HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alexey-salmin

2,758 karma · joined February 28, 2023

submissionscomments
alexey-salmin··on "Roadrunner": a bipedal, wheeled robot for multi-modal locomotion [video]
Not until these robots learn to self-assemble from a bag of rice like humans do
alexey-salmin··on Lost Soviet Moon Lander May Have Been Found
I hope for the same, but it's based on the assumption that space exploration will be human-driven. Unfortunately it's possible that it will be robot-driven instead and museums will stay on earth.
alexey-salmin··on How often do full-body MRIs find cancer?
Yes, IF we know the numbers, that's the whole problem. Unprompted full-body MRI scans turn up a completely new probability distribution. We CAN'T know the numbers as of today, it takes decades of controlled studies to get them. (Which is exactly what doctors advocate for)

Even for something as studied as colon cancer it's still controversial whether mass colonoscopies are better than occult blood tests. US sticks to the former, Europe to latter. US have higher rates of polyp removal, higher rates of cancer detection, higher rates of surgeries and ... higher mortality rates than EU. Why this happens is being studied today, there are some early results. What is absolutely clear though is that higher detection rates don't automatically lead to better outcomes, it can easily be the opposite.

Or take something as simple as sunscreen. It's well-known that sun exposure for light-skinned people can cause cancer and sunscreen is advised. A few multi-decade studies have shown that while it indeed eradicates the skin cancer it also shortens the life expectancy by a few years.

Primum non nocere, doctors and scientists are unsure whether sunscreen should be applied at scale and you effectively call for mass biopsies and surgeries.

alexey-salmin··on How often do full-body MRIs find cancer?
Whether treatment is net harmful or not depends on the level of the risk with no treatment. If you apply treatment with 15% chance of severe side effects to a tumor that will kill the patient with 50% chance in the next five years, of course it's net positive. If you apply it to a first-stage cancer that has 10% chance of progressing to the second stage, the very same treatment will be net harmful.

So no, most cancer treatments aren't net harmful now, but they likely will be in a world where your programme is implemented. Even something as "simple" as biopsy has mortality rates far from zero. Applying it at scale may not have the effect you expect. And surgeries and chemo are much worse.

alexey-salmin··on How often do full-body MRIs find cancer?
No, the detector doesn't fix that, that problem is not treating people without cancer. The problem is treating people with cancer that won't kill or harm them during their lifetime. In this case even a low risk treatment becomes harmful, let alone cancer treatments.
alexey-salmin··on How often do full-body MRIs find cancer?
> With my change: 95% of people who are shown scans have cancer and are treated earlier. 5% of people do not have cancer and get CT scans. 0.5% of people get useless biopsies Without my change: many of those 95% die, the 0.5% do not get useless biopsies

You assume that treating cancer automatically improves the outcome. Treating cancer often kills you, so treating a non-fatal tumor can easily be a bad decision. And a lot of the tumors found by agressive scans are like that, but we don't know yet how much exactly and how to tell one from the other. It's a new question that requires decades-long observations to answer.

> This is wrong. If you had a 100% accurate cancer detector, fewer people would die of cancer with no downside

You're saying it as if detection somehow cures cancer, it doesn't.

alexey-salmin··on How often do full-body MRIs find cancer?
There's a theory that the first-stage cancer is way more common than we think, it's just doesn't develop further most of the time, cause no symptoms and remains undiagnosed throughout the lifetime.

There's some support for this view because agressive screening for thyroid and prostate cancers increases the number of surgeries a lot but doesn't seem affect the mortality rates.

Risks from a surgery are non-negligible, if you perform it to treat a low-risk condition it may be a net loss in the end.

So you're technically right about the "early-detecting" part, but the "much easier to treat" step is problematic because it's unclear what a net-positive treatment looks like for low-risk cases. Probably it comes down to yearly monitoring of whatever was detected, not the actual treatment.

alexey-salmin··on Mathematicians disagree on the essential structure of the complex numbers (2024)
Not op, but the number of cards doesn't matter. Only one shuffle can exist at a time, the "number of shuffles" is not a number of natural objects but rather a cardinality of a set. And as we know sets and cardinalities open the gates of hell.

This doesn't mean it's not a "relevant thing to talk about". It just means that these mathematical constructs while useful don't maintain a direct connection to reality, kind of like complex numbers.

alexey-salmin··on Mathematicians disagree on the essential structure of the complex numbers (2024)
Natural numbers are "natural" enough but N as the "set of all natural numbers" not so much. It only takes N to build the Hilbert's hotel. Uncountable set of all subsets of N is probably even worse.

All that, of course, doesn't make N bad or useless. It just shows that mathematical objects don't have to follow the laws or intuition of the real world to be useful in the real world.

alexey-salmin··on Mathematicians disagree on the essential structure of the complex numbers (2024)
Idk, to me it feels much much better than just picking one root when defining the inverse function.

This desire to absolutely pick one when from the purely mathematical perspective they're all equal is both ugly and harmful (as in complicates things down the line).

alexey-salmin··on Mathematicians disagree on the essential structure of the complex numbers (2024)
The good news is that Q is not really entitled to a closure either.
alexey-salmin··on Mathematicians disagree on the essential structure of the complex numbers (2024)
There are ways to build C that result in:

1) Exactly one C

2) Exactly two isomorphic Cs

3) Infinitely many isomorphic Cs

It's not really the question of whether i and -i are the same or not. It's the question of whether this question arises at all and in which form.

alexey-salmin··on Mathematicians disagree on the essential structure of the complex numbers (2024)
I have MS in math and came to a conclusion that C is not any more "imaginary" than R. Both are convenient abstractions, neither is particularly "natural".
alexey-salmin··on France Aiming to Replace Zoom, Google Meet, Microsoft Teams, etc.
Canada is subject to the Monroe doctrine. Forge a link too close and there will be intervention of sorts.
alexey-salmin··on What came first: the CNAME or the A record?
The only reasonable interpretation of "possibly prefaced" is that the CNAMEs either come first or not at all (hence "possibly"). Nowhere the RFC suggests that they may come in the middle.

Something is broken in Cloudflare since a couple of years. It takes a very specific engineering culture to run the internet and it's just not there anymore.

alexey-salmin··on Iran's internet shutdown is chillingly precise and may last some time
Surely governments will not see any issues with this project whatsoever.

Though in US I think you can try publishing the code and blueprints as a book and claim the First Amendment, following the PGP story. May or may not work.

alexey-salmin··on List of domains censored by German ISPs
Do you mean that the law is OK, just the prosecution somehow goes too far? Or the law itself allowing prosecution of insults is the problem?
alexey-salmin··on List of domains censored by German ISPs
In my reading he meant the author of the parent comment specifically, hence "German supports" and not "Germans support". So not a generalization.
alexey-salmin··on List of domains censored by German ISPs
What's you position on criminal prosecution and house searches for insults of politicians?

https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2025/08/05/german-politic...

> The offence means that in certain cases, criticism of the government that constitutes insult or defamation against political figures is subject to criminal prosecution in Germany.

> Specifically, Section 188 was amended by law, adding "insult" to the offence in addition to "defamation" and "slander". The offence was also extended to include local politicians.

> Robert Habeck of the Greens, for example, filed 805 criminal complaints. The Greens' Annalena Baerbock filed 513, Marco Buschmann of the FDP 26, and Boris Pistorius of the SPD 10, among others.

> Politicians from other parties such as the CDU and AfD have also filed criminal complaints against insults from citizens.

> This includes AfD leader Alice Weidel, who has filed hundreds of complaints for insults online and has also made use of Section 188, even though her party is in favour of abolishing it.

> CDU leader Friedrich Merz, before he became chancellor, had also filed several criminal complaints for insulting behaviour, which in some cases led to house searches.

alexey-salmin··on You’re not burnt out, you’re existentially starving
> have kids because they otherwise lack meaning

That's how life on earth worked for 3 billion years. I think that assuming humans are somehow above that is unwise. We're not.

alexey-salmin··on FTX insider Caroline Ellison has been moved out of prison
I know, it's not meant to be a deep observation. Rather the "some start drinking at 21 while others already quit by then" kind of situation.
alexey-salmin··on FTX insider Caroline Ellison has been moved out of prison
It comes from experience, I know quite a few people who got their first job after 30. You study, you take the gap year, you study some more.
alexey-salmin··on He set out to walk around the world. After 27 years, his quest is nearly over
Biking is faster, you can arrange for all visas for 6 months in advance but not for years. Even for 6 months to have them all approved with no gaps requires either a lot of luck or a very strong passport or both.
alexey-salmin··on Adenosine on the common path of rapid antidepressant action: The coffee paradox
That's just how life feels without caffeine, not a withdrawal effect.
alexey-salmin··on Japanese four-cylinder engine is so reliable still in production after 25 years
Toyota 5A was in production 1987–2006, and IIRC was licensed to Chinese manufacturers afterwards. The A series as a whole lasted 1978–2006. Less modern than Honda K, but these were lovely engines. They just won't fail as long as you replace parts on time.
alexey-salmin··on A surprise with how '#!' handles its program argument in practice
> This is of course in stark contrast to dynamic linking, which is performed by a userspace program instead of the kernel

I'm not sure what the contrast is. In both cases the interpreter lives in userspace, in both cases kernel finds it via the path hardcoded in the file: shebang for text, .interp for ELF

alexey-salmin··on Microsoft-backed Veir is bringing superconductors to data centers
The very first sentence is confusing. "Power demands of data centers have grown from tens to 200 kilowatts in just a few years". I assume they're talking a single rack here, not "power demand of data centers".
alexey-salmin··on When Soviet-made cars roamed Singapore roads
Not within the socialist system, there was absolute zero incentive to do a quality job. Sometimes there were incentives to do more on the quantity (see "udarnik") with moderate success but these were detrimental to the quality.
alexey-salmin··on When Soviet-made cars roamed Singapore roads
It still makes me sad that Lada Niva is such a missed opportunity, basically world's first SUV with 4wd, unibody and coil spring independent suspension. The 2-door version looks good even.

Could have been a huge success if not for the quality and compromises in the engine/transmission.

alexey-salmin··on Startups are pushing the boundaries of reproductive genetics
Dogs are pretty f*ed up, I'm not sure it's a good example.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →