HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aguaviva

1,437 karma · joined August 8, 2024

submissionscomments
aguaviva··on An invisible desktop application that will help you pass technical interviews
Live coding session? Biased against people who don't perform well under pressure.

No, it's biased against people who perform perfectly well (sometimes exceptionally well) under real, actual pressure. But who do not take kindly to the bullshit / theatrical pressure typical of the standard interview context, these days. And to companies that just can't tell the difference (or are under the delusion that performance in the latter category is in some way predictive of performance in the former).

Take home project? It's too much work to do for free.

It's more that the companies simply abuse the process in various callous and careless ways -- either by assigning projects with inadequate specification and/or unknown goalposts (or plainly unrealistic expectations of the actual time required, given these ambiguities); or simply assigning scores of these assignments (often automatically to every candidate who applies) when in fact they have no intention of even looking at the vast majority of the submissions.

Easily ameliorated by simply paying people for their time.

aguaviva··on The Albuquerque "Broken Arrow" Nuclear Accident
Most of that 'batshit crazy conspiracy stuff' turned out to be true.

I'd ask you to quantify -- but no one is saying, or even insinuating, that it's "batshit crazy conspiracy stuff". Only that they don't see any particular evidence for it.

The fact that you're making such an obviously ungrounded implication (or you don't see the huge difference between the two positions) suggests you've become unduly caught up in your own semantically confused internal dialogues.

I'd call this 'evidence based'.

Except it's not, and in fact you're engaging in very common form of faulty generalization.

aguaviva··on Germany government collapses at a perilous time for Europe
Why do people [maintain] that Russia is capable of even threatening the EU?

Because its regime has verbally done just that, and has conducted sabotage and assassinations on EU soil on multiple recent occasions.

The fact that is attacking Ukraine in part as a response to its attempt to join the EU is also very reasonably interpreted as part of this intrinsically threatening stance.

aguaviva··on Germany government collapses at a perilous time for Europe
So, merely noticing that Russia is winning and has been for a long time

No, it wasn't that. The AfD boss's remarks were not having a certain take as to which way the war is currently going. He was calling for German goverment to issue a diplomatic recognition of this "victory" - right now, before anything has actually been negotiated and settled.

The two positions may sound superficially similar -- but are in fact radically different. Apples and oranges, basically. If this isn't immediately obvious to you, then I guess this is one of those situation where things that are obvious to others ... aren't obvious to you.

(which is ... acknowledged by Ukrainian-born pro-Ukrainian security expert Michael Kofman)

Except Kofman doesn't present the "Russia is winning" spin as you are implying. It might sound to your expectant ears like that's what he said. But it's not what he said.

He also isn't God, and other analysts have different takes. There are plenty of reasons why Russia's incremental and very slow gains on the ground do not automatically translate to "Russia is winning", in view of other things that are happening in the conflict. Or why an assessment such as "Ukraine is unlikely to reverse Russia's gains"; or even a more blunt "Ukraine is losing" is not simply equivalent to "Russia is winning".

aguaviva··on The Albuquerque "Broken Arrow" Nuclear Accident
The most you can get with that kind of "extrapolation" is some grounds for suspicion that something similar might be happening in the current day.

Meanwhile, my concern is with what is actually happening, you know, in current physical reality. Based in turn on some form of observable evidence. Not with what "might" be happening.

Which for some reason, seems to thoroughly flummox people in the "multipolar" crowd. It's like they've bought into this idea that events 40+ years ago establish a magical "pattern" that overrides any need to gather and ascertain the actual truth in the current moment (for example, in terms of what is happening in Syria).

So when we ask them why they believe US is, in actual fact, doing a certain bad thing (like causing regime change, say) in country X, despite no visible evidence of such -- it's become quite common for them to simply point out past shenanigans in other countries, and the resulting "pattern" that they see arising from such, as their "basis" for this belief.

"Iraq/Vietnam/Chile/etc, therefore everything the US does is also bad, therefore whatever is happening in country X today must be simply the US up to its usual imperial shenanigans, and if you can't see this you must be willfully blind or worse" is the apparent line of thinking here.

Which as a way of looking at things I find to be, well, rather weird.

Do ya wanna have some freedom fries with that?

No thanks, I've had enough junk food for today.

aguaviva··on The Albuquerque "Broken Arrow" Nuclear Accident
That's not how it works. Whatever you think is "really" happening in Syria -- you'll need to point to actual evidence in the current moment. Otherwise, it's just speculation.
aguaviva··on Scandal in Russian military town as new school is decorated with F-16 images
I gave a link to an article about Ukrainian ambassador in Germany defending glorification of Bandera in Ukraine and comparing him with Robin Hood.

And he was promptly dismissed from that position for making those comments.

As you "forgot" to mention.

aguaviva··on Scandal in Russian military town as new school is decorated with F-16 images
And how many children did you count in that video - out of a country of 40 million?

The infinitely bigger point you're leaving out is that those camps were run by a private association, not the government of Ukraine.

To the extent the Azov "movement" still exists, it has decidedly marginal status in Ukraine both socially and politically. If anything it (and what's left of other far-right groups since their electoral collapse several years ago) are pain in the neck to the Zelenskyy government, which considers them to be "a danger to democracy":

   It was a startling statement by anyone’s standards. Speaking to the Financial Times at the start of October, Ukrainian deputy Oleksandr Merezhko, the chair of the parliament’s foreign affairs committee and a member of President Volodymyr Zelensky’s Servant of the People party, said that ultranationalist elements within the war-torn country posed a very real threat to the government – and one that could one day stand in the way of any attempt to negotiate an end to years of brutal fighting.

  “There will always be a radical segment of Ukrainian society that will call any negotiation capitulation,” he said. “The far right in Ukraine is growing. The right wing is a danger to democracy.”
https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20241011-should-zelensky-...
aguaviva··on Scandal in Russian military town as new school is decorated with F-16 images
And who is building monuments[0] honoring Bandera[1] and names streets[2] after him all over Ukraine?

Local governments and various advocacy groups, with no support at the federal level. Meanwhile, a solid component of mainstream Russian society also continues to honor (and more broadly legitimize/normalize) a certain dead fascist icon:

   A surprisingly large number of Russians even believe that Stalin had mystical powers. As recently as 2003, about 750,000 people voted for a party that aimed to continue what it said was Stalin's attempt to battle the ancient Egyptian priesthood of Ra, which supposedly runs the world from its base in Switzerland. 
https://theweek.com/articles/467027/why-many-russians-still-...

  In classrooms across Russia, students are taught out of a modern textbook which represents Stalin as simply an efficient leader who had the unfortunate responsibility to resort to extreme measures to protect Russia and ensure its leadership role on a global scale.[57] A poll in 2019 found that 70% of Russians believed that Stalin had a positive impact on Russian history, while 51% of people in Russia viewed Stalin with a positive attitude.[58]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Stalin%27s_cult_of_pers...
aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
Actually I conveniently linked to the section within the article so you could find it.
aguaviva··on A New Frontier in Paleontology for Profit: Selling Shares in a Stegosaurus
https://archive.ph/OSKPT
aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
Actually, to the extent that it was about Ukraine, the entry point was that day's version of the "because NATO" thread. When that hit a wall (as it always does), someone flipped it over the "Nazi puppet regime" narrative.
aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
The NPD is a fringe party without any substantial numbers of voters

As is Svoboda, these days.

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
5 years after Russia invaded in 2014. Which made any objections its regime might have had about Ukraine's potential NATO membership plainly and irrevocably moot.

That's why the only years that matter (in terms of the "Ukraine/NATO caused it all" hypothesis) are 2008-2014.

Once Russia's regime did chose to invade, any moral capital it may have had in regard to the issue was instantly extinguished.

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
It just seemed weird that you thought nothing of pointing to a 48 minute video about mostly unrelated topics, as if anyone would actually fish through all that to get to the nuggets of pertinent information that you're suggesting are buried in there somewhere.
aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
If you consider how specific you are about word choices over actions, you are repeating the western narrative verbatim.

And this take showcases the fundamental problem with giving a fuck about major narratives, and our perceived overlap with or opposition to them.

As in: "Oh gosh, in taking position X, it looks like I'm overlapping with the received narrative, which happens to roughly include position X. Which is Bad, because that narrative is on the whole Bad. Therefore I should check myself and start importing positions from, or expressing empathy with narratives from the supposedly opposite direction. Because the enemy of my enemy can't be such a bad guy, once you get to know him", or something like that.

Which seems to be what drives about 90 percent of the "If you just listen to Putin, it turns out he actually has a point with Ukraine" take. (Along with an uncritical acceptance of the web of factual distortions about what actually did happen).

When it happened, the russian people responded differently than they did in a much more idealistic period.

Except it wasn't "the Russian people" responding back then. And it certainly isn't "the Russian people" who decided to launch the current invasion.

One nation state can annoy another into an economic collapse thus destroying it.

Okay I guess, and evidently you're alluding to the 90s shock therapy advice given to Russia and associated shenanigans. Fine enough, but that wasn't "NATO". And it's when one starts boldly and utterly conflating the two (I'm guessing on the principle that they're both "The West") where things start to get loopy.

Everything thing you say ignores what the Russians have been saying about NATO expansionism, and I think that is more key to understanding both sides of the issue.

That's the thing -- we don't get to hear from "the Russians" as a people in any meaningful sense these days. By and large, we only get to hear what its current regime says (and the various statements it pretends to believe). Which has some relation to what Russians as a people think, but is at best a highly distorted and manipulated representation of what they think.

I only suggested that actions of NATO contributed to the "irritation" that drug Russia into conflict.

Your words said a lot more than that, I'm afraid. Let's replay the tape:

  This lines up with what Russia says. "We do not want a military alliance that was built to destroy us expanding to our border."
It's extremely difficult to read this other than as conveying: (1) You do think this is what "Russia" (meaning its people) thinks, (2) That it's a reasonable position we should have empathy with and extend credibility to, (3) including, implicitly but unavoidably the "NATO was built to destroy Russia" part.

Instead of treating it as the obvious hogwash that it is, that no reasonably sane and informed person would ever believe.

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
No, I'm Victoria Nuland's and Jens Stoltenberg's secret lovechild.
aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
So NATO destroyed USSR

Well, we can see this conversation is going at least.

In any case there's evidently no meaningful relationship to the actual word "destroy" in play here.

Seems they meant "irritates" or "offends".

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
Predicted a conflict if the US expanded the NATO alliance further east after the USSR fell.

Except Russia formally greenlighted at least partial NATO expansion (to CZ, HU, and PL) via a formal treaty it signed with NATO in 1997. Which right there, should suggest to you that there's something deeply broken with this narrative.

"We do not want a military alliance that was built to destroy us expanding to our border."

NATO wasn't built "to destroy" Russia.

You can say that NATO annoys Russia, or "is built to challenge Russia's influence outside its borders" if you want.

But to say it was built, or at any point even remotely intended "to destroy Russia" is just dumb, emotional manipulation.

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
There's tons more

You need to understand that not everyone shares your addiction to YT's dopamine-jerking content feeds. In any case, no one has time to dig through that video to find whatever "evidence" you think is buried there.

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
You seem to think that only a concrete and signed membership plan is a red line,

It's the only one that the commenter was referring to.

Whereas even CNBC cites Putin's red lines.

Except you're shifting goal posts. The "red lines" referred to by the CNBC are entirely different (and separated by 13 years) from those referred to by the previous commenter. And anyway that's just CNBC's misreading of the events. Suffice it to say there was a lot more to Putin's noises at the time. More specifically, by that point the West did not (as you are strongly implying) have the option of deterring the invasion by simply complying with some specific, reasonable request Putin was making.

The only thing we really know about whichever of Putin's supposed "red lines" were supposedly crossed (thus "causing" this whole thing) is that no one seems to be able to articulate what they supposedly were.

And then we have this:

given the propensity of the Western media to call anyone and anything "fascist"

There is no such "propensity" within Western media. Or any other significant tendency. This is just complete nonsense.

Another day, another throwaway account with a throwaway argument.

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
Maybe somebody overthrew the government and installed a puppet

And when you're completely cornered on one line of disinformation, not just maybe but sure enough -- somebody will chime in with another.

The coup/puppet narrative in relation to these events is simply bogus. You can do your homework on it if you want, or not. I don't particularly care.

aguaviva··on One of the last Navajo code-talkers died on October 19th, aged 107
A handful of very high ranking Nazis were tried and hanged.

This is a misconception. As a result of the "Nuremberg Trials" which concluded in 1946 and focused specifically on high-level defendants, 11 people were hanged. But there were numerous other trials, including what were called the "Nuremberg Military Tribunals" from 1946-1949, the Bergen-Belsen trials, and so on, as a result of which scores of people of decidedly lesser status were executed, easily some 200+.

Nearly all the mid-level officers and civil authorities escaped any sort of punishment or justice, and continued happily serving in the West German state.

This smells like a major numerical fudge as well.

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
I think "in its very borders" was supposed to mean "to its very borders"

And we could forgive them for that small particular exaggeration, if that was all it was. But they took extra special care to double down on the "pushing" part, and dial it up a notch, to "shoving [it] its borders", which is unmistakably an intentional use of emotionally manipulative language. Which is the precise moment which qualifies what they said as propaganda.

As to what you're saying:

Ukraine in NATO being "the brightest of red lines"

Except there was no concrete "push" in Ukraine's case.

Ukraine's NATO membership application was formally rejected by NATO in 2008. This was very, very big news at the time, and Merkel still can't keep bragging about it.† Despite NATO's also offering some secondary, mollifying words about Ukraine "eventually" joining the alliance, there was no significant action taken to move that forward in the critical window of 2008-2014, when Russia invaded.

In fact, in 2010 Ukraine's path to NATO took a very significant step backward, when its parliament voted to abandon the goal of NATO membership and re-affirm Ukraine's neutral status.

And as for the phrase "brightest of red lines": If you actually pull up the text of the cable, it specifically refers to the MAP, or Membership Application Plan, which was explicitly denied to Ukraine in 2008, as indicated above. Precisely due the level-headed advice of people like Burns et all. But Russia invaded in 2014 and 2022 anyway. Because its actual reasons were never rationally connected to NATO expansion in the first place.

And yet - whatever sources you've been reading seem to have left you with the impression that Burns's "brightest of red lines" had in fact been crossed, and that this is what "caused" the invasion.

Why is that?

† https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c3e8y1qly52o

aguaviva··on Romanian court annuls result of presidential election first round
For what it's worth, the version of events that Wikipedia offers is much closer to what the commenter said than what you're saying:

   Muhammad Umar told Pakistan that he would be willing to turn bin Laden over to a third country, but the US refused, demanding a direct handover.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_invasion_of_Afgh...
aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
When Biden was trying to hand them over the country.

Effectively it was Trump who made that decision, via the Doha agreement.

Biden's role was merely to fumble the actual delivery as spectacularly as possible.

aguaviva··on Syrian government falls in end to 50-year rule of Assad family
Russian lost many battles against Afghanistan against the very same government today "taliban".

Except they weren't "the same" parties at all.

aguaviva··on Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satellites is now in orbit
Musk is better advised that it's a foolish attempt to become the fourth one.

Instead he managed to pull off a trick that not even Capone and Scientology were bold enough to try.

He became the government.

aguaviva··on The Albuquerque "Broken Arrow" Nuclear Accident
Ugh, the U.S. supported the Taliban during the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.

The Taliban did not exist during the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan.

If you can't get that right, after all these years -- how can you hope to make heads or tails out of whatever word salad you've been ingesting in regard to Syria?

aguaviva··on The Myth of Bananaland
Who would have ever thought that pushing a cold-war coalition eastwards towards an ex-superpower, including shoving it in its very borders, which it has long declared a "red line"

Except that's not what happened. In you know, actual, physical reality.

It's just what the aggressor told you, in its propaganda.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →