HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alexasmyths

819 karma · joined September 11, 2017

submissionscomments
alexasmyths··on Theranos Secures $100M in New Funding from Fortress Capital
There could very well be some functional aspects of the company's products.

It's not a consumer brand.

So ... if something 'works' and can be proven to work via regulatory approval, or validation from a big chain - there could be something there.

$100M rescue money to get a big piece of something may possibly be worth.

Lots of people have made a lot of money off of distressed assets.

alexasmyths··on Goldman Sachs Is Setting Up a Cryptocurrency Trading Desk
Sure - you can technically store wealth in currency. Just saying it's generally not ideal over the long haul, and that that is 'ok'.
alexasmyths··on At Vice, Cutting-Edge Media and Allegations of Old-School Sexual Harassment
"Disgusting -- they should feel ashamed."

This is VICE's standard operating procedure.

'Voice of a Generation'

alexasmyths··on The Californian Ideology (1995)
" The vast majority of millennials that did go to college got a degree in a traditionally "useful" field. "

? What ?

No. Most college degrees are minted in non-professional or degrees for which one will have very little direct ability to land a job [1].

There is no rule that says 66% of society should be able to spend four years getting an English degree.

Higher education is, and always will be expensive because it requires input from others.

[1] https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/05/09/310114739/what...

alexasmyths··on The Californian Ideology (1995)
"They saw their future prospects destroyed by a deregulated financial market, and now they're seeing the economic restoration that follows skipping them entirely and consolidating global wealth in the hands of a few while they struggle with basic necessities.""

I don't agree at all.

Millennial have more opportunity than any generation in history, by far.

They can chose what they want to do.

They can stay single, get married, be gay, be bi, whatever.

They are the first generation for whom international travel is accssible.

They are the first gen. where females can generally choose whatever career and it's not a big deal.

They are the first gen. to grow up with all the world's information at their fingertips.

They are the first gen. to not know full-scale war, mass poverty.

The 'financial system' was not 'destroyed' by anything - this is laughable. It was an accounting correction. The 1930's - this was an economic catastrophe. People were literally dying. The 2008 meltdown ... millenials were too young to be participants, it may have only affected a few jobs - and and it kept their housing costs down.

Aside from University costs (should we all be going to college?), and possibly housing bubble, they have it better materially than any generation - ever - and there's nothing to compain about.

"I find it kind of amazing that the myth of personal responsibility"

There is no 'myth' to personal responsibility, it's a core tenet of civilization.

If you finish school, learn a trade or get a relevant education, you'll get a job and live an ok life.

You are not entitled to a massive house, vacays all over the world and full on job security.

alexasmyths··on Sam Altman: ‘Too many’ Y Combinator companies raise money
"If you can convince an entire community to rearrange their finances"

If we all behaved conscientiously and responsibly, almost all of the world's problems would disappear.

alexasmyths··on Sam Altman: ‘Too many’ Y Combinator companies raise money
This micro-UBI thing is a bad experiment with good intentions.

UBI only works if it's fairly 'U'.

If you give UBI to 'one village' - that village will have tremendous leverage over the surrounding villages. Any rational application of commercial knowledge will - knowingly or unwittingly - drive competitors out of business, and that 'UBI village' could theoretically come to control a lot.

It only took a very small marginal advantage in transport costs for Oil companies to put others out of business and to create massive monopolies.

If you run a little 'sim village' experiment on that, you might find the UBI village owning all the regional real-estate over time and just extracting rent.

Another way of saying: a consistent, stable fixed income, even a not very big one, can be a powerful asset.

alexasmyths··on Goldman Sachs Is Setting Up a Cryptocurrency Trading Desk
"for me at least it is an opportunity to keep my own wealth. "

This is a really poor reason to use BTC.

A) BTC is supposed to be a currency - generally, a currency is not where you should be storing wealth. Currencies are not designed to be 'stores of value' - they are there to facilitate economic activity and transactions.

If you want to 'store wealth' - put it in real estate, bonds or equities. Commodities. Other currencies. A broad mix/basket of many of them.

B) There's no reason at all to think that BTC will necessarily be worth more/less than another currency. Why do you think BTC will 'always go up'? Much of the BTC hype may have already been had.

C) By simply keeping your currency in a trivial savings account, will roughly protect it from inflation.

In addition - most bank accounts are Federally insured - in case something goes wrong, you get up to $200K back etc..

D) Risk. BTC could go to zero tomorrow. Probably not - but possibly. It's extremely volatile = bad store of value.

People have this really odd view that 'currency = value' ... it's not ... currency is just a 'medium of exchange' - so you only need to hold it when you want to transact with someone else in a common/liquid way.

Over any reasonable length of time, currency is generally not a good place to hold value, and it's not designed for that.

If you have lot's of currency, trade it for something else, spread it out.

There will never, ever be a currency or any other magical currency store of value that will provide what you are kind of implying. Never. This is because the ratio of 'things people need' and the 'amount of currency they need to transact for' is constantly in flux, ergo, a 'fixed' currency constantly in flux relative to that.

alexasmyths··on Bitcoin Will Probably Never Be Embraced by the U.S. Government
No, it's a fact, and a very simple one.

The economy is very intertwined, with the banks at the centre.

If they start to go down - everything starts to do down.

It's as factual as saying if you choke and engine of oxygen, that it will stop burning.

It's simple cause and effect.

Yes - we understand very well the long-long term moral dilemma of 'too big to fail' - this is a well known issue.

And as I mentioned it was 'viciously unfair' - by the way - when the Fed absorbed those mortgages, they were saving millions of American homeowners as well.

A 'market correction' would have implied massive foreclosure across the US.

The 'winners' of the bailout were Banks AND those who owned homes. ALL American home values were propped up.

the 'losers' of the action were non-property owners.

'The more debt' people were carrying, specifically, 'mortgage debt' - the 'more free money' got from the Feds actions.

alexasmyths··on Bitcoin Will Probably Never Be Embraced by the U.S. Government
"practically giving one group of people money, under the guise of stimulating AN economy."

It wasn't under the guise of anything but saving the US economy from a wicked meltdown of epic proportions.

The dominos were set to all go down, the Fed kept a few of them up by rebalancing wealth.

As you point out - viciously unfair - but better in the long run.

FYI - a 'strict currency' is perhaps worse; crisis will happen. Strict currencies ties our boat to the dock, too much or too little water and we're all smoked. Moreover - outside of crises, the economy is dynamic - growing and shrinking, monetary policy helps manage that.

A strict currency is better than a poorly managed currency, but a well managed currency is better than a strict currency.

alexasmyths··on Bitcoin Will Probably Never Be Embraced by the U.S. Government
"Government does not need this ability,"

Extremely debatable, given the fact that every nation on planet earth basically uses monetary policy.

A rational policy whereby currency is exchanged for other assets at a rate using benchmarks is preferable to a strict currency.

A better economic policy might even allow almost anyone to exchange assets for currency. Then the market can decide how much is in circulation (though arguably that is already happening, just the levers are in the hands of a body, not a distributed group).

alexasmyths··on Bitcoin Will Probably Never Be Embraced by the U.S. Government
"Bitcoin doesn't lend itself to any of those Keynesian tricks."

A) Monetary policy is not 'Keynesian' - and it's a handy thing, which is why everyone does it, and nobody has a perfectly hard currency.

B) BTC is not a currency, it's perfect rigidity - ironically - is what attracted many speculators in the first place, killing it's usefulness as a currency.

alexasmyths··on Bitcoin Will Probably Never Be Embraced by the U.S. Government
"It’s an absolute threat to national sovereignty"

It's not a threat to anything but speculators bank accounts.

Nobody is using BTC as a currency.

alexasmyths··on Show HN: All Politicians in Switzerland
The EU is a national federation of 500M people from vastly different cultures - all of which already have their own governments.

Switzerland is barely bigger than Toronto - so they hard hardly comparable.

Switzerland is almost a 'city state' and at that level, direct democracy is much more achievable. Many municipalities in the west also have more direct ballots - that said - they don't cover the heavy-duty things like human rights.

It's also worth noting that more than 1/3 of the world's offshore wealth sits in Switzerland, largely due to privacy and detachment from regimes that can (could) not access information - and of course stability.

This is an incredibly historical advantage that yields enormous wealth for the nation as they manage incredible amounts of passive income. Buying and trading low risk assets.

It's a lot easier when you're rich, money papers over a lot of problems.

I am not a banker but I was almost recruited by a family office in Geneva a while back.

alexasmyths··on Show HN: All Politicians in Switzerland
" you're frankly talking out of your ass to put it politely "

Well I'm from Canada, and we rank HIGHER than Switzerland with 'full time politicians' - as do 100% of the nations that rank higher than Switzerland - as 'proven' by the very data you provided!

So to 'be polite' - maybe you're 'talking out your ass' x2 by providing research that repudiates your own logic, and while taking smack to others on a thread?

Consider 'reading your own research' and 'not calling others names'?

alexasmyths··on Show HN: All Politicians in Switzerland
"Remember it is a public service. It demands sacrifices of personal and professional time."

That isn't the issue - the issue is one of the practical amount of time and energy required to actually be a politician.

Full time or not full time - it's still 'public service'.

We don't have many 'part time brain surgeons' or 'part time police chiefs' ...

Politics is a profession like most others.

How on earth does the 'Minister of Finance' manage a national budget part time?

I can see a lot of fluffy ministers who don't do a lot - but most cabinet level positions (Parliamentary) and other senior legislators - there's no reason they can't or should not be full time.

"It works and provides less way for corruption and lobbying?"

+ You haven't said 'how it works' - how does a national minster of finance prepare and manage a national level budget on a 'few meetings a year'.

+ Less corruption? How? Given that 'everyone in politics also has a day job' - the lines of politics/business are considerably more blurry!

   - Is the 'Minister of Finance' allowed to work in banking?
   - How do politicians create taxation legislation when that could create significant conflicts of interest?
   - Canadian Minister of Finance - and others - have to put their assets in 'blind trust' to avoid corruption. Can't do that if everyone has a normal day job. It has to be considerably more difficult to manage issues of conflict of interest, surely.
There might possibly be an advantage to having part-time politicians - in the sense that full time one's often don't earn a lot of income, they have to be re-elected etc. so perhaps they are more vulnerable than those with normal jobs.
alexasmyths··on Show HN: All Politicians in Switzerland
"Even members of federal parliament only meet four times a year, and go back to their normal jobs in-between"

Ok, so then it's worse but in the opposite direction.

How on earth does anything get down when the Federal Elected Officials have 'day jobs' and 'only meet a few times a year'?

When do the make legislation?

How do they study initiatives, have working groups?

A mid sized company takes a lot of effort to lead ... how is the country led? Basically in the hands of the professional bureaucracy?

alexasmyths··on Show HN: All Politicians in Switzerland
That's quite a lot of 'politicians' for a country of 8 million people.

Some cantons have 200K people with 150 'politicians' ???

Bureaucrats - yes - many more, surely.

But Canada has ~350 at the Fed, and maybe ~300 provincial meaning maybe ~400 for about 900 people.

This seems like a lot of managers.

alexasmyths··on I don’t want to be the pink elephant in the room
"and we should be learning from what those cultures are doing that's different than us"

If people are being oppressed/suppressed, then surely we have some things to learn.

But cultures are often 'just different' and one may not be better than the other because more women or men do this or that.

We also have gendered roles in teaching, construction etc., nobody is screaming injustice.

alexasmyths··on German Kindergarten Campouts Test Helicopter Parents (2015)
Yes but those are different things.

Germans have very strong sense of behavioural norms that are communicated more subtly.

You don't get such a cohesive culture without fairly strict norms.

In America - you are probably referring to the 'PC rules' which are things that come at you as an adult, they are constantly changing, vague, locale-specific. And it's more of a new phenom.

Also - not sure if kindergartners should be using hammers either :). Maybe tiny ones?

alexasmyths··on Norway votes to decriminalise drugs and offer treatment instead of jail time
By the same graph, drug deaths are even lower in Romania, Bulgaria and Hungary than in Portugal.

And among the worst offenders are the liberal states of Sweden, Norway, Denmark etc..

So - having extreme anti-drug laws combined with nationalist/patriotic crazy authoritarian government is the policy to go with?

I'm kidding .. but you see that it's hard to look at that chart and make out more than Apples to Oranges.

It's also worth pondering how Eastern Europe has a tiny fraction of the problem that West seems to have, except for Estonia, which seems of the charts. It really is a tricky graph.

alexasmyths··on Luxembourg challenges EU order to recover tax from Amazon
It's perfectly reasonable for nation states to challenge the EU institutions, because the 'legitimacy' of EU institutions is not arbitrary - it depends on the support of member states!

If an EU institution is challenged by most members - it should absolutely be 'de-legitimized' and closed down!

This is the problem with the pro-Federalist psychology - added to the reality of 'bureaucracies that can only grow' - we 'assume' that a given EU entity should have supremacy, and not be 'undermined'? Why not? Who gave that EU organ power in the first place, and why does it have it?

I don't really support Lux's attempts to continue their low-tax status, but maybe they have a point.

As far as the Lux language - I think your argument is a stretch. Surely you know there are a zillion languages in the EU, each close to some other language. Having Luxembourgish 'recognized' doesn't necessarily carry them any favour or economic advantage, so I don't see how it's super relevant. I see what you are trying to get at - I just don't think that specific case is a good example.

alexasmyths··on Firefox is on a slippery slope
"I'm still not really sure what would lead you to believe that "they would even consider ceasing their advertising schemes if they had this additional income. "

For the same reason Mozilla exists today as 'kind of a non-profit' in the first place without tons of ads.

For the same reason that Wikipedia has no ads.

I'm not 'admonishing' anyone so much as pointing out we can't seem to grasp that nothing is going to happen for free.

The only path to 'ad free' is for someone to pay for it - and that's going to have to be users - or in the very rare case -a 'Big Corp' who sees the strategic value in it.

And yes - I do agree that 'most corps' would try to stick in ads.

Heck - even 'non-profits' like Mozilla - are sticking in ads!

But given what Mozilla is today, if they had the resources necessary, I suggest they would not be pushing ads. It's the last thing they want to do.

Finally - there are tons of services that people pay for that are not full of ads.

I don't get ads when I buy MP3s, and none of my paid apps have ads.

Do you think there are ads for t-shirts in my Salesforce app? Or SAP? Of course not.

Likely because the 'profit maximizing' option for Salesforce is to not put ads there in the first place.

So 'big corp' incentives can definitely align with user needs if things are right.

alexasmyths··on Luxembourg challenges EU order to recover tax from Amazon
"Pushing the envelope for their own gains at the cost of delegitimizing EU institutions"

Why does the EU exist, if not 'for the gain of the member states'?

Do you see the psychological paradox of Federalization?

A better argument is that if there is such contention, then maybe some of those EU level institutions should not exist.

And remember, the head of the commission is JC Junker, the very architect of Luxembourgs special tax schemes.

The job of the EU+Lux is to make the tax laws clear, not screw things up for business who by and large - just pay the taxes they are owed, but at the minimum possible rate.

alexasmyths··on Luxembourg challenges EU order to recover tax from Amazon
"I got one am very pleased to see the EU doing good work against tax havens. It's no wonder the British press hate the EU so much."

Oh please!

Jean-Claude Junker - the #1 man in the EU - was the architect of Luxembourg's tax-avoidance schemes.

Your statement very difficult to comprehend.

The UK is a regular taxed entity. It is NOT a haven really in any way.

Meanwhile: Luxembourg, Monaco, Lichenstein, Isle of Man and a few others are broadly tax havens, and Ireland is a huge haven in specific corporate circumstances.

Not only is the EU rife with tax havens - but they are also duplicitous in their application of the law.

The EU's grab of billions from Amazon, Google and Apple is theft of private property.

The EU is acting like Venzuela or a banana republic.

Re-interpreting the law retrocatively 25 years???

These 'big corps' will do everything possible within the law to lower their taxes - but they obey the law and pay their taxes.

If the EU, in 1980 had said 'here are the rules' - then big corps would comply.

But the EU deciding one day that 'oh, this tax law, which we have actively accepted for 25 years as meaning 'this' - now means 'that'. Retroactively.

This is what tin-pot dictators like Putin do when they wish to nationalize specific industries - and it's scary to any business person and bad for business.

The EU's job should be to make sure there is relative tax harmony, that the rules are clear, and then that people follow those rules.

Not to change them willy nilly and grab billions because of socialist populist sentiment.

If they want to change how things are - change the tax laws. that's it.

alexasmyths··on Firefox is on a slippery slope
I don't agree. This is entirely the choice of the team.

The idea that 'you are being sold' is not fair either.

You choose what to use, for how much, and the resulting product.

So if you want to pay $ a month AND have ads. Well, then do that. If not - don't.

If Mozilla wants to have an 'add free non-profit' they can do that.

But they can't because for whatever reasons - people won't pay.

Some people won't pay because they simply don't want to - and are willing to live with the alternative choice of 'having a sideload now and then'.

Other people use insufferable intellectualizations about all of it.

But mostly it's kind of greedy and irrational.

We get immense value out of web browsers. A $1 a month fee would enable Mozilla to forge ahead being the best browser, free for those who can't afford it - and ad free.

But we can't have that because we are not as intelligently organized as we need to be.

alexasmyths··on Firefox is on a slippery slope
"I am deeply disappointed in so much software lately, especially by the folks who once championed software freedom, privacy, and quality."

PAY. FOR. IT.

What can you expect from a group of people working for you for free, trying to scratch together their salaries from wherever they can.

The answer is not 'fork it' - because the existential question remains: who will develop the fork?

You?

Me?

A magical person who works without income?

More likely - someone who needs an income, and will have to find creative, weird ways like 'Mr Robot' to make it work.

A simple answer is 'pay for it'. A company / non-profit can still be committed to those things you mentioned.

alexasmyths··on Firefox is on a slippery slope
A lot of demands for someone who wants a few thousand people to work for us, for free.

I think if everyone who used MZ paid $2 a year, these issues might be resolved ...

alexasmyths··on Statistics, we have a problem
I was disagreeing with the use of the term 'predatory', I didn't suggest that what he did wasn't wrong.

Folks: someone touched someone on the thigh at a conference (inappropriately), and it's making international news? This is ridiculous.

alexasmyths··on Statistics, we have a problem
" it's predatory behavior "

Most people call it flirting (I mean the touching of a thigh).

Let's not make guys stupid romantic attempts out to be like rape.

If in a professional context, it's definitely inappropriate and must be called out.

← PreviousPage 2 of 21Next →