HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aguaviva

1,437 karma · joined August 8, 2024

submissionscomments
aguaviva··on Missiles are now the biggest killer of airline passengers
I‘d reserve the word „colony“ for its original meaning.

Which per Wikipedia is simply:

   A colony is a territory subject to a form of foreign rule.
And which was a perfectly reasonable description of the situation in all the peripheral republics, as well as many constituent parts of the RSFSR itself.

The fact that it might have also provided subsidies to some of the republics at various times (when not withholding food and/or engaging in massive, violent repressive actions against them) is entirely irrelevant to this definition. Recall that the Western colonial powers always bragged about all the infrastructure they built in their colonies, and South Africa always tried to point out the subsidies it provided its Bantustans, etc.

aguaviva··on Missiles are now the biggest killer of airline passengers
Like when Zelensky announced that Russians killed all border guards on the Snake Island after one of them said "Russian warship, go fuck yourself".

First, Zelenskyy was just reacting to what the DPSU (State Border Guard Service) told him. And mostly likely what they reported was (at worst) a somewhat premature, but not unreasonable inference based on the information they had at the time.

This information being, at the time, the following facts: (1) The aggressor opened fire shortly after the guard patrol refused to surrender, and rightly told the warship what, precisely, it needed to do with itself; and (2) all contact with the patrol was lost shortly after that; and (3) before the close of the same day it was observed that all infrastructure on the island had been destroyed after an intense air and naval bombardment.

Further, there was a significant delay (about 48 hours -- in any case on the 26th, 2 days later) between the assault on the island, and the first indication by the DPSU that some of the personnel on the island might still be alive. In any case confirmation was not provided by the aggressor until the 28th.

Meanwhile Zelenskyy's statement was issued on the 25th, so entirely within this window in which the details were not fully known, but during which it was perfectly reasonable to assume the soldiers had most likely been killed, based on the information available. Plus the war had literally just started, and it wasn't like he didn't have a lot of other distractions at the time.

In sum: no story here, just the usual fog of war. Definitely not in the category of an intential deception ("one big lie") as you're making it out to be. And unlike the DPSU, you've had close to a full 3 years to catch up with the full story by now, so if anything it is your own less than forthright representation of the matter which should be raising eyebrows, in view of this context.

In this evil, awful, insanely stupid war, based entirely on lies from the very start.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snake_Island_campaign#/media/F...

aguaviva··on EPA Promotes Fertilizer Carrying PFAS, Long After 3M Shared Risks
https://archive.is/PnPHo
aguaviva··on Denmark Offers to Buy USA (2019)
Not even. Russia has issues with itself. Not Ukraine.

And its regime has mega issues in regard to its long-term survival. Which it attempts to redirect, by causing issues for Ukraine.

That's what the last 11 years have been about, in a nutshell.

aguaviva··on Ugandan runner due to arrive in London after 516 days, 7,700 miles on the road
Crimea was Russian from the 1700s

It became a Russian colonial possession around that time. But that did not in any way establish an innate "Russian-ness" to the peninusla that overrides modern international law. Specifically multiple treaties affirming Ukraine's sovereignty over the Crimea that Russia itself signed (and which the Crimean electorate also ratified in 1991 via an internationally recognized referendum). And which Russia again affirmed via another major treaty in 1994.

Russia has a much stronger claim on Crimea than Ukraine, historically speaking.

You can believe you want about historical "claims" and whatever they are supposed to even mean. The vastly bigger point (and the only point that really matters in this context) is that in the 21st century, we don't go around starting wars that will inevitably murder hundreds of thousands of people so at one side can get a shot at "correcting" past border resolutions (that it never formally disputed in the first place).

There is a name for this tendency - "territorial revanchism". You might want to look at what happened the last time a major power in Europe started to pretend to believe that it had a historical imperative to avenge and reverse prior "humiliations":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revanchism

The Ukraine side has fascists of their own

As does your country, I'm sure. That doesn't mean that other countries get to start invading and bombing your hometown willy-nilly. And if they did, I somehow doubt you'd be getting on HN to tell us that "It isn't as black and white as people make it out to be. After all, we've got fascists of our own in this country. So the invaders have a point too, you know."

This entire conflict is based on overlapping and often contradictory versions of history.

The history really isn't that complicated, and the whole idea that the conflict is in any way based on "history" is part of the fabric of myths used by the aggressor to justify its invasion and to mollify and deflect opposition to it.

The war is about the ideology and interests of the small clique that runs Russia's current regime. Not about Ukraine or its history.

aguaviva··on More men are addicted to the 'crack cocaine' of the stock market
Who was the land taken from?

The people living there.

I think this was pretty clear from the context of what the commenter said when they referred to the "nations" from which the land was taken.

In terms of, you know, the people who had been living on that land peacefully for more than a thousand years.

Not from the various dying empires that temporarily occupied that land, and pretended to "own" it.

aguaviva··on The Swedish cabin on the frontline of a possible hybrid war
If Russia bombed people (or e.g. caved in a building where civilians could be expected to inhabit and thereby die in the collapse) then it would be terrorism.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mariupol_theatre_airstrike

aguaviva··on In praise of the hundred page idea
Snyder has been defined as “Nolte with an NPR tote bag”

The difference between you and I is that when I encounter a blunt, ad hominem smear like this (noticed the unsourced formulation "A colleague says ...", in the same way that Trump says things like "People say she's a Marxist" to cheering crowds), I tend to go, "Okay, another vitriolic rant. Am I going to have time to finish ploughing through this? Probably not."

Whereas your gut take seems to be some form of: "Yesss! Score one for the team! Where can I get more of this stuff?"

The article is full of other raw insinuations, and plainly broken argumentation that should be jumping out at you.

But go ahead, read whatever you want, and import whichever memes you want.

aguaviva··on Ask HN: Programmers who don't use autocomplete/LSP, how do you do it?
It's relatively common to call the use of dynamically typed languages without static type hints "untyped".

And it's relatively common for people to be simply wrong, or to be careless in their word choice in regard to lots of other matters.

I'm pretty sure you knew what I meant and are just trying the classic "you used this word in a way I don't agree with therefore you're wrong".

It wasn't, i.e. I wasn't considering the possibility that that was what you meant. This is the first time I've encountered this broken usage of the term.

aguaviva··on Ask HN: Programmers who don't use autocomplete/LSP, how do you do it?
To think that some people are still writing code like in the 70s.

This is a muddled hyperbolization. These features barely existed (in terms of widespread use) even 10 years ago, but everyone got along just fine, even founded FAANG-scale companies without them, and so on. Yet you're making it sound like if you aren't using them, then you're basically still writing COBOL.

Not using productivity tools is just hurting you.

The commenter very clearly isn't saying you shouldn't use them. And their point had nothing to do with any "sensation of superiority".

They simply meant that -- yes, it is possible to not only be productive, but highly productive without these tools -- and that if you just tried to get along with them for a while, you just might learn a thing or two. For example, if one is even the slightest bit hesitant as to how one would go about resolving one of the issues that the OP asked about, without the help of modern tooling features:

   What do you do if you need to look up the definition/implementation of some function which is in some other file?
Then one definitely has some important learning to do.
aguaviva··on Ask HN: Programmers who don't use autocomplete/LSP, how do you do it?
untyped languages (Python, Ruby)

Both of those languages are strongly typed.

It seems you're confusing the fact that the type checking happens at runtime (that is to say, that they are dynamically typed) to mean that they're "untyped", but that's just not the case.

If one is confused about the languages one is using at this level, then modern tooling features aren't likely to help much.

aguaviva··on US judge finds NSO Group liable for hacking journalists via WhatsApp
Friday, October 20, 2017:

   WASHINGTON - Stanislav Nazarov, 46, a dual citizen of Israel and Russia, has been extradited from Israel to face charges in an indictment accusing him of taking part in an international money laundering scheme.
Israel is quite financially independent these days, and has been so for decades. The US does not simply "bankroll the entire country" by any stretch.

But hey, it's a free planet, and you can believe whatever you want to belive. I certainly wouldn't want to get between you and one of your pet narratives.

aguaviva··on Ask HN: Predictions for 2025?
Not sure how we got to this, and it seems I may have misread you.

All apologies.

aguaviva··on The Hotel Guest Who Wouldn't Leave
https://archive.ph/8m3TM
aguaviva··on Happy 400th birthday to the world’s oldest bond
Modern Germany doesn't inherit from any of the predecessor states after WWI and the Nazi era.

Not quite. Its criminal code inherits directly from that of the 1871 Reich (including quite notoriously Paragraphs 175 and 218).

But it is correct to say that its constitution inherits only back to 1919, and it never maintained any pretense of connection to the Holy Roman Empire.

aguaviva··on US judge finds NSO Group liable for hacking journalists via WhatsApp
Life is short. Just doing what I can.
aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
I'm not insinuating anything.

You damn sure were.

Again, I don't know much about you other than you were very vocal about the definition of genocide as it pertains to the Israeli response

You're hallucinating. In this particular thread, I haven't touched on the genocide definition in the Oct 7th context at all. Someone switched the focus to Dresden, and I started chiming in on that.

and your abject silence and avoidance of answering a simple question.

Because it was a leading question, as already explained.

And the fact that you immediately whipped out the antisemitism accusation after I refused to take the bait proves that this was the stick you were carrying all along.

You're just a bully. Go away.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Wonderful blanket term.

Which (as used by the commenter) was very clearly meant to apply to those who support Israel's military operation.

Not to Jews in general.

I agree, [waving the antisemitism flag] just makes it clear to everyone who reads this who is one and who isn't.

Except when it's unsubstantiated.

In which case it's just a cheap, ugly smear.

aguaviva··on Ask HN: Predictions for 2025?
Perhaps you'd like to tell us, please, what political import you see in this comment on the current page of my history:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42483975

But don't let that slow down your witch hunt.

aguaviva··on In praise of the hundred page idea
even by right-wing ones—so, basically his own camp

Snyder isn't right-wing at all. Where did that come from?

aguaviva··on Ask HN: Predictions for 2025?
I don't think that is an option of any sort.

That's insane. Of course it's an "option". No one in these countries (outside of a very tiny portion of wackos) cares about the current borders, or dreams of starting a war to move them.

aguaviva··on Ask HN: Predictions for 2025?
The politics of Ukraine war is extremely complicated.

They aren't actually. And none of that history relates to the current war.

Which is all about Russia's internal politics and ideology. And not about the after-effects of post-WW2 territorial transfers at all.

Those transfers in turn were in turn the work of the Allied powers, not Ukraine.

aguaviva··on US judge finds NSO Group liable for hacking journalists via WhatsApp
You were presenting an either-or argument, pretty much along those lines. A basically very specious argument, it was.

I was paraphrasing you, but not unfairly in that sense.

The burden of proof is on those claiming genocide, not on me.

The burden of proof is on the occupying forces, to show that they are not causing undue harm to the population affected.

We could adjudicate this further, but as said - you've simply worn me out, via your patently spurious opening.

aguaviva··on US shoots down two of its own Navy pilots over Red Sea
It wasn't a trick, and I'm not subverting or redirecting anything.

Meanwhile, yours wasn't merely a keyboard slip. The point, simply, is that your encapsulation of the last 5 decades was very myopic. Don't mean to condescend, but it does seem that in terms of basic global history you're still playing catch-up, as it were.

The concern (as I attempted to articulate) wasn't so much that you were "lying", but that (going by your statements) you do seem to have a rather blasé attitude about the truth, and/or to have simply missed out on a lot of the major event chronology of the last 50 years. Which suggests that you're much more interested in your moral narratives than in what actually happened, or why.

The irony here is that we probably agree about 70 percent in terms of which side is "bad" and who is to "blame". It's just that that other 30 percent is, unfortunately, complex and intermixed.

If it helps, I hereby mention "legalized torture, secret laws, and secret courts".

In turn, if you like, you can "mention" the ethnic cleansings in Srebrenica, Prijedor, Foča, Zvornik, Doboj Bosanski Šamac and Bijeljina -- and what, precisely, you think the morally compromised Western powers should have done about this general state of affairs at the time.

That is, if these events ping your awareness at all.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_cleansing_in_the_Bosnia...

aguaviva··on Something is wrong on the Internet
It was the conservatives, not the communists, who betrayed Europe to fascism, war, and genocide.

Bitte. Please.

The KPD paramilitaries (with their various assassinations) and the the SPD (through their alliance with various reactionist forces at the time and the far greater violence they supported) did their part as well. And that's just Germany, not to mention events in Spain, etc.

It was a mutual effort.

aguaviva··on US shoots down two of its own Navy pilots over Red Sea
The same people who lied about how tough the Russians were, lied about how well the ANA was going to withstand the Taliban,

There's a difference between "lying" about things, and being simply deluded or deeply misunderstanding them.

Of course they lied about WMD. But they didn't "lie" about those other two situations. Whether you like it or not, there's a major distinction at play here.

lost the last 5 decades of wars

It's true that they lost the 3 major wars (Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan). But they didn't lose all of their pet wars in this time period. The Gulf War (I betcha forgot that one!) was a very, very major conflict that they won unambiguously.

So already, you're completely out to lunch, right there. But there were numerous second-order conflicts that they won also during this time period. This most significant was the proxy war against the USSR in Afghanistan (effectively the "First Afghan War" from the US perspective) which was unambiguously won, also. Which BTW had some pretty huge consequences (though it seems you've forgotten about those, as well).

And several second-order conflicts in addition (Panama, Yugoslavia, Kosovo) that were effectively won also, even if others (Syria, Libya) were not.

I know, I know - like Reagan said, "facts are boring things". What's my point, you ask? Let's get right to it.

What if they’re just full of shit?

Of course they're full of shit.

But what's vastly more important point is -- if you can't be even ballpark correct about the stuff above -- or (as seems to be more likely the case) you plainly don't care -- then what does that make you full of?

If it's all just word salad to you -- if the basic factual accuracy of stuff like this just doesn't really matter to you; as long as you can smoosh the various bullet points together somehow, and sculpt them in your into whatever broad, sweeping, hypermoralistic narrative that your worldview seems to hinge on -- then not only are you no different, really, from "them" and all of their big, fat stinking lies.

Effectively, you're on the same team.

aguaviva··on The Germany We Knew Is Gone
Same for Ukrainian refugees.

Who are there (and are emotionally traumatized) in no small part because your government chose to cozy up to Putin in the first place, and to look the other way while he started his rampage in 2014. Which doesn't excuse the behavior of those particular kids. But the situation needs to be understood in this context.

As a German I'm tired of going shopping and only hearing languages of the middle east.

For 5 minutes out the week. In that one particular aisle of the store.

Some of your complaints have validity, but I have to say this one sounds extremely petty. Not to mention naive. In large cities in Germany one has been hearing Middle Eastern voices for decades. Absolutely no one grumbled about it (or if they did, it's because they were, well, basically kind of an asshole).

If you're being suspected of intolerance, it's probably because (with respect to this particular complaint) you're making, auf deutsch gesagt -- aus einer Mücke einen Elefanten.

aguaviva··on US judge finds NSO Group liable for hacking journalists via WhatsApp
[flagged]
aguaviva··on Efficient German Language Learning: Is Anki the Answer?
Many focus too much on understanding meaning, but what's crucial is also training your mouth and larynx muscles to form the sounds naturally.

Yup, the value of simple vocal training part (combined with active listening, and occasional feedback on what one does day) seems to be greatly underappreciated. And the value of flashcard-based vocabularly training - generally overrated (beyond the very initial stages).

That said, it seems difficult to even get to A1 without some actual formal understanding of the basic rules of grammar.

aguaviva··on Doctors Without Borders declares the war in Gaza as genocide
Well, we disagree about the assuming-the-worst part, then.

I think mine was fair enough take, given what they said vis-a-vis the actual state of the world in the past 15 years or so. Or at pretty much any time since the State of Israel has existed.

As for understanding and inferring the intent of others -- it's an essential life skill, last we checked. Not sure why you'd try to knock it, when evidently it's a normal human capability that we all make use of to one degree or another, pretty much all the time.

See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_mind

If you think I'm reading too much into their words, then you'll need to provide specific substantiation for this claim. Otherwise your remark is basically a shallow dismissal.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →