HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ajayyy

752 karma · joined April 9, 2019

submissionscomments
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Good idea, feel free to join the Discord linked on the website so you chat with people about your idea.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Yea, I agree. However, companies need to advertise to get there product out there. Well, even I did by posting about this extension on hacker news.

I think there are ways to make ads more ethical than the average ad out there, and I appreciate those that do that.

- Developer

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
I think it's just a vocal minority, and on reddit there were way less people disagreeing with the extension :/

- Dev

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
That's not completely true. They are making a majority of the money (creators), but it's not directly related to what you watch. The entire pool is split by watch time (watch time from people even not subscribed to youtube premium) on all videos on the platform. So, more of your subscribers getting youtube premium does not benifit you.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
I find it the other way. As well, I am fine with youtubers who make it clear and whitelist those.

- Developer

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
I agree, this is what made me hit the tipping point however. I love kurzgesagt, they are amazing.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
haha, that is something I'd be scared this extension promotes, since that is something unblockable

- Developer

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
That is sad but true. That is why proper separation make sponsorships so much better and more ethical.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
I've thought of that a lot. You can look through my comments on this thread and my comments on https://www.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/cl5t45/i_made_an_a...

This was all built because of unethical ads, not because I was tired of seeing sponsors. I still don't think blocking every sponsor is the best option ethically, I think whitelisting is something that should be done to make it more ethical. I also think people should consider whitelisting channels from ublock origin (I do that).

More info here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20780728

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Yea, or if you are supporting them on patreon. It is like CGP Grey's "adblock absolution"
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Google doesn't like sponsorships, they don't get a % cut.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Yes, but for an outsider not part of the joke, like a child or old person, they don't know about that
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Corridor Digital has a timer on screen.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
I'm sure some people are okay with them, but they drove me to never watch his videos :/

Maybe I will try watching his videos again with this extension, I don't know.

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
People use adblock now, I don't see how this is much worse. In my opinion, this is more ethical than adblock since it allows easy whitelisting and has an easy to click unskip button.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Why not automate it, I've already spent countless hours over the past 2 months working on this software, I'm not wasting that time.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
I wouldn't say that. Only big creators get sponsors. I guess it depends on what you mean by small creator. And this isn't taking money, it would just be not putting any in.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Some people have different opinions. I oppose deceptiveness, and am not too opposed to tracking.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
That wasn't there I'm pretty sure, and even still, it doesn't say sponsored anywhere, just a plug for it. Yes, it is obvious to us what it is, but to an outsider or child? It is manipulative to those people.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
True, I shouldn't have included them in that list, they are edited out now.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
This kurzgesagt video is what made me start work on this extension: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FfgT6zx4k3Q

No mention of sponsor, doesn't say "supported by" accept in the top comment that was added later (not at the beginning). The description one wasn't there originally either.

It literally says "because we want you to have nice things, you can get a 30 day free trial". You can't get more deceptive than that.

- Developer

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
According to some guy on reddit, they do have pretty detailed viewer retention graphs.

https://i.imgur.com/LSobAV4.png

https://www.reddit.com/r/firefox/comments/cl5t45/i_made_an_a...

- Developer

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Right now, there is no easy way, but you can do it manually following these steps:

Get an sqlite DB GUI like this awesome one: https://sqlitebrowser.org/

Open up the DB from https://sponsor.ajay.app/database.db

Click browse data and switch to the userNames table.

Find the userID for your username in that list and copy it.

Go back to the sponsorTimes table and paste your userID into the filter text box under the userID category.

Currently, the only easy to access stats are at https://sponsor.ajay.app/stats/

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Follow this issue: https://github.com/ajayyy/SponsorBlock/issues/131
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Yea, or like YouTube's skip ad button.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
The API is open and database is downloadable, so feel free to try making something.

https://github.com/ajayyy/SponsorBlockServer#api-docs

- Developer

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
One reason this isn't visible could be due to the fact that there are two checkboxes. One just says that it includes it, and the other says to display it. The YouTube console tells you that you don't have to display it if you mention it in the video.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
I haven't watched wendover in over a year since I was sick of his sponsorships, but I remember never knowing when the end of a video was, because the sponsors were part of the same sentence.
ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
Would you be interested in an option in this extension to not actually skip the sponsors, but just show them in the seek bar? Then, you can be prepared for them, but choose yourself whether to skip them.

Follow this issue: https://github.com/ajayyy/SponsorBlock/issues/131

ajayyy··on Show HN: SponsorBlock – Skip sponsorship segments of YouTube videos
I don't fully agree with you. There are some channels that do sponsorships well: Jay Foreman, Tom Scott, etc.

There are some that do it terribly: Kursgesagt recently, Wendover productions (I hate deceptive segues), etc.

You can see more about my thoughts on this here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20780728

I guess it's a personal choice, but I prefer tracked ads that are properly labeled and not deceptive to integrated sponsorships and product placement any day. The real fear is that an extension like this will encourage even more deceptive and hard to skip sponsors (embeded product placement).

- Developer

← PreviousPage 7 of 8Next →