HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

agarden

996 karma · joined June 26, 2013

submissionscomments
agarden··on The mid-Victorian diet was a mini golden age of nutrition
Agreed. The key point in the article is that mid-Victorians had a similar life-expectancy to our own. From there it just assumes that dietary changes are what caused life expectancy to decline, starting in the late-Victorian era. That's an awful lot of assuming.

The interesting thing to me was not the dietary claims, but the claims about life expectancy. If those are correct, then it does rather strongly suggest that the mid-Victorians were doing something right that we have now got wrong. Or perhaps just that modern medicine has not done as much to advance life expectancy as is generally thought.

agarden··on The mid-Victorian diet was a mini golden age of nutrition
In my opinion, the interesting thing about the article is not the diet, it is the claim that if you remove death during and shortly after childbirth, mid-Victorian era life expectancy was about the same as ours now. If true, that's a startling counterpoint to the prevailing narrative of modern medicine's triumph.
agarden··on What ISIS Really Wants
That was an interesting read. It did sound like ISIS has a powerful faction, at least, that is only using religion as a pretense and tool.

On the other hand, that doesn't mean that all of ISIS is like that. It could be that such men as Bakr were instrumental in getting things started, but those brought in to provide religious pretense eventually became the more powerful faction.

Also, I don't see how temporary alliances with a secular regime indicate lack of true religious conviction. If making temporary, strategic alliances with Assad and fighting agianst the Syrian rebels was plainly hypocritical, I would think that would staunch the flow of true believers to their ranks. And while we may debate whether or not ISIS is the haven of belief it portrays itself to be, I don't think we can question that there are many, many people on the outside that it successfully recruits because they believe it to be that. Which requires at least that the hypocrisy not be blatantly obvious.

agarden··on Jessica Livingston
You started this thread with, "how can one write a piece about persistent discrimination against a woman without mentioning societal gender discrimination as a thing?"

The grandparent to my previous comment suggested that "if [PG] focused the essay more on gender discrimination instead of just on Jessica, she would not be comfortable with or allow the essay to be published."

You said that since PG felt he could write the article without mentioning societal gender discrimination, "I'm left to wonder whether he is even aware of the problem."

I linked to a video where Jessica covers the same material that PG did. She also does not so much as hint at societal gender discrimination. This can be consider supportive evidence, along with PG's footnote about feminism, for the GP's hypothesis that Jessica would not being comfortable with societal gender discrimination being in the article.

It would follow that if you are going to respect Jessica's choice to not talk about gender discrimination in her talk, you would have to also respect the choice of PG to not have it in his essay, on the assumption that he may have withheld any such commentary in deference to Jessica's preferences.

agarden··on What ISIS Really Wants
I read both. I wish the article you linked to had more substance. It provides no argument that ISIS is misinterpreting Islam, only assertions. If someone has an article that actually makes that case, citing texts and explaining the misinterpretation, I'd like to read it.
agarden··on Jessica Livingston
Elsewhere on this page someone linked to a talk Jessica herself gave on this subject[1]. It is remarkably similar to PG's essay. Jessica notes at the beginning that pretty nearly no one on the outside knows how large a role she has played at YC and then credits that to her preferred MO of working behind the scenes. She also does not mention her gender as a factor in being ignored.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NEp9aaQuYp4

agarden··on Jessica Livingston
It also provides an explanation for why national political conversations are so awful.
agarden··on The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
So who got to decide that it works this way?

The Constitution doesn't say it works this way, and that was the document that was voted on by the representatives of the people. So whoever it was that decided it actually works a totally different way, why should I care what they think?

agarden··on The Supreme Court could soon deliver a blow to the Sixth Amendment
If someone defrauds medicare for millions, then they do not deserve, in a moral sense, expensive counsel or any help at all, because they are guilty. But a person can be accused of defrauding medicare for millions without having actually done so. And in that case, yes, they deserve to be free to hire an expensive lawyer.

Why? Because the prosecutor set against them is an expensive prosecutor and is going to give the case more of his attention.

If you have been charged with a minor offense that carries small penalties, you will be charged by a prosecutor that is lower on the career ladder and cares less about your particular case; they will put less effort into it. But if you have been changed with a big crime that carries large penalties, that is going to be prosecuted by a better lawyer. A public defender might well be adequate to defend against a minor charge but be wholly inadequate against a major charge where the prosecution is very highly motivated and incentivized to win.

And since we do not know if the charged party is guilty or not, they ought to be presumed innocent and not restricted from hiring counsel of their choice and means.

agarden··on The Supreme Court could soon deliver a blow to the Sixth Amendment
It strikes me that the problem with Justice Alito's analogy is that it presumes guilt. One could retell the story this way: two brothers each received $5000 from a rich uncle on the same day, and also made $5000 selling old vinyl records that turned out to be highly collectible. Then they go and spend $5000 partying. The government comes along and accuses them of attaining the second $5000 through illicit means and freezes their remaining money on the presumption of guilt. Defendants then cannot hire the counsel they desire, lose their case and go to jail. But it wasn't drugs they sold, it was vinyl.

I'm not sure that my story would end up changing legal minds, but failing to consider it as a possibility is unpardonable.

agarden··on The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
(First a note: "what new law is the judiciary supposed to pass" was meant to be "what new law is the legislature...".)

I'm not sure we disagree. You seem to be arguing that no one branch is the final arbiter of what is constitutional; that each is allowed its independent opinion. I agree with that. What I was arguing against in this thread is the proposition that the judiciary alone gets to decide what is constitutional and that it gets to do so regardless of what the constitution actually says.

You ended with "This is all by design. This is how it's meant to work," which is a claim that only makes sense if we have a system where the constitution actually means something and its meaning is binding. If the judiciary is free to redefine the constitution however they want, then we are not living under a government that has a design or a correct way to work.

agarden··on The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
What if the removed justices sued and the judiciary hearing the case ruled that, in fact, Constitutional provisions be damned, the legislative branch may not remove justices.

Were that to happen, how could you argue that they are wrong?

agarden··on The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
If the old, nullified Constitutional provision said that dog-walking on Thursdays was illegal, what new law is the judiciary supposed to pass to make dog-walking illegal on Thursdays again? If the judiciary is free to impose whatever interpretation on whatever text they want, and then their interpretation is the real law, then there is no law the legislature can pass to change that.

Of course everyone always has the possibility of fighting; civil war is always an option. But if the <i>principle</i> is that the judiciary gets to make law just howsoever it pleases, then one loses the ability to call the government out on anything. It just becomes "that's not what I want" versus "that's not what you want".

Which is where we are at with this surveillance mess. Except that because we have a written Constitution with an explicit method for amendation, instead of an implicit right of amendment by Judiciary, we do have a basis for pointing out that the government is out of bounds and for demanding reform. Reject that and everything becomes legal and there is nothing you can do except complain that you don't like it.

agarden··on The Government Uses Zero Days for “Offense”
> <i>If the Constitution said "there may be no dog-walking on Thursday", the constitutionality of dog-walking on Thursday would rest entirely upon the decisions of the judiciary with regards to its constitutionality</i>

What you are asserting is that we are not ruled by written law, but by a judiciary, who feels themselves free to invent "escape hatches" to avoid old commitments now deemed undesirable.

agarden··on The Mathematics of Paul Graham's Bias Test
Let's assume that bias does persist past selection through the duration of the program. Does that change the interpretation when you look at First Round Capital's data that shows its female founders outperforming the males by 63%? I don't think it does.

The test may not be sufficient to prove that you have no bias, but it may be good enough to prove that you do. When it does indicate bias, it seems likely to be correct.

To put it another way, if it is 1948 and the only three black people in Major League Baseball are all superstars, then the distribution of baseball skill among black players is extremely unbalanced or there is a lot of bias keeping the average and moderately-better-than-average black players out.

agarden··on More parents, students saying 'no' to homework
I wonder if perhaps kids find the assigned work so dreadful because the manner of assignment assumes it will be. "Why should I read this?," asks the kid. "Because it is assigned," comes the answer. At which point, perhaps the child thinks, "Oh, you don't care about this, so why should I?," and the battle lines are drawn.

In other words, maybe the issue isn't whether or not something is assigned. Maybe the issue is whether or not the teacher cares about - and is excited about - the material. If the teacher thinks it is fun, maybe being assigned it is not such a heavy burden to bear.

agarden··on Write like you talk
This seems much better advice.

I found the opposite of PG. I discovered that when I worked on talking the way I wrote, my speech became much better and more interesting.

Now, PG speaks off the cuff pretty well. So I suppose if people find you well spoken, it makes sense to try to write more like you talk. But if you write better than you speak, make your speech more like your writing.

agarden··on The Cold Logic of Drunk People (2014)
If you really know, then yes. On those on flight 93 seemed to know. But the other two planes didn't and they didn't do anything. Totally reasonable.

Where I in the hypothetical train scenario, I would not pull the lever. Because in truth, I don't <i>know</i> that the five people will be killed. One of them may look up in time, shout, and all of them scatter. But the one loner? He may be too absorbed in his task.

The details in these kinds of things really matter. They make or break the morality of the scenario. And the details in the train & lever scenario are implausible. The supposed level of certainty is too high.

agarden··on How to act less stupid, according to psychologists
One can be cautious without being overly cautious. And one can prudently take risks.

An example of stupid behavior might be betting $10,000 that you will win the office March Madness pool, because you personally know the coach of Duke and are just convinced that he is a winner that will go all the way. That's stupid.

But if you are Warren Buffet and bet $1 billion (with a 'b') that no one at all will correctly call every game in this years NCAA basketball tournament[0], that's not stupid, that's informed and prudent risk-taking.

[0] http://time.com/34358/no-one-won-warren-buffetts-1-billion-b...

agarden··on Prohibition was primarily the work of one pressure group
Interesting observation. There is nothing in the Constitution about abortion and it being a right, though. So what we are actually seeing is widespread disrespect for Supreme Court rulings taking hold. The recent ruling on gay marriage is only going to accelerate that trend.
agarden··on [dead]
Previous discussion last week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10380513
agarden··on Paper is Dropbox's new vision for how teams can work together
He didn't leave Dropbox for Google, Apple, or Amazon. He switched to SpiderOak. Their selling point is that everything is encrypted client-side and they have no access to unencrypted files.

I have not yet abandoned DropBox. I am still paying ~$10/mo for their services. But I sympathize with the GP. Those questions are exactly the things I want answers to as well.

agarden··on On the manifestos killers leave behind
I am skeptical. The WSJ article[0] covering Lankford's claims has a graphic that shows none of those countries with even two mass shootings since 2000, including the Philippines. The Mother Jones[1] article says that only four countries broke double digits, and again, none of the countries I listed made the list. Or Mexico, which is widely reported to be rife with gang violence, including mass murders.

It appears that Lankford's paper[2] has not yet been published. When it is, and if it is available for free, we can look at the details of his claims.

[0] http://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-leads-world-in-mass-shooting...

[1] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/08/united-states-wo...

[2] http://adamlankford.com/research.htm

agarden··on On the manifestos killers leave behind
If you want to talk about people being shot, instead of just cases where civilians walk into a crowded place just to kill as many people as possible, then I think you need to take Syria, Iraq, Somalia, Palestine, and more into account. And I doubt, once you do that, that the US will still have the most mass shootings or carnage.
agarden··on On the manifestos killers leave behind
Elliot Rodger's manifesto: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/05/25/us/shooting-do...

Rodger thought it was a huge injustice that anyone else could have a girlfriend -- or anything else -- when he couldn't. Though he never seems to have actually summoned the courage to ask a girl out.

agarden··on Thresholds of Violence: How School Shootings Spread
>We don't believe them (or, at least, I don't believe them) not because it's impossible, >but because they do not put in the work to back up their daydream fantasies. > >Why would the same not be true of a wannabe shooter?

It is. I fully agree. And this guy had put in the work.

agarden··on Thresholds of Violence: How School Shootings Spread
This case of LaDue is certainly on odd one. I agree that it isn't clear he actually had the nerve to follow through. But it is clear he is following a script. He calls Eric Harris his hero. He cites all the precedents. Maybe humiliating such perpetrators would not have prevented LaDue, but if it prevented people like Eric Harris, then it would reduce the precedent, and hence probably also the attraction, for people like LaDue.

It's the riot theory the article starts with. If you can deter the people who get the riot started, you can possibly deter the people like LaDue who follow along just because it is now a thing that people do.

agarden··on Thresholds of Violence: How School Shootings Spread
Good question. Two aspects to the answer.

1) Let's say the article was about people who fell to their death because there was no fence at the top of the Grand Canyon. Let's further suppose that this was a pattern and it has been happening with increasing frequency of late, but it is still rare because the random gusts of wind that push people over the edge are rare, and further that the people falling had no idea that it was a risk posed by touring the Grand Canyon. And then you posted that in fact 294 people fell to their deaths every year but that number includes all the people who were out climbing mountains for sport. That number might be horrific, but the mountain climbers understood the risk and chose to take it. The tourists at the Grand Canyon thought that what they were doing was safe.

2) The solution for the one problem likely has nothing to do with the solution for the other. If many of those 294 deaths are because of gang violence or criminal activity, magically removing all guns might reduce that number, but it probably wouldn't reduce it much. Someone who is out just to shoot up as many people as possible may well not try to kill anyone if he can't get a hold of a gun. But someone who needs Guido dead so that he can't rat him out, he is just going to move to the next best weapon for the job. A crossbow, or a knife, or a poison dart, or a baseball bat, or a rock, or something.

agarden··on Thresholds of Violence: How School Shootings Spread
It seems to me that at this point there is a certain script for violence. It involves guns and maybe bombs, and the point is to kill as many people as possible to get as much media attention as possible. To a certain kind of person, that sounds like glory.

I think the way to stop the trend is to break the script. The key to it is that everyone cowers before the power of the attacker. For a brief moment, he can feel like a god. Make these attackers look incompetent, weak, and ineffective and the allure of the thing dies. If we could somehow change things so that the next time someone tries this no one cowers, but the perpetrator is instead killed or incapacitated or in some way humiliated by those he intended to victimize, the script breaks.

agarden··on Thresholds of Violence: How School Shootings Spread
Rock star and wide receivers don't get to anoint themselves. They can only achieve their goal if other people cooperate and give them that status. This guy did not require anyone's cooperation and his motivations were internal.

Maybe he would not have followed through, but prior to discovery there wasn't much to stop him.

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →