HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aleph_minus_one

5,089 karma · joined February 14, 2023

submissionscomments
aleph_minus_one··on If AI coding is lowering your code quality, you're not managing quality right
> AI writes unmaintainable code - you can see that many projects don't accept it.

There also exist other good reasons why projects don't want AI-generated code, in particular

- because of unclarity of copyright status and consequences of AI-generated code

- because the project leader simply made the observation than many programmers who hand in AI-generated code care more about "getting things done" and "pushing through their changes" (possibly to boost their CV) instead of deeply caring about code quality

aleph_minus_one··on André Weil and the Hodge Conjecture
> No way. Mathematicians don't assume things to be true even if there are no counterexamples.

It depends: there do exist some conjectures for which there don't exist any proofs, but a huge amount of results assuming this conjecture (which is very near to assuming that the conjecture is true). Examples are:

- Riemann hypothesis [1]

- Generalized Riemann hypothesis (GRH) [2], and potentially also Extended Riemann hypothesis (ERH) [3]

- Standard conjectures on algebraic cycles [4]

- perhaps Schanuel’s conjecture [5]

--

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Riemann_hypothesi...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Generalized_Riema...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Generalized_Riema...

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Standard_conjectu...

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Schanuel%27s_conj...

aleph_minus_one··on CCC invites all model citizens to 40C3
> The doc won't point it out explicitly and I apologize if my explanation offends anybody, but the intention is basically leftist, state-friendly bitcoin. The authors took a look at the anarchy of real cryptocurrencies and realized they don't actually like anarchy, so instead they want to make something "wholesome" that governments would be willing to go along with (since they can tax it).

While this is correct, I want to add a point:

Many hackers are not per se opposed to taxation (how else should public services be financed), but deeply distrustful about the red tape involved (the taxation laws in Germany are insanely complicated). Basically, their attitude is: if the government wants to tax "my" cryptocurrency, it is the government's responsibility to make the taxation laws as elegant, privacy-conscious and hassle-free as humanly possible.

In other words: if the government does not create taxation laws that are as hassle-free and privacy-conscious as possible (in a very strong sense: if in terms of effort (including the time to understand and apply the laws), it is much easier to ignore the laws than to turn in your taxes, the government failed its job), the government failed its job, so it does not deserve a concession from the cryptocurrencies' developers side.

aleph_minus_one··on CCC invites all model citizens to 40C3
And many Germans are deeply distrustful of such cameras.
aleph_minus_one··on CCC invites all model citizens to 40C3
> They brag about their great "data protection" laws, and the same same day you read in the news how yet another of their universities got hacked and how some incompetent government agency leaked the sensitive private information of hundreds of thousands of their citizens.

I would claim those people from Germany who are very privacy-minded indeed have a huge distrust of these data collections exactly because they know that sooner or later someone will crack these systems.

aleph_minus_one··on CCC invites all model citizens to 40C3
> Hacker conference: against authoritarian government, with talk about security, privacy, opsec etc.

> Also: can only buy ticket online with credit card and real name, no onsite sell available, your name is probably give to conference administrator for checking ticket, he will probably give it to third parties or keep it for "good reasons", etc.

I am indeed quite certain that many hackers in Germany independently already devised the same thoughts ...

aleph_minus_one··on CCC invites all model citizens to 40C3
Berlin is very different from the rest of Germany.
aleph_minus_one··on CCC invites all model citizens to 40C3
> I have a strong bias towards recording public environments and a heavy aversion to any censorship, whatsoever.

This is a balancing of legally protected interests [Güterabwägung] between privacy and censhorship. Independently of what the law may say, many Germans are strongly biased towards privacy here. Be also aware that in Germany the strong US-American concept of "free speech" does not exist; the laws that do exist are weaker.

> Given that, however, if someone asks me not to take their picture, I first give them the option of receiving a copy for their own purposes, and if they decline, I respectfully delete.

Why not ask for permission instead of objection? (even if, as you claim, the formal written law may be on your side)

aleph_minus_one··on Adversarial Fashion Makes a Statement on AI Panopticon
> Sock masks are actually kinda discreet with the right clothing.

Which kind of clothing are you talking about?

aleph_minus_one··on On Binary Translation and Its Consequences
> It seems there is a persistent rift between what hardware designers think users want and what users are asking for

> Nobody I personally know wants a faster CPU; they want competent, faster, native feeling software and more power efficient hardware.

I think you miss the point: what you claim that users want is not something that hardware designers have a lot of influence on (except for the aspect that the IC should be (more) power-efficient): these are rather problems that software developers are there to solve. So, hardware designers are simply the wrong persons to ask if you have such wishes.

aleph_minus_one··on Tao: Open math problems being non-renewably mined by AI
> I'm convinced that all the quantum talk is the NSA propaganda to convince us to drop RSA and move to some secure post quantum algorithm that they can easily break.

It is rather consensus that by now,

- too many potential weaknesses for RSA are known (in particular in how it is used in standardized cryptosystems [1]),

- it is a bad idea if too many "free parameters" of the cryptosystem are decided by the practical implementation (in RSA: the decision which primes to use to generate the key pair) instead of these parameters being part of the standard

Thus the advice to drop RSA is in my opinion sound.

But otherwise: many people indeed have the suspicion that the panic that a sufficiently powerful quantum computer might get developed in the next year is indeed used to push novel "post quantum algorithms" which

- have not been analyzed as thoroughly as older algorithms, and thus might contain weaknesses,

- were covertly developed by some three letter agency, and contain backdoors.

In other words: your suspicion might not be unfounded - this just does not imply that RSA does not have its risks and should thus arguably indeed be abandoned.

---

[1] Just to give one example: in the past, RSA was often used together with the padding scheme PKCS#1 v1.5, see [2]

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=PKCS_1&oldid=1342...

aleph_minus_one··on Tao: Open math problems being non-renewably mined by AI
> You may recall though that whole problem with '42' as the answer was the lack of knowledge of the question. The Earth was created as an attempt to provide the question, but was unfortunately demolished to make way for a hyperspace bypass just before the question was resolved.

In the second book of the book series, "The Restaurant at the End of the Universe", the question gets revealed: "What do you get if you multiply six by nine?"

aleph_minus_one··on OpenAI’s Navier-Stokes release included a Lean 4 formal proof
> It would be nice if someone used AI and/or Lean to sort out the abc conjecture, an important unsolved problem in Diophantine analysis.

People did attempt this:

https://github.com/katobungen/LANA_report_202607/blob/pdf/LA...

See also https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=15770

Here are Kirti Joshi's comments about the LANA project report: https://bpb-us-e2.wpmucdn.com/sites.arizona.edu/dist/4/404/f...

aleph_minus_one··on Leaving VMware just got harder after Broadcom pulled VDDK downloads
> Just insane what MBAs are willing to do to a product to squeeze short term profits. Even more insane that this country largely sees these people as a benefit to society and not the vultures they are.

I do understand the argument that it can be considered as a benefit for society if companies that have a very incompetent management that falls for this kind of trap of getting locked in by some vendor without having an emergency escape plan available get milked or even get bust. :-)

aleph_minus_one··on Programming is Art
> Nobody will go to an exhibition or a museum to stare at code like we do with paintings.

Because most code is a stinking pile of shit.

But at least I can easily imagine a world where people indeed do this. :-)

Indeed yesterday I drew some pictures (on my computer) that visualize what actually happens in some rather mathematical algorithms.

aleph_minus_one··on Programming is Art
> If this were true, there would be a large market for artisan code. There isn't.

Nearly every designer and artist knows that artisan stuff does not bring in the money, but rather commissions for "everyday stuff"; in German there exists the term "Eisdielen-Jobs" [1] ("ice cream parlor jobs") for commissioned, boring, "everyday" design jobs like, as the term implies, creating the design and illustrations for a menu map of an ice cream parlor.

--

[1] https://www.spiegel.de/karriere/illustrator-als-beruf-kreati...

aleph_minus_one··on QBittorrent breaks out of sandbox to commit crimes
> Like the gun that kills people rather than the murderer.

Relevant (NSFW):

> Guns don't kill people, I kill people - with guns

> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xC03hmS1Brk

:-D

aleph_minus_one··on Shutting down our public encrypted DNS
I don't know the US law (I live in Germany), but the intuition is clear:

1. Take some CC0/public domain source code.

2. Build a binary out of it and sell licenses for your software.

Case study: SQLite's source code is public domain. On the other hand, it is embedded in many commercial software products that are sold - and you are not allowed to reverse-engineer the software or redistribute binaries of it. This would be possible/allowed in a no-copyright world.

aleph_minus_one··on Shutting down our public encrypted DNS
> CC0 is an explicit attempt to emulate public domain in license form, isn't it?

Public domain is something different from an emulation of "there is no copyright":

You can take public domain material to build some program binary:

- In the current legal system, you can enforce restrictions on the usage of this binary, and can forbid redistribution, reverse-engineering, ...

- In a "no copyright world", you cannot enforce such restrictions.

aleph_minus_one··on Shutting down our public encrypted DNS
> But all software would be free by default, because all source would be in the public domain, and all reverse compilation of binaries would produce public domain code.

I am not aware of any open-source license which tries to approximate the "there is no copyright" situation:

- Such a license would not compulse you to publish the source code of any modification you make for it.

- Such a license would allow you to distribute compiled programs only.

- On the other hand, such a license must not restrict you to de-compile, modify or re-destribute any binaries built from the source code.

- But any such derivate of such a binary or source code would have to stay under the same license (this is a different kind of virality than "normal" viral licenses).

aleph_minus_one··on Shutting down our public encrypted DNS
> There may be a middle ground between the current maximalist copyright regime and ending copyright altogether.

The trenches between the different factions are far too deep for any middle ground to have any chance.

aleph_minus_one··on US Military disables ad trackers on troops' phones
Why even allow any mobile phone for the US solider if it could cause any arbitrary problem for the US military if the location data, name, unit, rank, ... of the respective soldier was published and permanently updated on a publicly viewable website?

It should be obvious that the US military has good reasons why this would be the death for many military strategies. So, why doesn't the military than treat every soldier who has a mobile phone near to him where the above could cause military problems to be a saboteur (perhaps even with the accusation of being a spy of a hostile nation) who should be charged by a military tribunal?

aleph_minus_one··on The Computer Museum of America reclamation project
> Antiquities and heirlooms can be a good stable investment, the same reason people trade art or watches or guns or cars.

It is only an investment if it (likely) gains yield. Otherwise it is just a means of preservation of value.

aleph_minus_one··on Reasons robotics is hard
> Also so they can watch each other, in case of the humans trying to shut them down.

That's why the human operator needs a gun. :-)

aleph_minus_one··on I don't have a smartphone or at least I wish I didn't
> I've seen supermarkets that offer targeted "in app only" deals.

In Germany, the grocery discounter Aldi (both Aldi Nord and Aldi Süd) explicitly created advertising campaigns that they offer the same prices even if you don't use an app. The economic background is that Aldi's competitor Lidl nudges customers to use their app for discounts.

An article: https://www.mobiflip.de/aldi-ohne-app-so-verpasst-der-discou...

Pictures of the billboards: https://i0.wp.com/www.mobiflip.de/wp-content/uploads/2026/07... https://i0.wp.com/www.mobiflip.de/wp-content/uploads/2026/07...

Texts:

German:

  GÜNSTIG
  OHNE
  BONUS-APP.

  EINFACH EINKAUFEN.
  ZUM ALDI PREIS.
English:

  CHEAP
  WITHOUT
  BONUS APP.

  SIMPLY SHOP.
  AT ALDI PRICE.
German:

  WARUM
  EWIG PUNKTE
  SAMMELN?

  GÜNSTIG
  OHNE
  BONUS-APP.

  EINFACH EINKAUFEN.
  ZUM ALDI PREIS.
English:

  WHY
  COLLECT POINTS FOREVER
  ?

  CHEAP
  WITHOUT
  BONUS APP.

  SIMPLY SHOP.
  AT ALDI PRICE.
Video by Aldi Süd (in German; try use YouTube's translation functionalities if you aren't fluent in German): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZF9wfg4XGfk

Lidl was furious that this campaign was so well received by the population (for this keep in mind that the Schwarz Gruppe (Schwarz Group), the corporate group behind Lidl, has big plans for cloud business (Schwarz Digits [1])), and created its own rather ridiculed counter-campaign:

https://www.mobiflip.de/aldi-greift-an-lidl-kontert-jetzt-ge...

Image: https://i0.wp.com/www.mobiflip.de/wp-content/uploads/2026/07...

German text:

  Hey, liebe
  Aldi Kollegen,
  erst Deutschland in Nord und Süd aufteilen und dann stolz von einem Preis für alle ohne App sprechen.
  Ihr habt Humor.

  Liebe
  Aldi Kunden,
  ihr seid natürlich ALLE herzlich eingeladen, von Hamburg bis München zu einheitlichen Preisen zu sparen – mit oder ohne Lidl Plus.
English translation:

  Hey, dear
  Aldi colleagues,
  first divide Germany into North and South and then proudly talk about one price for everyone without an app.
  You have a sense of humor.

  Dear
  Aldi customers,
  you are of course ALL cordially invited to save at uniform prices from Hamburg to Munich – with or without Lidl Plus [the name of Lidl's app].
--

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwarz_Digits

aleph_minus_one··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
> gestures broadly at HN and the tech industry

For me, HN ist rather some kind of counterweight/counterbubble where not everybody is insanely critical and cynical about Elon Musk and Sam Altman. :-)

aleph_minus_one··on How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been?
> while pathological liars like Musk and Altman are glossed over.

You seem to live in a bubble where these people are worshipped ... :-(

aleph_minus_one··on No country for mediocre mathematicians
> Nothing in your comment makes me want to go learn more theory, and I would argue that it's nonsense to anyone who is not a mathematician.

You are free to ignore mathematics that is not completely trivial. I prefer (and would rather recommend) to understand it, and use this understanding to build a >1-billion-USD/EUR application out of it. :-)

aleph_minus_one··on No country for mediocre mathematicians
I don't think she is untalented as a researcher in physics. Where she did not have talent at (and which is why she became a science YouTuber) is in "playing the career game" in physics research. Being a great researcher in some science requires very different talents than climbing the career ladder in this area of academic research.
aleph_minus_one··on No country for mediocre mathematicians
If you just want to do some stupid computations: sure.

But this is not what mathematics is centrally about. The central point is the kind of thinking about the respective topics (and understanding it) which these more abstract definitions encode.

Understanding the topic just enough to do some elementary computations does not give you the kind of thinking that is often near a transcendental experience.

Just to give one example: the reason why the localization of a commutative ring (a generalization of the field of fractions) is introduced is that many properties of ring hold if and only if they hold for all of its local rings; see for example [1]. This means to understand some property of a commutative ring R, we "just" have to understand its (simpler) local rings.

This is an example why one wants to study such ideas; on the other hand, I can imagine sooo many more exciting things to do with my life than dividing numbers by each others to form fractions. :-)

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Localization_(com...

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →