HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ahaucnx

3,813 karma · joined June 20, 2020

Passionate about air quality monitoring. Founded AirGradient after experiencing hazardous smoke from wildfires in Northern Thailand. Many of our air quality monitors are open-source.

Contact: https://www.airgradient.com/support/

submissionscomments
ahaucnx··on An Overwhelmingly Negative and Demoralizing Force
Can we stop with MBA bashing?

I feel it degrades a whole group of people to a specific stereotype that might or might not be true.

How about lawyers, PhDs, political science majors, etc.

Let’s look at the humans and their character, not titles.

By the way, I have an MBA too and feel completely misjudged with statements like that.

ahaucnx··on I won't connect my dishwasher to your cloud
This is not only a problem with dishwashers, but a general trend with many electronic devices.

We see the same in the air quality monitoring industry, where more and more manufacturers lockdown their devices and make them cloud only operable. We at AirGradient are open source hardware (and can run completely local) and we are very successful with it. So things like this are actually opening up the market for new entrants or existing companies to highlight the benefits of non-cloud models for the consumers.

So I do hope that these kind of post like from Jeff Geerling create more awareness also among the normal consumers to change their buying behavior and bulk that trend.

ahaucnx··on I outsourced my memory to an AI pin and all I got was fanfiction
It seems that the actual hardware is just a dumb microphone with a Bluetooth connection to the phone and basically the whole thing is running on the cloud. Couldn’t e.g. an always on AirPod etc do the same trick?
ahaucnx··on U.S. State Department Shuts Down Pollution Monitoring Abroad
This is actually affecting a few of our projects in countries without hardly any air quality monitors where we use(d) these stations at the embassies to calibrate our low-cost open source monitors.

It's really ironic, because this project started on Twitter and also there is a good study out there about how cost effective these monitors are [1].

[1] https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2201092119

ahaucnx··on Why Blog If Nobody Reads It?
There are couple of reasons why I blog. Some of them are the typical ones like to reach my audience, to inform about your products or opinions that I have.

But there is one thing that hasn’t been mentioned here yet.

Sometimes I also blog to put something onto the record.

For example, if there’s something really important for me that the company should follow like our open source philosophy.

I blog about it to make sure that people see it and measure us against it. It is basically a way for me to help we stay on our course because we don’t want to break a public record.

ahaucnx··on [dead]
Yes I agree.

You should be transparent about promoting your own company. Sneaking it into like this will definitely backfire.

What prevents you from being open about it?

ahaucnx··on 2024: A Record-Breaking Year for the Ocean Cleanup
I live in Thailand and I applaud their work - also here at the Chao Praya river.

However, I wonder if the money would not be better spend in lobbying, enforcing etc. a plastic tax on throw away plastic goods.

In my home country in Germany, the use of throw away plastic is much less due to effective regulations.

If we have only a finite amount of money to stop plastic pollution, invest it in recycling or avoidance?

ahaucnx··on How my indoor air made me sick and dumb (and how I fixed it)
I think in general it's a very good article and I like the summary in the end how the different interventions can also have trade offs.

The only thing I would disagree with is the recommendation of the uHoo monitor. There are many people not happy with the accuracy and AQSpec, a US EPA test center, also tested the unit with pretty bad results.

See http://www.aqmd.gov/docs/default-source/aq-spec/field-evalua...

ahaucnx··on Building a Self-Hostable Product
We do something on the IoT side with our local first air quality monitors. So no forced platform lock in or subscriptions. We are pretty much the only one in the space doing this and it has definitely been a big advantage for us to differentiate ourselves. I think there is a big underserved market with self hostable products (didn't we once call these desktop applications ;) Wish you all the best with your business model.
ahaucnx··on What happened to the world's largest tube TV? [video]
Yes, I immediately noticed that it's likely AI written and I thought that this really discounts an otherwise great story.

What I mean is that if the author does not put in the least effort to make it not AI sounding, how much does the author actually care about his/her content?

ahaucnx··on The era of open voice assistants
It's not clear to me from the description if this is also completely open source hardware. Are the schematics, BoM, firmware published under a permissible license? If so, where are they accessible?

And if not, I would be curious to know why it haven't been fully open sourced.

ahaucnx··on Xiaomi Home Integration for Home Assistant
Actually since a year or so, we use the ESP32-C3 and the SHT40. You can check our website for the new model [1].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/documentation/

ahaucnx··on Xiaomi Home Integration for Home Assistant
Not all manufacturers.

At AirGradient, all our air quality monitors can completely run local. Our official firmware is on GitHub and people could even flash their own (adjusted) version.

We believe this is how IoT devices should be and are very vocal about it. So I think there are a few manufacturers that think different.

ahaucnx··on Facebook's Little Red Book
For me it started with AltaVista.
ahaucnx··on I Want an Honest Office
I am not sure if I agree.

In turn this would mean that if a company is profitable, it can have a nice office and spend more money into "unnecessary" things?

Wouldn't it be better to reinvest that profit into the business to make it even more profitable and grow it?

Doesn't the story somehow imply that as soon as you are profitable you can rest on your success? For me that could mean the beginning of the end.

I think you should provide a decent office to your employees to be productive without unnecessary luxuries and it doesn't really matter if the company is profitable or not.

ahaucnx··on Show HN: The App I Built to Help Manage My Diabetes
This comment looks so much ChatGPT / Gemini generated.

I'm not against using it but it feels inappropriate for hacker news discussions and I am not really sure it adds value.

ahaucnx··on Show HN: I built a(nother) house optimized for LAN parties
I would recommend to use an TVOC sensor that detects smell very easily and then automatically switch on a fan. Could be a fun project.

Just need: - TVOC sensor like the SGP41

- ESP32 microcontroller

- Electric Relay

ahaucnx··on Installed an open source garage door opener, and I'm loving it
It's great to see more and more open source hardware products that work seamlessly with home assistant.

Home assistant is getting more and more user friendly and these open IoT devices also improve significantly.

I am quite positive that there will be an "alternative" ecosystem to proprietary subscription locking in ones.

ahaucnx··on We're experimenting with advertising
Asking for feedback from the community but not directly indicating how this feedback can be submitted sounds to me insincere and probably just PR speech.
ahaucnx··on Open washing – why companies pretend to be open source
I believe often companies or rather decision makers are afraid of going fully open-source because they invested a lot of money into the product and are afraid some other company uses it, offers it cheaper and ultimately harms the originator.

So even they might believe in open-source they put protections in place that ultimately lock it down and thus make it closed source but trying to keep the impression of being open.

In our journey at AirGradient towards becoming fully open-source hardware (all code and hardware licensed under CC-BY-SA), we had the same concerns but ultimately decided to go full-in and open up everything with an officially approved open-source license.

I believe there are a few important aspects and "protections" that are open-source compatible that help companies protect their investments.

Firstly, requiring Attribution is compatible with open-source and can help companies get a lot of visibility and competitors probably don't want to attribute another company and thus are often not likely to clone.

Secondly, using a share-alike license also makes it unattractive for many other companies using the code.

Lastly, I believe the code itself is often not the valuable part compared to the brand value, employees, reputation, business model, network and implicit knowledge that a company builds up.

It really worked for us to go that way with a true open-source license and I hope many others will do it too.

There are already some easy to understand licenses like CC in place and I do hope that they also create awareness around "open washing".

ahaucnx··on Ask HN: Founders, what was the major sourcing channel for your first 100 users?
Check out Mautic. You can self host and connect to AWS SES for a very low cost solution.
ahaucnx··on Source-Available Is Meaningless
We open sourced our air quality monitor (firmware & hardware) under CC-BY-SA.

The SA (share-a-like) gives quite a lot of protection in regards to the concerns that the author rises as most companies that would take our source code would not be willing to keep it open and also probably not so keen to attribute us as originators.

I think what also many people forget is that the source-code is actually only a small part of business success. In my opinion the network, reputation and community that a company builds has much more value than the actual code.

We went fully open source hardware more than 2 years ago and it was probably one of our best decisions as a company.

ahaucnx··on Low Cost CO2 Sensors Comparison: Photo-Acoustic vs. NDIR
There are many cases where the level does not drop to ambient levels, e.g. offices in basements, low-energy houses etc.

We even saw schools where the classrooms were not able to drop to ambient levels over the whole unoccupied weekend because the ppm levels on Friday afternoon were beyond 3000ppm.

The automatic baseline calibration period of some of the NDIR CO2 sensors can actually be adjusted through the software. I believe the Aranet allows that and also we do have that feature on the AirGradient dashboard. So you can switch it to a much longer period or switch it off completely.

ahaucnx··on Low Cost CO2 Sensors Comparison: Photo-Acoustic vs. NDIR
Achim, founder of AirGradient here. Just want to clarify that this submit was not done by me or our team.
ahaucnx··on Low Cost CO2 Sensors Comparison: Photo-Acoustic vs. NDIR
The MH-Z19 is similar from the performance of the S8 but we do see more noise in the readings and the MH-Z19 also seem to have less life time. We see some of them dying after around 5 years whereas the S8 has a ten year warranty and so far have been rock solid for us.
ahaucnx··on Infineon's CO2 Sensor Monitors Indoor Air Quality
If you take the time and actually read the blog post I linked to, you will see that mostly it is about indoor CO2.

However, to understand the performance of these different sensor technologies it is important to point out that they fail under certain environmental conditions, e.g. outdoors.

ahaucnx··on They stole my voice with AI
There are definitely elements in the voice that totally sound like Jeff.
ahaucnx··on Infineon's CO2 Sensor Monitors Indoor Air Quality
Not sure what you mean with calibration here. Above is not so much about calibration but correlation. Basically comparing the monitors to the reference data.
ahaucnx··on Infineon's CO2 Sensor Monitors Indoor Air Quality
Outdoor CO2 levels can go up to 700-800ppm in rural areas due to plants creating CO2 [1]. I was initially surprised it's that high but it was verified with reference instruments.

Why measure CO2 outdoors?

We are able to detect emission sources pretty well now with our outdoor monitors [2] that have the SenseAir S8 NDIR sensor built in. You can see some real data in the blog post I wrote about launching our global CO2 map [3].

So setting up a dense network of these sensors in a city would allow to measure if for example the introduction of low-emission zones or switching to electric buses etc. would work.

Another use case is to check for leakage in underground CO2 storage facilities.

All-in-all it's still experimental (to some extent) but we know the accuracy is there and we can see more and more use cases as outlined in my blog post. So we now work hard to get more and more of these sensors out there to get more data to identify additional use cases.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/performance-of-low-cost-co2...

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/outdoor/

[3] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/airgradient-global-co2-map/

ahaucnx··on Infineon's CO2 Sensor Monitors Indoor Air Quality
Great project, lovely design and super cool that it's also open source hardware.

We at AirGradient open sourced our monitors around 2 years ago and this has been the best decision for our company.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →