HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ahaucnx

3,813 karma · joined June 20, 2020

Passionate about air quality monitoring. Founded AirGradient after experiencing hazardous smoke from wildfires in Northern Thailand. Many of our air quality monitors are open-source.

Contact: https://www.airgradient.com/support/

submissionscomments
ahaucnx··on Infineon's CO2 Sensor Monitors Indoor Air Quality
We did some extensive testing of photo-acoustic and optical NDIR CO2 sensors indoors as well as outdoors and also in comparison to scientific reference instruments.

I just updated the blog post that I wrote last year [1] with the specs of this new Infineon sensor and also our experiences with doing CO2 measurement outdoors.

In summary we can say that under normal indoor conditions (e.g. small range of temperature, relative high range of CO2 etc.), the photo-acoustic NDIR sensors perform well.

However, outdoors they significantly underperform optical NDIR sensors to the extent that they are barely usable. See for example this chart [2].

It's hard to say why exactly they perform so poorly outdoors but I believe that they rely on quite complex internal algorithms that probably have been only developed with typical indoor conditions in mind and as soon as some parameters like temperature are out of the typical range, they significantly drop in their performance.

Furthermore, we also detected that they are sensitive to interference from low frequency noise which could for example come from ventilation systems, refrigerators etc. This is not surprising as they rely on their internal microphone to do the photo-acoustic measurements.

All of this and the rock-solid performance we see with optical NDIR sensors made us quite wary about the photo-acoustic sensors and not use them in our open-source hardware monitors. As I said, I believe they work quite well in general but because we saw also some really strange and unexpected behavior of these photo-acoustic sensors, I'd now always prefer optical NDIR sensors if possible.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/co2-sensors-photo-acoustic-...

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/co2-sensors-photo-acoustic-...

ahaucnx··on Will open science change chemistry?
I'm a strong proponent of open data but I think it needs to go beyond science. Companies should also be incentivized or even required for keeping designs, data, interfaces etc. open. Because often scientists are reliant on devices and data platforms that restrict ownership. So even if the scientist wants to keep his data open, a product or a service that the scientist uses for his research might prevent this.
ahaucnx··on Founder Mode
I agree 100%.

I would really underline the ability of the founder to have this pretty unique ability to see and set the strategic direction of the startup which requires a lot of abstract thinking with the tactical and operational skills to make sure you earn money right now.

ahaucnx··on Is Your Air Quality Monitor Trustworthy? How to Test and Find Out
We were working on this blog post for a few months to make sure it's really detailed. Happy to answer any questions.
ahaucnx··on Canada wildfires last year released more carbon than several countries
This -among climate change in general- is one of the reasons we launched the largest crowd sourced real time CO2 map. [1]

The main idea behind is to create more awareness on local and regional emissions like the wildfires in Canada as well as to generate public available data with a dense network of CO2 sensors for scientific research. [2]

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/map

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/airgradient-global-co2-map/

ahaucnx··on We Don't Have Any Sales People
I wrote that article.

This is something that I'm quite serious about and finally managed to write about it.

I would be very interested to hear some thoughts on it from the hn community because I wonder if there is an important aspect that we somehow completely miss.

ahaucnx··on Why Ed-Tech Startups Don't Scale (2022)
I second that.

Originally we were targeting schools as our main customers but found it incredible difficult to sell too.

The main reason probably that the beneficiaries (the students) are not the decision makers (the school admin) and that our product (air quality) is also not a core aspect of a school.

There also seems to be a run to the bottom regarding quality of products in many schools and no appreciation for sustainable and long lasting products.

We moved on in the meantime which is a pity because we would have loved to work more with students on air pollution and climate change.

ahaucnx··on Launch HN: Sorcerer (YC S24) – Weather balloons that collect more data
Interesting. I have two questions:

1) What parameters are you measuring ? Did you think about also measuring gases?

2) What's your business model?

ahaucnx··on Clean Fuel Startups Are Collapsing
One issue could be that many of these startups are venture funded. So they don't need to quickly find a solution that works and then scale up.

As a result they might spends too many resources on something that just doesn't bring a net benefit in the end.

I understand that some of these technologies need large upfront funding but there needs to be a better vetting in place about their success probability.

ahaucnx··on Detailed Map of Cancer-Causing Industrial Air Pollution in the U.S.
I think the scary thing is that we can measure these health outcomes and probably connect to a source like a chemical plant but we still don't understand what exactly is causing the cancer.

For example there are more than 10.000 VOCs in the air. Some are harmless but many are not. It's extremely difficult to measure them and categorize them and nearly impossible to do so in real time.

So even though the EPA measures air quality continuously, they probably only cover a fraction of the harmful substances in the air.

ahaucnx··on Ask HN: What do you monitor on your servers?
Be careful with hosted services like Amazon CloudWatch. They can get quite expensive if you log too many details. I think you can really save a lot of money with your own solution, eg using Prometheus / Grafana.
ahaucnx··on NASA Citizen Scientists Spot Object Moving 1M Miles per Hour
With more affordable sensor technology, citizen science has a huge potential to become a strong force just by being able to deploy a large number of people in a short time span.

However some of the problems is that it's not really recognized (yet) by academia and governments and thus also not adequately funded.

It would be great if there is a more systematic approach to citizen science but only in astronomy but also global challenges like climate change and biodiversity.

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
The clarity also uses the Plantower sensor. A high price does not necessarily mean better sensor modules.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
You raise some good points. I will reflect on them. Thanks!
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
I had a look but it's unclear that it is an NDIR CO2 sensor. There are cheap Chinese CO2 sensors that actually do not measure CO2 but estimate it from VOCs. You can test this easily. Spray some Ethanol around your sensor and see if the CO2 rises a lot. If so then it's not a real CO2 sensor.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
Achim Founder of AirGradient here. Yes, I'm curious about this too.

Could you clarify what exactly in this post you think is spammy?

We do try to write interesting and informative blog posts and also highlight important aspects that are not that generally known. Like in this article the data ownership issue of the AirThings.

In fact as part of our open-source philosophy we also see our responsibility creating awareness and informing about these things.

Why shouldn't we then try and distribute these posts to for example hacker news?

The posts only get traction if people like the content and upvote it. What's wrong with that?

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
Achim from AirGradient here.

I'm often personally going on Zoom call with customers to make sure they get 100% out of the monitor and address these types of questions. Please send me a note through our support form and I'm happy to help [1]. Please make a note in the support ticket to this link so that it will get assigned right to me.

Now regarding the CO2 sensor. We use the SenseAir S8 which is one of the best NDIR sensors out there. If you do not like the auto calibration, you can now switch this off in the dashboard or change the automatic baseline calibration to longer periods. To do this, go to Place Settings, General Place Settings.

In case you still have these wild swings, contact our support with your sensor ID and we will have a look.

Regarding VOC, this has also recently addressed and you can now change the learning gain offset to make it more behave like an absolute sensor. We clearly describe the behavior of the VOC sensor on our website and this is actually the behavior of all newer generations of VOC sensors. We use the Sensirion SGP41 which is regarded one of the best ones.

Now, you are free to call it a "useless piece" but I'd appreciate if we keep the discussion fact based. As far as I know, there is no other air quality monitor in the same price range that is substantially better than ours.

Measuring air quality pollutants is not as simple as measuring temperature so there are inherent shortcoming in some of them. It is part of our mission to educate people on these. This is why we published for example the air quality cheatsheet. [2]

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/support/

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/documents/infographics/AQ-Monito...

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
I am not ruling it out in the long term. I actually also would love to have a wired Ethernet connection and if we grow further we might very well come to the point where the 5% really matter and we have more resources available to develop it.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
The DIY basic will be back in stock soon. What we discontinued is the DIY pro that was the larger unit but to be soldered.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
The reason we did not do the AQ-Spec yet is that we are still doing a lot of research into fine tuning the accuracy of the monitor. For this we run a co-location project with more than 25 sites around the world. Here we compare the AirGradient to reference grade instruments to see exactly how they perform and which algorithms can tune them better. You can read more about this on our research page [1].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/research/

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
We used to have a DIY version that required soldering but the problem was that a number of people overestimated their soldering skills and couldn't get it done. Then obviously that is frustrating for them. So we discontinued it for now. I would love to bring back a more "advanced" version in the future.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
Yes, these things have come up quite a few times. Regarding Radon there are unfortunately no 3rd party sensor modules available that we know off (and are reasonably priced). If you know any, please let us know.

Regarding PoE, we have made a survey some time ago and less than 5% of the users were interested in PoE. However, the hardware integration is not straight forward and it would increase the price of the unit for all customers. This is the main reason we did not do it yet.

However our open hardware has an extension plug and this could be an excellent community project for somebody to develop this as an extension card and then share the design.

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
With our latest firmware we now natively support Home Assistant and the monitors are auto discovered. So no need to flash ESPHome anymore.

We also expose a local API that makes it very easy to make GET requests to the monitor within your local network and basically gives you all possibilities for easy integration.

[1]https://www.airgradient.com/home-assistant/

[2]https://github.com/airgradienthq/arduino/blob/master/docs/lo...

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient One vs. Airthings
Achim from AirGradient here. You raise an excellent point.

Often T&C are indeed just written by lawyers and potentially not being enforced at all.

However, it really does restrict what you can do with the monitors in practical ways.

Let's say you want to build a business around using AirThings monitors with your own dashboard analysing the data and giving value added services. If you don't officially own the data, are you actually allowed to use it and monetize it for your own purposes?

With these T&Cs and if you do this (and I actually know a few companies that do exactly that) you open a legal liability that AirThings could come after you.

ahaucnx··on We Launched the Largest Real-Time Global CO2 Map
Use the orange button on the top left to switch to CO2. Default is PM2.5.
ahaucnx··on We Launched the Largest Real-Time Global CO2 Map
If possible mount it: - at least 1.5m above ground to avoid dust from the ground getting into the sensor - avoid proximity to HVAC system or barbecue grills etc that could influence the sensor - if possible mount it in permanent shadow so that you get a relative accurate temperature reading (if needed)
ahaucnx··on We Launched the Largest Real-Time Global CO2 Map
Yes it's easy to upgrade. You can purchase the CO2 module in our online shop under the spare parts section.

The CO2 module will go into one of the PM slots. So you will have a spare PM sensor.

Feel free to also contact me through our web site support form if you have special questions on the upgrade.

ahaucnx··on We Launched the Largest Real-Time Global CO2 Map
Yes. There are many PM maps with a lot more monitors like PurpleAir map but I don't know any for CO2 comparable to what we launched.
ahaucnx··on We Launched the Largest Real-Time Global CO2 Map
Yes, at some point we probably need to lift the adjustment above 400 for the automatic baseline calibration which is easily doable.
ahaucnx··on We Launched the Largest Real-Time Global CO2 Map
At the moment we have the automatic baseline calibration set to a default of seven days. This means the sensor modules auto calibrate to around 400ppm every week. This typically gets them very close to each other when co-located.

However, as the article points out, the measurements are not reference grade and should not be taken as an absolute correct value but our tests show that the sensor modules are actually performing very well [1].

Rather it is important to look at the patterns of the measurements, e.g. do they correlate with traffic patterns or wind directions (e.g. downstream from a power plant etc).

I think the example I give in the original post about the pollution from the speed boats captures this quite well.

We do hope that with this open-source hardware project, we can motivate much more people to build a monitor and contribute their data. Then with the growing data set there can be extremely interesting applications with machine learning and adding additional data sources like wind direction, emission inventories etc.

The data is freely available through our public API [2] and if somebody wants to start modelling it, please get in touch with us. It would be great to co-operate.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/performance-of-low-cost-co2...

[2] https://api.airgradient.com/public/docs/api/v1/

← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →