HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ahaucnx

3,813 karma · joined June 20, 2020

Passionate about air quality monitoring. Founded AirGradient after experiencing hazardous smoke from wildfires in Northern Thailand. Many of our air quality monitors are open-source.

Contact: https://www.airgradient.com/support/

submissionscomments
ahaucnx··on We Launched the Largest Real-Time Global CO2 Map
All data is crowd sourced from people that purchased our open-source outdoor monitor Open Air [1] either as a kit or the fully assembled version.

Once the monitor is operating, the user can opt-in to make the data public and enter longitude and latitude of the location. Then it will appear as that spot on the map. If people have privacy concerns we recommend them to just move the location a bit off from their exact one.

A level of 702ppm is not necessarily an indicator for an emission source. There are quite substantial natural diurnal cycles, especially in the country side as plants emit CO2 in the night. We have observerd peaks with up to 800ppm just based on that.

I think a common misconception is around climate change that we believe that the 430ppm that we currently have is very constant across the atmosphere when in reality it can have substantial variations.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/outdoor/

ahaucnx··on We Launched the Largest Real-Time Global CO2 Map
Achim from AirGradient here.

We are super thrilled about launching this and the examples that I describe in the blog post are quite encouraging that we can get some really useful data out of it.

Happy to answer any questions.

ahaucnx··on Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?
It's now called "OneOpenAir.ino". We are still in the process to update the help files.
ahaucnx··on US EPA Enforcement and Compliance on Apple Fabrication
Achim from AirGradient here. Please contact me with our website support page. Happy to send you a free monitor to help.
ahaucnx··on Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?
Achim from AirGradient here. I fully understand your frustration.

Maybe a bit of background information to put this into perspective.

Until around a year ago, the open-source DIY kits where a seperate 'side project' as we focused on our (now retired) closed source air quality monitors.

However last year we decided to go fully open-source hardware and started to merge the closed source features into the open-source firmware. Because we needed a much better code base, a complete re-write was required (also supporting two different MCUs).

So the last 6 months was really a transition period and things were a bit messy but I believe we have a much better onboarding and instructions [1] now available on the website and are continuing to work on it.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/documentation/

ahaucnx··on Ask HN: What indoor CO2 monitor do you recommend?
Achim, founder of AirGradient here.

These are all valid points that came up at the beginning of the year and we took this feedback very seriously.

I'm happy to let you know that we have implemented already point 1) and 2) in the latest firmware version.

You can now set the "learning gain offset" for TVOC and NOx from the default 24h to basically 1 year. As a result the monitor will behave much more like an absolute TVOC monitor as the baseline reset is much longer.

We have also implemented the automatic baseline calibration period, which you can now set to a much longer period than one week.

We are also looking into feeding the last vale back into the sensor to avoid the reboot issue but this is more tricky to implement.

By the way, if you compare the granularity that we offer now to fine tune the sensor modules, I'm not aware of any competitor offering the same feature set. But we won't stop here. We currently working on fine tuning compensation algorithms for PM.

ahaucnx··on Toxicity of Wildfire Smoke Could Be Ten Times Greater Than That of Ambient PM
We just published this article yesterday. Happy to answer any questions that might come up.
ahaucnx··on Own a weather station? We want your data
It would be great if this could be extended with air pollution data. Combined with weather data like wind speed and wind direction, the data could be of great use in forecasting for example air pollution from wildfires.

There are some platforms for air pollution like OpenAQ [1] or sensor.community [2] but as far as I know none really has such an open API like weather.gov and allows individual contributions.

[1] https://openaq.org/

[2] https://sensor.community/en/

ahaucnx··on CO2 helps viruses stay alive longer in the air
Airthings has some good hardware and I like the e-ink display but it has terrible terms of use that severely restrict your ownership rights.

Here are some excerpts from Airthings T&Cs [1] that I find very problematic:

In 15.4. of Airthings T&C it writes: “We own and shall retain ownership of all rights to all data and information collected via the Services provided to you…”

Furthermore, in 15.2 Airthings claims all rights for modifications that you might carry out on the Airthings monitor: “You hereby assign to Airthings all right, title, and interest (including Intellectual Property Rights) that you may have in any custom developments, modifications, or derivative works of the Services and Products created or developed by or for you, including but not limited to design, artwork, technology, software, data, functionality, and documentation.”

