HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

akuma73

271 karma · joined August 28, 2013

submissionscomments
akuma73··on The Singularity Is Further Than It Appears (2015)
Flash and DRAM only have localized activity so heat isn't so much an issue - yet.

There is actually a limit study using fundamental physics that shows that the amount of heat you can remove from a solid per unit time has a limit. Overheating is unavoidable below a certain volume. We're very close to that limit.

akuma73··on The Singularity Is Further Than It Appears (2015)
There are thermal issues with die stacking. Where does the heat go?

This is a general problem in solid state physics. Power density is already a huge problem.

akuma73··on The Singularity Is Further Than It Appears (2015)
What will replace Moore's law as the engine of exponential growth? The progress in the last 30 years in computing will not be replicated in the next 30 years for the simple reason that we are hitting hard physical limits of atomic scale and thermodynamics.
akuma73··on How Physics Falls Apart If the EMdrive Works
I'm with Sean Carroll here. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence (Bayesian reasoning).

http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2015/05/26/warp-dri...

akuma73··on Feynman’s first paper (1939)
Here's the wikipedia entry which also mentions Einstein's paper: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capillary_action
akuma73··on Demystifying the i-Device NVMe NAND
Don't feel too bad.

Fully understanding the complete stack of a modern computer system is outside the scope of almost everyone. These things are complicated and we've built abstractions, interfaces and modules to manage the complexity.

People specialize in their own fields. I am trained in digital integrated circuit design, but don't ask me to build a file system.

akuma73··on Transistor Production Has Reached Astronomical Scales (2015)
That's how exponential work. There is an end to it and it's not far off. Exponential transistor scaling (Moore's Law) has ended.
akuma73··on Has Physics Gotten Something Really Important Really Wrong?
Bohmian mechanics is fundamentally incompatible with quantum field theory. QFT is the best theory we have today (standard model).
akuma73··on Sharpest ever view of the Andromeda Galaxy (2015)
It's taken 15 billion years since the big bang for our relatively complex atoms to form - from supernovae. Yes, we were generated in the core of stars. The entire superstructure of the universe is what allows us to exist in the first place.
akuma73··on Lamborghini Is Forging Ahead with Forged Carbon Fiber
The point is to broadcast your economic status.
akuma73··on A reprieve for Moore’s Law? Work on gallium nitride semiconductors
I agree here with the word "possible".

However, progress on this front would be slow due to the increased cost of software development. Software would be much more difficult to write leading to longer lead times for applications.

I don't think the app stores would scale at the same rate that it did for iPhone or Android.

One analogy is parallel programming. This is generally very difficult, so people avoid it, even when hardware vendors give you get a bounty of cores. Another example is GPGPU - very slow progress on mapping data-parallel apps to the GPU (image processing etc.).

We may not know what future devices and applications are not possible due to Moore's Law's end. Another example is the recent explosion in deep learning - this was only possible due to the increase in FLOP density as a direct consequence of Moore's Law. These algorithms were around in the 80s.

akuma73··on A reprieve for Moore’s Law? Work on gallium nitride semiconductors
Great list! To quote Bob Colwell (former Intel fellow and DARPA director), it's hard to replace an exponential. There will be non-uniform improvements and "one-off" type of breakthroughs but a sustained 2x every 2x years is just not going to happen ever.

As a thought experiment, what if Moore's Law scaling had ended in 2000? No smartphones.

I agree that the value of software engineering and computer architecture in general will increase as the transistor-scaling free ride ends. We have to make more efficient use of existing transistors that will no longer scale going forward.

akuma73··on A reprieve for Moore’s Law? Work on gallium nitride semiconductors
It's not as if Intel and others haven't looked at this and other III-V materials.

These GaNs seem to be more suited towards amplifiers and a replacement for the kinds of components that GaAs is currently used - not digital logic.

For a look at a potential III-V materials for use in digital logic, have a look at this article. http://www.extremetech.com/gaming/203926-analyst-intel-will-...

IMHO, Moore's Law will end in about 2019-2020. No exponential can go on forever. This will have huge ramifications for silicon valley. You're already seeing a slow-down. Ever wonder why Intel chips aren't getting all that much faster?

akuma73··on How Intel missed the smartphone market
Low margin ARM is already cannibalizing high margin x86 as more and more compute uses cases move from PC to smartphone (social media, casual gaming, web browsing, video, camera and so on). Photoshop, spreadsheets and the like are still on PCs - for now. The platform itself has shifted from Windows to Android/iOS.
akuma73··on How Intel missed the smartphone market
>> low-margin x86 would cannibalize high-margin x86

What happens when low-margin ARM cannibalizes high-margin x86?

akuma73··on Intel to Cut 12,000 Jobs, Forecast Misses Amid PC Blight
The end of Moore's Law has broad industry-wide implications. Imagine if Moore's Law had ended in the year 2000 - no smartphones...

A lot of future technologies that rely on exponential increases in silicon capability will not be possible. It's almost impossible to replicate an exponential.

The rate of progress will slow and look more like more mature industries such as aerospace.

akuma73··on Why would you learn C++ in 2016?
When Moore's Law ends (imminently), performance and performance/watt will be harder and harder to come by.

In the long term, there may be a reversal in the trend towards "easy" languages.

akuma73··on Computers Without Clocks – Ivan Sutherland (2002) [pdf]
Intel used an asynchronous technique in their Pentium-4 processors. You may recall that the internal core ALUs ran at 2x the frequency of the rest of the chip. This was done with self timed domino circuits.

These are notoriously difficult to get working.

akuma73··on Austin: No Place to Go but Up
I couldn't agree more.

In my experience, most of the people that really love Austin are the types that have never lived in a large diverse city before. Of course Austin is great compared to some small town. There's no point of reference.

/lived in Austin for 12 years

akuma73··on Which Type of Exercise Is Best for the Brain?
That is interesting, but the rats in this study don't have as well engineered feet as humans and don't sweat either.
akuma73··on Beat the Fed
Perhaps I am economically naive, but why does there need to be any inflation? Why isn't 0 a target?
akuma73··on Intel Skylake Launch, with Architecture Analysis
Intel is still incentivized to provide much higher performance CPUs to the market because they compete with themselves - they want to encourage upgrades.

What you're seeing here is beginning of the end of Moore's Law. Dennard scaling is dead and that will limit performance going forward.

The implications are huge for the computer industry. As Bob Colwell liked to say - imagine if Moore's law ended in the year 2000. We'd never have smartphones.

akuma73··on Hayabusa-2 probe uses 64-bit MIPS CPU to explore the origins of the solar system
May I ask why?
akuma73··on AMD Launches Carrizo
You mean "when" :)
akuma73··on Intel Buys Altera for $16.7B
I don't really understand this deal.

Altera and Intel already have a fab agreement and Intel is desperate to get customers into their mothballed fabs.

All this talk of technology collaboration could be accomplished with strategic partnerships/licensing that would certainly be less than $16.7B.

This looks like a case of a foundry player buying their customer to prevent it from defecting to TSMC in the future. To me this is a sign of weakness.

akuma73··on A wave of experiments is probing the root of quantum weirdness
Sean Carroll does a fantastic job here: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/eternitytohere/quantum/
akuma73··on A look beyond x86: OpenPOWER and AArch64
X-Gene 1 is in ancient 40nm technology. Haswell is 2 generations ahead in 22nm Finfet technology.

The gap should close as the process technologies get closer.

akuma73··on “Reasons you shouldn't join us: if you're looking for work-life balance.”
Yes, you're right, of course.

Being more specific - there may be transition periods where you may become more valuable (through training or whatever) at which point you have the opportunity to seek higher compensation. If one does not seek higher compensation, then one is trading their higher potential salary for other wants/needs (maybe they trade the enjoyment of their current work at a lower pay over the higher salary at another job).

In equilibrium and in an efficient market, the value of the labor provided is equal to the cost of the labor provided.

Of course, in the real world, there are inefficiencies and irrational behaviors, but to a first order - it's approximately correct.

akuma73··on “Reasons you shouldn't join us: if you're looking for work-life balance.”
Employers pay their employees exactly what they're worth - by definition.

If an employee is dissatisfied with their pay, they have the option to either negotiate a higher salary or find another job with higher pay.

akuma73··on Possible unconventional computing techniques of the future
You see this somewhat in mobile computers (phones). The power and thermal constraints limit performance, so developers limit features vs. their desktop counterparts.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →