HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aguyfromnb

276 karma · joined November 16, 2019

submissionscomments
aguyfromnb··on Rolls-Royce plans mini nuclear reactors by 2029
>It's too expensive, dangerous and redundant in the face of emerging renewable tech which is becoming cheaper and more efficient by the month.

Why are you comparing the state of nuclear energy today with the potential scientific breakthroughs of renewable energy in the future?

If you compare nuclear of today with renewables of today, then the winner is clear. If you compare the two accounting for potential scientific breakthroughs..who knows?

aguyfromnb··on Man diagnosed with coronavirus near Seattle is being treated largely by a robot
>If you have decent insurance, you pay your maximum out of pocket and insurance pays the rest (at negotiated rates).

I think the OP's question was more: who decides this person gets treated by a state-of-the-art robot, while this person gets a prescription and told to go home and rest?

aguyfromnb··on We Wasted $50K on Google Ads So You Don't Have To (2019)
>If they can't understand what your business proposition is in 5 seconds you have failed landing page optimization.

Are these people searching through Google for a company like yours though?

aguyfromnb··on How housing became the world’s biggest asset class
>QE has impoverished us all (except for the fat bankers).

Tech people crying foul about "the bankers" making them poor them is hilarious. Easy money is big reason the industry is booming; it's made you rich (by any reasonable standard).

aguyfromnb··on Glenn Greenwald Charged with Cybercrimes in Brazil
>That doesn't mean there wasn't evidence to be found.

How can anyone ever clear their name with a mentality like this? They investigated and didn't find sufficient evidence. Saying, "yeah, but there could be evidence" means nothing will convince you.

aguyfromnb··on Glenn Greenwald Charged with Cybercrimes in Brazil
>but it's pretty clear that the Russians we're actively involved trying to get Trump elected.

Really? It's my understanding that the Russians were sowing controversy for all parties and all kinds of people. Intelligence officers have testified that this was the case during the impeachment hearings.

aguyfromnb··on Epic Tells Customers It Will Stop Google Cloud Integrations
>In fact, they could open a network of Google hospitals, and run their own software on them, or buy a big chain. Much like Amazon got WholeFoods,

I'm a fan of Google, but what's with people thinking Silicon Valley companies can easily "get into" everything? What business is Google in that leads you to believe they could run hospitals? They couldn't even design a decent social network, which is their wheelhouse. At least Amazon was selling groceries before they bought Whole Foods.

aguyfromnb··on Let People Move to Jobs
>banks can lend money that didn't exist until they lend it to you and that stops existing the moment you pay it back

Of course. How else should the money supply increase but to create it out of thin air? All of it is. Imagine not being able to buy a house until Fred paid mortgage his off? This is a reason why getting off the gold standard was a good idea. What's the point of having a dollar be equivalent to the price of an ounce of gold (which itself is an arbitrary peg), along with all the mechanisms required to maintain that peg? If you want something equal to the value of an ounce of gold, buy an ounce of gold.

This is what Bitcoin proponents get wrong about its use as a currency; a static supply is a problem. Why would you want to limit people's ability to perform transactions in the unit of account? If you can't increase the supply as needed, then you have to find ways to further divide what's out there (which is just the other side of the same coin).

aguyfromnb··on LastPass stores passwords so securely, not even its users can access them
>but the service just kept getting worse and worse

And more and more expensive. I used it for 8 years, cancelled this year after I noticed it was $45USD per year (over $50 CAD!). Impossible to justify with so many cheaper or free alternatives.

aguyfromnb··on “You're stealing our water”: Germans protest against Tesla gigafactory
>Compared to VW and Dieselgate, they’re saintly.

Your baseline for being a "good" corporate citizen is "better than VW"? That's a low bar.

The fact that you can point to 2 or 3 different analogues for corporate misdemeanor proves my point. Tesla is one company.

>But Tesla using tax subsidies in Nevada and not meeting Buffalo inventive targets?

It's not about "using subsidies". It's about making promises tied to those subsidies and not fulfilling them. Tesla is in tax arrears in Nevada. How is that possible for such a successful company? That money pays for services the company and employees uses. Is that something a "good corporate citizen" would allow to happen?

What about violating labour laws? Securities fraud? SWATing a whistle blower?

I will ask you this plainly: why are Tesla getting loans from a government running internment camps, and telling us "China is the future"? Musk wouldn't sit on a commitee with Trump, but will take his business to China? Is this really something a "good corporate citizen" would do? This is an obvious line in the sand to me and many other people.

Again, I make no claims that Tesla are necessarily better or worse than the next company. but you referred to them as "good corporate citizens". Attitudes like "you can do anything you want as long as it's in the name of being green" are going to seriously harm the climate change conversation in the long run.

aguyfromnb··on Let People Move to Jobs
You most certainly can lend money you don't have. Of course, you're going to have to come up with it somehow (so will the bank), likely by borrowing it. Which is fundamentally no different than what a bank does, albeit their balance sheets are larger and counterparties different. It's "borrowing" all the way down,and how the financial system works.
aguyfromnb··on “You're stealing our water”: Germans protest against Tesla gigafactory
>It's in Tesla's best interests to be a good corporate citizen, and they (in my opinion) walk the walk.

In which way are Tesla considered "good corporate citizens"? They are anti-union, not paying taxes in Nevada, being sued for racist environment in their factories, not fulfilling their obligations in Buffalo. I don't even feel like looking up other ones.

They'd be lucky to be called "average" corporate citizens. Can you give examples of how they are "good"?

aguyfromnb··on “You're stealing our water”: Germans protest against Tesla gigafactory
>Tesla should just build another factory in China.

Yeah, maybe they can build one in Xianjiang for cheaper labour. Why bother with laws?

aguyfromnb··on Hyundai and Kia back Arrival, a British startup making electric delivery vans
>then rapid acceleration seems like obvious low-hanging fruit

It's energy intensive.

aguyfromnb··on Volkswagen exec admits full self-driving cars 'may never happen'
>He has no software background...

Yeah, because making Formula 1 cars "go fast" involves no software whatsoever, right?

I love how you dismiss "Formula 1 engineer for many years". Maybe if he helped build a payment processor we could take him seriously.

>He has no idea how to make a self driving car.. and honestly, why would we think he would?

Because he's running the autonomous car division of the biggest automaker in the world? I have no idea if he's right or not, but dismissing him as not knowing what he's talking about is hubris. He's trying to build this stuff.

aguyfromnb··on Hyundai and Kia back Arrival, a British startup making electric delivery vans
>They can also probably deliver more packages per hour with how fast electric cars can speed up and regeneratively decelerate through stop signs and delivery destinations.

Is this sarcasm??? Do you honestly think that regenerative braking is harder/faster than brakes? Are you the type of person that is hard accelerating from every stop sign in the suburbs?

aguyfromnb··on How Tesla's battery costs impact its gross margins
>They could certainly get commodity seats from a traditional auto supplier, but they must have some line-of-sight to making them cheaper, or better or maybe just more customized than what a supplier would produce.

That's what they think. What do you think? Do you think it's possible for a single player to be the best builder in everything?

When it comes to manufacturing, the world is flattening out. You can produce things from components built and sourced all over the world. But Tesla is going in the other direction. One has to at least question their reasoning, and not assume "Elon knows best".

aguyfromnb··on How Tesla's battery costs impact its gross margins
>So compared to revenue, Tesla spends much more on R&D

No, they don't spend "much more".

Old, dying GM and high-flying, take-over-the-world Tesla spend nearly identical amounts as a percentage of revenue. How can that be possible? One is building factories and semi-trucks and solar roofs and AI chips and robo-taxis and "ramping up investment" and the other is going out of business (so I hear).

>None of them have a charging network or battery efficiency or battery production capacity close to what Tesla has.

Tesla arguably makes the best EV on the market right now, that's true. But this idea that no one wants anything else, once again, flies in the face of the data. Competitors are selling well all over the world. And that's what we want, isn't it?

>None of them have a charging network

The charging network was a genius way to get people to buy EVs at time when range anxiety was an issue. It was one of Elon's best moves.

But the days of it being a real competitive advantage are almost gone. Car companies don't own gas stations. It's cost center. Did you see the lines over the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays? Who wants that?

aguyfromnb··on How Tesla's battery costs impact its gross margins
Show us where it shows up on the financial statements then? I bet you cant. Because after stiffing Nevada[1], Buffalo[2], and California [3], Tesla went hat-in-hand to China for special loans and promises to pay taxes there[4]. I guess you could say it's "smart business", in the same way that PE buying a company, gutting it and selling it off for parts is "smart business". But make no mistake: China owns that factory.

This is not conspiracy, it's in their disclosures. I simply cannot understand what people root for a company doing these things.

[1] http://thestoreyteller.online/2020/01/17/tesla-surges-to-92b...

[2] https://nypost.com/2019/08/28/cuomos-buffalo-billion-tainted...

[3]https://www.vox.com/identities/2019/9/30/20891314/elon-musk-...

[4]https://www.autonews.com/china/tesla-pay-china-323-million-y...

aguyfromnb··on How Tesla's battery costs impact its gross margins
>Sure, but batteries are far more 'core' to Tesla's businesses than trucking or car carriers.

That's true, but I'm not sure it makes any more sense than car carriers. The cells that Tesla users for their battery packs are commodity products. Why would you bother to try to manufacture those? I mean, batteries are core to Apple's business too, but they aren't producing them.

The value-add is in their pack technology. The move back to vertical integration is odd.

aguyfromnb··on How Tesla's battery costs impact its gross margins
>Based on the companies they have been acquiring, it certainly looks like they want to start their own manufacturing.

They also bought a trucking company and said they were going to start building their own car carriers.

aguyfromnb··on How Tesla's battery costs impact its gross margins
>They'll sell the most lucrative products first while ramping up the R&D to tap into more markets when those eventually saturate.

People keep saying stuff like this, which has no basis in reality. Here is the data:

https://ycharts.com/companies/TSLA/r_and_d_expense

They haven't even doubled R&D with the Model 3, from a low base, and R&D has actually DECREASED since 3 years ago. Where do you see them "ramping up the R&D"?

Tesla is averaging about $1.5B annually in R&D spend. For comparison, GM spent $7.8B last year. VW spent over $13B.

Tesla aren't even investing fast enough to keep up with their capital depreciation, but somehow people keep saying things like, "they're re-investing all their profits". If they are, show the data.

>They have the Tesla semi ready to go as well in limited volumes

Really? Where are they building it?

aguyfromnb··on The Silicon Valley Economy Is Here. and It’s a Nightmare
>SoftBank is Japanese and its Vision Fund is mostly Japanese and Saudi money.

Does that money exist in a vacuum? No, it's invested in American companies, for the most part. SoftBank has set absurd valuations, which other VCs have benefited from.

aguyfromnb··on The Silicon Valley Economy Is Here. and It’s a Nightmare
>And as far as I can tell the whole SoftBank funded fake tech masquerade thing is starting to melt down, so?

If you think this starts and ends with SoftBank, you're crazy. SoftBank may be the biggest and worst offender, but this stuff is rampant in SV and the VC world. It goes well beyond the last few months.

You can pretend this is exaggeration, but public sentiment is starting to turn.

>What about the New York Economy. What about the DC Economy. What about the Texas Economy.

What about them?

This article is about the Silicon Valley Economy. Are you asserting that the NYT doesn't write articles covering wars or Wall Street scandals or political controversy? Their pages are filled with them. Go read those if that's what you're looking for.

aguyfromnb··on Google is finally killing off Chrome apps, which nobody really used
>Android apps and Crostini on Chromebooks are not two of them. In fact, Android apps is one of the migration paths away from Chrome apps, a fact this article fails to mention.

So should someone buy a new Chromebook on the hopes that this new system of apps will continue to be supported down the road? I think once you're burned once, that's hard to buy into.

aguyfromnb··on “Customer support at Tesla is even worse than I claimed last time”
>I'd rather enjoy discovering that Nicholas Taleb was bullshitting here...

I'll go with user error here, but who cares? What do they think, Taleb purchased boost on a whim to race someone at a red light, then asked for a refund when it was over? The fact that they straight up said "no refund" is crazy, and telling. I'll bet Tesla operates like an insurance company: deny all claims until it's too noisy to bear.

aguyfromnb··on New study: The advertising industry is systematically breaking EU law
Every time there's a corporate scandal of sorts (Boeing and Wells Fargo come to mind as recents), the people here scream for accountability.

So what say ye, Googlers, Facebook employees and others? Should fines or prison fall on your shoulders? Why do you continue to do it, knowing you are breaking the law? Knowing you are harming people? Glass houses and all that...

aguyfromnb··on A Man Who’s Spending $1B to Own Every Pop Song
Fortunately,demand also plays a part in price setting, and simply charging astronomical prices is a sure way to increase piracy or open new markets.
aguyfromnb··on Toyota will transform 175-acre Japan site into a ‘prototype city of the future’
Tunnels under cities to decrease traffic?
aguyfromnb··on Toyota will transform 175-acre Japan site into a ‘prototype city of the future’
>I want this so badly it hurts. I ache for it.

How badly? Because I assure you, there are many communities (caveat: I'm Canadian) where the idea of letting your child bike the streets is not equivalent to signing a death warrant.

Here's the rub: you have to leave the metropolis. Not many people are actually willing.

← PreviousPage 9 of 14Next →