HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

adityapurwa

456 karma · joined February 25, 2015

submissionscomments
adityapurwa··on Ask HN: What is something you built but never marketed?
I built Playtune https://playtune.app - a web game where you can turn any YouTube videos into a rhythm game. It comes from a frustation from playing rhythm game but they have limited song catalog. Playtune literally have millions of song that you can play. Any song that is uploaded to YouTube can be played as long as it allow embedding. You can even make a rhythm game out of five minute craft videos if you want or linus tech tips.
adityapurwa··on Digital banking, now halal
I am just trying to explain that profits in Islam are different from interest as you mentioned. If you want to learn more, I suggest you find an islamic scholar who had expertise on this field, they have better understanding on the law. It would result in misunderstanding if you tried to applied your terms / perspective without knowing the details of the law.

Best of luck!

adityapurwa··on Digital banking, now halal
Halal is just another word for sharia compliant. If it is against islamic law (sharia), then it is not halal (haram). Halal certification is a different thing.

When you deposits money, bank might offer you annual interest of 1%. No matter what happened, whether the bank is at loss or not, you get the 1%. This is riba. If the purpose of the deposits is to be used as investment, then it must be clear from the beginning and there would be risk of loss.

When bank lend money to a person, bank asked for an interest of say 5%, bank does not care if the person is profiting or not, they will get their additional 5%. This is riba. Lending in islam is a social activity and no profits should occur from it. Would there be risk for lender? Yes. Would it means they can profits from it? In Islam, No.

I am not confident with the premise that you said a business is guaranteed to earn profits. I’ve seen business rise and fall, pre covid and after covid. I’ve started some of my own business and some got profitable and some doesn’t, some were profitable in the beginning, some started to see declines.

I don’t understand what is sneaky about sharia law for banking, it prevents anyone from being unfair and that anyone know the risk from a transaction, and that no one should profits from their partner loss and that loan shall not be profitable.

adityapurwa··on Digital banking, now halal
> 2) if you fail to pay, the property is in the hands of the "not-" bank that will kick you out, you will STILL owe them, generally more money than was to be repaid for you to get the property 3) if the bank gets into financial trouble you will lose your house 4) there are none of the normal protections (such as maximum interest rates, limits on administrative fees, ... and technically 2) is also an example of lack of protections)

Then I assume 2 would no longer be a risk? Bank owned the property, if you failed to pay bank will sold it to someone else who can pay, bank will then return your money if it sold higher than the set price.

Point is 3 is a weak contract issue, when you made the purchase, the contract should be clear that bank can not seize the house unless you failed to pay. If the contract says bank can cancel the transaction however they want or whenever they have issue, no one would want to do business with them. Imagine accepting a project but we put the terms, we can cancel the project and not return your money if we have issues with it.

Again 4 is also a contract issue, we have to draft the contract to make it feasible for both parties. It is basically an installment, you buy $100k house for $100/month. That’s it, the values are clear, the monthly payment will not go higher or lower, you can even pay the remaining directly with hard cash on the next month if you want.

adityapurwa··on Digital banking, now halal
The argument is not from me, but from scholars and religious researcher and I am just forwarding it on HN. The money you put on your digital wallet should not magically increase. It should be like your physical one. When you put $100, that’s what you get. When you put $100 and you get $110 without trade is riba. When you buy $100 for $110 is riba. Riba is when money magically appears without any effort/business. When you put money into a wallet, the terms is that you just want to store it, you don’t want the wallet to somehow circulate your money into investment, that’s not wallet, thats bank. If it is the business you do the deal with that provides cashback (you buy meat and the meat store give you 10% discount or 10% cashback) then it is allowed as they are the first party who were part of the transaction, you don’t “lend” them money at all.

Credit card that charges interest/fee is already considered riba in Islam, no need to go into the cash back situation as it is already forbidden in the first place.

The Al Quran clearly answers your questions. “God forbids riba and permitted trade/business”. Riba had 0 risk for the lender, while investment/trade/business has risk. It is unfair to invest but only wanted profits, in business there’s a risk of loss, and there’s a chance of profits. Investing time and skills, or money for other business is allowed. No one would label it riba. When you starts being unfair by investing and you wanted only profits in return, without risk of loss - then that’s loan, not investment.

The etymology definition of riba is interest, but the actual ruling around it and the law is very complex.

I agree that some financial institutions are just using the label Sharia and Halal while in actualities it is just conventional banking.

adityapurwa··on Digital banking, now halal
In Islam, the bank has to own the house 100% if they want to sell it. You are not allowed to sell item that isn’t yours in Islam. If the bank purchased the house via leasing and that it isn’t 100% owned by them, they are not allowed to sell it to anyone at all. You can not sell loan for loan in Islam.

It is similar to a seller buying some cars for $10k each, and sell them on their dealership for $15k each. They can provide installment payment for the buyer and sell it for $20k each and they can pay it per month for $500. The difference between price is not loan/interest, its their profits.

adityapurwa··on Digital banking, now halal
Credit card charges interest, and any kind of interest is considered usury/riba and it is forbidden. Loan was supposed to be social activities where the other party should not benefits anything from it. If they want to provide money and gain profits, then they can do the investment contracts, which means now there’s a possibility of loss for the investor. This is halal and considered as a partnership.

Digital wallet is recognized as such: 1. User “lend” money to the digital wallet provider when they top up, say $100 2. The money is used for any kind of things as it enters the circulation of the wallet provider, it could be invested, it could be loss 3. When wallet provider provides cashback, say they spent $100 then they obtained back $10 4. The $10 is considered as interest because now the user have $110 on their wallet (the $100 already spent though) - despite they only “lend” the wallet provider $100.

Conventional bank and conventional credit cards exist in Indonesia, some provides cash back and other kind of rewards. So yes, it does exist.

adityapurwa··on Diluting blood plasma rejuvenates tissue, reverses aging in mice
There are various blood removal method, one of method that I’ve seen and commonly used is Hijamaz/Bekam. A small incision is made on the skin (usually the back); then a suction cup is used to draw the blood out. It is widely popular in Asia, I usually see it done by Moslem as they are recommended by their prophet to do so. Make sure the method is correct and that the equipment is sterile though.
adityapurwa··on How toilet paper is made (2014) [video]
It’s an Indian name but I am not Indian and quite far from India :)

It’s an interesting story from your side! Wish for your children to be healthy, and for everyone else that are having crisis of TP and other essentials items to be able to get through it. Stay safe!

adityapurwa··on How toilet paper is made (2014) [video]
Wow! Thank you! It is embarrassing and might be impolite to ask people how do they clean themselves, but today I learned something that might be useful when I travel. Thanks!
adityapurwa··on How toilet paper is made (2014) [video]
Exactly - That's why I wondered how because I really want to know how in case I traveled to a place that only uses toilet paper again :)

But in my place, you are not allowed to throw anything into the toilet and use a bin instead.

adityapurwa··on How toilet paper is made (2014) [video]
Hi, thank you for asking!

Most of the public facilities in my town are equipped with bidet/jet + toilet paper (some might provide soap at the toilet, if not; they always provide soap in the hand sink. In this case, it's better not to touch your private parts with bare hands and use the toilet paper to fully clean it). All of the office that I went to always provides soap and toilet paper. So you don't have to bring your own kit.

The shape of the toilet and the positioning of the bidet/jet definitely could reduce the amount of water going outside the (pardon) hole. But there's always some of it that got out. It is advised that we wipe the water on the seat with toilet paper to make it dry. Some also provide a cleaning solution to wipe the seat before using it.

Usually, there's a cleaning service nearby that always wipe the floor and clean everything.

From my personal experience with toilet paper, I need to use a load of it to make sure its thick enough to protect my hands from touching it directly as there's no water to wash it later except outside in the hand sink. I could easily use half of the roll to fully clean myself and make sure there is no residue at all (further wipes doesn't leave any mark behind the paper). Also, we don't throw the paper into the (pardon) hole, there's a dedicated bin for it and the smells (pardon) when it is opened is a whole new problem (I don't know if the gas is dangerous, but its really something). But then again, as it is not cleaned with soap, I am sure there are some bacteria left behind and it makes me feel uncomfortable.

I don't know what to say about the perception of people, but I do think it does change the perception, I am just not sure how :)

adityapurwa··on How toilet paper is made (2014) [video]
I always wondered how people used toilet paper to clean themselves as I tried it once before when I travelled to a place where they only have toilet paper and it is a bad user experience and incredibly messy for me. The amount of paper required to totally clean myself (pardon) properly is massive.

I live in a a place where we use a bidet to clean ourself, or the water jet thing if it doesn’t have any bidet. Then we put a soap in our left hand and wipe it (pardon) on the area of interest to clean everything as we wash it with water. Then we wash our hands and its clean and refreshing.

Additionally, I combined both. First cleaning with water and soap, then wipe it with toilet paper. I personally think this combination is good, its clean, and it does not waste a lot of paper.

adityapurwa··on The future of design tools
My memories might be blurry. But I think it was photoshop, and there was this slice tool where you can define the segments of the design and export it to HTML. But Fireworks might also have the same feature, I personally never used it so I can’t say for sure.

Oh also remember Dreamweaver :)

adityapurwa··on Show HN: Infection Simulation
Thanks! Will update it to credit their inspirations:)
adityapurwa··on Ask HN: How are you coping with all the (mostly bad) news around you?
Here’s my personal take:

1. I don’t trust news by default, when I saw something that might affects me, just then I started digging the facts across multiple sources.

2. I don’t share news, even if that could help others, unless I am 100% sure its a factual news.

3. Focus on what I can control, e.g government trying to hide something? Its not like I have the power to uncover the facts and I am not sure either if they’re trying to hide something.