I wrote about it in a review with our monitor [2].

[1] https://www.airthings.com/en/legal/terms-of-use

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/airgradient-vs-airthings/

(Edited and included Airthings T&C)

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient vs. Airthings
After our last comparison with the Purple Air monitor got a positive response here on Hacker News, we wrote another review. This time comparing our indoor monitor AirGradient ONE with the popular Airthings View Plus.

Happy to answer any questions.

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient vs. Purple Air
Thanks for letting me know. It's fixed now.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient vs. Purple Air
The most important thing is that you use an NDIR CO2 sensor. The best are in my opinion from SenseAir (e.g. the S8 that we use in our monitors). Then you can also get them from Sensirion, Winsen or Cubic. I believe for normal operations they perform all quite well.

Important is that you can adjust the automatic baseline calibration duration if you operate the sensor in a closed space that does not regularly get fresh air. Ideally put it into a longer period like 30 or 90 days or switch off and manually calibrate it regularly. I believe not many monitors offer that flexibility out of the box.

If you have some basic electronic skills, you can actually look at our open source build instructions and just build the basic monitor with the CO2 module [1].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/documentation/diy-v4/

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient vs. Purple Air
I believe that the Sensirion SGP41 is the slightly better VOC sensor and it also gives an NOx signal that can be useful:

"The testing results show that the SGP41 has a better response for 9/10 tested VOC solvents and can detect the level of NOx gases, which is a unique and important feature for hazardous and toxic gas detection and alarm systems."[1]

In general measuring VOCs is quite challenging and people really need to understand these type of sensors. A couple of months ago, I wrote a whole blog post about these issues. [2].

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9654358/

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/tvoc-explainer/

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient vs. Purple Air
Yes and to be honest, most of the air quality monitors use very similar PM modules.

So often there is not too much difference in the accuracy of the monitors. I wrote about this some time ago [1].

However when it comes to data ownership, API access, costs and repairability that's where there are big differences. In many reviews these aspects are in my opinion not enough covered.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/most-aq-monitors-use-same-p...

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors Compared: AirGradient vs. Purple Air
We plan to compare more monitors. This is the first of this kind of reviews so we want to first see how well it is accepted and then do more.
ahaucnx··on Record-breaking increase in CO2 levels in atmosphere
In comparison to air pollution measurements of PM2.5, there are not many monitors out there that measure CO2.

Last year we started experimenting with measuring CO2 outdoors with low cost sensors and saw promising results in the accuracy compared to much more expensive reference stations [1].

As a result we added CO2 to our open source hardware air quality monitor AirGradient Open Air [2].

I'm very thankful that 1000+ of these outdoor monitors have already been deployed over the last couple of months by our strong community.

With a large amount of these monitors out there, we can make a significant contribution to understand better where exactly these emissions are coming from and ways to reduce them.

Climate change and air pollution are linked together but too often still a separate discussion. By bringing both into an open hardware project, I do hope we can have a positive impact.

Please reach out if you have questions or want to participate!

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/performance-of-low-cost-co2...

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/outdoor/

ahaucnx··on Ask HN: What have you built with ESPHome, ESP8266 or similar hardware
Last year I wrote a blog post [1] about different CO2 sensors and how they work. The best are NDIR (light) followed by photo acoustic sensors. Indoors they have very similar performance but outdoors, the NDIR (light) are much more accurate. In my personal opinion, the best ones are from SenseAir.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/co2-sensors-photo-acoustic-...

ahaucnx··on ESPHome
First of all many thanks for helping to maintain such a great project!

The feedback I have right now is that for the ESP32-C3 chip, provisioning over USB (Improv_serial) is not supported. So then the only option is to do provisioning over BLE if you want to get the "Made for ESPHome" certification.

However, this blew up our partition size from 1.2 MB to 1.9 MB and basically prevented us to add any further code and we got stuck there (we now develop a native HA integration).

So my feedback would be to try and reduce the overhead for the provisioning.

ahaucnx··on ESPHome
What I love most about ESPHome is the strong and engaged community.

For our open-source hardware air quality monitors [1], a member of the community developed a sophisticated ESPHome integration [2]. His integration comes with all features that we have in our default open-source firmware. Sometimes he was even quicker implementing new features than we did! So in a way, this helped and motivated us to make our own software version better (kind of open source competition).

So a big thank-you from my side to such a great community!

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/

[2] https://github.com/MallocArray/airgradient_esphome

ahaucnx··on How to Determine the Error of an Air Quality Sensor?
These are all excellent points that demonstrate the complexity of air quality measurement -especially for PM.

We are planning many more articles like this one and hopefully step by step we can cover some of these aspects as well.

ahaucnx··on How to Determine the Error of an Air Quality Sensor?
Yes that's a good point. We will look for more suitable photos to illustrate this better - ideally from the same city. We could probably use Chiang Mai, Thailand where our company of located and has wide annual swings of air quality.
ahaucnx··on How to Determine the Error of an Air Quality Sensor?
Just to clarify. We label the banner BELOW the article with this disclaimer. The article itself is purely written from a science perspective and not at all an advertisement.
ahaucnx··on How to Determine the Error of an Air Quality Sensor?
It really depenends on the PM sensors you use. For the Plantower 5003 we use in our monitors, you only hear a faint noise from the fan when you put it directly at your ear. However some other monitors need an extra fan in the enclosure and some of them can get noisy.

For CO2, the Sensirion SCD41 is a good sensor which uses photo accoustic principle. We found NDIR sensors using light spectometrie to be a bit more accurate like the SenseAir S8. Price wise the two are quite similar.

ahaucnx··on How to Determine the Error of an Air Quality Sensor?
I believe you talk about the section about normalized RMSE (nRMSE). The nRMSE on the right side is 6% and thus lower than the nRMSE on the left side with 66%. The lower the nRMSE the better. So I believe the article is correct.

However it's always important to not only look at one performance metric but a bundle, e.g. including R2 for the correlation to make a good judgement of a sensor quality.

We covered some of the basics in an earlier article [1].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/sensor-performance-precisio...

ahaucnx··on How to Determine the Error of an Air Quality Sensor?
This post is part of a series of posts. We already wrote a few posts about sensor calibrations, e.g. how to develop a correction algorithm for temperature [1] or how to use R for making a linear regression [2].

In one of the next topics we will dive more into PM correction and the sensitivity to relative humidity.

If you want to know more about the science of air quality monitoring, we are also running webinars that you can watch on our reserach page [3].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/slr-temperature-example/

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/using-r-for-sensor-correcti...

[3] https://www.airgradient.com/research/

ahaucnx··on How to Determine the Error of an Air Quality Sensor?
Achim from AirGradient here. Thank you for your support. Very appreciated.

We are currently working on bringing a lot more features into our open-source firmware [1], for example mDNS, local API etc. to make it even easier for non-cloud connectivity. We are also working on an offical home assistant integration.

[1] https://github.com/airgradienthq/arduino [2] https://www.airgradient.com/documentation/local-server/

ahaucnx··on Open Source Hardware Is Not a New Concept
Hardware and software is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0 Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International.

It's mentioned in our build instructions but we can probably make it more clear in the terms and conditions.

So yes you can take our existing design and launch a competing product as long as you keep it under the same license.

ahaucnx··on How I decide if your website is worth a revisit
I think what's often underestimated is actually the performance improvement you get from removing trackers.

I did so 2 months ago for our landing page and it now loads 4 times faster [1].

Fun fact. All the tracking I removed I am not missing at all because I actually never used it [2].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/load-times-improvement-with...

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/why-do-we-need-so-much-trac...

ahaucnx··on We own all rights to all data collected via products purchased by you
Author here.

This issues really itches me and it would be great to hear opinions on this. Maybe I am too sensitive for these things? Please let me know your thoughts!

ahaucnx··on Jeff Geerling reviews MNT Reform open-source laptop [video]
Even though this laptop seems to be a bit impractical and really made for very specific (hacker) use cases, it's great to see more open hardware options coming up.

Hopefully MNT will use the same philosophy and design a more main stream laptop with better ergonomics and a faster processor in the future. Then it could be something, I would consider purchasing.

← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →