HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aisenik

203 karma · joined September 3, 2012

submissionscomments
aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
What has Mossad been up to? Just boolin'?

It is possible that mistakes were made in the aftermath of WW2. It is possible that the victors have rewritten history in a favorable light -- in fact, that is the most reasonable expectation. This must not be used to justify genocide for if our society takes that path the victory against the Axis powers is meaningless and evil will have triumphed in the world.

Israel is more than Netanyahu and less than the Jewish people. Humanity must unite and destroy the power structures that incentivize the hyperscale atrocities we are currently manifesting.

aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Indeed. The lowest of the horses, however, is clearly the USA. Our history and our actions (POSIWID is the most effective heuristic in the modern information environment), including the capricious abandonment of the very successful JCPOA, suggest complete dishonesty in this realm. There is zero reason to believe we have any legitimate reason for attacking Iran and every reason to distrust our stated motivations. Iraq was 22 years ago.

We presented outright fabrications to the UN to justify an imperial war after the president campaigned against "nation building." It is hard to ignore the parallels to Iran and Trump, proclaimed "anti war" candidate that you had to vote for to prevent WW3. Here we are.

aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
If someone claims to be providing "the complete context" they are intentionally misleading you.
aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Israel just attacked Iran. Perhaps the perceived bellicosity of Iran is both justified and overblown?

What is the reason to trust Israel, who engaged in subterfuge to develop nuclear weapons in the 1970s, over Iran?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vela_incident

aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Thank you for the engagement.

It is extremely important to document the facile and childish level of argumentation within the industry whose hubris seeks to force the world into the period of its greatest calamities. Society failed to highlight the intellectual immaturity of the Nazis and it has yielded the material reality we exist in today.

Again, I appreciate your labor and contributions to the historical record.

aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Strict adherence to the JCPOA, capriciously discarded by the man who just bombed Iran in my name, suggests that Iran's position was legitimately held.

In fact, it implies that someone else is lying. Probably the country that just did a complete 180 on its intelligence assessment and attacked another country unprovoked, if you want my assessment.

It's not like the USA doesn't have a documented history of lying and engaging in information warfare to justify wars of choice. This isn't even our first time this century.

aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
I have provided information and you have provided innuendo.
aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
It is remarkable to see such intellectual dishonesty from so highly a respected figure here.

Those of you who received adequate Liberal Arts education will see through him, whether you agree with his intended rhetorical outcome or not.

aisenik··on Pentagon Has Been Pushing Americans to Believe in UFOs for Decades, New Report
Incidentally, the mature and honest way to approach this is to not let your emotionality cloud your comprehension and assign the conflicts in your head to the statements I have made. Instead, you explain the phenomenon to a sufficient detail such that the misperceptions you are afraid of other users making can be addressed.

Assigning your fears to me, in conflict with the words I have used, is at best disingenuous.

You guys are supposed to be impressive leaders of society into the Brave New World.

aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
Did I say the Supreme Leader is a benign figure? Iran has problems. Big ones.

You are disingenuous and malicious when you portray my position in this way. The Supreme Leader has a longstanding public opposition to nuclear weapons. He is the respected religious leader of the Iranian government. The actions of the Iranian government, including their adherence to the JCPOA that Trump capriciously discarded, are consistent with this fatwa.

You must provide some other justification for your stance than merely accepting the US propaganda.

aisenik··on U.S. bombs Iranian nuclear sites
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ali_Khamenei%27s_fatwa_against...

Probably something other than the one thing that would justify lifting the mid 90's fatwa declaring the creation, possession, and use of nuclear weapons against Islamic law.

How aware is this community of the Supreme Leader's staunch opposition to nuclear weapons?

This is pure imperialism.

aisenik··on Pentagon Has Been Pushing Americans to Believe in UFOs for Decades, New Report
It's funny how defensive yet unsubstantial this is. It, at best, confirms the initial observation.

There's no accusation in the factual observation that "this site" removed the article from visibility. Why so defensive? Is it rhetorical?

aisenik··on Pentagon Has Been Pushing Americans to Believe in UFOs for Decades, New Report
Guys who built the reality-destroying thought-control panopticon getting high off their own supply. Real Fermi Paradox stuff.
aisenik··on Marines being mobilized in response to LA protests
A vast, open one with a nearly 1000 page document outlining their plan hosted on their website whose primary operatives are now high-level government officials.

Hard to believe? That's exactly what they're relying on: they think people are too stupid to believe there's an actual radical white-supremacist Christian Theocratic movement working to destroy the United States. It's the biggest known internal existential threat of the last 150 years and our corporate media and political environment has resulted in conditions that have enabled it to manifest nearly unchallenged.

aisenik··on Marines being mobilized in response to LA protests
"Blue lives" flags are intensely fascist, unpatriotic symbology and an explicit desecration of the American flag, that might be a good place to start your research.

State-sanctioned organized crime by white supremacist terrorists, that's the connection with Republicans. They pardoned the insurrectionists that violently captured the capital building and pay off murderers whose crimes achieve their political goals. It's mostly happening out in the open, brazenly. We're not rational machines, we're easily manipulated and it takes less energy to settle into beliefs others want us to have. "Flood the zone" works but reality is still happening.

aisenik··on Marines being mobilized in response to LA protests
if the cops are all rioting and playing murder-musical chairs with peaceful people living their lives freely, crimes of opportunity will happen.

it's the feds and the sheriffs and the police causing unrest, by intent and design.

aisenik··on Trump threatens to cut Musk's government contracts, escalating their public feud
> Two of the guys at the head of the biggest open conspiracies in the world are likely to be conspiring if their actions result in favorable conditions

This is not long or complex. It can be reduced to "liars lie" if that helps.

aisenik··on Musk-Trump dispute includes threats to SpaceX contracts
Musk is a known pedophile-accusation-maker and affiliated with the Epstein child rape organization through his Kung-Fu lessons with Ghislaine Maxwell. Prior supporters will be less reactive for the first reason and more likely to perceive the situations as unfounded petty accusations for the latter (the dissonance of both Trump and Musk being connected to child rape is resolved this way).
aisenik··on Silicon Valley aghast at the Musk-Trump divorce
It's not open: DOGE is overseen by Russell Vought, Christian Nationalist and orchestrator of Project 2025. We're on the brink of a fully post-Constitutional government and it's happened in plain sight.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell_Vought

aisenik··on Trump threatens to cut Musk's government contracts, escalating their public feud
Occam's Razor should not be used for self-harm. Two of the guys at the head of the biggest open conspiracies in the world are likely to be conspiring if their actions result in favorable conditions.

This social media spat is happening immediately after "Welcomefest," a bizarre Republican-light centrist conference, and positions Elon Musk to capture the centrist Democratic apparatus. This follows a pattern of fecklessness and capitulation from the party's power centers, including major Democratic figures advocating for realignment with MAGA on core issues.

There's another pattern too: we have seen a concerted effort from the MAGA movement to capture societal institutions and forcibly reform them into alignment with their radical agenda to replace the US Constitution. Aligning the DNC into a technocratic fascist organization that supports their monarchic visions of domination will be an incredible humiliation (though far from the last). And quite simple.

I'm going to assume conspiracy from the guys arrogant enough to get caught boasting that the opposition is too credulous to accept an open conspiracy.

aisenik··on Grok answers unrelated queries with long paragraphs about "white genocide"
POSIWID suggests that the purpose of the American tech industry is to create a system of global surveillance and control to facilitate eugenicist white supremacists enslaving humanity and creating a decadent global aristocracy that rules through violently enforced deprivation under totalitarian theocracy.

Notably, this outcome was repeatedly predicted for decades. This error provides stark evidence that LLMs and corporate algorithmic information control are fully-weaponized tools being wielded against society-at-large. The power structures that have yielded these conditions are an existential threat to liberty, democracy, and the future of humanity.

The only moral path for members of this community is to divest from the industry and align your lives against these power structures. Righting the hyperscale cultural atrocity of capitalist cybernetic domination will be a multi-generational struggle: the actions you take now matter.

aisenik··on First baby born in UK to woman with transplanted womb
The emotions fueling my reaction are based on the way I experienced the word as a child in the 80s and 90s, and I could delve deeper into that but it's mostly irrelevant beyond the fact that I experienced the word in hateful ways.

In truth, I misspoke when I said "Nazi demographic" and had intended to write "Nazi era demographic," as the word's origination was in its use to describe the nascent trans community in Weimar Germany. In fact, the Nazis disregarded the validity of trans status entirely and the folks we'd regard as trans women today were classified as homosexual men before being subjected to the violence of the Nazi state. Trans men received a different, no less humiliating punishment.

The motivation in asking the question, beyond my disgust, is that I have observed a trend on this site of anachronistic language that fell out of favor after being associated with hate speech. It is generally being used in contexts supportive of the prominent far right agenda, and I seek to illuminate the motivations of the commentators who facilitate such odious reversions in discourse.

I apologize for my lack of clarity.

aisenik··on First baby born in UK to woman with transplanted womb
It's bizarre that you try to talk down about trans issues that you are not informed about and label your interlocutor, a trans woman, as transphobic for not highlighting trans men when talking specifically about women.

If the answer to why you use the word "transvestite" is "I am steeped in 90s celebrity and watched RHPS" fine, but your disingenuous accusations of transphobia and extreme interest in a topic you seem exceptionally ignorant about fit a corrosive pattern that attempts to shutdown meaningful discussion. The rise of eugenics-era language is deeply concerning and I would actually like to better understand why this site in particular has seen an increase of commentary using regressive 20th century language.

aisenik··on First baby born in UK to woman with transplanted womb
I can totally comprehend trans women having babies. Heck, I can comprehend cis men having babies: Arnold Schwarzenegger did it in the 90s.

I can't truly comprehend the mass data collection and surveillance system, how it interplays with intelligence and law enforcement, and what the impact of connecting a global constellation of privatized armed satellites and a constellation of advanced phased array antennas & sdrs to either end of the system will be, however. I believe there are bigger threats to humanity than bodily autonomy.

aisenik··on First baby born in UK to woman with transplanted womb
You'll be surprised to learn that neovaginas are also possessed by cis women. Trans men requiring vaginoplasty and receiving a uterine transplant are the nichest possible edge case, your "gotcha" is pure distraction.

Trans women will receive the modern* uterine transplant operation, this I can state with certainty. Birth is done via C-section as a requirement of the UTx operation, the vagina is required for discharge. I haven't been able to pay attention to the operation for a few years, but it is clear that you are operating from uninformed conjecture.

*The first uterine transplant was performed on a trans woman in Germany in 1930, Lili Elbe. This pioneering surgery lead to her death, as transplantation medicine was not adequately developed at that point in time.

aisenik··on Russian Propaganda Has Now Infected Western AI Chatbots – New Study
To what extent is Microsoft responsible for this, and to what extent are radical white supremacist hate groups responsible by actively using these ideas to foment hatred and recruit new members?

I don't see an issue with training to suppress manifestations of "14 words" rhetoric. It would be concerning if their training data was inducing LLMs to advocate for racial animus, but restricting the ability of an LLM to reproduce white supremacist rhetoric does not appear to meet that standard. These are ideologies whose proponents have engaged in mass violence and recruited public resources to further their ends. It's okay to be proactive with known threat actors.

aisenik··on First baby born in UK to woman with transplanted womb
I did intend to type "Nazi era", though I find the clarification is meaningless to the point. I'm all for reclaiming words, but I am unaware of any significant efforts to reclaim and promote the word in question. It is anachronistic and inextricably connected to 20th century transphobia and violence against trans women in particular

Re: your second point, a closer reading of the comments will show that this thread is discussing "women."

e: The far more interesting discussion is whether the revival of eugenics-era language is justifiable. This is hardly the first example on this site of arrogant commentators casually reviving language that came to be understood as hateful in the 20th century.

aisenik··on First baby born in UK to woman with transplanted womb
I've had my eye on the UTx op for the better part of the decade. It is my understanding that there's no medical reason to expect it would not be successful in a trans woman. I don't have recent numbers but we passed >100 uterine transplants a while back. The most complicated physical requirement is a functional vagina for discharge (which is generally on the roadmap for trans women interested in carrying a child).

I am unaware of trans women having received this operation yet, but Lili Elbe died after the first uterine transplant nearly 100 years ago, before the Nazi regime destroyed trans medicine and eradicated contemporary trans existence. Given the global climate, I don't expect any trans recipients to be eager for publicity. It will happen, and soon.

aisenik··on First baby born in UK to woman with transplanted womb
Unless the procedure has changed dramatically, it requires a functional vagina. Neovaginas are qualified but I would not expect most male-identified people to opt for vaginoplasty.
aisenik··on First baby born in UK to woman with transplanted womb
Almost everyone who opposes trans people's existence today. Opposition to trans rights is rooted in patriarchal hegemony and the control of bodies. Our existence is a fundamental threat to the foundational perspective of the predominant power-structure in society.

No one does a womb-check before granting women validity. It's always been a vibe thing and people who do not conform to the prescribed model of existence as a man or woman are constantly denied full privileges under the framework. It's not just trans women getting the short end of the stick here, it's everyone: men who do not embrace dominance culture or otherwise display "effeminacy" are denied true Man status, women who don't meet beauty standards or possess a submissive demeanor are slurred as bull-dykes or the dreaded transexual.

This isn't an issue with any real reasonable basis for it's opposition, it's a golem of pure hatred and disgust in a suit vs. people who want to live full, free lives.

editing to add: the first known uterine transplant was performed on Lili Elbe who received treatments through the Institute of Sexology in Germany. The Institute was famously destroyed by the Nazi regime. It's barely coincidental that fascism has risen again as medical science brings this technology to maturity. Trans women gave their lives for this medical miracle.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →