HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ai_critic

557 karma · joined June 15, 2025

submissionscomments
ai_critic··on Hyundai buys Boston Dynamics
Well, humans obviously do those jobs, so a clearly a general purpose robot (in this case, a biorobot) has been found to do the job better. Don't overthink it.
ai_critic··on What happened to nerds?
This is such an obviously correct comment that I imagine it'll languish down below the fold.

Playing off of it, the submission says something worth highlighting:

> One of them builds autonomous weapons for the Pentagon.

Luckey was perfectly happy doing VR at Facebook until he got shoved out over politics.

It's not just letting the non-nerds in--it's a decade-plus long campaign to push nerds out if they have the wrong ideology.

ai_critic··on Ask HN: I am a junior CS and math major. I have no hope for SWE or math. Advice?
> It feels impossible to predict the future and so I am not comfortable putting my chips anywhere.

Life is unpredictable, which is part of what makes it worth living. The only genuinely incorrect move is not putting down your chips.

ai_critic··on H.R. 6028 would fundamentally change the U.S. Copyright Office
I don't think you've at all addressed why moving anything there towards the executive is desirable, especially given the capriciousness of the current executive.
ai_critic··on The World Has Moved On
I do not understand why you are being downvoted for what is, essentially, a statement of bald fact and realpolitick.

Trump took advantage of a party already weakened by the Tea Party, and successfully turned it into a cult of personality at a time when the opposition was ideologically unprepared to deal with very real policy issues that their constituents were observing.

ai_critic··on The World Has Moved On
Do not read Doctor uncritically.

> An army of wreckers, led by the demagogue John Farson (who styles himself "The Good Man") are slowly but surely conquering the land, laying waste to those few remaining outposts of civilization and conscripting the young men in the conquered lands to march on their neighbors.

What he's leaving out is that in the novels Farson explicitly was a rabble-rouser pushing for democracy, egalitarian rule, and the downfall of the aristocratic class--and he used that to cloak anti-social behavior and butchery.

Sound familiar?

(Not that Cory is a butcher--hah!--but that he's deliberately eliding the "type" of demagogue Farson is. Consider why that might be.)

ai_critic··on I Am Not a Reverse Centaur
Do you think your CEO has no sense of accomplishment when your team ships a product feature?
ai_critic··on Aspen – Local LLM for Mortals
Do you have any sort of hardware specs? Architecture? OS?
ai_critic··on AI is slowing down
To put it more bluntly: he provides neither in his pursuit of rage views.
ai_critic··on Confidential submission of draft S-1 to the SEC
> We have not decided on timing yet; it may be a while because there are things we want to do that are likely easier as a private company.

Presumably those things were harder as a charity/non-profit.

ai_critic··on AI is slowing down
It helps if you look at Zitron's work history and experience. He's a hype man and a games journalist. His opinions on this are whatever sells, not exactly whatever is correct.

This is alarmingly obvious whenever he talks out of his depth about things like how companies actually use AI and reason about business decisions.

ai_critic··on I'm skeptical about efforts to revolutionize schooling
Real talk: which kids have you interacted with? What social class? What ethnicity? What household structure (nuclear, multigenerational, single parent, single parent plus intermittent partner, divorced with shared custody, dirtbag but grandparent covering)?

I've found that the people who are more optimistic about kids tend to live in a particular category of socioneconomic bubble.

ai_critic··on Elixir v1.20 released: now a gradually typed language
What functional stuff is throwing you off? A whole bunch of it can be written procedurally when starting out.
ai_critic··on The Public Should Own Half of the Big A.I. Companies
The word you're looking for is "copied".

Don't fall for the great lie of intellectual "property".

ai_critic··on More than 6 out of 10 people turn to AI for psychological support
Is anyone actually surprised? The baseline empathy and emotional intelligence of people, both online and offline, has absolutely tanked--I think Covid was the epoch, but arguably going a lot farther back since then. People are just shitty.
ai_critic··on Bernie Sanders: The American AI Sovereign Wealth Fund Act [video]
I don't even trust the American people to handle the relatively simple task of not voting for septuagenarians and felons, to his claim midway through, much less running and guiding a company.

I also love the claim that while it all is built on humanity's works, we would only be benefiting Americans--which is it, Bernie?

"A 50% tax on stock" is also a nice way of saying "we're going to nationalize these companies", which is not really something to be done lightly if at all.

Sanders continues to be a--well-meaning!--clown.

ai_critic··on Erin Brockovich made a map to track data centers around the country
c'mon now it's not nice to say mean things about ed zitron like that
ai_critic··on Agents Dont Want VMs
> if the agent does something in a VM you have to figure out what happened.

If you can't audit what users are doing on a Linux system you have no business pretending you can run a k8s cluster.

(k8s was a ZIRP-fueled evolutionary mistake for most of the industry.)

ai_critic··on Plain: A bias-free news site with no ads, no tracking, and no clutter
Simple things:

1. When I click anywhere on a tile, have it expand out (instead of having to click just that little link).

2. It'd be cool to have a link to the source of any of this stuff.

3. Consider streamlining the font stuff to bundle/make fewer requests.

ai_critic··on At least 25 Flock cameras have been destroyed in five states since April 2025
That's...exactly what happened with the Boston Tea Party: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intolerable_Acts

Had France not been willing to subsidize an insurgent campaign to distract the British, it's incredibly likely those Acts would've remained in place for some time.

People who rush to using violence as an answer frequently do not consider the outcome if they've misjudged their opponents' capacity for it.

ai_critic··on 3D Gaussian Splatting in a Weekend
> spherical harmonic encoded materials

This in particular has been hilarious for the exact reason you mentioned. For anybody curious, here's a paper from 2008 about this technique:

https://www.ppsloan.org/publications/StupidSH36.pdf

ai_critic··on Zig → Rust porting guide
It's a combination of pragmatism (not wanting to wade through slop, not wanting to shove out newbie developers) and politics (usual contemporary techie progressive stuff that's now oddly anti-technology).
ai_critic··on The 'Hidden' Costs of Great Abstractions
> However, there is absolutely nothing stopping an LLM from "deciding" tomorrow that a fix it built a week ago is no longer real, because not only has that fix left its context, but also the bug was not obvious.

Yeah, and we've never had deterministic tools like GCC suddenly fuck up commonly-relied-on undefined behavior between releases. Sure.

I get what you're saying, but again, to the vast majority of devs, none of that shit matters. Whether that's a good thing or a bad thing is a different discussion.

ai_critic··on The 'Hidden' Costs of Great Abstractions
Counter-point: most developers have no idea or eagerness to actually do that debugging, so it doesn't really matter.
ai_critic··on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (May 2026)
[flagged]
ai_critic··on The Science Behind Honey's Eternal Shelf Life (2013)
That's just because they're trying to keep all the best honey for themselves, obviously.
ai_critic··on Qwen3.6-27B: Flagship-Level Coding in a 27B Dense Model
"Create me an SVG to drive MAXIMUM ENGAGEMENT for my sponsors".

Missing an opportunity here, lol.

ai_critic··on The Future of Everything Is Lies, I Guess: New Jobs
"meatshield" has the correct connotations for that sort of work.
ai_critic··on The Future of Everything Is Lies, I Guess: New Jobs
I think that this is an interesting attempt at taxonomy, but it's a bit on the magical thinking end (and I say this as somebody that does a good amount of what's described as the incanter role). It's a combination of the author's previous witchy aesthetic (see his excellent "<x>ing the technical interview" series) and progressive labor politics (which are asymptotically doomed in the current automation push).

The biggest failure of imagination, I think, is the assumption we'd use humans for most (or *any) of these jobs--for example, the work of the haruspex is better left to an LLM that can process the myriad of internal states (this is the mechanical interpretation field).

ai_critic··on Peptides: where to begin?
I take certain medications--nothing interesting, nothing controlled, nothing abusable. I have to deal with a whole thing just to get refills, because my PCP forces me to come in every time--and even that is now just a telehealth call that is annoying.

In Mexico, for meds like mine, you can just buy them at the pharmacy. There's no reason for all this nonsense.

(Edit: same PCP refused to prescribe GLP-1s early, without any scientific or medical reason not to. Delayed my weightloss by months until I found a place that would.)

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →