HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

albntomat0

1,267 karma · joined May 11, 2014

submissionscomments
albntomat0··on BleedingTooth: Linux Bluetooth Zero-Click Remote Code Execution
> even the OS/browser you're using is written in C

Those have tons of exploitable bugs!!

NASA rovers and car ECUs have minimal people looking to exploit them, so I'm not overly convinced they're exploit free either.

I'm not a Rust evangelist or even a user, but the current paradigm of "THIS TIME, we'll write safe, complex, performant C/C++ code properly" isn't the solution, nor is manually squashing bugs one by one.

The solution seems to be a combination of improving the tooling around existing C\C++, and starting new projects in safer languages when possible.

albntomat0··on Yellen calls for a global minimum corporate tax rate
(I'm not a proponent of the 0% corporate tax, fwiw)

If you are running the SaaS from Monaco and only selling things in the US, isn't it right that you'd only pay sales tax?

It's the mismatch when work is done in one place (for some definition of work), but profits taxed elsewhere that's the issue, as I understand it.

0% corporate tax and higher individual income tax works as long as a company and its employees have to use the "full stack" of taxes, and can't mix and match across borders.

albntomat0··on Yellen calls for a global minimum corporate tax rate
Doesn't your train of thought only work if collected corporate taxes accurately reflect activity in a country?

I think the frustration is in part due to a corporation conducting business in one country, and playing games so the profits occur and are taxed in a lower tax one.

albntomat0··on The Mythology of Red Bull
I'm a fan of multiple big projects of Red Bull, including Formula 1, skydiving and Flugtag.

I've honestly looked for ways to support their activities, as I enjoy this "advertising", but dislike their drink.

albntomat0··on Google’s copying of the Java SE API was fair use [pdf]
I believe the parent commenter was highlighting the particular wording of the opinion, rather than the actual decision itself.

One could imagine an opinion supporting the same decision with less clear or precise language. As I understand the process, the opinion was frequently reviewed and advised by Breyer, but actually written by one of the clerks.

albntomat0··on Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail
I think the real alternative here is that fewer folks will spend time looking at Apple products or not fully investigating weird behavior encountered normally that could be a security issue.

The author specifically said that they were looking based on bug bounty guidelines. The next person in the same shoes will look at some other company's products instead.

albntomat0··on Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail
Then Apple gets a reputation for refusing to pay, less folks look for and responsibly disclose vulns in Apple products, and their security posture as as whole suffers.
albntomat0··on Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail
Here's an alternative view:

- Apple is a $2T company, that we trust with our data. That valuation is in part based on that trust. It's entitled of Apple to produce a product that contains shitty exploitable symlink handling and continue to have no meaningful repercussions (which is true in the industry as a whole).

If this was a bug in a small, under-resourced FOSS email client, or the exploit required many highly skilled person-years to find, maybe I'd feel differently.

albntomat0··on Bitcoin as a Battery
> Wrong. I can use it to pay someone to do work, for example. "Work" in both societal and physical senses. That means the energy is not lost in a bitcoin.

That moves the definition of battery far away from normal usage. That means anything of monetary value is a battery, whether it’s cryptocurrency, a $20 bill, or a piece of gold.

Paying someone to do work has the actual energy come from another source, such gasoline or food.

albntomat0··on Hermes, a JavaScript engine optimized for React Native
Do you have more information on this? I remember looking into it a couple months ago, and being told the jit wasn’t going to be developed further. Thanks!
albntomat0··on Academic “ghost-writing”: the cheating scandal no one will discuss (2020)
As someone with a masters in CS from a big name US school, the demographics of my cohort were super interesting. With the exception of a very small number of folks (<5% of total), everyone either had specific outside support (mainly government computer security scholarships of some kind) or was from outside the US.

I think this is because the cost of getting a masters doesnt make sense for someone with a CS undergrad who can easily apply to FAANG/etc.

albntomat0··on Academic “ghost-writing”: the cheating scandal no one will discuss (2020)
I also personally appreciated the time limits of exams as well. They seemed like a good balance to projects whose outcome was primarily decided by how much time one could spend (there's a clear balance in the real world utility of performing well under unstrained time, and time management, etc).
albntomat0··on “When the entire household goes to bed, I do curl development for 2 more hours.”
I get up an hour or so early on most days to work on a personal project before my normal dev job.

I find it's really helped my mental health, especially when work can be a bit frustrating (in entirely normal ways)

albntomat0··on India to propose cryptocurrency ban, penalising miners and traders
I think I did a poor job of stating my understanding of your comment.

I was pointing out that the proposal of a bill does not mean it will get passed nor that the majority of the legislature supports it. This is similar to how you were pointing out that the finance minister disagreeing with the bill doesn't mean the Indian government is fully against it.

albntomat0··on India to propose cryptocurrency ban, penalising miners and traders
Yes.

The comment I was replying to speculated that the disagreement was between legislature as a whole and the finance ministry.

My comment pointed out that the disagreement could be internal to the legislature itself.

albntomat0··on India to propose cryptocurrency ban, penalising miners and traders
There's also a big gap between which bills get introduced and what actually gets passed
albntomat0··on Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry
> A 2018 study cited by Haaretz estimated that 80% of the 2,300 people who founded Israel’s 700 cybersecurity companies had come through IDF intelligence.

The specific quote is that 8200 grads have founded a large number of cyber security companies in general, and the article follows by discussing specific offensive and surveillance ones (NSO, etc.). My read of the article is that it implies that most of the 700 companies are similar. The link for the study links to a paywalled article about the survey.

Since defensive cyber security is a bigger market, I'd like to know if 8200 grads found offensive companies at a significantly higher rate than defensive ones.

albntomat0··on Israel’s lucrative and secretive cybersurveillance industry
Is there any sense of how many 8200-grad founded companies are in the "sketchy" side (not sure what other word to use) of cyber-security?

The article mentions 4, and implies the rest of the 700 mentioned are similar.

albntomat0··on Girls perform better academically in almost all countries (2015)
That's an interesting statistic. Do you have a source? I'd be interested in learning more
albntomat0··on Coinbase mafia shows how tight a circle holds sway over Bitcoin
> Do Swiss Franks pay dividends or other types of cashflows?

There is consistent demand by the Swiss government, in the form of tax collection.

albntomat0··on Are You Trading or Gambling?
True. Bitcoin as currently designed doesn't support the transaction throughput or latency anyways for folks to buy gum, only larger money transfers. (I'm a skeptic, FWIW)

Without the presence of transaction fees though, things would fall apart once the block reward ran out, as asked in the original question.

albntomat0··on Are You Trading or Gambling?
Each transactions has a fee value set by the sender, that goes to the miner. Miners select the top N transactions by fee, so miners will still have an incentive.
albntomat0··on Are You Trading or Gambling?
I understand and appreciate the point you're making (I want to add this as my response is slightly flippant).

How many BTC will it take to buy a Toyota Corolla in Feb 2022?

albntomat0··on Facebook is pushing back on Apple’s new iPhone privacy rules
I agree, with the addition that Facebook wants to keep control of their user data and repeatedly sell it via ads, rather than directly sell it to some third party org to repackage.
albntomat0··on Facebook is pushing back on Apple’s new iPhone privacy rules
I agree that the original wording could be better.

I'd phrase it more along the lines of Facebook indirectly selling the data as hypertargeted ads, while keeping control of the data themselves.

albntomat0··on GameStop, Bitcoin and the Commoditization of Populist Rage
Do you allow literally anyone, regardless of situation, to claim "woe is me"?

I understand that "one-downmanship" can be used to dismiss legitimate claims, but the existence of such tactics does not automatically validate anyone who claims their lives are hard.

The original article used a line from Hobbes regarding existence pre-society, which does not apply. The author could have used many valid other things in the US (homeownership and marriage rates, opiod addiction, savings rate) that would have made that part of their argument valid, but decided to go to the rhetorical extreme.

albntomat0··on GameStop, Bitcoin and the Commoditization of Populist Rage
I have a somewhat modified view, in that articles like this (and ones regarding income inequality) need to be specific in exactly what they mean by comments like "nasty, brutish, and short", or inequal wealth distribution.

Do they mean decreases in life expectancy? Student debt? Homeownership? Disease prevalence? Violent crime?

It's continually stated as an axiom, but poor writing such as that really weakens their argument.

albntomat0··on Interest surges in top colleges, while struggling ones scrape for applicants
I definitely agree with individuals taking actions within the system to optimize their chances is fine (e.g. targeting colleges that don't require standardized testing if the applicant doesn't do well on those tests, but not things like the fake sports recruiting that was in the news a year or so ago).

I may be biased as I did well on standardized tests. I have family members that volunteer to do admissions interviews as alumni of a very major name university. They both mention how gamified some applicants are taking the process, with some high school students' parents essentially buying them research opportunities and other experiences to talk about on their applications. While standardized testing is influenced by family wealth and resources, I'm convinced standardized tests (SAT/ACT/AP/etc) are the least influenced part of college admissions, and thus should remain in some form.

albntomat0··on Interest surges in top colleges, while struggling ones scrape for applicants
What are your thoughts on standardized tests as the most standard (not sure what a better word is here) comparison between applicants?

I recognize that a lot has been written about the SAT/etc being biased, but high school grades and "experiences" are worse (how does one compare what a "B" in Calculus or club president actually means, in all high schools across the US??).

albntomat0··on Interest surges in top colleges, while struggling ones scrape for applicants
The key difference between the parent commenter's proposal and a loan, is that the proposal ties the amount paid back to the income of the graduate.

The thinking is that conditions would be structured to better ensure the college degree provides suitable income (only for certain majors, only if the college provides certain data about grads, etc).

← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →