinced that the skill loss is as bad as people make it out to be, nor am I convinced that "taste" degrades like "skill" does. After all, it's easy to teach someone a framework. It's very hard to communicate why something is not as functional or why the UX isn't as good as it could be.

All this to say, I believe these are valuable questions, but we should be careful what presuppositions we bring into the equation. My value has never been my ability to write code. It's been my ability to make people's problems elegantly go away. I do not believe AI is making that worse (yet).

Side-note: If it IS making my skills worse... I'll just sharpen them later. It's not like experimenting with AI for a few years is going to permanently disable me.

adamtaylor_13··on Please Use AI
I'm going to design an AI agent to preview Hacker News posts so that I don't have to sift through smug, self-righteous posts like this to get to actual, thoughtful dialog on technology.

I'm so sick and tired of the endless slaps on the wrist because I choose to live my life in a way that the author would not prefer.

adamtaylor_13··on About LLMs at Zig Days
You claimed to "fix a logical fallacy" by merely stating your opinion that this is theft. Many (most?) disagree with the premise that using an LLM is somehow tantamount to theft.

I invited you to attempt to present an argument, which you have neatly side-stepped.

adamtaylor_13··on About LLMs at Zig Days
Re-stating an opinion does not somehow establish it as a fact. I'd welcome an effort to support what you're saying instead of just hand-waving this as some sort of self-evident fact of the universe.
adamtaylor_13··on About LLMs at Zig Days
Why do people insist on using extreme rhetoric like this? If you don't personally like using LLMs, that's fine. The only point this comment serves is to stir the pot.

Using your first example, if it was true and universally accepted that this was plaigerism--we wouldn't use it, now would we? But that's not the universal opinion so instead you're just twisting someone else's comment to stir the pot.

Again, if you don't personally like LLMs and you personally feel like it's plagiarism cool, don't use them. Or at least make an argument for it.

But as it stands, this comment is just low-effort trolling.

adamtaylor_13··on Dynamic Workflows in Claude Code
Yep. And yet, there's still some level of specification you have to do.
adamtaylor_13··on Dynamic Workflows in Claude Code
While pedantically correct, I think the comment above assumed that you've correctly specified the work. If you can't correctly specify your work, AI agents are just going to help you get a non-solution faster.
adamtaylor_13··on Claude Opus 4.8
People get so wrapped around the axle with "anthropomorphizing". For regular folks with no technical background, sure maybe a bit of caveat sprinkled here or there is useful to help them understand what is or isn't true, but on HN it would seem to me that the bar is high enough that we can just use shared language to generally talk about capabilities.

When they say "Honesty" I don't think to myself, "Goodness, does this model have moral understanding?" No, I understand they mean it's less likely to directly bullshit me, which models frequently do.

I don't feel like this level of pedantry around language is useful for people who more or less know what's going on with LLMs. (Again, I concede that perhaps with a less technical audience, there's more need for it.)

adamtaylor_13··on Can we have the day off?
Others are willing to do my job for less. And yet... here I am making what I make.
adamtaylor_13··on Why AI Agents Cannot Change Software Systems
This is a lot of words to confirm what we already know: we have exosuits, not robots.

Use them as capability enhancers, not drones who go do all the things without review.

adamtaylor_13··on Magnifica Humanitas
I believe capitalism is the least-bad system we've created so far. Perhaps there is a better one, but as I said elsewhere the failed experiment of communism isn't one we should keep attempting--the cost in human lives is far too high.

But, to your other point, I think human greed is innate. I can't think of evidence that would suggest that greed is somehow cultural or learned. Boil the system down to the lowest common denominator, you find greed. Scale it up: greed. No matter what you do, you cannot remove human greed systematically.

adamtaylor_13··on Magnifica Humanitas
I did not excuse capitalism from critique. I'm not sure how you arrived there from my comment.
adamtaylor_13··on Magnifica Humanitas
The specific evil in my mind was the Great Leap Forward, but there are dozens we could draw from history.

And I attribute them to communism because that's literally how history attributes them, though obviously pro-Communism thinkers would disagree.

adamtaylor_13··on Magnifica Humanitas
Re: B my guess is probably not (human nature and all that), but I'm open to ideas! I just think failed experiments where tens of millions died are probably not ones where we just flippantly "try again".
adamtaylor_13··on Magnifica Humanitas
You have to somehow separate the horrible evils that have been inflicted on the world by Communism before you can get people to consider words closely associated with it.

Being anti-communism is good not only for the individual's health but for their society as a whole.

adamtaylor_13··on Bun support is now limited and deprecated
Those studies have well known flaws. I'm measuring my output so I happen to know I'm not only going faster, but the quality is better.

I'm not vibe-measuring my output ;)

adamtaylor_13··on Bun support is now limited and deprecated
We desperately need some new terminology to describe using LLMs to support development work. "Vibe code" has a strict definition but no one really cares. I have a really hard time believing that the Rust port was 100% "vibed" the way the original definition was laid out.

It's a big slushy of emotions that I understand (both positive and negative) but it makes it so hard to actually tells what problem someone actually has when they just use "vibe coding" as a general LLM usage slur.

I'm using LLMs to assist my development and I'm measurably (in all the ways we engineers could possibly care about) doing better work faster.

adamtaylor_13··on AI is just unauthorised plagiarism at a bigger scale
I read the article, but I disagree. People are angry, and that's completely understandable. I believe it's a justifiable response to the huge upheaval happening. But being angry about LLMs does not magically transmute their output into "plagiarism".

It has always been possible to take someone's public work, put a twist on it, and then sell it as unique. (I'm not making a moral/ethical argument, only a legal one.) I have yet to see any evidence that LLMs are fundamentally different from that approach.

← PreviousPage 6 of 20Next →