HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aftoprokrustes

353 karma · joined May 22, 2023

https://nostalgiedunesagesseavenir.fr/
submissionscomments
aftoprokrustes··on What hallucinogens will make you see
I actually have that kind of experiences (mostly on a subtle level, but sometimes more intense, to the point that tears might well up) regularly as a result of my meditation/spiritual practice. For me it is more "seeing the divine expressing itself through the person" or feeling a particular kind of universal personhood in a tree, as if that particular tree stood outside of time, representing all of life. It can also happen with my own emotions: sometimes I will feel sad or angry, and the feeling will transform from "my anger" to "an expression of cosmic anger" or "the Divine expressing itself through me as Anger".

It might be a bit different from the experience described in the citation, but to me that description definitely sounds familiar (in particular the simultaneity of the particular and the universal). The effect of my practice on my daily life and the way I relate to it also sound pretty similar to the way some use psychedelics for spiritual or therapeutical practice. I actually lost quite a lot of my appetite to experiment with psychedelics since I started this kind of practice.

I mostly practice following the teachings of Rob Burbea, but I am also fond of reading texts from mystics of the Abrahamic religions, and this kind of experience is also reported regularly in that context. Mother Theresa for instance, when asked how she could stand being at the contact of so much suffering, said something along the lines of "I look into the eyes of my patient, and what I see is the glaze of my beloved Christ".

aftoprokrustes··on Scientists need to get high
I pretty much agree with the article, and I would argue that the reintroduction of subjectivity goes much further than just the study of psychoactive substances for medical purpose.

I tend to believe that the obsession with drugs in our cultures can be traced back to the reformation and the going away from religious experience as a form of wisdom and a valid way to access reality. When one reads the texts of christan, muslim or jewish mystics from the middle ages, one can only wonder at the depth of experiences and the care that is taken to interpret those experiences and build a model of the world that includes them. My feeling is that with the shift to stronger and stronger materialism, mystical experiences were more and more seen as suspicious and potentially a sign of mental disorder. As such, drugs are more acceptable, as one can always explain things away with "neural pathways" and "neurotrasmitters" and whatnot. The experience can be seen as interesting, but what is finally "real" are just electrical signals in a big meatball.

While continuing research from this materialistic perspective is essential, there is a growing recognition that one should allow other ontologies and epistemiologies, that allow the use of direct experience to derive knowledge. This means accepting that some researchers and philosophers explore world models where consciousness is not just an phenomenon emerging from physical process in the brain, but potentially has an existence of its own, or even is primary. If you are interested in this topic I would recommend reading the Galileo Report, written by scientists and philosophers who work with consciousness, and in particular Near Death Experiences: https://galileocommission.org/report/

Side note: I also think that this materialistic view favors the conception some have that drugs can be the only path to accessing some insights. In other cultures, such as the Ayahuasca consuming tribes of south america or the Amanita Muscaria consumers of Siberia, drugs are seen as powerful helpers for establishing contact with the spirits, but are by no means mandatory or necessary to this end. In Siberia for instance, Amanita is mostly consumed in "heterarchical" societies, where non chamans are "allowed" to contact the spirits. It is just something that can help, when one misses the necessary training or gift. In "hierarchical" societies, where the chaman is seen as being of a different species, use of drugs is actually seen as illegitimate, as the chaman should be able to communicate with the spirits thrpugh his/her skills alone. The difference with our culture is the ontology of the experience: one is not tripping for the trip, but to take contact with spirits and ask them something. Whether this happens with fireworks or more silently is less relevant. But we do not want to entertain the idea of spirits, so we are only left with the fireworks. But the real gift from those experiences is not the experience itself, but the opening of potential ontologies it allows, and the practice with choosing the right ontology in the moment to sustain and open the experience. Which is something that, again, also does wo der without drugs.

TL;DR: what we need is to accept non-materialist ontologies as legitimate in a research setting

aftoprokrustes··on Notes apps are where ideas go to die (2022)
I used the Zettelkasten idea for a bit more than a year, and it was truly a joy to use. Unimportant idea get naturally forgotten, while important/relevant ones get reinforced and revisited a lot. Building the links feels like having a deep discussion with a knowledgeable friend, and, once in a while, you get that surprising insight when a note from a book about a completely different topic you forgot you read pops up and sheds a new light on your current reading.

But the main weakness of that system is what makes it so powerful: it is, by nature, extremely time consuming. It is so powerful because, in order to add the smallest note, you need to sift through dozens of them, amend them, thinks about connections, create notes for those connections... In a sense, it is the exact opposite of what the article describe: the system _prevents you_ to just jote a quick note and forget about it. I does make it very powerful as a "second brain", but I ended up finding that the joy and insights I got out were not worth the time investment. I guess this is a reason app builders do not emphasize the process: "get more out of your reading by spending a few more hours per day organizing your thoughts" is not super sexy.

I now see that system as relevant only to people whose _main_ focus is to collect information and extract new insights from them: philosophers, anthropologists, some types of sociologists... But if you just want to remember a blog post about weird CSS tricks, this is probably overkill.

aftoprokrustes··on Ketamine no better than placebo at alleviating depression, unusual trial finds
Not really. If it is the _experience_ that is the main cause for reduction of depressive symptoms, it means that other ways to generate similar experiences (such as meditation, talk therapy, prayer, sensory deprivation...) could have a similar effect. If it is the physical effect of the medicine on the brain which is responsible for the effect, it would mean that it might be possible to design drugs that have the same effectiveness without being psychoactive.
aftoprokrustes··on Ketamine no better than placebo at alleviating depression, unusual trial finds
This might be true if what you want is to emulate the experience under actual psychedelic drugs; I do not think that this is necessary if your only aim is to create _transformative_ or _healing_ experiences.

One of the core concepts of Rob Burbea I mentionned above is the idea of "imaginal middle way", which, in short, consists in seeing mental images as "neither real nor not real", "simultanously discovered and created". Going deeper into that topic would require way too much text and time for a simple comment here, but I can tell from experience that this way to engage with imaginative faculties can have deep and long lasting effects. And the important aspect here is that, while engaging with the image, one is constantly balancing between reification (considereing the image, for instance of a divinity, as having independent reality) and disdain (considering the image as "just made up").

aftoprokrustes··on Ketamine no better than placebo at alleviating depression, unusual trial finds
I think I see what you mean, in the sense that without the substance the trip does not exist. The distinction I was trying to make was between the subjective experience compared to potential brain changes induced by chemical reactions.

The "chemistry" side of the debate would be that the trip is a side effect of the substance modifying neurological pathways (or similar), but what is actually important are those physical modifications to the brain, not the experience.

The "trip" side of the debate would be that the only important thing is the experience, and that whether it is induced by drugs, fasting, meditation, prayer, video games, etc. does not matter that much.

Obviously, there is also the possibility that both sides are valid: the fact that the experience can be transformative in itself does not prevent the physical effect of the molecule on the brain to be beneficial as well. There is even the possibility that one of the two has a positive effect, while the other is rather negative.

aftoprokrustes··on Ketamine no better than placebo at alleviating depression, unusual trial finds
There are people looking at "psychedelic game design", see e.g. https://anticiplay.medium.com/chocolate-covered-magic-mushro...

They are not looking at creating a "trippy" experience per se, but rather to generate an experience that produces a potential shift in the way to relate with the world

aftoprokrustes··on Ketamine no better than placebo at alleviating depression, unusual trial finds
As a relatively seasoned meditator, I am absolutely sure that this is the trip that helps, not the chemistry. One way to look at meditation (and, I hear, psychedelics) that fits my experience is that it has the potential effect of opening the range of "ways of looking", to change the way one builds the perceived world. What propulsed my meditation to a totally different level was to see it as a practice of actively engaging with other ways to perceive the world, and let those act on the psyche, rather than as some form of "mental gym". As I understand, what makes a psychedelic a psychedelic is that it propulses the user into a state where the workings of the mind is apparent (Psyche-delic, this which reveals (delic) the mind (psyche)), and new ways of perceiving are opened. If one considers depression as primarily a form of "negative filter" that turns all external objects as dull and uninteresting, it makes sense that psychedelics can help get out of it, and that a necessary condition for that is to actually consciously experience those transformations of perception.

Unfortunately, this means that the standard way of doing medicine research, with control group and placebo, is unlikely to ever be applicable to this area of research, and that a new epistemiology of medical research has to be developped for it. I find it super interesting.

(side note: if the idea of meditation as active engagement with "ways of looking" is intriguing you, I highly recommend looking up the teachings of Rob Burbea)

← PreviousPage 4 of 4