4. Think positively, judge what is in front of you, stay safe by default. Government saying no one is infected with corona yet? Think positively and believe them, and stay safe by self social distancing. Unless you have the knowledge and resources to do research, its gonna waste a lot of your time while you can use it to prepare for your safety and those around you.

5. As for WFH, changes are always hard. Make sure to keep communicating and clarifying things that aren’t clear. Keep notes of anything important. Get enough sunlight, exercise, stay clean, drink enough water.

6. Whatever happens, happens. Remove all negative thoughts, for every hardship, there’s ease and comfort at the end ~ like how its always been (think about a hard problem from the past, and how it can be solved and there we are, still here and strong and learned something).

Best wishes! TLDR; Ignore news by default, stay positive!

adityapurwa··on The future of design tools
I remember when slicing means using the slice feature from Photoshop. Now slicing is just writing code and copying bits of css from Figma (or something similar). Ah the good old web where (almost) everything is an image :D
adityapurwa··on Ask HN: What are you thankful for?
For everything ~ The events had that happened to me, the people that I had in life, is like a bunch of neural network that made me what I am now. It doesn’t have to be always positive, a negative weight is also the reason my life points to what it is now.

Not to say my life is perfect, but with the flaws I had, people still cared about me.

Thank you my family, friends, enemies - everyone. One can’t be grateful to God until one be thankful for the kindness of others.

adityapurwa··on Office pranks should not end with the ER, vomit, or tears
We try to keep our workplace a prank-free zone. Even a simple prank of turning off lamp when someone in a bathroom is not permitted.

Not that our workplace is a strict and quiet like a library. Its pretty much alive with jokes here and there.

Pretty much the only “pranks” we got is screenshotting someone face during a call when they make funny expressions and we shared it to a Slack channel dedicated for that.

adityapurwa··on Interactive Space / Planet Simulator
I really love space / orbital mechanics, so I made this for fun and hoped everyone enjoyed it! Not based on actual physics, if you know how actual physics works for simulating orbital mechanics, feel free to edit the code!
adityapurwa··on Ask HN: Biographies recommendations – both Westerner and Non-westerner
The Biography of Prophet Muhammad: https://www.amazon.com/Ar-Raheeq-Al-Makhtum-Sealed-Nectar-Bi...

Learning the ups & downs of a human, who tried to change the world, and delivered the religion of Islam.

adityapurwa··on DigitalOcean Kubernetes Is Now Generally Available
Congratulations! A personal fan of DO because of its simplicity and its easy to understand transparent pricing.

I hope that with the addition of more features, DO still kept its simplicity.

Not really into Kubernetes yet (no personal project that requires it, but at work we used it), but the first time I tried Kubernetes was at DO (the guide on getting started need some improvements).

adityapurwa··on Mercury – Banking built for startups
What is the availability of the service for countries outside US? Is it supported? If not, what are the plans for supporting it?
adityapurwa··on Stellarium 0.19
I think its because I remembered reading about Alcyone being a star that our solar system orbits. It was called the great sun I think?

Also if you opened Stellarium and looked at the Pleiades where Alcyone resides, you could see blue-ish formation and it looks beautiful for me.

adityapurwa··on Stellarium 0.19
I remembered when I was in junior high school, I used to play with this software and also Celestia. I even created my own sky culture just out of curiosity and because I love looking up at stars at night. It feels beautiful that we can change the time, travel back and noticed that its the same stars people had been seeing since ancient times.

Celestia also helped me understand how alone and isolated is our planet. I would move the focus to mars, then sun, then nearby stars, then my personal favorite Alcyone, then out of the galaxy. It showed me how vast the universe is.

Stellarium helped me see the stars from earth. Celestia helped me see the earth from the stars.

Amazing software that make my childhood feels wonderful.

Thank You!

adityapurwa··on The cloud skills shortage and the unemployed army of the certified
This is so well written and beautiful. Thanks for putting it on this perspective.
adityapurwa··on Ask HN: Is it normal to fall out of love with coding?
Thats exactly what Ive been feeling recently. But then I realized, we evolved, we grew, thats why our passion might change, and maybe you found a new passion that feel more exciting that coding.

I just written a piece of mind that might help you notice, whats going on with your passion. You can read it at https://link.medium.com/Td65gAxIkT

adityapurwa··on Towards a Better Pythagorean Cup
I still don’t understand what is the purpose of having such a cup, wouldn’t it just waste the water or used to limit the amount of water?

Anyone could help me, what is the usage and purpose of P cup?

adityapurwa··on Skim reading is the new normal. The effect on society is profound
I don't know whether this is the effect of me having read a lot of documentation by skimming, now I skim almost everything that I read.

I think most non-tech people that I met still reading normally.

adityapurwa··on Startup School: Every Company That Applied Is Now Accepted
I was so happy seeing the email of me being accepted to Startup School, but then I saw another email about it being an error, I am a bit sad, but then after reading I'm feeling happy again, than you to YC for giving us an opportunity.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →