HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ahaucnx

3,813 karma · joined June 20, 2020

Passionate about air quality monitoring. Founded AirGradient after experiencing hazardous smoke from wildfires in Northern Thailand. Many of our air quality monitors are open-source.

Contact: https://www.airgradient.com/support/

submissionscomments
ahaucnx··on Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled in the real market
One of our community members actually added Home Kit support.

See: https://forum.airgradient.com/t/airgradient-integrations/703...

ahaucnx··on Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled in the real market
At the moment you need to flash ESPHome onto it (can be done easily via the browser) and then there is a well maintained ESPHome configuration script available.

https://github.com/MallocArray/airgradient_esphome

ahaucnx··on Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled in the real market
This is definitely on our radar.

At the moment we still have a lot of dynamics in the product, eg frequent firmware updates on the shipped units and this is why we currently prefer to ship directly.

Once things are more settled down we will look for fulfillment centers in Europe and the US.

ahaucnx··on Matter, set to fix smart home standards in 2023, stumbled in the real market
It's true that the trend in the industry definitely goes towards subscriptions and closed eco systems.

We at AirGradient see that very well that more and more companies force their users into the cloud and some monitors even refuse to show current air quality when not registered to the cloud. Imagine you would need to register your fever thermometer with an app in the cloud before you could measure your temperature...

Part of the problem is not only the investors in Matter but also VC funded smart home equipment manufacturers that are pressured to go down the recurring revenue business model.

At AirGradient [1] we want to demonstrate a counter example. Our fully certified air quality monitors are open source hardware and thus we provide the firmware code and they can be easily re-flashed with whatever software you like to use. With this openness a great community has emerged that maintains integrations to various systems like Home Assistant via ESPHome.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/

ahaucnx··on ESP32 Wemos D1 Mini – Sprinkler Controller Open Source
We used a few thousand of the D1 mini (ESP8266) for our air quality monitor kits and had a couple of issues.

On some of them the WiFi would not work at all. Kind of like the onboard antenna was not properly connected. Other died after a few months without any special reason that we were aware of.

Another problem with these boards is that you do not know exactly the specs of the other components. For example we got different rated voltage regulators (5v to 3.3) that caused some issues because sensors we put on the 3.3v did have higher requirements.

Interestingly we had more issues with the "original" ones than the clones. I actually wrote a small blog post about it [1].

Another issue is that it is difficult to get proper ROHS and REACH certifications for these modules. This makes it difficult if you want to use them in a finished and certified product.

All of these issues added up and we made the switch away from the module and now put the ESP32-C3-MINI directly onto the PCBs of our indoor and outdoor air quality monitors. Together with an external hardware watchdog, this seems to pretty much eliminate all issues we had. If you are interested in the shematics, its all open source [2].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/d1-mimi/

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/instructions/ov...

ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
Please reach out (again) to me [1]. We are just launching a new main board with the ESP32-C3 that might fix your issue. Happy to send it you.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/support/

ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
- ASA

- DIN 2738 tool steel

- I don't know the tolerances. My engineer probably knows

- Not considered

ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
UV residence, hardness, mold suitability characteristics etc.
ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
Original poster here. Yes this is also what I heard from people that did molds in Europe. Much much more expensive and takes 4 times as long.
ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
Author here. Yes I agree with you. Having your own mold expert really saves a ton of money and makes things much more smoothly. We work with a great engineer based in the Philippines. You can contact me [1] and I can connect you with him.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/support/

ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
Achim from AirGradient here. Yes all our monitors [1] work nicely with Home Assistant. Especially via ESPHome [2].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/indoor/

[2] https://www.airgradient.com/integrations/home-assistant-esp-...

ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
Author here. Our mold costs were in the USD 5k - 10k range. Price per plastic part really depends on the weight and the material but you can probably assume USD 1 - 4 per part.
ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
Author here. We only worked with Chinese mold makers but from what I understand there are some country specifics, e.g. it is important to define the mold ownership in the contract. But yes, a lot of the advise probably applies independent of the country.
ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
Author here. Yes this is a good point but did not really apply to us as all our air quality monitors are open-hardware anyway.
ahaucnx··on What we learned making a plastic injection mold with a Chinese mold maker
Author here. We use ASA plastic.
ahaucnx··on Indoor wood burning raises women’s lung cancer risk by 43%
I second this. My sister has an enclosed fireplace and last time I visited her, I measured the air quality next to it and was surprised to find no elevated PM2.5 inside the room.

However keeping the door just a bit open emitted a lot of smoke into the room and gave a completely picture.

So I would recommend measuring the air quality in your home if you run any fire place.

I should probably write a blog post about it sometime.

ahaucnx··on The AirGradient Manifesto
Background story why we gave ourselves a manifesto [1].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/why-we-wrote-a-manifesto/

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
Be aware that Awair has intentionally bricked their first generation of Monitors [1].

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Awair/comments/y7i5ku/awair_discont...

ahaucnx··on Are Our Articles Disguised Ads?
Thank you for the feedback. Very appreciated. We are actually working on an "integration" section of our website that would show code examples and link to repos that provide code samples on how to link our monitors with all kinds of different backends and data platforms.
ahaucnx··on Are Our Articles Disguised Ads?
I wrote this in response to a comment in yesterday's discussion [1]. It would be great to hear some thoughts and feedback.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37652832

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
Your comment about "disguised ad" also gave us some food for thought and I just wrote an article how we want to be transparent about our own product promotions and some changes we have implemented [1].

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/are-our-articles-disguised-...

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
By the way, we have worked with the Plantower A003 and saw much more failure rates than with the 5003 model. So I'd not really recommend it.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
Carbon filters typically do not last very long so it's good to monitor TVOCs.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
Thank you. This is a good suggestion.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
It looks to also have a Plantower PM sensor but the smaller version (PMSA003) [1].

[1] http://www.aqmd.gov/docs/default-source/aq-spec/field-evalua...

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
The VINDSTYRKA does not contain a CO2 module which is the most expensive part of the BOM, so it's not directly comparable.

For this blog post I only looked at the monitor tested by AQ-Spec [1] and the Ikea one is not in their list.

[1] https://www.aqmd.gov/aq-spec/evaluations/criteria-pollutants...

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
I only took sensors that have been tested by AQ-Spec into consideration because they mention the PM module used and the Awair Element was not tested by them.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
Achim from AirGradient here. First of all, I appreciate your openness and I hope the following helps to clarify a few things:

1) All our monitor kits are licensed under CC-BY-SA (and not as mentioned above CC-BY-NC). There was a short period where we had them under NC license but since NC is not truely open-source we switched to the more permissive SA license. We wrote in more detail about this on our blog [1]

2) We are aware that our open-source firmware is currently lacking the quality level we would like to see because we have been very busy with the hardware side of the project. I do hope that in the coming months we will have more time to look after the firmware side and I already had a couple of calls with contributors in the last few days who are happy to help. It's definitely an area we need to improve.

We are currently setting up a focus group and I would love to have people included that might have a more critical view on the project. Please contact me if you would be interested to participate.

[1] https://www.airgradient.com/blog/thoughts-on-licensing/

ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
The AirGradient also uses a SenseAir CO2 Sensor like the Aranet but also measures additionally PM and TVOCs.
ahaucnx··on Air Quality Monitors from USD $169 to $6k use the same low-cost PM Modules
We actually plan to bring the version back that needs soldering. We took it temporarily out of the shop because a number of people overestimated their soldering skills and couldn't get it running. The usb and jst plug are difficult to solder for people without much experience.
← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →