165 karma · joined December 14, 2020
But she is well known for being a philanthropist and for taking stance against "dirty money", so she probably deserves some credit.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/disney-...
crypto is as easy to steal as any other property.
I was just playing along the game "crypto is safer"
it's not
> If an attacker takes the keys to your bank or the keys to your wallet you are compromised
Nope.
If I can prove that the keys to my bank account were stolen I don't lose anything.
That's why, again, we use banks.
> Maybe your bank is insured and will refund your withdrawals if you can prove you were forced to withdraw by an attacke
it's a requirement for members of the World Bank
go see the list of Countries
it includes places like Liberia, Afghanistan, Nicaragua
of course in Colombia or Los Angeles (same level of criminal behaviour) it happens more than in safer places, that still means that the greatest danger is losing your life, not your money.
and how is that different when using crypto?
I don't think that people using crypto become magically bullet proof.
> this is just ignorant - I've witnessed this multiple times. Maybe it's you living in Italy that has no exposure to the realities of poorer countries if you're ignorant of this common attack.
where exactly?
can you point me to some info?
you probably don't know that banks have to reimburse you if someone stole your money from the ATM, because it's their duty to protect them.
but even admitting you are right, they can only steal the amount of money you can withdraw from the ATM
if they get the keys to your wallet using the proverbial gun pointed at your head, you lose everything and can't get it back
police can't even do anything about it (to make it clear, you can prove you had the money before they were stolen, because the bank keeps a log of the transactions made by the ATM machine and can tie them to your persona, how can you prove those bitcoins were your property? if you own the keys you own the wallet)
paraphrasing Asimov
my ignorance is not as good as your knowledge
> You seem to have little clue how cryptocurrencies even work here
doesn't a point stand on its own, not based on the authority of the person making the point?
who said that? ... I can't remember
anyway, I was involved in btc from 2014 to 2016.
dropped it and never looked back.
> Now of course someone can put a gun to your head and demand your private key, but they won't have any indication that you even OWN a private key with crypto whereas with fiat they can just raid your house and claim the cash.
that's why we have banks and don't keep our money under the mattress.
so that the bank is responsible of keeping it safe and I don't lose it if the bank gets robbed.
what happens to my bitcoins if someone robs them?
but let's imagine you are in a poor country, can't open a bank account because the system doesn't accept you, you don't trust it, there is no bank system in your country, whatever...
now imagine you need to buy something that your family needs. you convert your bitcoins to fiat money (someway, that's another cane of worms entirely), because of course you can buy a Tesla with bitcoins, but not primary goods, and you are back at square one: you have cash in your home that is not safe.
> I'm not sure what ledger you think will prevent criminals from taking cash from your house or bank in the same manner
do you seriously don't know?
> people at gunpoint are made to withdraw cash from ATMs. It's common enough.
it's not.
because you can only withdraw a small amount of money from ATM (€ 250 in Italy) so the incentive is close to zero.
thieves steal the ATM machine and try to break it later
it's extremely rare, but it happens.
but even then the incentive is very low, because if you break an ATM machine the money inside is tainted with a special paint that makes it useless and highly recognizable.
> Again, there's no situation where crypto is easier to steal than a countries fiat.
bitcoins are useful only when converted to fiat money.
you can't buy bread for your family with bitcoins in Somalia.
You can't in Italy as well.
infact they steal your fiat money, which is much more valueable for a thief.
anyway you seem to not understand how developing countries work, at all.
money is not stolen from you, it's seized by corrupt governments and corrupt police forces.
crypto doesn't solve that, in any way.
if you can hide crypto, they will seize the goods you buy with them.
don't believe the hype
-- Public Enemy
do you own BTC?
anyway, you don't have to believe me (again)
> According to bitinfo, which tracks the total number and value of bitcoin addresses, 75% of addresses are home to less than 0.01 bitcoin, and 97.54% have a balance of less than one bitcoin
hardly nonsense
their nominal (aka imaginary) value is right now $60,000 dollars each, in real money
if btc could not be traded in fiat currencies, which is the real goal of every btc investor, their value would drop again to zero
because that's their real (aka physical) value
it's accurate
you don't have to believe me, just think that Satoshi alone owns 1% of the bitcoins in circulation, than there are a major crime organization in Bulgaria that owned $ 1.2 billion worth of btc (currently owned by the Bulgaria government), the FBI that seized many bitcoins around the World (1.5% of the total), including those of silkroad, followed by btc trading companies.
only a quarter million users (4% of the total) own a full bitcoin, while the majority owns less than a half bitcoin.
they bought at X and sold at X minus some, not much, but a loss nonetheless
or bought at Y and sold at Y plus some small amount and.never tried again, for various reasons including "not worth the risk".
technically not a loss, but not a good investment either.
also many thousands wallets are inaccessible because the keys were lost (a friend of mine made almost two bitcoins in payments 8 years ago, he lost the keys soon after...)
while the 1% got extremely rich, the 99% had neither the capital or the will to risk to get there. which is completely understandable.
I don't really understand why people don't read other people comments
I've literally said "as an Italian with roots in Africa" my African family was dirty poor and my Italian family isn't reach either.
I guess you are not from a poor country, so why are you imposing your rich country world view on me?
trustless systems are THE problem in a "restricted country" you'd know if you'd ever visited one.
They can and will take waway from you everything at will, imagine what would happen to a family that suddenly has money to spend but nobody can say where the money is coming from...
if there's no proof that the money is yours, you can't claim the ownership, taking it away from you it's easier.
"but... but... there's an entry in a global immutable ledger that says that the money was transfered from this anonymous wallet to my anonymous wallet and..."
"so you have no document proving that the money is yours! they are legally of the government now. we're also taking the keys of the wallet."
living the life of warlords or mobsters or arms dealer, hiding the sources of your income like criminals, is not what people in developing countries want!
they want banks and laws like everybody else
they don't want to try to be rich by investing in a pump and dump speculative asset so that Musk can make more money.
They absolutely want trusted systems, as small as possible, so they can trust them, not the global financial tools of the richest 1% elité
Of course I received a couple downvotes, that rippled over my previous comments on completely unrelated topics, like this one, just because my other comments where more than 24 hours old and they couldn't be downvoted as per HN rules (the parent comment was already 15 hours old when received the only downvote - meaning nobody cared for it - at the same time of the btc thread that was fresh).
> You cannot downvote comments which are direct replies to your own comment, and you cannot downvote 24 hours after the original comment was made.
If downvotes where ided, it would be obvious that the downvotes on the comments on this thread were just retaliation from the frustrated owners of bitcoins whose propaganda was being questioned.
The id doesn't have to be the real useranme, it could be a random id that identifies a user for a brief period of time (48 hours) so that other users could report the issue, knowing that it's not their paranoia, but a real thing.
so it would be illegal to send crypto money
if we are exploring illegal ways to do things, crypto is just one of many solutions and probably not the cheapest or easiest
> Assuming that you can trade Bitcoin on both ends, it really is often the simplest way to simply move money between people outside the formal banking system
Talking about Africa, as an Italian with African roots, it's not.
the idea that you need cutting edge technology to solve developing countries problems is a die hard one and represent a "rather privileged Western notion", developing countries have their own systems that already work.
When there is a mobile network, people are able to send money even without an internet connection using mobile phones of 4 generations ago. In Africa it is possible since middle 2000s.
For example: https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/M-Pesa
In many African countries, where China is financing developing projects, you can use WeChat.
Anyway, you can already send money to Burundi, Cameroon, Ghana, Kenya, Madagascar, Malawi, Mozambique, Rwanda, Tanzania, Uganda, Zambia, and Zimbabwe (and many others https://www.xoom.com/about) using Xoom
Yes, Iran or Venezuela or North Korea are not there, because that would be illegal for an US business, but it's illegal to send crypto as well. The hard part of sending money to such countries is not technical, it's legal, I understand if people want to send money back to their families, but it's an hard task by design when people living in those countries aren't even allowed to leave the country or own a bank account in a foreign country (because of the US)
https://www.euronews.com/2020/02/13/italian-banks-are-closin...
Crypto doesn't solve that problem, it only makes the people at both ends liable.
Do you think that the US would allow bitcoins to flow in Iran to finance what they consider an enemy regime? (rightfully or not)
Besides, if you want to send money to some controversial countries, there are other solutions, already available https://yekpay.com/en/irr-remittance/transfer-money
You don't need no crypto and developing countries need no Western saviours.
the expenses to keep the system running are diluted too.
probably less than 1% made a lot of money, the rest lost some.
if the spin becomes "Biden wants it" without any proof, Biden videos will keep being downvoted only because those who oppose to him think he is censoring YouTube
But that's not what downvotes on YouTube should be used for
I am sure Biden as the President of the USA has the power to ask YouTube to reset the counters and call it a mistake, there would be no need to change the entire platform for everybody else
there is nothing more hostile to users than the fake information YouTube is providing
I would go as far as to remove the votes completely and sort the videos randomly
It's the same old story of HN downvotes
They happen randomly, sometimes users are targeted by bots that downvote everything they write and, most of all, if there is no way to know who downvoted you, the only way to survive it is to make a new account, because "moderators" don't care, their job is not to protect users, but to protect their employer.
Same goes for YouTube they are an ads company disguised as a UGC platform.
Advertisers and Premium subscribers are the real users.
Wanna really be user-friendly?
Show voters' ids!
We all know it will never happen.
and is the tree I am cutting a battery too?
wouldn't it be easier (and more sustainable) then to plant trees than mine bitcoins?
So yes, it's arithmetically a total waste.
Why don't you?
If higher cognitive functions are not necessary, than a virus can have free will.
bovines don't lack self narrative, they lack the ability to create complex communication systems.
> Watch them demonstrate a learned skill
and how do you know it's not merely imitation?
btw, insects can learn too
> The experiment which showed a human brain reaches a decision before conscious awareness of that decision?
the experiment that showed a lag between cerebral activity and actual action that was labeled as "brain takes a decision before we do" even though Libet never said it, but has been disproved 40 years later (the effect exists, but it doesn't show lack of free will at all)
> we agree humans and non human animals pass and fail the same tests?
not until their mentoring will include notions of ancient past civilazations that are long dead but transmitted their knowledge
also, not until they will be able to reconstruct their past history and of the entire universe by observing and studying remains, without any prior knowledge of what they are
see, if you look from afar a soapbox car and a real car look very similar
but if you look them closer, they are nothing alike
> You can do that with any positive-negative reinforcement mechanism, doesn’t need morality etc.
where's the freedom if the reactions have been engineered through training?
I did
poor terms to describe what we already don't have a solid explanation for
> whose language I do not speak would pass and fail exactly the same tests as me if there was a test that didn’t depend on language.
it doesn't matter, cows lack the tools to explain themselves, we don't
namely, in this case, a language (any language!)
> Quick internet search of teaching cows tricks says they can act in a non-predetermined way
can you prove it? :)
And how do you know it won't end up like the Libet experiment?
> And animals copy each other, so it’s not like non-humans in general can’t learn from each other, though I don’t know about bovines in particular
They don't have history books though, and schools and teachers
DNA does not help much if the knowledge dies with its creator
> If you weren’t even trying to change my mind, congratulations
I don't believe in free will the philosophical tool
I think we have machinery that we still do not understand that make us what we are and most of what we are is due superior processing power
It doesn't matter to me ifnI chose to move my arm, when I am driving and see an obstacle I don't have to think to use the brakes and I am thankful that training built up new neuro-paths to react that way
> Why would it involve those things, and why do you believe cows can’t forecast the consequences of actions?
because to forecast the consequences of every action you need to be able to judge the consequences
if you don't have a framework to judge the consequences, you can't forecast them or at best you can simply forecast an action-reaction scenario: this happens and then this happens, but if you cannot give them a score, all scenarios are equal
Exactly.
As I've said if they can't explain to us what they are doing and why, it is completely useless to try to frame or define it.
it would simply be what we think it is, but not the real thing
> Conversely, there’s learned helplessness — discovered by animal research and yet also demonstrated in humans. Do humans demonstrating this lack free will?
difference being humans can explain why they ran and we can rationalize post facto and learn from each other
children don't run if they see a gun
do they lack free will, chose to not move, or lack the ability (and the knowledge) to process that information?
free will probably does not even exists as consciousness, they are poor terms to describe what we already don't have a solid explanation for
but since we are able to process context, something cows are not capable of, I understood that OP meant the most common meaning of free will: acting in a non predetermined way (however bad or inexact as a definition it is)
cows don't
because we have selected them in centuries and only kept the most docile, so it is expected that they won't run or act in expectedly, we literally engineered them to be what they are, we can rake it for granted, the same way we can be sure that a car with an empty tank won't start
asking for a satisfying definition of free will in this context completely misses the point
yes they could still have free will in the sense that they chose to walk or eat orm ove their tail, of course
but in that sense a plant chose to grow towards the light or not?
I actually believe free will does not exists and everything is pre-determined.
We are born and have to die, don't get to chose our parents, how we look, where we are born, our gender etc. etc.
We can however micromanage the time in between being born and dying, as every other living creature in the World, but we have far more sophisticated micro managing tools
we also have vastly superior tools in general, we are the only animal on the planet that can control fire and have an opposable thumb thus we are the only animal on the planet that could evolve to the level we have reached
which also gave us the ability to entertain ourselves with intellectual riddles such as free will
> I'm not asking if animals understand free will, but if they have it
as I've said I don't believe free will exists, but a cow lack the machinery to process the concept of free will, which also involves guilt, morality, responsibility and deliberation AKA being able to determine the consequences of different courses of actions.
If cows have it, it's not like ours, it must be something far simpler.
the point about aggression is that cows still have their own personalities, but that doesn't qualify as freedom of choice
many people see cows behaving differently and assume they chose to act that way, but it's not like that.
it's simply the result of some random combination of DNA and environment
they respond to food, loud noises, other physical stimuli, but not to philosophy.
Also, if you open the gates of a farm, cows don't run.
Quoting Dennet
Let us return to our vultures. Consider the hypothesis that for all I could ever know, rotting chicken carcass smells to a turkey vulture exactly the way roast turkey smells to me. Can science shed any light, pro or con, on this hypothesis? Yes, it can almost effortlessly refute it: since how roast turkey tastes to me is composed (and exhausted) by the huge set of reactive dispositions, memory effects, and so on, and so forth, that are detectable in principle in my brain and behavior, and since many of these are utterly beyond the machinery of any vulture's brain, it is flat impossible that anything could smell to a vulture the way roast turkey smells to me.
but let's suppose cows have some sort of free will concept.
if they can't explain it to us, how will we ever understand it? (because it's impossible they have the same free will concept we have)
and if we project our roast turkey smell (free will) concept to cows, how can we be sure that it's what they need or want, if they can't even communicate a yes/no to us?
All our philosophical concepts are based on millennia of history that's been transmitted to future generations that built new concepts on the old ones
They are not "natural"
if you take a child to a remote location and abandon him/her there they wouldn't even know about death or illness, let alone laws or rules or free will. Because nobody thaught them.
We are basically still stuck in a Solaris situation.
but the question still stands, so I propose another one: how do we know that dogs want to live in our homes?
modern neuroscience can explain a lot of things that philosophy still consider questions.
> That's funny to you?
It happens every year to wild cows too that are impregnated by males because that's what bovines do.
they don't plan on parenting
Also calf mortality is correlated with the body weight of the mother when they are born, domesticates cows have almost zero calf mortality rate, contrary to what happens to wild cows.
They will also die due to predators, weaknesses, attacked by a bull or older males or for other natural causes, that they don't encounter when living in a farm
It's perfectly natural for a cow to see her calves die, it's part of their biological destiny.
every animal, except humans, lack the neurological structures to process the concept of "free will" which is entirely a human construct.
If they had free will, they would fight for it or at least some of them would.
One could argue that we still don't know the human brain, so how can we exclude that animals haven't what it takes to understand free will?
But it's the same thing of saying that God exists because we can't disprove it.
And if we assume that cows understand it, why exclude other animals, like fish, or some plant or fungi?
We assume they don't have it because they never showed to care about it.
Cattle can be incredibly aggressive too.
it is proven that regardless of age and environmental conditions, some individuals remain more aggressive than others. Aggression in cattle can arise from both genetic and environmental factors.
Aggression between cows is worse than that between bulls. Bulls with horns will bunt (push or strike with the horns) in which can cause more damage overall
interesting read from Dennet
https://lafavephilosophy.x10host.com/dennett_anim_csness.htm...
that's per household, not per capita.
the median salary in US is $ 36k/year[1]
in China is $ 13.5k, but cost of living in China is more than 50% cheaper than in US on average and education is basically free
Kentucky has the same population of Switzerland but less than half average income (27k vs 62k)
14% of the population in USA relys on food stamps
OP said I would not say it is developed, just because the top percentile of the population seem to live lavish lives, does that apply to US as well? (or Italy, where I come from and similar patterns are observable)
there is more than the average and the median when 1.2 billion people live in the same country
development is not homogeneous anywhere
[1] The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported a median personal income of $865 weekly for all full-time workers in 2017. The U.S. Census Bureau lists the annual real median personal income at $35,977 in 2019 with a base year of 2019.