HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alialkhatib

175 karma · joined March 14, 2012

computer scientist; previously anthropologist

https://ali-alkhatib.com

submissionscomments
alialkhatib··on Wikipedia needs an IDE, not a WYSIWYG editor
Most non-English versions of Wikipedia have dramatically less content than the English language version, and even the more common language versions like Spanish seem to be significantly less accurate. Make whatever claims you want about what role we should play in English hegemony (blah blah blah), but that's one feature Wikipedia affords where the job is far from done.
alialkhatib··on Wikipedia needs an IDE, not a WYSIWYG editor
I was also somewhat skeptical of the author's claim that the barrier to entry for Wikipedia editors was the editor itself. I've read a few papers concluding that Wikipedia contributions are declining because of the community pushing out people who don't understand the many rules that have been developed[1], or in other cases because editors have gotten into turf wars over articles they feel some sense of ownership over[2]. Meanwhile, I haven't read anything concluding that the editing environment was a strong deterrent (although I haven't been looking, so I could be willfully blind).

Edit: more articles identifying interpersonal friction as the leading factor deterring would-be editors [3,4]. At this point I'm suspicious of the author's due diligence in studying the problem, making the proposed solution more dubious.

[1] Suh, Bongwon, et al. "The singularity is not near: slowing growth of Wikipedia." Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium on Wikis and Open Collaboration. ACM, 2009.

[2] Thom-Santelli, Jennifer, Dan R. Cosley, and Geri Gay. "What's mine is mine: territoriality in collaborative authoring." Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems. ACM, 2009.

[3] Kittur, Aniket, and Robert E. Kraut. "Harnessing the wisdom of crowds in wikipedia: quality through coordination." Proceedings of the 2008 ACM conference on Computer supported cooperative work. ACM, 2008.

[4] Halfaker, Aaron, Aniket Kittur, and John Riedl. "Don't bite the newbies: how reverts affect the quantity and quality of Wikipedia work." Proceedings of the 7th international symposium on wikis and open collaboration. ACM, 2011.

alialkhatib··on How would you improve BART?
I read somewhere that getting it to go through the Peninsula (with affluent homeowners fighting such construction) would be a non-starter. I don't recall how Caltrain factored in (it may be a little quieter but it's still certainly pretty loud and runs right through the Peninsula), but I suspect this is why they didn't bother to include that or other options extending service toward the South Bay.
alialkhatib··on Best Papers vs. Top Cited Papers in Computer Science
That's an interesting idea. For what it's worth, I would cite the publication which prompted the idea behind my approach, so I don't think this is the answer to your question.

That being said, I think you're onto something. I was recently involved in a project leading to a paper for a conference, and while I don't know whether it'll get accepted (meaning I don't know if it's even representative of the kinds of papers conferences want to see), I notice in hindsight that we had only a few citations that really informed a totally novel methodological approach we used. By contrast, we cited a ton of research in the domain area we studied.

So my takeaway is that it's hard to bring in dozens of papers to inform one's methods necessarily because methods (like a protocol) require one somewhat coherent narrative. Integrating the collective body of knowledge about a topic (like, oh let's say.. online labor markets) is a lot easier, making "rapid-fire" citations in that context more likely.

I'd like to see a seasoned researcher (or at least someone with the experience of a few publications) weigh in on this though.

alialkhatib··on How to see your iOS8 health data
The more I look at these measures, the more I wonder whether Apple has a plan for all of this or if they're just throwing spaghetti on the wall and seeing what sticks. Some of these seem like there's tie-in (body measurements can be assessed through a Withings scale, sleep can be assessed through a Jawbone UP or similar device, and the "Me" section is mostly static), but does Apple have any plan to get people to track their Molybdenum intake on a regular basis? Or their BAC? Or their body temperature?

I'm not saying they need to, but in the past it has seemed like when Apple provided an affordance, they also had a clear use case. If nothing else, you could fully use the device/service in the way they describe, and that would sufficiently justify its adoption for many. With Health, I'm not seeing that. I wonder if this will threaten the overall adoption of Health, which in general seems like not a terrible idea - anything that gets people thinking more about their activity and diet seems like a good thing.

One could argue that their solution is to leave it to third party devices and integration. Apple doesn't need to make a scale to help you track your weight (Withings has already done it, as I'm sure others have), nor does it want to touch the quagmire that is nutrition by claiming to measure the nutritional value of any food. Let some food-related startup do that dirty work, as long as Apple provides some interface for the measurement to end up in this data silo.

This argument seems weaker to me than the argument seemed when Apple first started accepting apps for the iPhone (later iOS). Health currently leaves huge swaths of its UI barren for lack of data, and I'm not sure that hardware developers can swarm to fill in those gaps the way software developers could with the platform.

Maybe I missed the part of their talk where they made it obvious how they envisioned Health (and HealthKit) to be used in a fuller way; if that's the case, I'd appreciate a pointer.

alialkhatib··on Namecheap for Students: free domain bundle
I'm not seeing anything indicating that it's limited. You might be referencing the list of universities at the bottom of the page, but my impression is that that's just a "leaderboard" representing which universities have claimed the most domains.

Can you point to/quote the limitations?

alialkhatib··on Data Mining Reveals How Social Coding Succeeds and Fails
This is really neat. It's a shame that they didn't take a look at this through an anthropological lens (even in their conclusion), because "Dunbar's number" [0] would have given some perspective on the limits of small groups, where a community of 30-50 seems to be a well-established grouping size (and ~100-250 seems to be the limit for a "small" group).

For that matter, this seems relevant to the anthro theory that communities fall into one of four types of organization (families/bands, tribes/clans, chiefdoms, and states) [1]. In this context, it looks like the authors have identified the emergence of these groupings of organization, especially through their metric of "efficiency" and how bands and tribes differ.

0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar's_number

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociopolitical_typology

alialkhatib··on Arnold Schwarzenegger based programming language
As seen 2, 2.5, and (more famously) 6 months ago:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7920116

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7897173

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7299658

alialkhatib··on Tech's Fiercest Rivalry: Uber vs. Lyft
(like caycep said,) from everything I've read, the venom spat back and forth between Microsoft and Apple sounds a lot fiercer than this. This is probably the fiercest rivalry in recent history, and I may be remembering history with more exaggerated brushstrokes, but I don't think this is the fiercest.

I will grant that the "battle lines" seem to be drawn a lot less clearly now than they were back then. Again, that might just be the effect of remembering history after the "fog of war" has settled.

alialkhatib··on Dress codes: Suitable disruption
I'm pretty sure you can find a suit for $40 and a hoodie for $200. Put the hoodie on a pedestal as the symbol of "hacker cred" and you'll inevitably see hoodies for far more than even that as designers capitalize on founders with more money than sense.
alialkhatib··on Macintel: The End Is Nigh
What you're describing (a mobile device that docks into a workstation environment and powers the KVM) sounds like the dream mobile product designers have been having for well over a decade. I remember Canonical recently coming up with a concept of a phone that would do this (see: Ubuntu Edge[0]). That being said, the roadmap implied by iOS 8 and Yosemite strongly suggests that they're just going to bridge these gaps over the Internet. Google is also pretty clearly going in this direction, and given the ubiquity of Internet access (especially compared to available KVM terminals), I think this is the direction we're all going to go in.

0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubuntu_Edge

alialkhatib··on High Res PSD's layered mobile device photos
I'm not sure what the budget for most mobile app startups is, so I'm not sure if it'd be more reasonable for a startup to find some friend with a DSLR to take some shots for lunch or coffee (essentially getting something 80% as good as these, without the extra features of layers etc for approximately 10% of your asking rate). These freebies certainly look like they're high quality, though, and that's a start.

Something that strikes me as way more important is that transforming a screenshot so that it looks natural in the hand of the model is probably the most valuable thing you can offer here. This means giving it some perspective (skew, rotate, etc...), right? Automating that for each image by providing a macro or something would really make these images more valuable in my opinion. Even text instruction rather than a script would be useful.

I don't have Photoshop, and maybe Pixelmator is ignoring scripts such as these since it doesn't understand them, so I may be giving you advice you already know. If not, consider figuring out a way to package that, because that'd certainly make these images more useful (perhaps even worth more than $70, although I really have no context for stock photo value).

alialkhatib··on Ten things people want to know about Python – Python Wiki
I'm not sure why this is here. I don't see any recent substantive changes on the RecentChanges page[0], and there's nothing on the page really indicating why this is HN-worthy. Unless this is supposed to be illustrative of questions in desperate need of revisions...

0: https://wiki.python.org/moin/RecentChanges

alialkhatib··on Show HN: CommitCal – View your commit history in calendar
This is a pretty neat idea. I tend to think of and use my calendar to look forward, but every view I have of my calendar shows me some past content. Why not put some useful information there? I considered what my calendar would look like if I threw all of my emails at it but I figured it would get overwhelming unless I filtered them somehow. Maybe the Gmail API will make an email version of your project more feasible.

Anyway, I digress. Some notes:

- I'm only seeing public commits; I realize you don't necessarily want to complicate things with authentication, but I have practically nothing going on publicly. I'd probably rather see what I'm actually up to rather than what the world sees (unless this is supposed to be a tool for me to watch other people's commits, in which case I guess public activity makes sense).

- I might prefer to see activity of repositories in which I'm working rather than individual activity. This is more complicated, but it'd be more worthwhile for me to see if someone else commits something (or many somethings) in the recent past to a project that I'm working on. It would especially give me a reminder that I need to pull in the morning and see what's new.

