HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ai_critic

557 karma · joined June 15, 2025

submissionscomments
ai_critic··on Meta announces nuclear energy projects
If you believe that figure, that's still comparable to solar's best ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar-cell_efficiency ).

Optimal steam plants can get do better, exceeding 50% in some configurations ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combined-cycle_power_plant#Eff... ). Steam is awesome.

ai_critic··on Meta announces nuclear energy projects
> “It’s not like the NRC asks for an extraordinary amount of information,” said a former nuclear official who was involved in reviewing Oklo’s failed application and spoke on the condition of anonymity to avoid jeopardizing their work in the industry. “The NRC asks three questions: What is the worst that can happen, what are the systems, structures and components in your reactor that prevents that from happening, and how do you know that?”

This...does not square with the successful hamstringing of the nuclear energy industry by regulation over the past several decades.

ai_critic··on guys why does armenian completely break Claude
Claude is apparently more of a Tur-key solution to these problems--issues with Armenian support are thus to be expected.
ai_critic··on Itanium
The Itanic has finally finished sinking.
ai_critic··on The Worst Thing About Elon Musk Is That He Got Away with All of It
Like the fellow or not, outright lies like "When Musk’s plans inevitably fail" undercut any credibility this creed might have.

Tesla cars, the new Optimus thing, SpaceX, xAI...like, the dude has a track record of making things happen.

Be upset about the concentration of wealth, be upset about a misunderstanding of public policy and misalignment of values in the execution of DOGE, be upset about petty manchild antics on Twitter--but for fuck's sake, can we please stop ignoring the evidence (good and bad) in front of our own eyes?

ai_critic··on Israel could be bringing back the death penalty – but only for Palestinians
Sure--I was just adding that quote so it was obvious that it was from the article and not just a repeated joke line or something.
ai_critic··on Israel could be bringing back the death penalty – but only for Palestinians
(for context, this is from the article)

> “There is no such thing as a Jewish terrorist,” said Limor Son Har-Melech, of the far-right Otzma Yehudit party, as she and the other noose-wearing supporters insisted the measure will deter militant attacks.

ai_critic··on I wish people were more public
We have systematically dismantled by popular consensus the safety of liberalism and belief in a marketplace of ideas.

There is no advantage to being "more public" when it's all to common to get hit by marauding bands of idealists and trolls of all atripes. Nobody rewards you for having nuanced opinions on things like immigration publicly, nor trans rights, nor even something as banal as programming language choice.

We've now lived through a full pendulum cycle where public writing that was insufficiently woke was punished via internet lynch mobs and state pressure, and now we are seeing the exact same thing with insufficiently reactionary ideas invoking...internet lynch mobs and state pressure.

So, no, I don't think I will be more public, and I'll be unsurprised--if sad--when other rational actors do similarly.

There's no reason to be public, because people have made it clear that they'd rather support a system that attacks that than protects it.

ai_critic··on The Lost Generation
It a truly, truly a mystery why the GOP, Trump, and "white" ethnopolitics in the US and abroad have found such fertile ground.

It'd be nice to go back to the blase liberalism, slow and steady in its progress, of the 90s.

ai_critic··on The New Must-Have College Admissions Skill: Tolerating Other Viewpoints
It is a very distressing formative experience to discover that the world contains a plurality--sometimes, even a majority!--of people who do not share your prejudices, perspectives, and often even axioms.

I envy the calm strata you must inhabit.

ai_critic··on The Fatal Trap UBI Boosters Keep Falling Into
No problem!

The big thing--usually missed by most folks, especially engineers whose intuitions and experience are correct but in the wrong domain--is that you don't balance a country's budget like you do a household's. The scale is different, the incentives are different, the problems and tools are different.

Of course, to confound things, it's entirely possible that we should treat a country's balancebook like a household's, and it's just the dumb luck of near 3/4 of a century that we've gotten away with assumptions like mine. :)

ai_critic··on The Fatal Trap UBI Boosters Keep Falling Into
There's an assumption there that buying down the national debt is an important goal. Reasons that one might not want to take that position:

* Having debt helps keep a currency useful as a global reserve and store of value, with great soft-power benefits (though, honestly, the reverse is more true--being the reserve currency makes running up a debt easier).

* Having debt helps keep us out of capital-W War, as it binds nations together financially--if we owe another country a sufficient amount, they have a vested interest in seeing it come back. (Incidentally, historically, this is a shaky assumption as well.)

* Having a policy allowing for debt helps make re-investment in infrastructure and civilization-scale efforts more easy to accomplish.

* Having a debt helps encourage inflationary currency policy, which (in moderation!) has knock-on stimulatory effects on the economy. Some minor inflation is good for helping to encourage people to spend rather than hoard.

The more cynical take, of course, is: how can we not afford to pay UBI?

* Is it cheaper to remove, retrain, or simply resupply folks who are otherwise economic unproductive?

* Is it politically expedient to buy off the population whose only useful product is votes than to balance the budget?

* People are upset about work and making rent today...creditors of the US are some distant threat, and it's unlikely any politician will be in-office when that bill comes due--why hold off?

* We've spent more money on dumber things, what's wrong with this?

I don't exactly agree with any of the above points (in either category), but it's not hard to imagine people who do.

ai_critic··on I Want You to Understand Chicago
Eh, they're not, though, and you disregard them at your peril--just look at where we are now.

It's not for no reason this particular issue has been used so effectively. I'm not saying you have to agree with them, and I'm not saying that you have to believe their belief is coherent or sensical, but if you don't recognize that those beliefs are held honestly and widely you're in for a rude surprise...as we saw in the 2024 election (and before that, the 2016 election).

ai_critic··on I Want You to Understand Chicago
It's not particularly a "surge" in crime, as the issue (illegal immigrants) has built up over time.

However, in years past, everybody just kind of overlooks it--and on the local level, it's basically not a problem beyond the normal folks being mad at demographics changing. Most all of the immigrants are working and participating in the economy--ironically, making them more vulnerable to the .gov than if they were just criminals!--and that's fine for the cities.

But, now, the federal .gov (under the direction of Trump et al) is deciding to finally enforce the law and doing so in the most cartoonishly thuggish and evil way possible.

ai_critic··on Ask HN: What's holding back industrial robot automation in America?
"Why isn't there more industrial reshoring via robotics?" is a narrower subset of the question "Why isn't there more industrial reshoring?"

It might be helpful to start at the endpoint and ask: "Okay, we have fully automated factories and power and resources for them, all under US control...how do you turn a profit? What do we even do with that much surplus capacity?"

Not that I think this is a bad thing, mind you!

(I'll also point out that the assumption is that we don't have a lot of domestic industrial capacity which is...not accurate. Wasteful, overpriced, and in that weird slump of tech where we used to have really good tech and coasted for too long, sure: but, I'd double-check that the reality on the ground matches what everybody's claiming on social media.)

ai_critic··on The H-1B Visa Program and Its Impact on the U.S. Economy
An interesting take on this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmY6-2idC1o
ai_critic··on America Tips into Fascism
Which facts in it are incorrect, would you say?
ai_critic··on Ask HN: Thoughts on Curtis Yarvin?
> Of course his writing is so obfuscated I guess he could use hindsight to twist his own words into something like a correct prediction.

I think that's exactly what he's doing.

ai_critic··on The issue of anti-cheat on Linux (2024)
I miss PUBG, but the fundamental purpose of anti-cheat software is to circumvent and curtail user freedom. I don't really want affordances for that in my OS.
ai_critic··on Ask HN: Thoughts on Curtis Yarvin?
Perhaps, but Zizek is at least funny and so on and so on.
ai_critic··on Ask HN: Thoughts on Curtis Yarvin?
He's a windbag and perhaps the best example of how some people really just need a wedgie.

That said, he does raise some interesting points--in extremely roundabout ways--and it's incredibly telling how different people react to him. The amazing amount of butthurt und sturm und drang that comes up whenever urbit is mentioned, for example, is almost always due to political/tribal stuff and not due to technical deficiencies or the deliberate obfuscation of whatever ideas actually might be there.

I think he's basically riding coats of the populist MAGA movement at this point in an almost ESR "I helped make this" sort of way, and while an interesting footnote in the evolution of NRx he's basically just an edgelord with some extra money.

ai_critic··on Hkust Launches the Largest AI Education Sandbox Game "Aivilization"
How does one get a code?
ai_critic··on Trump admin ranks companies on loyalty while handing out favors to Big Tech
I'm incredibly not a fan of loyalty tests and picking winners and losers. At the same time, it doesn't seem surprising that the pendulum pulled over by companies earlier (for example, Twitter deplatforming) and the previous administration's actions (for example, what amounts to harassment of SpaceX as a matter of principle) wouldn't now swing back the other way. This is the problem with normalizing that sort of politicization of commercial spaces--your guy ain't always gonna be in power.

(Now, Trump's enough of an asshole to perhaps have done this anyway, but this certainly made it easier to sell.)

ai_critic··on Anyone melding GPT-level intelligence with physical world?
What on earth ever gave you that impression?
ai_critic··on Water Cremation (Alkaline Hydrolysis)
This has already been put into informal production at scale:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/national/2009/01/27/s...

ai_critic··on The demographic future of humanity: facts and consequences [pdf]
That this somehow is a surprise to anybody is baffling.
ai_critic··on The demographic future of humanity: facts and consequences [pdf]
And this is bad why, exactly?

Women already don't want to be mothers--and everybody has pushed so hard that being a housewife is bad!--so what's the issue here?

ai_critic··on No More Copyright Protection for Anyone [video]
Okay boomer.
ai_critic··on Where Have Men Gone? We're Right Here
https://archive.is/BjxrL
ai_critic··on Where's Firefox going next?
As of 2024Q1, Brave had a market share of 1.27% vs Firefox's 3.97% (via Cloudflare, here: https://radar.cloudflare.com/reports/browser-market-share-20... ). As of 2025, 1.05% vs 4.10% ( https://radar.cloudflare.com/reports/browser-market-share-20... ).

Interestingly enough, right, we can see that the same CEO left Mozilla and then started Brave, and we can see the growth of Brave and the decline of Mozilla.

You can argue, sure, that market conditions are responsible for Mozilla's plight--the decreasing value as antitrust insurance for GOOG and so forth. But, Brave managed to do well in spite of that, and to my knowledge if you look at the pay, at his peak at Mozilla Eich was making in the 800-900K range while Baker made over 6M a year from 2022 to 2023 (and just a bit under 6M in 2021). So, for around 8x the price, you had worse leadership.

To restate again: the dude started a new browser company and grew it to a quarter the size of Firefox--and this without having GOOG as a sugardaddy.

It's an incredibly mid take to assume that individual competence in business is somehow not actually relevant.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →