HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ahf8Aithaex7Nai

364 karma · joined July 28, 2022

submissionscomments
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on If you tax them, will they leave?
> If we remove from life everything that people have access to by industrialization and mass production, then many or most people would say that "society" has collapsed.

I agree.

But I'm not convinced by the next paragraph. You present it as if it were a matter of 0 or 1. But I don't see any good reason why taxation shouldn't be used to make adjustments without immediately collapsing the entire incentive structure for investment. Less profit is still profit. If this argument were valid, there would be no large industries in countries that tax companies more heavily than the US.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on If you tax them, will they leave?
> the gigantic prices of real estate and rent, created by the monetary system being based on real estate instead of productivity

Rents are expensive because real estate is expensive. Real estate is a good store of value. The massive accumulation of surplus wealth among a small portion of society has led to an increased demand for stores of value. Someone looking for a house to live in competes not only with others who want to live in it, but above all with the super-rich who want the property as a store of value. That's why real estate is expensive.

> Wouldn't building a rocket to go to Mars for example be such an endeavour, which is bigger than chasing the imaginary dollar number?

That's conceivable. But I don't see the space science fiction of Le Guine or Asimov being realized in the activities of Musk and Bezos. To me, the whole thing seems more like an awkward dick measuring contest. The awkward situation with Shatner was a good example of how hollow and superficial this whole thing is. These people could go down in history as benefactors and heroes of humanity. But they don't have the guts for that. Either they launch rockets or go to the gym or sit with Joe Rogan or try to undermine democracy and replace it with a neo-feudalist hell.

Edit: I agree with you that we don't necessarily have to focus on the billionaires who are so prominent in the public eye. Below them, there is a larger class of super-rich people who have their fortunes managed for them, never lift a finger in their entire lives, and yet still attract an ever-increasing share of society's overall wealth.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on The lost art of XML
I think I understand your point. I only brought parsing into play to illustrate that XML is complicated, not because it's my general focus. I wouldn't classify namespaces, etc. as additional languages and tools, but that's beside the point.

> in your application nothing prevents you from using a dumbed-down version of XML

That's right. And if XML were exactly that, then there wouldn't be so many people frustrated with it. Unfortunately, in a professional work context, you don't always have control over whether it stays within this manageable subset. Sometimes the less pleasant aspects simply come into play, and then you have to deal with the whole complicated mess.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on The lost art of XML
> The complexity about XML comes from the many additional languages and tools built on top of it.

It's not just that, is it? There are also attributes versus child elements, dealing with white space including the xml:space attribute, namespaces, schemas, integration of external document fragments with xinclude:include or &extern;. Each of these is a huge can of worms in its own right. There are probably more that I'm not even aware of right now.

A few years ago, I wrote a fully functional parser for JSON that is easy to verify for correctness and that isn't just lying around somewhere as a toy, but is actually used (by me) in various projects time and again. Overall, building this parser was almost trivial. With XML, I'm not even sure I would be able to write a correct and complete parser.

But I agree with you that XML-based languages and XML tools make things even worse. I had to work with XML a lot over ten years ago. I still get annoyed when I think about XSLT, or dealing with schemas, or the challenge of finding usable tools that are reasonably compliant with standards.

You can only have a positive view of XML when you think of something like this:

    <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
    <booklist>
      <book>
        <title>Example Book</title>
        <author>Max Mustermann</author>
        <year>2025</year>
      </book>
      <book>
        <title>Second Book</title>
        <author>Erika Musterfrau</author>
        <year>2026</year>
      </book>
    </booklist>
And at that level, I have (almost) no problem with XML. But as soon as things get more demanding and you really take the various aspects of XML's value proposition seriously, you enter a world of pain and despair. At least, that's how it was for me back then. Maybe I would see things differently today, but I'm not really interested in finding out.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on The lost art of XML
> It's designed to be written by hand

Are you sure about that? I've heard XML gurus say the exact opposite.

This is a very good example of why I detest the phrase “use the right tool for the job.” People say this as an appeal to reason, as if there weren't an obvious follow-up question that different people might answer very differently.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on No management needed: anti-patterns in early-stage engineering teams
> Again, they are not part of the capital class.

I vaguely remember reading something recently, probably by Branko Milanović, about how there is a class of workers in the tech sector who earn so much money that they are gradually starting to become capitalists. When you have so much money left over that you can start putting your capital to work for you, you cross that very line. I don't mean a home savings plan or ETFs or anything like that, but if you have seven figures and can skim off returns that you could live well on, then you're definitely no longer working class.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on I dumped Windows 11 for Linux, and you should too
My last Windows was Windows 95 (or 98?). I've been exclusively using Linux for ~25 years. I use Ubuntu because I've been using it for ~20 years and have better things to do than try out different distros. My mother, my grandmother, and many of my non-computer-savvy friends also use Ubuntu. I know a Germanist who uses Debian.

It's a bit like with cars. If you know someone who really knows about cars, they'll be able to recommend a solid, simple, super cheap, practical car that will just work and give you no problems. It'll probably be something like a 2010 Toyota Aygo, which you can pick up for next to nothing on the used car market (here in Germany) and which you would never have thought of buying yourself. This is a Linux laptop. Other people who never got this insider tip that driving can be cheap and hassle-free might instead buy a new car from a German manufacturer on credit for half a gross annual salary (or even a whole one). Two years later, the car may already be in the repair shop because the engine is losing oil or because the Nanoslide/Nikasil cylinder liner coating is damaged.

With the Aygo, you can drive from A to B just as well as with any other car, and you might even have a little more fun doing so. But if you need CarPlay and heated seats, distrust things that are cheap, and love that je ne sais quoi that comes with things you've just bought for a lot of money, then this simple 2010 Aygo is not for you.

This weekend, I wrote code for a non-trivial compiler on my old everyday laptop. I didn't even buy it; I got it for free because the previous owner considered the device obsolete and unusable. Slowly, the thing is getting too old for me too, but Linux (Ubuntu) has gotten another couple of years of use out of it. Meanwhile, a friend of mine just bought a used Macbook that still cost more than I would ever spend on a new laptop because she has to write papers for her studies and thinks she needs a “good” computer for that.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Repair a ship’s hull still in the river in -50˚C (2022)
> I'd bet Honda easily outsells BMW in Europe.

Probably only if you include motorized two-wheelers with a displacement of <=125cc.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Repair a ship’s hull still in the river in -50˚C (2022)
That's right. I wonder if the decision-makers at KTM regretted that afterwards.

Addendum: Considering that the GS has been a bestseller ever since. It feels like every other motorcycle enthusiast in Germany rides one. It has been the best-selling motorcycle almost every year since then. In Italy, many also seem to prefer riding GS bikes over Guzzi/Ducati/Aprilia.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Real Biological Clock Is You're Going to Die (2018)
I like the text. A few additions: not everyone has to have children. Not all of us have the opportunity to do so. It is possible to live a fulfilling life even if you have not brought children into the world. If you do not have children and it is foreseeable that you will not have any, do not let anyone convince you that you are doomed to a marginal existence. A child does not only need parents. It also needs other adults: uncles, aunts, neighbors, teachers, etc. Children need a healthy society, and everyone who contributes to this is contributing to the well-being of children. For my taste, the text also lacks a political component. Parenting is not just a personal project. It is also a service to society. The parents of a child are raising a person who will participate productively in the economy of the future. It annoys me that this is treated as a free side effect. When you realize this connection, parenthood as an imperative for personal fulfillment takes on a strong ideological connotation. The fact that so many people remain childless today is a failure at the societal level and should not be compensated for by appeals at the individual level.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Kidnapped by Deutsche Bahn
> Cost of a car is extremely hard to predict, not just because of unexpected repairs

Cars aren't complicated. Make the right choice (buy cheap, buy japanese or french, avoid wet V-belts, prefer timing chains). Change oil and oil filter often. Keep an eye on the brake pads, shock absorbers, brake discs, tires, brake fluid, rust on the bodywork. Taking care of all this is surprisingly inexpensive. Of course, you can also have a car mechanic do all of this. Then you pay for their labor. But I really don't see any nasty surprises that might be lurking there. Of course, it depends on how well informed you are. If you've never looked under your car, then it's obviously a surprise when the floor panel is rusted through.

I understand that this is unreasonable for most people. But there is scope for ensuring that costs can be planned very well. However, I must admit at this point that you might as well deal with the complicated DB tariffs if you want to.

> but also because the price of gas is literally political.

Super 95 currently costs between €1.60 and €1.80. I still find that pretty easy to budget for.

> The train experience in Germany is as bad as it is because of ...

I agree with all your points. I'm just totally disappointed that we as a society can't manage to make public long-distance transport appealing. I would love to live in a world where I would feel like a complete idiot if I drove from Leipzig to Stuttgart and back instead of just taking the train.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Kidnapped by Deutsche Bahn
DB is a joke and a disgrace to Germany. I have actively avoided traveling by train for many years. The company is customer-unfriendly from start to finish. I find the confusing ticket prices particularly bad: Sparpreise, Super-Sparpreise, Frühbucher-Tarife, Flexpreis, Sparpreis Gruppe, BahnCard, Gutscheine, ...

If you don't want to pay extra, you have to book six months in advance and be familiar with the fare system. It's super frustrating. It's just a train ride. I don't want to have to plan and organize it like buying a new car at the best price or trading stocks. And in the end, you can't even count on arriving on schedule. If you're unlucky, you'll be stuck at the train station in some godforsaken village.

I prefer to travel by car. The travel costs can be easily calculated based on the price of gas and fuel consumption. The total maintenance costs for a car are transparent. You are much more flexible and autonomous when planning your trip. The probability of arriving more or less on schedule is almost 1. And if you do get stuck in traffic, at least you have a little private, quiet, warm, and dry space around you.

If it were reliable, inexpensive, and uncomplicated, I would still find it more sensible to travel by train. But that is far from being the case. Instead, DB manages to combine the disadvantages of administrative bureaucracy and market economy.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Don't Become the Machine
You don't seem to realize that you are undermining what you have written by sharing it with us here. That gives me hope for you. Of course, you can counter my objection by leaving it open in retrospect whether the text was meant seriously or not. Mind ninja! Always one step ahead! In any case, you won't be able to live a good life as a living gradient in a game-theoretical hell, denying your own goal orientation but strangely still interacting strategically with the world.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Auto-grading decade-old Hacker News discussions with hindsight
He doesn't deny that his point of view forms an echo chamber.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
Yes, I understand that it's about saving on labor costs. Depending on how successful this is, it could lead to major changes in the labor market in economies where skilled workers have been doing quite well up to now.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Horses: AI progress is steady. Human equivalence is sudden
Perhaps you have missed the essential point. Who drives the cars? It's not the horses, is it? And a chess computer is just as unlikely to start a game of chess on its own as a horse is to put on its harness and pull a plow across a field. I'm not entirely sure what impact all this will have on the job market, but your comparisons are flawed.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Self-hosting my photos with Immich
I don't think it would add any value for you. For me, it adds value because I only have to turn my head to the left to see the computer that contains all my photos since I started taking pictures with a smartphone.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on What OpenAI did when ChatGPT users lost touch with reality
I didn't use that word, and that's not what I'm concerned about. My point is that an LLM is not inherently opinionated and challenging if you've just put it together accordingly.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on What OpenAI did when ChatGPT users lost touch with reality
It's not meaningless. What do you do with a person who contradicts you or behaves in a way that is annoying to you? You can't always just shut that person up or change their mind or avoid them in some other way, can you? And I'm not talking about an employment relationship. Of course, you can simply replace employees or employers. You can also avoid other people you don't like. But if you want to maintain an ongoing relationship with someone, for example, a partnership, then you can't just re-prompt that person. You have a thinking and speaking subject in front of you who looks into the world, evaluates the world, and acts in the world just as consciously as you do.

Sociologists refer to this as double contingency. The nature of the interaction is completely open from both perspectives. Neither party can assume that they alone are in control. And that is precisely what is not the case with LLMs. Of course, you can prompt an LLM to snap at you and boss you around. But if your human partner treats you that way, you can't just prompt that behavior away. In interpersonal relationships (between equals), you are never in sole control. That's why it's so wonderful when they succeed and flourish. It's perfectly clear that an LLM can only ever give you the papier-mâché version of this.

I really can't imagine that you don't understand that.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on After my dad died, we found the love letters
Capital letters come from Roman script. Lowercase letters come from a medieval administrative script (Carolingian minuscule). So you could say that we are mixing two completely different scripts. This becomes very clear when you look at a text written entirely in lowercase letters: the typeface is so uniform that I, at least, find it very pleasant to look at. Unfortunately, this is not the norm. Instead, I am condemned to live in a world where I have to look at writing consisting of two obviously thrown-together scripts day in and day out. Schopenhauer was right: the world is a vale of tears!
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Gleam OTP – Fault Tolerant Multicore Programs with Actors
Just write 'for' and 'while' yourself if you need it. Here is ‘for’ in Elm/Gren:

    for : Int -> Int -> Int -> (Int -> msg) -> List msg
    for start stop step action =
        let
            range =
                if step > 0
                then List.range start (step) (stop - 1)
                else if step < 0
                then List.range stop (abs step) (start - 1) |> List.reverse
                else []
        in
            List.map action range

It should be just as trivial to write this in Gleam.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Addictive-like behavioural traits in pet dogs with extreme motivation for toys
Because we basically have none.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on After nine years of grinding, Replit found its market. Can it keep it?
The burden of proof lies with the person making the claim (even if implicitly), not with the person questioning the claim.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on After nine years of grinding, Replit found its market. Can it keep it?
This has nothing to do with charity. Every employee can contribute to the bottom line. It is the company's responsibility to organize and empower its employees in such a way that added value is created. If this is not achieved, the employees have still given up their time and must be compensated for it.

You are welcome to optimize your processes so that you no longer need any employees. But society will still consist of people who need money. And if you don't pass on the surplus you have accumulated in the form of salaries, they will get what they need from you by other means.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Study of 1M-year-old skull points to earlier origins of modern humans
It's not that simple. It's true that a willingness to criticize and falsify established assumptions and skepticism toward arguments based on authority are part of the scientific ethos. It's also true that many scientists simply do what they've been taught to do, without questioning methods or taking an interest in the philosophy of science. But your last sentence is so sweeping that it would allow flat-earthers to be considered scientists and intellectuals.

What is being criticized here is an attitude that believes one is the only one capable of critical thinking and that everyone else is just an idiot who is already overwhelmed by the task of tying their shoelaces in the morning. This is simply arrogance and has little to do with constructiveness, let alone scientific ethos. You treat yourself to that little dopamine rush of saying “ackchyually” and then just carry on playing Bubble Shooter on your phone.

This is very common here on HN. And when this ultimately hardens into blanket skepticism toward institutions, you are closer to the flat-earthers than to the scientists.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Type Theory and Functional Programming (1999) [pdf]
> But in practical programming with imperative languages, arbitrary side effects can't be disregarded, so they don't collapse into the functional paradigm.

I'm sorry to have to say this so bluntly, but I think you understand as well as I do that in a language such as C#, it is entirely possible to write large amounts of purely functional yet useful code, just as you would in Haskell. That's why it's possible in SICP to wait until Chapter 3 to introduce the special form set!. That is the issue I was concerned with.

> from a physical perspective

I already mentioned that this is not the perspective that interests me. I don't care at all about the physical substrate for computation.

Thanks for the paper. I might take a look at it, although I've already been given a good tip elsewhere with map theory. I'm not convinced by the claim that properties and relations occur in natural language but sets supposedly do not.

The last paragraph isn't very helpful either. I'm not sure who is misunderstanding whom here, but we don't need to hash it out. This isn't a conversation I'm enjoying.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Type Theory and Functional Programming (1999) [pdf]
Thanks! It seems that in the metatheory, one can resort to type theory in order to avoid having to fall back on set theory in a circular manner. Unfortunately, I don't know anything about that, but I'll take a closer look at it.
ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Type Theory and Functional Programming (1999) [pdf]
> You can construct lambda calculus with Turing machines and Turing machines in lambda calculus.

I realize that these models of computation are equivalent. My point was rather that the imperative paradigm collapses into the functional paradigm in practical programming when I disregard the admissibility of arbitrary side effects.

> e.g. Functions can be formalized as sets and sets can be formalized as functions

I can derive functions from set theory in my sleep, and I can kickstart set theory without functions, but I wouldn't know how to define the concept of a function without sets. And even if I did: I can't even specify the characteristic function of a set without resorting to the inclusion relation.

> But it's hard to argue the machine at the end is stateless.

I'm not really that interested in the relationship between the various paradigms and the machine. What interests me most is how well I, as a human being, can write non-trivial programs. To me, it is immediately obvious that the composition of purely functional program units is conceptually simple enough to be done by a child, while unrestricted side effects can very quickly make things very complicated. However, I don't want to get involved in the discussion on this topic. I have accepted that others see it differently, although I find that completely baffling. I don't want to take away anyone's for loops, etc. To each their own.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Type Theory and Functional Programming (1999) [pdf]
That's already been happening for quite some time. Mainstream programming has done little else in recent years than converge toward functional programming.

Also, they wrote "functional," not "purely functional."

By the way, from a formal perspective, imperative programming is an extension of purely functional programming.

ahf8Aithaex7Nai··on Microsoft blocks Israel’s use of its tech in mass surveillance of Palestinians
I'm 40. For me, the modern world didn't just start in 2019. And the list is additive. The fact that Microsoft has been on it since the 90s doesn't stop me from also listing Google, Apple, and Amazon.
← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →