HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alex504

399 karma · joined January 31, 2016

submissionscomments
alex504··on Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range
> posting a salary range has many positive downstream effects

I agree. I'm just not sure if I agree that it particularly benefits underprivileged groups. I don't see a compelling argument being made by the author that the system of negotiation specifically is biased. Whether a salary range is posted or not everyone has to negotiate and engage the market. There is no way to get around this and if you aren't willing to do it you are going to be taken advantage of.

A salary range posted by the company who is trying to hire you is not going to tell you how much you should be making there. They are going to try to pay you less. It seems like what people really want is for employers to magically pay everyone exactly what they should be making without negotiating, which is simply not possible, because nobody knows what they should be making until the market sets a price.

> The first is that better candidates will get the maximum salary out of a company, and less qualified candidates will get less.

I'm not assuming this. In my experience whether someone negotiates more or not at all has more to do with their experience around the process in general. More junior candidates or candidates who haven't switched jobs more than once or twice are more likely to be underpaid. I personally screwed this up about 4 times before learning my lesson.

> minority candidates will be looked at differently when asking for money

I don't disagree with this. I don't see how posting a salary range changes this. If the company / market is willing to pay less to an underprivileged group, that is going to be reflected in compensation regardless of whether a salary range is posted or not.

> There's also the difficulty of determining one's worth

The way you determine what the market is willing to pay is to find out what the market is willing to pay. There is no other way to do it. For someone looking for a job you should try to get multiple offers, negotiate them, and see how much you end up with. That number is as close to your market value as you are going to get.

> this ignores the fact that our society is set up to encourage confidence in straight white men and discourage it in many other group

I guess I really just don't buy this argument as it pertains to this topic. Negotiating compensation shouldn't be a matter of confidence after a certain point in your career. After you have done it a few times it is not very intimidating. It is a fact of life and something everybody needs to learn to be comfortable doing. If you can't become comfortable doing this, you are going to make less.

alex504··on Job descriptions should show a salary or salary range
What she is saying does not line up with my experience regarding how this works.

> As a woman... I’m unlikely to bring up the topic of salary with a potential boss.

If you have that attitude you are going to make less money than someone who negotiates. Period. Companies will try to pay anyone, no matter their race, gender, or religion, less. There is also no reason to feel bad about discussing salary - it is a part of the process, just like submitting your resume and interviewing.

Would publishing a salary in a job description make things more equitable? I don't think so. The keyword in job market is MARKET. It is not as simple as publishing a salary. Every role I've interviewed candidates for had a range we were willing to pay. The best candidate will get the maximum of the range, and a candidate that we are less excited about will get the low end. The candidates are always being judged against other candidates, and how much we think they will cost. What we are willing to pay fluctuates and depends on how we feel about the candidate after the interview, how badly we need someone, and how many other candidates there are at a given time.

Just like in any market that is this small, there is negotiation involved. Employers want to pay less, employees want to make more. The way you arrive at a price is making offers until both sides agree.

That is simply the way it works. It is a barter system. I don't buy the idea that women / bipoc can't navigate this system. It is something you have to learn. White men aren't born being able to navigate it - it took me about 5 years to be fully comfortable with the process. Before that I was underpaid.

alex504··on Ask HN: What tech job would let me get away with the least real work possible?
ding ding ding
alex504··on Ask HN: What tech job would let me get away with the least real work possible?
I was never the type of person to try to write a framework to solve a tiny little task, but I am probably 50% more effective with my time since I stopped caring about my job. I am not stressed out at all and that makes a massive difference.

That being said I probably work about 75% less (~10 - 15 hours a week if I'm being honest) so the joke is still on my employer.

alex504··on Credit Suisse Takes $4.7B Hit on Archegos Meltdown
Whoever sold the jesus guy stock
alex504··on MacBook Owners' Butterfly Keyboard Lawsuit Gets Class Action Certification
4 years seems like a bit of an insult in this scenario. These laptops are very expensive bought new and this is a defect; you would think they would repair them for life or at least as long as the life of the laptop.

I've been using the same MBR laptop since 2013 for personal use and haven't found any reason to switch. I would be pretty mad if I owned one of these and had to get it fixed, or wanted to resell it and had a lower resell value because of the keyboard.

It also feels worse because they continued manufacturing them for years after they knew there was a problem. 4 years smells similar to the planned obsolescence scandal in iPhones, as it implies that the lifetime of one of these is 4 years which is just not the case in my experience. They are hoping people will say "my laptop needs a new battery and a new keyboard, might as well drop another 2 grand for a new one" instead of keeping their perfectly good laptop.

alex504··on Lost in Thought: Psychological Risks of Meditation
That's the fun part :)

The most accomplished people who I know in this stuff have spent decades moving from teacher to teacher.

Eventually you can tell who is full of shit and who isn't. There are certain red flags that you can learn to spot pretty quickly. If you spot a red flag it also doesn't necessarily mean the person doesn't know something worth learning, it just means they are stuck somewhere else. There are a lot of pretty high level people who are a little bit egotistical for example but it doesn't mean they don't know some useful techniques.

The guy teaching me has trained under like a dozen very well known people over the years and his current teacher spent several decades in Asia working his way up through a series of teachers. The latter person I'm describing has talked about being very skeptical of his teachers to the point where in one instance he went into a teachers fridge to confirm he was lying about what he did or didn't eat.

alex504··on Lost in Thought: Psychological Risks of Meditation
Psychedelics are a good analogy. I don't think they are worth much in our culture and carry serious risk for people who are unstable. Even if you find an authentic shaman, you aren't going to have the cultural context to make it worthwhile by flying there over a weekend.

There is also probably not much more dangerous than a very poorly functioning spiritual practice / teacher. The story here about Vipassana is unsurprising to say the least. It is sort of like squatting a 200kg weight with bad form, over and over again for years, but instead of your body you are breaking your consciousness.

The key takeaway is that if you want to pursue this stuff you really need to find a good teacher who you trust.

alex504··on Why I don't like Tailwind CSS
"I am fortunate to have only worked with Tailwind CSS in local sandboxes, and not in any production projects or on an actual team of other devs."

Does anyone else get frustrated when people post blogs like this without actually using the technology in any meaningful way? I was also skeptical of Tailwind, and disliked it for the first 2 weeks or so of using it, but now I'm not so sure.

This reminds me of the phenomenon in outdoor gear where 75% of the reviews are people who bought a tent and set it up in their backyard and for some reason deigned it necessary to write a review.

alex504··on Pfizer Covid vaccine approved for use next week in UK
I am not a doctor but normal pneumonia recovery doesn't cause myocarditis, memory loss, abnormal liver function, kidney damage or gastrointestinal damage.

It seems very likely at this point that COVID is a disease of the blood vessels, which has the potential to do some really nasty damage to your organs. The numbers are hard to estimate but I've seen experts say that they think about 5 times the number of people who die will have enough problems to be considered having a long term disability. With estimates of case fatality being about .5% - 1.5% that would mean about 5% of the people who get it will have enough long term damage to be disabled.

alex504··on Pfizer Covid vaccine approved for use next week in UK
Yeah I think that basically sums it up. The dangers of long term COVID far, far outweigh the potential risks of the vaccine. It seems many people have a fundamental distrust of vaccines and many also still don't understand how dangerous COVID seems to be for people who have relatively little risk of dying from the disease.

I haven't been able to come up with a theory as to why public health departments and the media haven't been making the long term effects a key part of their messaging.

alex504··on I had Covid-19, and these are the things nobody tells you
It seems like the much more likely and scary scenario for young people (myself included) is long term health problems that are difficult or impossible to treat and basically destroy your quality of life.

I was curious if you have done any research on that? I keep hoping to find something to put my mind at ease.

alex504··on I had Covid-19, and these are the things nobody tells you
Have you gotten tested for any possible heart damage? There are some reports of athletes being benched because of a heart condition caused by COVID that can cause sudden death during exercise.
alex504··on Dating App Scams
This is very, very sad. It is an extreme example of how when society moves away from in person communication it becomes meaner. When you remove the in person element people start acting much worse to each other.
alex504··on Let’s avoid talk of ‘chemical imbalance’: it’s people in distress
I found ssris to be a prison. A profound spiritual stasis. They cut me off from myself. They muted my emotions so instead of learning to deal with them I stayed passive and simply ignored them. When I got off of them I spent quite awhile learning who I was and how to live with myself. I have come a long way as a person and I wonder if that change wouldn't have taken place sooner had I not taken them.

It seems that lots of very smart people take these drugs and I wonder how many are emotionally and spiritually stunted by them.

alex504··on I won’t buy ebooks anymore
I pirate most books unless they are available at my local library. I feel bad about it but I do it anyway.

If I'm being honest, if there were no piracy options I would be buying alot more books. Probably not as many as I pirate but still probably 500 dollars a year or so worth.

The catch is that it is true that if a book is unable to pirate I will probably not buy it. This is probably true for a lot of people. The reason is that there are other books available to pirate. That is the key distinction. If there were no piracy options I would be forced to buy some, but because there are piracy options I buy almost none and therefore you could say I wouldn't buy them anyway if they arent available to pirate.

alex504··on What people get paid to work in journalism
Thanks for saying this. I am sick of software engineers thinking they are smarter and than other people because they make more money.

How much money you make does not equate to your worth as a human being.

Software engineering is not that difficult.

There are lots of things just as difficult if not more difficult than software engineering.

The majority of software engineers contribute very little to society if anything.

Just because you have a good software engineering job does not make you a successful person or better than other people who are pursuing other ways of living their lives.

alex504··on Book Review: The Body Keeps the Score
Clearly a big part of these approaches is the affect of placebo. Placebo is also a big part of the impact of many parts of western medicine. In clinical trials antidepressants barely outperform placebos for instance.

You've raised a good point that this makes it even harder to determine how well something is working. Was it 100 percent placebo or did change take place outside of the effect of the placebo?

However just because the placebo effect is present doesn't mean we should dismiss it out of hand.

The term "scaling out" and a "boring environment" to me requires a treatment as simple as for instance setting a broken bone. A procedure like this is very easy to train someone to perform and there is relatively little in the way of differentiation between patients. An arm is an arm, it's very easy to see the problem as well as to see how a treatment is working.

But for instance in the case of acupuncture or qi gong or yoga, it would be very hard to replicate on a large scale. The practitioner matters a huge amount, as does the exact condition of the patient. Is the patient actually trying ot do the yoga? Is the acupuncturist good (most aren't). What kind of yoga is the person doing? Is the yoga or qi gong teacher leading them in the right direction for their particular issue? It isn't nearly as simple as a routine medical procedure.

I'm not saying that all of these treatments necessarily are effective. The issue I have is how quickly some are to dismiss treatments as not being backed up by evidence when the evidence will be very hard to come by, and ignoring the nuance involved. Personally my experience has led me to believe that acupuncture done by someone that knows what they are doing will work more than a placebo. The same certainly goes for qi gong in my personal experience.

alex504··on Book Review: The Body Keeps the Score
Yes I found this very amusing. For several reasons:

- Within a week he seems to have found that the content of the book was more effective than years of his treatment of atleast one patient

- He buries this as deeply within the article as possible

- This experience casts light on the crux of my issue with the article, which is that it is very much a "prereplication" book review.

The reality is that neither the author of the book or the review have solid empirical evidence one way or the other, in terms of modern style studies. The book review seems to be drawing an overly negative conclusion about the research because of this fact. To me this is a demonstration of an overreliance on empiricism that seems to dog alot of western medicine practitioners in general.

I found this line very revealing:

>later studies – done in an atmosphere of boredom, by large multi-center consortia – are almost always disappointing.

I'm not sure what the phrase "atmosphere of boredom" signifies but it doesn't sound like a faithful attempt to get something to work. If you are doing any of these treatments in an atmosphere of boredom will it actually be effective? Is doing it in an atmosphere of boredom really a valid way of testing it?

I haven't read the book but will read it. It does seem to me that the thesis of the book, that trauma causes the mind to disconnect from the body and shapes the body, is something that Chinese medicine / Qi Gong practitioners have known about for thousands of years. I don't have any empirical evidence to back these specific practices but I have mountains of anecdotal evidence that would seemingly be rejected by the author of the review.

alex504··on The Impact of Meditating Every Day
It sounds to me like you will reach a better practice without the app regardless of cost. I would force myself to do it without the app for 20 or 25 minutes, just wait for the timer to go off. Do that a few times and it will get easier. From my experience you will get better results this way as the guides are ultimately a distraction.
alex504··on People Simply Empty Out (1986)
There are not 1000s of Bukowskis out there in my experience. Some artists are undeniable and they don't have problems becoming famous. For example I've seen a lot of really good musicians in crappy venues. I've also seen musicians of the same caliber who are famous.

But I've never seen a great musician in a crappy venue. And when I see a world class musician it is undeniable that they are great.

In my experience there are 1000s of writers not quite as good as Bukowski and some of them will make it but very few. When a truly great writer comes along I believe the hard part is actually writing the great literature and not finding a publisher.

alex504··on The Impact of Meditating Every Day
Not sure what your practice is like with the app. But for a stability practice which is the more common type, I would set a timer and sit with good posture so your skeleton is supporting itself. Focus on your breathing especially within the body. It's important not to meditate from the head but from the body. When your attention wanders and you notice it go back to concentrating on your breathing.
alex504··on On Tolstoy's “War and Peace”
Most people dont think War and Peace was even Tolstoys greatest novel. Anna Karenina is regarded as the greatest novel of all time by lots of authors and critics though of course there is no consensus and its sort of a silly notion.
alex504··on Facing opposition, Amazon reconsiders NY headquarters site, two officials say
Nobody informed is opposed to it because of the finances. People just don't understand why we would want so many more people when gentrification and overcrowding are already making life harder for everyone in the city. If 25000 people with jobs at over 150k a year decided to leave and go to Boston, personally I would be excited.

A few things taxes can't seem to buy are lower rents and a public transportation system that isn't completely overcrowded.

alex504··on Facebook retires Nuclide Atom extension
To be fair any modern IDE or text editor that supports JavaScript supports JSX
alex504··on Show HN: An Almost Ideal React Image Component
I'll reply because it seems like 25% of every thread I've read on front end development in the past 5 years has a comment like this.

This library doesn't really have anything to do with React. Just because it is implemented in React doesn't mean that React needs this, over say Vue or Angular or VanillaJS or w/e "cool" library you like. In fact I would say the existence of libraries like this should make you want to adopt React over a library with less adoption.

I would also suggest you be more open to the idea that these kinds of things matter quite a bit when you are operating at scale. This type of library isn't really intended for the use case where spending time making optimizations isn't important or interesting.

alex504··on Spotify opens on NYSE, valuing company at almost $30B
I've recently tried out every major service: Google, Spotify, Apple Music, Tidal, and Amazon Prime.

They are all insanely buggy. I was a Spotify user for about 6 years before this and it was buggy, and is getting buggier as far as I can tell.

alex504··on Angular 2 is terrible
The use case for Angular 2 is super hardcore enterprise. Lots of developers, very large multimillion dollar projects, and safety being a top concern.

Everything must be done in a very standard way, and it assumes you need a bunch of stuff that only a fairly big application will need. Testing is very highly emphasized, with components being forced to be written in a way that is testable.

This guy clearly doesn't know what Angular is doing under the hood, meaning there is a bunch of stuff going on in his app that he doesn't understand, which is causing him lots of bugs and heartache. Many a time developers have built Angular apps without understanding what they are doing and ending up with a flaming pile of garbage that needs to be completely rewritten. However if you know what you are doing or hire someone that knows what they are doing to set up an application for you, I think the framework does have its advantages.

Having said all of this I really disliked my time working in Angular, with things like the terrible docs and lots of hidden esoteric knowledge needed being big flaws that they should address. For my company it made sense though.

alex504··on Original Diablo Pitch Document (1994) [pdf]
I was very interested to see that the team they pitched included only 11 people, including designers and illustrators. Only three programmers ('One chief programmer and two junior programmers').

Am I correct in thinking that a team this size would be considered closer to an indy game in 2016? I am not a game developer but this seems like a very stark comparison to the current landscape / size of software teams (not just limited to games).

← PreviousPage 3 of 3