1,209 karma · joined November 6, 2013
Probably not your intent, but this sounds incredibly patronizing.
In practice, this means that each time a server goes down someone has to be on-call to run a command to redirect them. It's also breaking your utilization-based sharding scheme.
> In the era of cloud computing, downtime has become less of an issue.
Well, yes and no. Downtime is less frequent because of robust, automated load balancing. Individual servers, whether VMs or containers or whatever you prefer, are far less reliable. That's intentional. It's cheap commodity hardware, designed to die, and 'cloud native' applications are supposed to handle that properly via things like automated load balancing.
> I like attempting to simplify supposedly complicated issues ... It's true that all requests are not equal but statistically, over time, with all servers being similar, the differences will tend to balance out.
This is an example of one of those simplifications that seems intuitive but just doesn't work. It is completely normal for there to be multiple orders of magnitude differences in request cost, between customers, and at different times. Even if you assume that your application is static (which it hopefully isn't), customer workloads are not. Their behavior will change, which means your sharding needs to change. This is already solved by existing load balancing algorithms described in the linked article.
What problem do you see with existing solutions that you're trying to solve?
> Manual/statistical load balancing --- assign users to a specific server based on their login credentials.
What happens when that specific server goes down? Needs an upgrade/deployment? You'll have to failover to a different server, which brings you back to an automatic load balancing strategy.
> Latency can be reduced to zero by simply forwarding the connection to the proper server once the login is complete.
Modern load balancers add a meaningless amount of latency per request. If you're truly forwarding it in the networking sense, then a load balancer/reverse proxy is still involved.
If you mean something like redirecting them to an endpoint that points directly at an individual server, you get back to the first problem. What happens when that server goes down?
> A statistical model of server utilization can be maintained and users assigned or re-assigned as needed.
This is one of those things that sounds _very simple_, but in practice is incredibly complicated.
If we say that it's not a pretend virtue to care about democracy and freedom around the world, then wouldn't it would be a reasonable imperative to interact with the world?
If the US is simply better at it, isn't that relevant?
It's not like other (former) superpowers didn't do the exact same things:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_involvement_in_regime_c...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_involvement_in_regime_...
Even ignoring the consent and ethical issues, doing something double-blind in a government ran system impacting statistically significant number of children simply can't be done. You can't maintain the blinding.
'Automatic rollbacks' are, frankly, absurd. How do you 'roll back' a child in 8th grade that failed algebra? Your quick iteration turns into dozens of cohorts to be tracked and managed.
https://www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2022-12-15/la-ed-schoo...
Reach out and tell him that. I'm sure he'd appreciate it.
It's unavoidable when you allow too many different interests to have a say in the process.
Yep. In fact, I specifically asked you for your proposal, and you chose to rant about identity politics instead of policy. Which is on brand, I guess.
> Going out on a limb here, but are you perchance a real estate agent? Because that would be the most hilarious of conflicts of interest.
Nope. The current system for performing real estate transactions is wildly inefficient, rent-seeking, insecure, and I'd love to see it destroyed.
Oh lord.
> I’ve bought Bitcoin many times without any KYC. In old days localbitcoins and these days ATMs in many countries ... There aren’t any “exchange in the coins path”. I’ve exchanged paper fiat currency at Starbucks, in a hotel lobby.
Sure, ok. Now take just one tiny step forward. Think about what happens next. Those coins have extremely high odds of passing through a KYC system in the near future. That can, will, and frequently has been used to trace users who are dumb enough to think "I paid for bitcoin for cash, I'm now anonymous".
> The wallets I use are open source 100%.
And nothing nefarious has ever slipped into open source software, right? Do you have no idea what a supply chain attack is?
You use NPM, you really ought to.
> There is no third party. only your operating system, the internet connection and the source code.
And, of course, your OS and the internet can be trusted. This is a great example of the level of critical thinking cryptobros achieve.
> I also broadcast my transaction over the ToR network so my internet provider and the Bitcoin network has no visibility.
Ok, so you mitigate the announce IP, which is one of the least useful ways to do analysis. Cool.
> yesterday I bought my lunch for my wife and I, $21 using by Bitpay debit card. I loaded the card 2 mins before with those dollars by sending Litecoin ...
So it has objectively worse utility, UX, and more dependencies than fiat?
This is not a good example.
> Years ago I met an artist from Argentina on an internet forum. She was painting what I thought were nice paintings. She was selling professional prints of those. I sent her Bitcoin and she sent me the prints.
Ok. This is still not useful. Western Union, Paypal, SWIFT, all cheaper and in some cases faster.
> I’ve hired a developer in Crimea to work on a security software and he was paid for his work in Bitcoin
Protip: if someone is willing to be paid in bitcoin, they are not worth the bitcoin you're sending.
> When my sister in law had a baby shower I bought all the gifts at Buy Buy Baby using a digital gift card purchased 30 mins earlier using Bitcoin.
As above: "So it has objectively worse utility, UX, and more dependencies than fiat?"
> Bitcoin is revolutionary and has a decent shot at bringing fiat government currencies to their knees so they are forced to act responsibly and not brr brr money print.
You have absolutely no idea what a central bank does, do you? Well, I mean, you obviously think you do. But you really don't. A basic class on economics would do you a world of good.
No, because despite the mixed-bag that a single payer system would bring, it is not actually destroying healthcare. Unless you intend to force them to provide their services for no pay.
> Perhaps the costs of allowing a deleterious institution to continue existing dwarf the costs of reforming them, on occasion.
Absolutely. Private property is not one of those institutions.
> Family formation is down, bankruptcy is up, and somehow I imagine that you have not figured in the trillions in lost value from these and the like realities that are extant because the 3rd most basic human need is unaffordable in this country.
It is substantially less than destroying the entire real market, unquestionably. That doesn't mean that it's not a problem that should be addressed. But free, permanent housing to everyone is not, in any way, a practical solution.
> Perhaps you can explain why taxation is so anathema to you. Are you one of the nutcases who consider it theft?
I'm not. I've got no problem at all paying my taxes. I have no interest in those taxes being wasted.