HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

aleph_minus_one

5,089 karma · joined February 14, 2023

submissionscomments
aleph_minus_one··on No country for mediocre mathematicians
> mathematicians or physicists fall into this category of knowing a lot about many thing . Sabine videos for example . she knows everything it seems

Sabine Hossenfelder, for obvious reasons, knows quite a bit about physics, though on some physics topics she has opinions that are outside the mainstream. For other areas, I am rather certain that she has a talent to learn about them up to some shallow level quite fast, which suffices to create some video about the respective topic, and then move on.

aleph_minus_one··on No country for mediocre mathematicians
> Is there’s something more to that?

Yes: this is about building the quotient field (field of fractions) [1] for some integral domain, or more generally, building the localization ([2], [3]) of a commutative ring with respect to some given set that is closed under multiplication (the special case of the quotient field for a ring R is obtained when one chooses R\{0} as such a set).

--

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Field_of_fraction...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Field_of_fraction...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Localization_(com...

aleph_minus_one··on Debian votes to allow "responsible use of generative AI"
> They are increasingly pulling away from the idea that they should mentor people to do better.

Two considerations on this:

1. In the USA, it is common to switch jobs often (in opposite to, for example, Germany). So, in the US-American system it is not often worth the effort to invest a lot of mentoring ressources into some employee if he will leave soon anyway.

2. I personally observe that I often do try to give less experienced programmers good hints on how to improve, but my kind of thinking about programming is often so different that my advice is often of no use for them. Or I often get the arrogant reaction by less experienced programmers that I care far too much about obscure details. I thus seriously do believe that the only way to help junior programmers to become better is to completely crush their ego and arrogance (just like a doctoral study programme in, say, mathematics does to the doctoral students), which is of course not allowed at work. :-(

aleph_minus_one··on Debian votes to allow "responsible use of generative AI"
> If you had actually thought through what you were doing, it was a few min to fill it all out.

... for people who are native speakers of English.

aleph_minus_one··on Debian votes to allow "responsible use of generative AI"
> Just had a thought, what if you made new contributors write a human-authored essay on why they’re submitting a patch, and then check it against Pangram?

The problem is writing such an essay takes magnitudes more of an effort for people who are not native English (or whatever the language is in which discussions are done about the project) speakers.

Also, relatedly, essays written by non-native English speakers often get considered to be AI-written by common AI detection systems, even though no AI was involved when writing them; see for example

> I'm Kenyan. I Don't Write Like ChatGPT. ChatGPT Writes Like Me.

> https://marcusolang.substack.com/p/im-kenyan-i-dont-write-li...

aleph_minus_one··on Iceland votes on whether to restart talks on joining EU
> Is there any "western" values coalition?

I would claim (both by living in Germany and the posted diagram) that for each of these values, most share this value, but not everybody. The problem is that for each value, the stakeholders who do/don't share it can be different. So, a lot of agreements are very complicated.

This is also in my opinion a central reason for the rising anti-EU sentiments in many countries: the more is dicated from above in Brussels/Strasbourg, the more often it happens that in some group who has a really strong opinion on this topic strong anti-EU sentiments will become socially very accepted in this group.

The solution that I would thus propose to keep these anti-EU sentiments not to escalate would be to keep the areas where the EU has any influence to those areas

- where there is an insanely strong consensus over what is "right" vs "wrong" over the whole EU, and

- which are politically rather uncontroversial (i.e. the opposite of being a political minefield).

aleph_minus_one··on Debian votes to allow "responsible use of generative AI"
> Treating coding as the therapeutic reward for other things (typically tolerating bureaucracy) and then indulging obsessions about it absolutely is unhealthy.

> And I've seen exactly this across multiple large and small organizations in multiple countries, in addition to being all over here and the red site.

I know that experience, but I do have a different opinion on this:

Many such people studied computer science (a similar point holds for mathematics, physics and some engineering disciplines) because they love coding.

Unluckily, the job that they got does involve barely any clever coding, but rather

- tolerating and gluing together shitty code pieces that someone else wrote

- tolerating red tape

So, such people simply do in their free time what they love. And to come back to my point "similar point holds for mathematics, physics and some engineering disciplines": these people try to use their little free time to prove some novel theorems or put their shed full of machines like 3D printers, CNC mills, CNC lathes, laser cutters, self-built pick-and-place machines, ... to work on their own beloved engineering projects.

aleph_minus_one··on Autism mutations drive neurodevelopmental pathology
> If you see a person without legs, do you tell him he is a piece of shit because he can't run? So why harass autistic people?

If you have not yet realized it, here is a black pill for you: most people are deeply manipulative and bullying basically all the time. For example nearly all social rules that are commonly accepted in society are basically about which kinds of manipulations and bullying of other people are accepted by most people vs not.

With this in mind, the answer to your question

> So why harass autistic people?

is trivial: because it is currently socially mostly accepted.

aleph_minus_one··on The turbulent AI era is here
> Before cloud you had to hire a dedicated server and you were looking at $1000/month (in say 2000).

Rather: perhaps 50-100 USD per month got and still gets you a quite good server to start your project. If you were looking for bargains, you could even get a server for less.

aleph_minus_one··on OpenAI Jalapeño: Better than Nvidia Blackwell
> Every time a company has spent resources doing this, a competitor innovated on the software and made the custom hardware irrelevant.

This often happened, though not always.

An important counterexample are 3D graphics cards, which basically put the OpenGL/DirectX fixed-function pipeline into silicon. It took a long time and many iterations to make the pipeline more programmable until the 3D graphics cards turned into modern GPUs.

Even today, GPUs live on as separate hardware in a computer instead of having become integrated into, say, the CPU. Intel's attempt to do something like this with the Larrabee project [1] was discontinued.

---

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Larrabee_(microar...

aleph_minus_one··on Disrupting a new covert influence campaign from Russia
> I broadly agree with your thrust but I'm going to assume you're a bot. Who would benefit from such a perspective as yours?

Not ReptileMan: Depending on the country and social environment that you live in, such opinions of "ordinary, living" people are nothing unusual. In my experience the reason why many people think such opinions barely exist "in normal society" or accuse posters of such opinions to be bots is that these normal people live in a bubble in which such opinions are rare.

aleph_minus_one··on Woman stranded in Spain after UK's eVisa system mistakes her for twin sister
> will have to place a human behind the keyboard with the authority [...] to change the data from incorrect to correct.

Whether such a person has such a permission in the system or whether the permission system of the software can actually model this is a work process that has been turned into code.

aleph_minus_one··on Woman stranded in Spain after UK's eVisa system mistakes her for twin sister
> That being a slow process is not a software engineering issue, but an organizational issue.

Business software is work processes that has been turned into code.

aleph_minus_one··on How Europe is killing makers and micro-entrepreneurs
> I'm trying to think of a single metric by which the EU hasn't been a massive success.

- Number pages of lunatic regulations

- Money gone into the EU

- Not a metric, but fitting very different philosophies of how to handle the domestic currency under one umbrella (ECU, Euro) has lead to massive tensions between the involved countries and their populations in particular when the Euro crisis hiy (e.g. in German "Pleitegriechen" [bust Greeks], PIIGS (pigs) countries (Portugal, Italy, Ireland, Greece, Spain)). If there wasn't a common currency, each country would have solved this problem on its own terms. Now there is hate that continues up to today, and these countries (including their citizens!) can be used as scapegoats.

aleph_minus_one··on Woman stranded in Spain after UK's eVisa system mistakes her for twin sister
> If CEOs were legally required to regularly use their own products as an ordinary customer, the world would be a better place.

This is like the argument "developers should use the software that they write" (dogfooding).

Let me give one example: the previous person who designed and developed the previous version of the software which I now work on really could use "his" program insanely well. The problem was rather that he was basically the only person who really did understand it sufficiently well to not to be triggered by problems other users had. Yes, a huge part of my job is over the years to turn this piece of software into something that is understandable by other people, too,. :-)

aleph_minus_one··on How Europe is killing makers and micro-entrepreneurs
> Nah, it should either become one, or dissolve, but this half baked shit definitely isn’t it.

Since the current situation is shit, and one EU national state will be shit, too, this only leaves one option. :-) So let's dissolve the EU before even more billions are wasted in this futile project.

aleph_minus_one··on Woman stranded in Spain after UK's eVisa system mistakes her for twin sister
My experience is rather that the typical software developer is ultra-cautious, and will always leave some loophole open in the workflows of the software in case something unexpected occurs that could not be foreseen, in particular considering the high stakes that are involved when something goes wrong with the software: I am not exaggerating when I claim that if something like what is is described in the article happens to some people, they often will start praying to their god that he kills the responsible people for this bug in the software in the most brutal imaginable way. Software developers know that.

Other stakeholders typically don't apply such caution.

aleph_minus_one··on How Europe is killing makers and micro-entrepreneurs
> America does it with 50 states

And Germany has 16 federal states.

aleph_minus_one··on How Europe is killing makers and micro-entrepreneurs
> People here are always complaining about the EU as if it's a single state, even though it's very clearly in the process of becoming one.

Rather: if you look at what the EU is doing, it is rather a huge advertisement that the EU should not become one.

aleph_minus_one··on Woman stranded in Spain after UK's eVisa system mistakes her for twin sister
> Software written by people that don't use the software themselves. It has happened to me so many times, I come across a piece of software with weird bugs or interactions that would be immediately fixed if the developer just spends 5 minutes using the software like an end user would. Dogfood all the things!

My experience is completely contrary: developers typically do care deeply about such things. The problem is rather that very commonly managers actively disallow these poor developers to apply their diligence to the software that they develop.

I really have a strong feeling that you want to participate in the ugly vendetta against software developers that has been going on for decades ("Replace all software developers"; current season: "Replace them with AI").

Don't do that. Rather fight the people who are really responsible (who are often (project) managers or Scrum masters).

aleph_minus_one··on The Lost Treasure of Sid Meier's Pirates
> Is there another game like Syndicate or Lemmings out there?

Concerning Lemmings: Gemini listed the following games that are at least similar in spirit:

- Humanity (2023)

- Zombie Night Terror (2016)

- Spirits (2011)

- Craftlings (2026)

aleph_minus_one··on The Lost Treasure of Sid Meier's Pirates
> Even Syndicate has a spiritual successor made by former syndicate devs

For those who are asking: this successor is Satellite Reign:

> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satellite_Reign

aleph_minus_one··on Australia passes law to levy tech giants that fail to pay for local news
Did you seriously believe that governments play fair? :-)
aleph_minus_one··on Mathematics in the age of AI
> > If a magic oracle tells you p=np, that's useless. How would that change anything?

> Oh it would change a lot. It would be an enormous psychological boost for everyone to find a practical algorithm.

OK, I tell you that P=NP, and that I am a magic oracle. So, you have you psychological boost for finding a practical algorithm for free. :-)

aleph_minus_one··on The little-known winstart.bat batch file
> I've forgotten now when it changed, but I remember older versions of Windows let you exit back to DOS once you'd finished doing GUI stuff. I'm guessing that was probably removed in Win95 as that was the first "proper" Windows that didn't rely on already having DOS (IIRC).

Until Windows 3.x this was possible (though not recommended). With Windows 95, there was a boot menu that you could access via the F8 key - my previous post should make it very clear why I still have this in my muscle memory after 20-30 years. Via this boot menu, you could boot into DOS 7.0 (or if an older DOS version was installed before the Windows 95 installation, also this older DOS version). In DOS, you could still run

> win

to get to Windows 95.

aleph_minus_one··on ADHD charity complains about Channel 4 documentary
> I do believe there is some truth to it. The reason we have had an upswing in diagnosed people is that society's demands have gotten higher and what was previously considered normal is no longer within the normality corridor.

Related quote from the Jargon file [1]:

"1994-95's fad behavioral disease was a syndrome called Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD), supposedly characterized by (among other things) a combination of short attention span with an ability to ‘hyperfocus’ imaginatively on interesting tasks. In 1998-1999 another syndrome that is said to overlap with many hacker traits entered popular awareness: Asperger's syndrome (AS). This disorder is also sometimes called ‘high-function autism’, though researchers are divided on whether AS is in fact a mild form of autism or a distinct syndrome with a different etiology. AS patients exhibit mild to severe deficits in interpreting facial and body-language cues and in modeling or empathizing with others' emotions. Though some AS patients exhibit mild retardation, others compensate for their deficits with high intelligence and analytical ability, and frequently seek out technical fields where problem-solving abilities are at a premium and people skills are relatively unimportant. Both syndromes are thought to relate to abnormalities in neurotransmitter chemistry, especially the brain's processing of serotonin.

Many hackers have noticed that mainstream culture has shown a tendency to pathologize and medicalize normal variations in personality, especially those variations that make life more complicated for authority figures and conformists. Thus, hackers aware of the issue tend to be among those questioning whether ADD and AS actually exist; and if so whether they are really ‘diseases’ rather than extremes of a normal genetic variation like having freckles or being able to taste DPT. In either case, they have a sneaking tendency to wonder if these syndromes are over-diagnosed and over-treated. After all, people in authority will always be inconvenienced by schoolchildren or workers or citizens who are prickly, intelligent individualists — thus, any social system that depends on authority relationships will tend to helpfully ostracize and therapize and drug such ‘abnormal’ people until they are properly docile and stupid and ‘well-socialized’.

So hackers tend to believe they have good reason for skepticism about clinical explanations of the hacker personality. That being said, most would also concede that some hacker traits coincide with indicators for non-hyperactive ADD and AS — the status of caffeine as a hacker beverage of choice may be connected to the fact that it bonds to the same neural receptors as Ritalin, the drug most commonly prescribed for ADD. It is probably true that boosters of both would find a rather higher rate of clinical ADD among hackers than the supposedly mainstream-normal 3-5% (AS is rarer at 0.4-0.5%)."

--

[1] http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/weaknesses.html

aleph_minus_one··on IDE Nostalgia (2022)
> I wonder if a whole external device is really necessary for the one-handed device for chords. I think with a customisable keyboard, you'd be able to chord.

Not with a normal keyboard (though there do exist specialized keyboards for gamers with which this might be possible). The reason lies in the key rollover, which is very limited for many off-the-shelf keyboards:

> https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Key_rollover&oldi...

> https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Key_rollover&oldi...

"To reduce cost and design complexity, most computer keyboards do not isolate all keys. Instead, they use a matrix of key switches, without any isolation diodes, that assumes that only a limited number of keys will be held down at any given time. With these keyboards, pressing as few as three keys can cause ghosting effects, although care is taken when laying out the matrix arrangement that this does not happen for common modifier key combinations."

aleph_minus_one··on The little-known winstart.bat batch file
> I suppose it isn't if you never had it on real hardware. Win32 was well marked as the complete OS takeover for the PC. DOS remained only to boot Windows and as backup OS. If you absolutely needed to jump back to DOS you still could, however you were heavily expected to force your DOS programs to launch and live in their own little DOS environments, much to everyone's chagrin.

I remember that at the time of Windows 95, I very often had to boot back to DOS 7.0 (which was also delivered as part of the Windows installation) to run DOS games, which were still very popular until like the middle of the 00 years.

And yes, when Windows XP came out (2001), people were somewhat disappointed that you couldn't simply boot DOS anymore to play your old beloved games. Over the years, DOSBox got sufficiently stable and PCs got sufficiently powerful that this gap could be closed.

aleph_minus_one··on Google has stopped pushing Git tags for some Android source code
> This is explicitly about commemorative coins, not regular ones.

The formulation is not so easy to read (very common for German laws), but it includes also the regulations for normal coins:

"Erfolgt eine einzelne Zahlung sowohl in Euro-Münzen als auch in deutschen Euro-Gedenkmünzen, ist niemand verpflichtet, mehr als 50 Münzen anzunehmen; dies gilt auch dann, wenn der Gesamtbetrag 200 Euro unterschreitet."

"If a single payment is made using both euro coins and German commemorative euro coins, no one is obliged to accept more than 50 coins; this also applies if the total amount is less than 200 euros."

So, there exist two cases in which the vendor is not obliged to take more than 50 coins:

- The payment consists of both normal Euro coins and German commemorative euro coins

- The payment is less than EUR 200.

--

Independently, there does exist another source of law by which the vendor is not obliged to take more than 50 coins: Artikel 11 der EG-Verordnung Nr. 974/98 des Rates über die Einführung des Euro, EU-Amtsblatt L139 vom 11. Mai 1998:

> https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/DE/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELE... (German)

> https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELE... (English)

"As from 1 January 2002, the participating Member States shall issue coins denominated in euro or in cent and complying with the denominations and technical specifications which the Council may lay down in accordance with the second sentence of Article 105a(2) of the Treaty. Without prejudice to Article 15, these coins shall be the only coins which have the status of legal tender in all these Member States. Except for the issuing authority and for those persons specifically designated by the national legislation of the issuing Member State, no party shall be obliged to accept more than 50 coins in any single payment."

Relevant part of this article:

"Except for the issuing authority and for those persons specifically designated by the national legislation of the issuing Member State, no party shall be obliged to accept more than 50 coins in any single payment."

aleph_minus_one··on Google has stopped pushing Git tags for some Android source code
But after one person does this, the source code access is a solved problem.
← PreviousPage 7 of 34Next →