HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alex_sf

1,209 karma · joined November 6, 2013

submissionscomments
alex_sf··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
> unhoused people were never prospective clients of the real estate industry

See, this is what I mean. This sort of 'solution' is advocated by people that have never bothered to contemplate the second order effects.

Try to imagine what would happen if we implemented this. Anyone that is homeless gets permanent, free housing. You pat yourself on the back.

Except, now I sell my house. And I come to you and tell you that I'm homeless. Are you going to give me permanent, free housing too?

Because if you do, you have now created the economic catastrophe that I described.

And if you don't, because I don't deserve it on the basis of XYZ, you've just recreated section 8.

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
Another great point. Truly insightful.

This is the level of discourse adults experience from cryptobros, and it's why no-one except other cryptobros actually take you seriously.

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
There is a ton of trusted third parties involved. You're trusting:

- The KYC of your exchange, and any exchange in the coins path

- The wallet you're using

- The recipient to provide the correct address

- The exchange rate

And you're trusting all of that hasn't been tampered with, which involves even more trusted parties.

It requires an order of magnitude less trust to send cash in the mail. It's cheaper, too.

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
> No-coiners are exhausting.

More than naive cryptobros?

> Bitcoin triggers a deep psychological anxiety in some people and their reaction is to construct these defensive arguments in their heads about why Bitcoin is stupid, a scam, useless, etc.

It is obviously stupid, slow, and wasteful. Ignoring all the other problems with cryptocurrencies, just on those three axes ETH is superior.

> If in another 10 years it continues it’s success and we have widespread point of sale usage and micropayments etc, and value is, maybe $200K/coin. Then these people might require some type of specialized psychological therapy to handle their disbelief.

You love to monologue, huh?

> On the other hand, Bitcoiners even if it crashes to zero somehow, will be saying at least we tried, oh well.

A great sign of a moron is that they attach themselves to non-falsifiable ideas so they can't be wrong.

> Bitcoin opinions are some type of strange personality litmus test. I find it very curious as the test result feels very unpredictable for me when applied to people I know well.

It's very predictable. Is someone naive to the point of being borderline childlike? Wants to get-rich-quick? Hates the government? Bitcoin fan.

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
> - Bitcoin doesn't use DHTs.

I didn't say it did. But the idea of distributing data in a P2P fashion is not novel.

> - The term blockchain was coined after the Bitcoin white paper was published, to describe the mechanism used in Bitcoin.

I'm not very interested in the particular etymology. The fundamental ideas of a blockchain, regardless of what you call it, had been laid out by multiple people years before the bitcoin whitepaper[0].

> - Bitcoin was the first system to solve the double spending problem in a decentralized way.

No, it wasn't[1][2].

> The network is actively used. Just yesterday, there were 345K on chain Bitcoin transactions totaling a value of around 4 billion USD.

..Ok? That's about the level of activity I would expect between speculation, scams, and drugs, sure.

[0]https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.06130.pdf

[1]https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4268195

[2]https://arxiv.org/abs/0802.0832

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
It's only useful for speculation, scams, and drugs. What other utility does it have?
alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
I think it depends on what you consider to be the first such system.

The earliest ones I personally recall using were Liberty Reserve and E-Gold, which were basically fine, I guess. It was a good way to send money around with less eyes on it. Before that there were things like DigiCash, but I don't know much about that one. There was a whole bunch of random ones during the 90s, but most of them were ponzis and rugpulls (some things never change).

In my opinion, BTC took off in a way that others didn't for a bunch of reasons:

1) It was the first usable system that was decentralized, AFAIK. This is a pretty desirable characteristic, of course.

2) It had (and has) flaws, but there was no obvious means of it being a rug-pull or complete scam. E.g., it wasn't supposedly backed by gold/silver/whatever that didn't really exist.

3) You were able to get some bitcoin to use for 'free' by mining. Prior systems you had to buy into. The threshold to participate and profit was much lower.

4) The protocol is simple enough for those first few points to be trivial to verify.

5) It entered a sort of 'spiral' relationship with darknet markets and more general cybercrime. As those surged in popularity, the demand for bitcoin surged, which fueled interest in bitcoin, which fueled interested in markets, which.. etc.

alex_sf··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
If I can pay your company $5 to get a customer with an LTV of $10, that's a deal I will take all day. I am not being exploited.
alex_sf··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
Ok, everyone gets permanent housing. You've now just fired 2 million people, just in the immediate vicinity of the real estate and mortgage markets. The US homeless population is only a quarter of that, but, let's not actually think about numbers or anything.

Next will be the inevitable fallout of destroying ~45 trillion in wealth. The consequences of which, bluntly, I can't even really fathom at the moment.

I'm assuming you'll be planning to tax more to give the effected some sort of UBI? Please confirm and I'll explain how that will also blow up in your face.

> conceptually the solution is pretty simple

It is if you don't actually think about it. At all.

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
I like bitcoin. I use it. It's cryptobro nonsense to claim anything to do with it is in the 'top 100 non-literary' documents ever produced by humanity.
alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
That's the norm for an RFC. It rarely defines something new; it's a formalization of what's starting to occur to ensure interoperability.

And really, the RFC comment is somewhat tongue-in-cheek. The idea that the bitcoin whitepaper is some holy document, or even anywhere near the "top 100 non-literary" documents created by humans is profoundly stupid.

If someone genuinely believes that, I need to talk with them synchronously to try and figure out where, exactly, it ranks. Obviously ahead of the Rosetta Stone and the Treaty of Versailles, but does it beat out the Magna Carta?

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
791, 793, 4271, 8446, 2246, 821, and more, I'm sure.
alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
Wow, that's a great point. I hadn't even thought to approach it like that.
alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
> Satoshi combined them together in a novel form, for sure, but it’s still largely useless.
alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
Sure. Whitepaper was released in 2008. Genesis block was in 2009.

In 2007 we had Combating Double-Spending Using Cooperative P2P Systems[0]. Prior to both the whitepaper and the genesis block, we had Distributed Double Spending Prevention[1].

These are all particular subsets of distributed consensus problems, which have been studied in the context of CS for at least 30+ years (Consensus in the Presence of Partial Synchrony[2]).

[0] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4268195

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/0802.0832

[2] http://groups.csail.mit.edu/tds/papers/Lynch/jacm88.pdf

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
We had DHTs, we had blockchains, and double spending was solved at least 2 years before the bitcoin white paper.

Satoshi combined them together in a novel form, for sure, but it’s still largely useless.

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
Yeah, but, it's really not going to be. Like, there is absolutely no chance of that, ever.

Even in the very-unlikely world where some sort of decentralized cryptocurrency is used for anything other than scams and drugs, it's not going to be bitcoin, and blockchains existed for decades before bitcoin did.

alex_sf··on The Bitcoin whitepaper is hidden in every copy of macOS
Really though? I’m confident there are 100 RFCs alone that were more impactful.
alex_sf··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
> How much of that "real value" correlates with currently held value?

It might lag a bit, but almost exactly. That's the whole idea. Real household incomes in the US from 1950 to 2000 very nearly doubled, and purchasing power increased even more. The 'rich get richer' is irrelevant if everyone else is, too.

> By your metric Bell Labs should be worth more than any other company in existence.

The fact that they aren't means that no, they shouldn't be. It's the capitalism equivalent of "the guy with a great idea for an app". If you aren't actually delivering that value to people that need it, you aren't getting paid for it.

> Having loads of money isn't just about generating value. It's about extracting value.

Generating and extracting value are the same thing, ignoring the connotation.

If you create a device where, with one press of a big red button, you can cure cancer/world hunger/war/disease, but you never actually press that button? You haven't actually created any value. You haven't done anything.

alex_sf··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
Your evaluation of yourself and your position in the world is apparently solely informed by what Twitter tells you to think and the availability of gadgets around you. And clearly not informed by ever actually having visited China or India, or having formed any significant friendships with people there.

To think the 3rd most significant source of value in your life is cheap microcontrollers is.. wild.

Indoor plumbing? Refrigeration? A health department that ensures you aren't eating food fried in gutter oil?

You are taking these entirely for granted, because everyone has those, right? This is a great example of what privilege actually is.

Let's make this simpler for you.

Your original proposal is that, of course, the wealthy (read: anyone that makes more than you) have too much, the homeless have too little. So, like a child faced with this problem, you surmise we should take things from the wealthy and give them to the poor.

SF spends $100,000 per year, per homeless resident, on 'fixing homelessness'. Exactly how much more should they be spending, and why would that change anything?

alex_sf··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
You are literally reading and posting on an ad for Y Combinator. Everything that you use every day that you don't pay for is a direct result of ads.

Yes, they definitely have made your life better.

alex_sf··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
Again, this is your bubble talking. Look around you, and compare your life to any human 50 years ago, or anyone outside a first world country today. You are outrageously privileged entirely because of that very real value generated.
alex_sf··on Why TinyML is still so hard to get excited about
Well, it can. The definition of public vs. private cloud depends entirely on who is selling it to you.

It's not even a binary at many of the large providers: you can have dedicated servers ("my own server") in a public cloud at AWS, for example.

Personally, I keep it simple. If I can physically hit a box and no-one can get mad at me, then it's private and mine.

alex_sf··on Bob Lee, former CTO of Square, has died after being stabbed in San Francisco
"What if we took money from the people that have provably used it to create more value and instead gave it to drug addicts who shit on the sidewalk?

I know SF already spends 100k/yr per homeless resident, but we really need to push that up."

This whole line of thought is absurd, you're in a bubble.

alex_sf··on Why TinyML is still so hard to get excited about
I agree, but that's colo/on-prem. Not a private cloud, which is typically just some allocation of dedicated resources from a public cloud.
alex_sf··on Tesla ordered to pay more than $3M to former worker in racism suit
I still haven't heard a reason I'm supposed to be wrong that isn't based on the (incorrect) color of my skin.
alex_sf··on Why TinyML is still so hard to get excited about
'private' cloud.
alex_sf··on Tesla ordered to pay more than $3M to former worker in racism suit
I'm a member of a systemically oppressed group. Try again.
alex_sf··on Tesla ordered to pay more than $3M to former worker in racism suit
The inability to self-regulate your emotions in response to what other people say is a behavior that you're supposed to outgrow sometime in middle school.
alex_sf··on AI won't steal your job, people leveraging AI will
Again, the idea that you should rely on any single source for information is the issue. Nothing changes with ChatGPT other than the apparent expectation that it is infallible.
← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →