HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

akshatpradhan

369 karma · joined April 18, 2012

http://www.ComplianceChaos.com

Policy Writer for the Big 5 (i.e. ISO 27001, HIPAA, FEDRAMP, PCI-DSS, and now GDPR!)

I’m also familiar with SSAE-18 SOC 2 and SOX ITGC.

##CompSec on irc.freenode.org

/r/HIPAA /r/PCICompliance /r/ISO27001 /r/SOC2 /r/FEDRAMP

submissionscomments
akshatpradhan··on GitHub Audio
Sounds like it was inspired by Listen to Wikipedia.

http://listen.hatnote.com/

akshatpradhan··on Ever wondered how many open FTP servers there are?
AP Style Alert. Internet and web are no longer to be capitalized. Check the googles.
akshatpradhan··on How do I give our security auditor the information he wants? (2011)
Exactly, and if you feel there's isn't a safe place to discuss social responsibility regarding PCI and HIPAA, you can check out

http://www.reddit.com/r/hipaa (250+ redditors)

https://www.reddit.com/r/pcicompliance (250+ redditors)

As well as ##CompSec in irc.freenode.org

akshatpradhan··on How do I give our security auditor the information he wants? (2011)
PCI doesn't say anything crazy. Its all reasonable stuff. Scroll to page 20: https://www.pcisecuritystandards.org/documents/PCI_DSS_v3-2....

Networks, System Hardening, Boundary Protection, Access Control. Nothing in the PDF says anything unreasonable. The naysayers just don't want to open up the PDF and READ.

akshatpradhan··on How do I give our security auditor the information he wants? (2011)
Hi, I tried to explain the other deeper complex situation happening with PCI below but it was flagged?

Image of flagged post: http://i.imgur.com/eCZHAyJ.png

This is the reddit link I was referencing in the image: https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/4z25cb/hipaa_brea...

If you don't like my HN comment, at least read that reddit post. We need PCI because of the crap observed from that reddit post.

"Speaking of PCI, I remember having to tell the PRESIDENT of the company I used to work for that "No, I will not print out the customer database with full CC+3, including their name, address, and phone number. You could ruin the business." Took a while to really make him understand that."

If you need a PCI Auditor, make sure they have a background like me: http://www.linkedin.com/in/akshatpradhan

That's all I want to say. No need to flag me for it...gratuitous negativity?

akshatpradhan··on FBI’s Deep Web Child Porn Ring Questions Role of Gov’t in Society
Does the FBI read HN? I don't think they realize how much they're missing out from not reading this feedback and actually giving it a few seconds worth of contemplation =/.
akshatpradhan··on A New Wireless Hack Can Unlock 100M Volkswagens
A google search of "US Government 128 bit quantum factoring".

Stop trying to blame the government for corporations not doing due diligence.

If anything, the real failure is Government not enforcing agreeable security measures like NIST and ISO across all US Organizations.

akshatpradhan··on Unsafe levels of toxic chemicals found in drinking water for 6M Americans
ConsumerSearch also did a meta review of the best water filters:

http://www.consumersearch.com/water-filters

They wrote a buying guide for your next water filter:

http://www.consumersearch.com/water-filters/how-to-buy-a-wat...

akshatpradhan··on Find a new city
This post reminded me of this interesting 2 min video by ASAPScience about City vs Rural living: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TRb52O76HxQ
akshatpradhan··on Squarespace Announces Local Development Server
Why does Squarespace insist that we code up our tables?
akshatpradhan··on Massachusetts Bans Employers from Asking Applicants About Previous Pay
It feels like we may need a site-wide HN reminder about avoiding gratuitous negativity. Especially in our current heated climate.

https://blog.ycombinator.com/new-hacker-news-guideline

akshatpradhan··on Uber Hasn't Had an Effect on Drunken-Driving Deaths, Study Finds
>It's crazy that people are so adamant to do social engineering for Uber that they won't even agree to entirely uncontroversial claims, like most taxis in Boston are clean or have functioning card readers -- things which are indisputably accurate.

I'm from Boston. I took a ride from Brighton to Hynes. The cab driver goes through Storrow Dr and he skips the Kenmore exit to get to Hynes. I think he's going to take the Beacon Hill exit and he skips that too.

I asked him why he didn't take the exit and he said, "Oh I thought you wanted to go to the Prudential."

Prudential is the same place as Hynes. The taxi takes me all the way up Storrow to I-93 then to I-90 west finally taking the Copley exit back to Hynes.

My bill ended up $45 from Brighton to Hynes.

I have countless horror stories of cabs not picking me up because the distance was too short (South end to Fenway is too short), credit card machines "not working" so it's cash only, cabs not showing up at all or extremely late.

I even have a cab scam story in Baltimore which I commented about here on HN.

Uber has questionable ethics, but at least I don't have to deal with frustrations.

I've lived in New Englad over a decade so this is my anecdotal experience with Boston cab drivers.

akshatpradhan··on How I built an app with 500,000 users in 5 days on a $100 server
>Yes, it's a pain and particularly the user authentication solutions are very complex. https://github.com/hassox/phoenix_guardian

This is why I don't see the point of moving over to Elixir. Rails has ready-to-go and battle tested "modules" that you can pop in and go.

If I used Elixir now, I would have to wait for the community to build something battle tested or I can home-roll my own Elixir authentication. The Poster above just said, "It's a pain particularly user authentication."

akshatpradhan··on Google to Train 2 Million Indian Android Developers
>Regardless, i don't see this google training program improving the ratio.

I don't understand. Training is training. If you don't think training improves the ratio of good to bad developers, then why do we have all these training programs in the US like Coursera or Stanford's Open Computer Science Courses? The reason we have MIT Open Courseware is to train and improve developers...thereby improving the ratio of good to bad developers. That logic holds true for any training program. The Google Training Program should improve the ratio as well.

akshatpradhan··on Google to Train 2 Million Indian Android Developers
>When I see the word "training", I take it to mean that the people taking part learn just enough to get started, but not really enough to make something of quality. That's where my negativity stems from.

You could say this very same thing about Coursera or MIT Open Courseware. And you're right, people in Coursera sometimes learn just enough to get started but nothing more. That's just the thing, "Learning just enough to get started" is not an Indian Specific phenomenon.

People dropping out of training courses happens all over the world and that's normal when Educating and Training. If Google's "training" gives you a negative feeling, then your negativity should be directed towards Coursera and MIT Open Courseware and other Training Institutes, not just Google's Training Courses for Indians.

akshatpradhan··on Google to Train 2 Million Indian Android Developers
That's why there's Secure Developer Training and Security Awareness Training.

Seems like the big concern from everybody here is Indian Malware Apps. To get closer to better security, I think now would be a good time to encourage Google to offer Secure Android Coding Courses too.

akshatpradhan··on Google to Train 2 Million Indian Android Developers
>People still pay $1000+ for someone to make an Android app of questionable quality for them.

And if that Android App actually makes money, then you now have leverage to charge a high hourly rate to fix the questionably-made app.

Sounds like a win for you.

akshatpradhan··on Google to Train 2 Million Indian Android Developers
>If anything this would lead to more complex malware apps.

Are you saying that Indians who get trained in Development will consciously become more nefarious and wittingly release more malware?

I honestly feel like you can say that about any group of developers in the world. There's bound to be 1 bad actor in every group. That's just security.

akshatpradhan··on Google to Train 2 Million Indian Android Developers
From what I understand, you're saying more Developer Training will lead to more Indian malware apps?
akshatpradhan··on Google to Train 2 Million Indian Android Developers
Are you suggesting training DOES NOT help reduce risk associated with Malware Apps? If that's what you're saying, then we should throw Secure Development Training and Security Awareness Training out the window for everybody. :)
akshatpradhan··on How Uber secretly investigated its legal foes and got caught
At the end of the day, Uber did go too far, "Schmidt and his client were being investigated by a secretive research firm, staffed by veterans from the CIA and the National Security Council, conducting an investigation on behalf of Uber’s top executives. As soon as the lawsuit was filed, those executives took an interest in Schmidt and his client, sending out operatives to dig up what they could find on Uber’s new antagonists."
akshatpradhan··on How Uber secretly investigated its legal foes and got caught
Its about not getting ripped off. With Lyft/Uber you can escalate if you feel ripped off. With Taxi Cartel's, there's nobody to take your complaints. We feel ripped off whenever we've had to ask this of ourselves, "Gosh, we seem to have gone a longer route" or "Did he start the meter before I got into the car?"

Side story: In Baltimore this happened to me. I got into a taxi and the driver starts asking me tons of questions. I'm politely answering and having conversation but I'm clearly not paying attention to the meter. We drove for 7-10 mins, 2-3 miles or so, and upon arriving to my destination is when I realized the cost was $30.

akshatpradhan··on Minnesota woman broadcasts police stop and shooting on Facebook Live
I'd rather comply then risk getting shot to death.
akshatpradhan··on Apollo 11 Guidance Computer source code
If this were to be rewritten in a high level language, I wonder what would it look like?
akshatpradhan··on Minnesota woman broadcasts police stop and shooting on Facebook Live
Don't you see why we need police body cams? Imagine if the police had forced her to turn off the phone. This video wouldn't exist. We wouldn't have even known about this.

I remember being pulled over by the cops. I was on my phone while he was doing the license check, and the officer told me to turn off my phone. I complied, so it's interesting to see how this woman luckily got away with recording the video. If the police had told her to turn off the phone, there's nothing she could have done at that moment in time. All transparency of the incident would have been lost.

He's dead. My professor once said, "The police have gone from 'Serve and Protect' to 'Seek and Destroy'."

akshatpradhan··on America's top earners are Asian men
You're only accounting for one form of selection bias when in reality there are two.

The first form of selection bias is inside your country. If you don't already have status and wealth, then you won't even be able to overcome the cognitive/emotional load that's required to leave your country.

The second form of selection bias is when the Immigration Officer says yes or no.

The first form of selection bias is far more effective at weeding out the "low" earners and ensuring the top earners are pre-selected for immigration.

There is a third form of selection bias but that may not help with this conversation, and that's geographical. Crossing an ocean has historically been seen as riskier then crossing land, so that weeds out the risk averse.

akshatpradhan··on OS X DNS cache reset script
Too bad they didn't address the DNS problem in the Keynote. This is a bit of an exaggeration, but I do feel I've spun mDNSResponder more often than using their Messages app.

That's not a positive feeling. Especially if you're with a client and your browser stops resolving and your client is watching you open up terminal to spin mDNSResponder

akshatpradhan··on The U.S. Navy’s Big Mistake: Building Tons of Supercarriers
Or research money will be poured into an Iron Dome[1] for Carriers.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_Dome

akshatpradhan··on Jessica Livingston’s Pretty Complete List on How Not to Fail
Awww no engineers here can enlighten me into how to turn Compliance into something people want (#1 rule in her post) :(
akshatpradhan··on Jessica Livingston’s Pretty Complete List on How Not to Fail
I'm in the interesting position that I've built something that everybody needs, but nobody wants.

I've built a product that manages the compliance process for the Big 5 (i.e. PCI-DSS, SSAE16-SOC2, HIPAA, ISO 27001, and FEDRAMP).

My product, ComplianceChaos[1] competes with RSA Archer, Protiviti, Lockpath, Aruvio, and MetricStream.

From my research, 80% of IT operations around the world can't confidently certify themselves against any of those information security frameworks. When recently talking to Security Directors and above, they claim "I don't need to comply" or "well we may not be the best, but we're not the worst, so compliance just isn't a priority."

We understand that a big business like General Electric will not do business with your company unless you can show some kind of proof that you're compliant with the Big 5. For example, if you're a cloud service provider or SaaS, GE wants you to certify for SOC 2 and ISO 27001.

We also know that if you host on Amazon's FEDRAMP Compliant environment or Catalyze.io's HIPAA compliant environment, it doesn't automatically mean your company is also compliant. Your company still needs to go through the compliance process too."

When I first set off to build this product a couple years ago, the security officers first exclaimed, "We need a compliance tool so that we don't have to deal with scattered documents and long spreadsheets." When I built the MVP and continued iterating on it, security officers again exclaimed, "this is the most beautiful compliance product I've ever seen! Better than RSA Archer."

However, when I asked them to use it, for FREE, they would say, "Well it's nice, but compliance just isn't a priority for us because the business has other missions like doing real security work". Explaining to them that compliance frameworks like ISO 27001 and FEDRAMP is real security work was met with deaf ears. In fact, they would retaliate saying, "Compliance like ISO 27001 isn't security. It's a low bar, bare minimal, and not enough."

When I counter with, "But 80% of the industry can't confidently assert that they've done due diligence in meeting the compliance controls. If compliance is so bare minimal, then why do only 20% go all the way to Attestation instead of all 100% of you guys?" That question would again fall on deaf ears.

I've recently pivoted to a services company, no thanks to TrustWave for getting sued for performing subpar security compliance auditing work. I'm specifically looking at you auditors who ask employees to put their passwords in a spreadsheet.

So here I am, having built a product and auditing service that IT Operations do in fact need, but do not want. They don't want the politics behind it nor the emotions behind it, and wish to sweep compliance under the rug.

How do I solve for #1 Make something that people want, when nobody wants compliance, but definitely needs it?

[1]http://www.ComplianceChaos.com

I'm going to sleep now, but I would really appreciate reading your responses in the morning and I'll definitely respond too.

← PreviousPage 2 of 8Next →