HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alexasmyths

819 karma · joined September 11, 2017

submissionscomments
alexasmyths··on WebAssembly, an executable format for the web
"WebAssembly makes the web more open because it puts nails in the coffin of Flash, Unity Player, and the like."

In practice, it does not.

It's too low level, and the APIs to access browser features are not available, so you have to go through seriously ugly APIs and just do it in JS anyhow.

So if you have to go to JS to do pretty much everything, why are we using WASM again?

Performance? Is performance the issue? Because if it is, isn't there maybe better ways of solving that problem?

It's certainly not for portability, we already have that.

To make 'web development available to C coders' ... Not sure that's it since they will invariably have to know web browsers anyhow ...

WASM is a great idea that won't gather steam until there are direct APIS. Which is on the roadmap I think.

I'd suggest just trying to build a simple WA, or even trying to make a simple app out of WA. Things look different then.

It's a nice dream to have, we're still a ways off.

alexasmyths··on Poverty in Japan
" The idea that a new culture cannot arise from the blending of extant ones is contradicted by countless examples"

I didn't imply that new cultures could not be created by the blending of others.

But it's glaringly obvious that this is mostly not what is happening in most places in the world.

What I am describing is easily demonstrated in various ways:

+ The most obvious is the lack of diversity in language, and the 'Anglicization' of many places in particular. For example, there were dozens of languages spoken across France: Nicoise was spoken in Nice, Monegasque in Monaco. This is gone now, standardized into French or Italian. The European B-school, INSEAD, used to require English/French/German - now just English.

+ Architecture: using ironically Monaco as an example, the newest area of Monaco is indistinguishable from a North American suburb, which is sublimely funny because most of the rest of Monaco has a very specific and interesting aesthetic.

+ The suburbs of Singapore, Toronto, parts of Europe - are are starting to resemble one another in ways unimaginable just a few years ago. You can be in a shopping mall in either or and it might take you a few minutes to know in which country you are in. Same stores. Nearly the same food. Same soft drinks. Same products. Similar holidays (!).

+ The globalization of brands and commercial products is a huge thing. Have you been to North Africa? They are now plastering Monoprix stores across there with the exact same merchandise that you find in France, and frankly, pretty similar to what you find here.

My father motorbkiked across North Africa in the 1970's and it was a very different place. Now - even the Tunisian youth dress effectively the same as the kids in Paris.

In storefronts across the Magrheb, Coka Cola is trying to market people away from regular Tunsian tea - this 'works' for country managers because a $2 can of coke adds more to the GDP than a 50 cent glass of tea - even of those are not good measures of intrinsic value to Tunisia.

Everyone - in every country - is now being conquered by a specific set of products band brands, representing an ever narrowing set of cultural ideals.

... and as for the UN objective - yes, it's nice that we care about people in the developed world. But

A) There is no long term economic reasoning behind the need for 'constantly more people'. This is pensioner/ponzi scheme economic problem. Pension shortfalls based on perpetual growth scenarios are obviously unsustainable ...

So ... B) Replacing one culture entirely with another is genocidal.

There is no way to replace 10's millions of Germans with people from various parts of the world, and for Germany to be German. The German culture would be extinct, and they will have bequeathed a functioning state to a nice bunch of newcomers - who might speak German - but are not otherwise German.

Were this to have happened over 100 or 200 years - possibly - this would be the evolution of culture. Sure - I get that. All cultures evolve and absorb over time.

But on the scale that the UN is proposing - this is not about 'poor people becoming Germans' - it's about 'poor people replacing Germans'. As Germans are literally replaced - well - they disappear forever. This is Orwellian.

The thing that differentiates 2017 from any period before is really one of scale. There has always been migration, there has always been movement - of course we all live in something akin to a 'compound culture'.

But that is history - what's happening now is happening 'light speed' and there is no time for cultural acclimatization. Toronto - the most diverse place on planet earth - is absolutely not developing it's own cuisine, or it's own language, or behavioural norms, musical styles. It would - over time - in a more regular scenario. But culture takes time to form, and we're moving way too fast.

Starbucks will not stop until they have 'total global saturation' - and neither will Amazon, Facebook, Coka Cola.

They will displace everything in their path, change behaviours ideas and norms to conform with their own profit motivations.

Government administrators everywhere are looking for GDP maximization and will focus on things that apparently 'increase efficiency' - like speaking English - but which mask an underlying existential cost of losing value due to lost cultural attributes - i.e. how much does the world 'lose' when people stop speaking Nicoise? And Monegasque? And various Aboriginal languages? And Slovak? It's hard to know, but it's something - and when you add it all up, it's a 'big thing'.

alexasmyths··on Poverty in Japan
Admiring one's own culture, or the culture of another, and recognizing the value of them, isn't a 'thin margin' away from xenophobia, I think.

FYI I live in an area where I'm a tiny ethnic minority English speaker among a sea of people who are of a different culture, including my GF and most of my friends. I've also lived around the world as an ex-pat/immigrant/minority.

I think global mass immigration will lead to a single (or maybe a small group of), globalized, commercial civilization(s) without culture, and we will lose most of what makes us great.

It's happening right now - and quickly.

We will eventually defeat climate change - but once we lose culture, it will never come back.

So that's a real thing.

There's no reason that a nation must continue to have 'more people' so I don't see why people must continue with the arbitrary demands of 'more people'.

The motivation for 'mass immigration' is mostly commercial and partly social - there are globalist forces who wish to move masses of poor people to rich countries.

This is not a crazy Breitbart conspiracy, here it is on the UN's web site:

http://www.un.org/esa/population/publications/migration/migr...

The title alone is Orwellian.

And just as there are xenophobes/bigots out there, there many who relish the thought of wiping out successful cultures for various reasons.

When we think about 'retirement' or even 'retiring early' often that's a little bit aspirational ... where would we want to live, if we had the choice? Well - people don't chose to live in the 'suburbs' near an 'IKEA' and a 'McDonald's' and a 'highway'. Generally, I think most people, from most backgrounds, chose to live in a place that has some kind of cultural context - either their own, or another, but certainly not the globalized Starbucks Suburbs.

Our 'global policies' right now are focused very much on the material, not the things that ultimately matter to us because they're a little more intangible.

alexasmyths··on A decentralised Universal Basic Income platform based on personal currencies
I don't for a second see how the issues we're trying to solve have anything to do with the technology or even social contract of currency.
alexasmyths··on Poverty in Japan
That's great.

I suggest it's probably not a huge factor for most people.

But there's a huge amount of information embedded into culture - ideas, mannerisms, forms of education, language, social strata - it goes far, far beyond 'language and cuisine'.

Large scale immigration wipes that out and does not replace it with a new culture, rather, a 'globalized' set of values - and a Starbucks on every corner.

So in the interests of having actual 'diversity' on planet earth, because as of today we are witnessing an 'extinction event' of culture, we might want to consider the impact of some of our policies.

Immigrants (and FYI I've been an immigrant at stages of my own life) are mostly just regular people, and so we don't want to play into the hands of xenophobes or 'racial purists' or whatever, but at the same time, we have to recognize the imperative of culture itself. Is all.

alexasmyths··on Poverty in Japan
"we also live under an economic system predicated on endless growth."

Yes, but it does not have to be this way.

It's just the way it's designed for now.

alexasmyths··on Poverty in Japan
Uhhmm - you visited basically anywhere outside the periphique in Paris?

I mean the entire ring around Paris is a ghetto - as grungy as any American city.

Murder rates are not as bad - but petty crime and other forms of violence are just as bad.

The level of social malaise due to lack of integration of newcomers from the Maghreb and M/E is growing quite quickly.

And Marseille? Lyon? Even worse.

So yes - the American 'hardcore ghettos' are the worst, but beyond that I don't think Europe is that higher.

And the US has a considerably larger middle/middle-upper class of aspirants, which is a difficult proposition for most Europeans.

alexasmyths··on Poverty in Japan
"Nobody has that figured out. For now the answer for developed countries involves allowing in immigrants to make up for the deaths."

No - this is false.

There's nothing to 'figure out'.

We simply don't need as many people.

We'll have to deal with it a some point in the future, but there is no imperative for America to keep adding more people willy nilly.

The 'we must add bodies' ideal is just an extension of national corporatism.

alexasmyths··on Poverty in Japan
"Do people really romanticize it, outside of certain delusional anime fans?"

Are you kidding?

Extremely low crime rates?

Exceptional innovation, powerhouse industry, dozens of cultural imperatives, engineering marvels?

It's one of the most civilized places in the world. Not easy.

"refusal to open up or otherwise encourage mass immigration"

And why would Japan turning into Brazil or America be a good thing?

Why do so many people think that it's a cultural imperative to wipe out one's culture and join the globalized morass of cultureless consumers, killing themselves over the latest Nike's and deriving their identity via their smartphone brand of choice? Constantly warring over what historic culture owns what neighbourhood? What constitutes progress? No thanks.

What you might consider to be 'authoritarian' - they might consider to be 'social cohesion'. Whereas you want to 'do whatever you want' they might consider 'one's responsibility towards society' as a more important social function.

And FYI they don't have 'social issues' out the wazoo - the opposite.

Mental health - it's an issue that is still considered taboo, moreover, with an aging population, amply problematic, no place is perfect.

alexasmyths··on Apple ‘On Schedule’ to Terminate Music Downloads by 2019
headphone jacks give a pretty crisp signal :)
alexasmyths··on Show HN: Airmash – Multiplayer Missile Warfare HTML5 Game
Bravo! Cute game. So many things done well.
alexasmyths··on Cards Against Humanity Redistributes Your Wealth
Only about 1/2 of Americans at any given time work (very roughly - think kids, elderly etc.) so most Americans don't pay tax is technically kind of correct, but not very meaningful at all in any discussion.
alexasmyths··on Cards Against Humanity Redistributes Your Wealth
Wealth concentration is a problem but poor countries are not poor because some rich Westerners 'have a lot of power'.

Nice sentiment though, and that counts for something.

alexasmyths··on Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorders, research suggests
Ha ha ha. Ya. Glancing over. Irony :)
alexasmyths··on Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorders, research suggests
"but if you can’t reasonably quantify it based on anything empirical,"

Simply the writing quality, grammar and sentence structure of the comments on HN would easily be enough to prove that HN readers (well, commenters) are above average.

I spend enough time glazing over headlines, stories and comments from other sites out of casual interest and I'll bet any amount of money this is true.

alexasmyths··on Apple is close to acquiring Shazam, sources say
"What is the success metric for these playlist companies?"

Extremely difficult to determine.

And the 'taste-makers' in music are very hard to find, though they should easily have access to the latest/hippest tracks.

Design is one of the hardest things for a reason.

If fashion truly were a commodity H&M etc. simply would not exist.

alexasmyths··on The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of the Market
I meant to say that a managed currency does not imply inflation, as the commenter was saying.

I'm saying a managed currency can be whatever you want it to be. I agree targeting deflation would be bad.

Hint: deflation is kind of bad, and we have massive deflation with BTC :)

alexasmyths··on The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of the Market
What he means to say is that the currency goes up, prices go down.

So if a currency goes up in value, that's actually economic 'deflation', because the prices of goods go down.

Now - I don't agree with any of the commenters arguments at all, but the terms 'inflationary' and 'deflationary' are used in that context.

There are some that argue the inflation and deflation are not a function of the price of goods - rather - simply the amount of money in circulation and that's it. I think this is the Austrian position.

alexasmyths··on The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of the Market
"Since taxes are not voluntary, this creates built-in demand for the fiat money."

Not really.

The real underlying demand for a currency comes from the advantage that everyone gets by using the same currency in a common market.

The 'required for tax' purposes is a side-show.

Does anyone with any financial background appreciate that most businesses in the US want to use a single currency for their US transactions, and definitely not a 'grab bag' various currencies?

Nobody wants that. Nobody.

Also, the requirement to 'pay taxes' in a common currency is not coercive.

As long as there is liquidity in currency, then you can exchange whatever asset you want for USD and pay your taxes then.

Libertarians are still free to use whatever they want in their business dealings. Of course, we all use USD because it's pragmatic and useful.

"Capital controls are an artificial construct of the state"

Western nations do not really have 'capital controls' other than for the purposes of taxation and fraud. And sure, you could say 'taxation' is an 'construct of the state' but it's certainly not 'arbitrary'.

"When the money supply of your currency is not constrained (by gold, or otherwise), then it inevitably inflates, often unpredictably and uncontrollably."

Totally false. Inflation is a target by most central banks. They can make it positive or negative, generally, and target specifically 2% for certain reasons. You can argue against the 2% if you want, but not that managed currencies are inherently 'one thing or another'. They are whatever they are designed to do.

By having a 'perfectly hard currency' - you forgo the risk of having some crazy person doing monetary policy - but worse - you lose the possibility for having monetary policy altogether. How could you possibly not mention this as the most obvious drawback to a strict currency (i.e. no monetary policy)?

Monetary policy is a very powerful instrument for helping the economy along. Without it, it would be impossible to ensure enough liquidity as the market expands. Also, the economy would not be resilient to 'shock' events.

The reason zero economies on planet earth used a fixed-currency regime is because it does not work.

"The libertarian position on wealth inequality is that as long as the distribution of wealth was determined voluntarily"

This position is false, as capitalism itself is game of gaining leverage towards monopoly. Without some degree of redistributive taxation, 90% of the US economy would be in the hands of a small group of people. (And P.S. I'm no communist)

"Bitcoin is such a system: all participation in Bitcoin has been voluntary. "

Again, false.

Bitcoin is not a currency. If anything, BTC has proven how ridiculously bad this 'crypto-currency' idea has been as a currency. By it's very own 'relatively strict' status, it has increased it's value ('deflationary' in your terminology) - and has become useless as a currency.

-----> If we were using Bitcoin as a currency, the economy would be tanking due to a deflationary death-spiral <-----

EDIT: by 'death spiral' I'm referring to a common economic idea. As prices of goods go down, investors tend to hoard cash rather than invest it, as holding currency might be a better investment strategy than spending. Without investment, other parts of the economy slow, furthering the impetus to holding cash. The 'mass deflation' we've seen in BTC is equally as destructive as 'mass inflation' we would see from some really poorly managed gong-show currency.

Put another way: yes, you might like it if your 'new tennis shoes' were 1/2 price next week, and 1/2 that price the week after - hey - cheap tennis shoes! But think about it: has the economy just magically been 100% more productive each week? No. Of course not. So - what's happening is a monetary game that will soon hit your paycheque (i.e. your boss can pay you 1/2 your salary each week because that's your real market value). But worse - because of this drop in prices, your boss will be less likely to expand because his cost of capital equations show him it's smarter to hold the cash.

But it's all moot: Bitcoin is not a currency. It could be used as a currency, but it's not. It's just a purely speculative thing that's going on. People trading numbers for money 'because'. There's no rhyme or reason. There is no 'big government vs. small government' ideology here. There is no 'libertarian' behind BTC currency. It's just a meme with money that's interesting to watch.

alexasmyths··on Jailed for a Text: China’s Censors Are Spying on Mobile Chat Groups
" so we self censor."

I don't.

I mean - you'd have to literally indicate you wanted to cause harm to a government official to get in trouble with the US Feds - and it's not unreasonable they do come after you as that is rightly a crime.

But you can say almost anything you want against Trump or the US Government otherwise, and nobody will care.

alexasmyths··on Jailed for a Text: China’s Censors Are Spying on Mobile Chat Groups
The CIA, FBI, DEA etc are not 'censors' either.

They are law enforcement.

Censorship of US citizens for the purposes of state propaganda is a whole other different thing than anything the CIA/FBI/DEA does. And FYI the CIA may be proactively involved involved in propaganda, like helping some Hollywood movies ... but they are not running around tell you not to say bad things about Trump on Facebook, is my point.

alexasmyths··on Jailed for a Text: China’s Censors Are Spying on Mobile Chat Groups
The NSA is watching, but they are not censors.
alexasmyths··on Japan eyes startup visa program
I can see why these things make sense to legislators and policymakers - but in all pragmatic reality, I'm weary of it actually working.

1) Most startups fail. What happens then? What is the path? Many folks will come from 2cnd-tier economic nations, and don't want to go back. It gets complicated.

2) Investment requirements are easily provided for by people who want to 'buy citizenship' and it's easy enough to hire a few friends/family members, park their money in an account, and pull it out when they are done. The 'businessperson' visa was widely used as a backdoor to a passport in Canada.

It might make sense to make the visa commensurate on $X in a round A or something, but then it all gets very complicated.

It might be just better to have a smart immigration policy to retain top talent across the board in the first place.

It's really not 'founders' that make the business - it's 'the founders and everyone else'.

alexasmyths··on Silicon Valley Is Sneaking Models into This Year’s Holiday Parties
Not only does it not commodify women, you're assumption that men will treat them as objects is possibly bigoted.

Men having polite conversations with women is 'wrong' only in a dystopian future.

I personally think it's a little ridiculous and would not want to attend, nor would I put together a party like that, but it's a matter of social taste, not morality.

alexasmyths··on Silicon Valley Is Sneaking Models into This Year’s Holiday Parties
"but for the misogynistic dynamic"

Male appreciation of female company is utterly and absolutely in not 'misogynistic'.

Not only that - it's also very normal, and frankly good.

If people are treated as sexual objects, then you can complain.

alexasmyths··on Silicon Valley Is Sneaking Models into This Year’s Holiday Parties
" The whole point is to celebrate with the employees and their families and recognize the hard work everyone has put in over the year. "

Not really, that's more a 'New Years' thing.

Christmas 'party' is just really a Christmas season gathering.

It really isn't even a party.

Imagine 100 years ago, your grandad owns a printing press in town. December 20th he brings in Egg Nog, a cake, everyone stops working. Maybe a local musician sings a few songs. Maybe some people drink a little too much.

Or maybe he pays for a nice dinner at the local restaurant and people show up and 'give thanks'. Light a candle.

That's it.

We are so 'de-culturalized' in North America we don't even know how to do something normal.

Of course a 'holiday party' could technically be anything people want it to be, but there's no reason to go to this level.

When in doubt: just go out for dinner. :)

alexasmyths··on Silicon Valley Is Sneaking Models into This Year’s Holiday Parties
This is fine. (I mean gender issues aside).

Because they are on 'roller skates' they are differentiated, and basically identifiable as 'hosts/hostesses'.

There's nothing wrong with hiring hosts for a party.

It's when they are mixed-in as guests it's cheezball.

alexasmyths··on Coinbase down for maintenance
"How much money needed to come into the bitcoin market for it bump from 15k to 19k?"

Almost none.

If there are just a few transactions at a price, well, we assume that is the worth of all bitcoins in existence.

Which is a crazy assumption, but hey.

alexasmyths··on IBM scientists demonstrate 10x faster large-scale machine learning using GPUs
To be fair - most innovation boils down to this kind of incremental stuff. 99% of 'tech' is an amalgamation of more basic ideas, not 'magic leap' kind of innovation.

I mean, we all love the magic, but I think we're getting spoiled as of late with all the magic AI/Deep Learning stuff coming out.

alexasmyths··on Steam is no longer supporting Bitcoin
Dollars are created and exchanged for TBills (and since 2007 a lot of real estate) on the free market by the Fed.

So TBills are in fact a kind of 'faith in the governments ability to pay' - but that is a measurable, tangible, verifiable thing.

Euros are generally backed by real estate and other 'high quality' assets.

Most good national currencies are managed that way.

So - the central banks basically control how 'one asset (i.e. real estate) is turned int currency' back and forth, keeping enough currency going so as to allow for economic expansion, and to keep inflation at about 2% and unemployment in check.

At least in theory.

← PreviousPage 4 of 21Next →