HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adfgadfgaery

95 karma · joined March 8, 2022

submissionscomments
adfgadfgaery··on M1 Ultra Geekbench Score
>The pro-AMD anti-Intel commentary on the internet got completely out of control for a while.

Not really. It was entirely justified, but things have changed. Prior to Alder Lake Intel really was just plain worse than AMD in most respects.

Processor vendors have leapfrogged each other many, many times before. A new architecture is supposed to beat everything else on the market. Recent years have been weird because Intel bungled 10nm at about the same time AMD bungled Bulldozer. We are getting back to normal.

adfgadfgaery··on Apple M1 Ultra
It doesn't make much sense to me. The M1 is designed to have memory in the same package as the processor. This leads to reduced latency and increased bandwidth. Moving to off-package memory might totally destroy its performance, and there is an upper limit on how much memory can go in the package.

The M1 Ultra is already a little light on memory for its price and processing power; it would have much too little memory for a cloud host.

adfgadfgaery··on Apple M1 Ultra
This line is nonsense and you can safely ignore it. There have been multi-chip-modules that act like a single socket for many years. In particular, pretty much every current AMD CPU works that way. I guarantee you that for the M1 Ultra, just like every CPU before it, the abstraction will be leaky. Programmers will still care about the interconnect when eking out the last few percent of performance.

Remember the Pentium D? Unfortunately, I used to own one.

adfgadfgaery··on Apple M1 Ultra
The M1 Ultra is by a very wide margin the bigger of the two. According to Tom's Hardware [1], top-of-the-line Epycs have 39.54 billion transistors. That is about a third of the 117 billion in the M1 Ultra. Apple builds bigger than anyone else, thanks largely to their access to TSMC's best process.

The M1 Ultra is a workstation part. It goes in machines that start at $4,000. The competition is Xeons, Epycs, and Threadrippers.

adfgadfgaery··on Apple M1 Ultra
Yes, certainly. I don't think that's relevant in this case, though. Why would anyone care if their workstation CPU draws 60W or 200W? It's easy to cool in either case and the power consumption is trivial.

M1 is clearly the best design on the market for mobile devices and is merely very good for desktops. Let's keep the enthusiasm realistic.

adfgadfgaery··on Apple M1 Ultra
That line is blatantly dishonest, but not for the reasons you pointed out. While the i9-12900K is a 16-core processor, it uses Intel's version of big.LITTLE. Eight of its 16 cores are relatively low performance 'E' cores. This means it has only half the performance cores of the M1 Ultra, yet it achieves 3/4 of the performance by Apple's own graphic.

Alder Lake has been repeatedly shown to outperform M1 core-per-core. The M1 Ultra is just way bigger. (And way more power efficient, which is a tremendous achievement for laptops but irrelevant for desktops.)

adfgadfgaery··on Apple M1 Ultra
Ice Lake shipped in 2019. The current generation is Alder Lake, which is slightly ahead of the M1 in single-threaded performance according to most benchmarks.
adfgadfgaery··on Apple M1 Ultra
AMD is currently shipping high-end CPUs built with up to nine dies. Their ordinary desktop parts have up to three. They are not built with "cache in-between". There is one special I/O die but it does not contain any cache. Each compute die contains its own cache.
adfgadfgaery··on Ford to Impose Non-Negotiable Pricing on EV Sales as Part of Model E Plan
No one I know likes wearing a seatbelt.
adfgadfgaery··on Ford to Impose Non-Negotiable Pricing on EV Sales as Part of Model E Plan
>But the overwhelming majority of owners think it's great.

I don't care at all what the overwhelming majority of owners think. Maybe 95% of customers are happy to have saved a few hours in a dealership, but when the 5% are without a car for six months that's pretty cold comfort.

The problems I am discussing are very serious. It is not enough for them to be uncommon; they must be unheard of.

adfgadfgaery··on Ford to Impose Non-Negotiable Pricing on EV Sales as Part of Model E Plan
Tesla's no-dealership model has been an unmitigated disaster. I have never heard of any other company making people wait months for repairs, nor have I heard of any other company repeatedly making delivery estimates that are wrong by months, nor have I heard of any other company delivering cars over a year after they were paid for.
← PreviousPage 2 of 2