There are a few approaches to this, and depending on Github's API one might be easier than the other, but I imagine they'd all skin the cat at the end of the day.

Feel free to take or leave my suggestions; either way, cool weekend(?) project.

alialkhatib··on Show HN: We Got Your Back
- I'm sure your intentions are good, but imagine the interpretation of someone for whom most interactions of this nature are bad (or at least unrewarding). Who says you're not some lazy pervert hoping to get lots of women to contact him just so he can hit on them?

Again, I realize that's probably not you, but given that these kinds of people exist, why would someone take a chance, especially considering how little work you've put into proving your intrinsic motivation?

- Thanks for accepting my knee jerk reaction; I expected you to (rightfully) take more offense from it.

- I don't think women in tech care for a tweet (it seems impersonal and empty to me), but I could be wrong. Having your twitter handle certainly allows people to gauge how serious you are on the whole about your views though, so I appreciate your openness with it.

- I'll submit a pull request to that end when I get a chance, thanks.

- You're clearly trying to crowdsource this, but you're not scaffolding enough. Like you said, you're not sitting on your ass wondering what you can do; so what are you doing?

alialkhatib··on Show HN: We Got Your Back
A couple thoughts:

- +1 to minimaxir's comment; this whole thing sounds creepy. Are you offering a supportive tweet? 1-on-1 mentorship? An inside track at hiring at your respective companies? (is that last one even legal in your jurisdiction?) The vagueness here leads me to assume the worst. I'm sorry for being a cynic and for pre-judging, but not much in this industry has encouraged idealism when it comes to women in tech.

- I read "Uber" and thought of the sexual assault from March. Arguably unfair since that was one of your drivers, but that was my knee jerk reaction. You make no effort to explain why you're on the list (not that anyone bothers to explain why this list exists, see previous point), and I'm left to think whatever pops into my head. Again, cynicism reigns.

- Delete "harping". In fact, delete the whole line. The word connotes the tediousness of women complaining about all the sexist shit they deal with in Silicon Valley; it sounds like you don't really get where women are coming from (which begs the question again: why are you doing this?).

Please try to make this more substantive. I would like to support anything that supports gender equality and inclusiveness, but this is so vague that I don't know what you stand for, what you offer, or what my own support would entail.

alialkhatib··on Stanford Large Network Dataset Collection
If you figure out a more intuitive way to communicate confidence intervals visually, please post it here :)
alialkhatib··on Stanford Large Network Dataset Collection
Ah you're right, sorry about that.

That post is really interesting. I know ggplot2 does quite a bit of it, but the visualizations are really nice.

You mention significance a few times but I don't see alpha levels or significance testing per se; do you mean significant in the casual sense, or are you just withholding the stats talk for the audience of (most likely) laypeople? If it's the former, you might find statistical significance in even the avg % grade by gender, given a large enough sample size.

I might be overlooking the part where you talk about this, and I apologize if that's the case.

alialkhatib··on Stanford Large Network Dataset Collection
This is cool (although unless something has changed recently on that page that I'm not seeing, it's kind of old).

In the HCI group at Stanford we recently had a talk about massively online open courses (MOOCs), how Harvard and MIT recently made their edX data available (albeit to other researchers, not completely publicly)[0], and how Stanford could do the same with its own MOOC data. We were wrestling with the idea of making it only available to other established institutions the way Harvard and MIT did it, but the irony (and maybe hypocrisy) of limiting MOOC data access to those within the ivory towers was not lost on us. The alternatives (scrubbing the data more rigorously or to varying degrees depending on our trust level of the entity requesting it) seemed better, but also has problems; how do you determine those levels, what if someone shares their privileged data with an untrusted individual, etc... (these are not unique problems; if we have any hurdle to clear we always have to worry that someone who clears it will break that wall down and mess the whole thing up[1]).

We're really struggling to come to a good solution on this problem in part because IRB protocols were not originally designed for this kind of stuff. They were imagined for the kinds of experiments where the data collection itself was what endangered participants, not the analysis. As a result, IRB approval for a protocol outlining the collection of data might not foresee every imaginable permutation of data analysis that could reveal embarrassing or incriminating details about participants.

I'm sorry, this is becoming a rant. The point is that we're talking about making more data - specifically more MOOC data - available for research and analysis. Hopefully we'll figure something out that will be interesting to (white hat) hackers without it endangering participants in the hands of black hat hackers.

0: https://newsoffice.mit.edu/2014/mit-and-harvard-release-de-i...

1: case in point: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AOL_search_data_leak

alialkhatib··on Get rid of all the boring git commit messages like 'small fix'
Agreed. This makes it easier for programmers who write bad commit messages to hide in plain sight with messages that might look (at a very cursory glance) like they're substantive.

I'd rather have a tool that automatically caught every commit with an unsubstantial message and notified me that I might need to remind that programmer to be more descriptive with their commit messages. Even better if it provided a "wall of shame" of programmers in a repo to make them feel bad about writing unhelpful messages. That might get too simplistic (commit message quality doesn't correlate perfectly with length), but the point remains that I don't want to make it easier for them to replace trash with less obvious trash.

alialkhatib··on Ask HN: Little hacks that make your life easier?
I actually feel like Vimium is nice even if you're not familiar with Vim. Or that was my experience. And when I later made a conscious effort to learn Vim's commands and use it more frequently, the navigation controls I had learned in Vimium made the learning curve less steep than I think it typically is for people first starting out.
alialkhatib··on Tinder Auto-liker script in 70 lines
Based on Cammi Pham's story[0] it sounds like auto-liking profiles en masse is not all it's cracked up to be. Summarizing her post (and probably forgetting a detail or two), you end up with tons of worthless results you don't really want, and you're so inundated with "connections" - messages from other eager people - that you can't get through them quickly enough to get to the good ones before they get sick of waiting and block you.

Neat mini-project, but it might be more interesting to see what kind of cool stuff you can do with Tinder beyond this.

0: http://www.cammipham.com/tinder-hack/ (and incredibly not posted to HN as far as I can tell)

alialkhatib··on PDFy – Instant PDF Host
I'm skeptical about the longevity of a site that operates entirely on donations, but seeing that you offer the source code for free (and it runs on PHP, which is arguably pretty well-supported), and your license is reasonable (if crass, but who cares?)...

This is really great. Thanks for posting this.

alialkhatib··on Postmates NYC treats their deliverymen like trash
It depends on your understanding of the invitation. I agree that this is contentious, but I could see how Postmates would argue that the invitation only incidentally states that the orientation begins at 6:00pm. The time you are requested to arrive is 5-10 minutes before that.

This isn't about the forces of the courier market (although I'm sure there's a fascinating market in NYC). This is about breeding a culture where participants in that culture have a sense of punctuality that supersedes all else. I wouldn't have been much more surprised if showing up too early would have gotten the author turned away. It's easy to show up 45 minutes early to something if you blow out everything leading up to that appointment, which you can do because you see it as a one-off. Being on time for every appointment you make takes more diligence. It takes cutting people (even yourself) off from an arguably more interesting diversion.

I wouldn't lose much sleep over this story; the author describes another courier who's been in this situation before. He clearly failed and was given a second chance. This isn't one of those "fail once and you're banished for life" kinds of things. Postmates will probably keep slamming the door in these people's faces until they show up 5-10 minutes early (ie they learn the lesson Postmates is trying to teach).

Or, you know, they find another job, where this kind of nitpicking isn't normal.

alialkhatib··on Timeline of the far future
As seen previously on HN...

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7221530

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6861343

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3944223

And the first and seemingly most successful go at this page:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3936320

alialkhatib··on Github for Mac is here!
This should say "an incrementally newer version of Github for Mac is here!" but that wouldn't be nearly as click-baity as the author's title ("Github for Mac is here!")

I like the new design, especially the UI for branching (which seems more prominent to me, but I hadn't used the old version in a while so I'm not sure I'm remembering it accurately). New icon is cool too. Looks like it's more Yosemite-appropriate.

alialkhatib··on Show HN: Code in any language. With Anyone. Anywhere.
There are a number of other (albeit rudimentary, but equally free) collaborative coding sites out there. What does this offer that the others don't? Or is it not about features, but execution instead?

It's also been about 45 minutes since I signed up, and I haven't gotten an invite yet. I'm not necessarily inclined to believe that you're being hammered by requests, which suggests someone is just asleep at the wheel. If you're not really ready for users, by all means wait until that time and then post here. My impression was that "Show HN" connotes readiness for us to kick the tires at least a bit.

I'm open to disagreement on that last point, but my understanding was that unfinished product showings generally evoked ire from users.

alialkhatib··on How I Became the Most Hated Person in San Francisco for a Day
If I gave someone my real name for a reservation and then flaked, there's nothing they could (practically) do about it anyway. The name is just the key you use to associate yourself with an otherwise secret list of reservations.
alialkhatib··on Don't major in CS: 5 reasons why
I'm actually not that concerned about CS jobs being outsourced particularly soon. I think the impulse to do it will be there - it seems like a readily outsourced job, right? just committing boilerplate code, right?! - but the reality is that determining requirements and co-located work is crucial (this is backed up by decades of research which I can go dig up if someone wants). You can no sooner outsource the development team than you can management and everyone else interacting directly with those developers. And at that point it sounds like you're just talking about a company in another country.

Reason 1 (about human culture etc...) should actually strike a cord with me since I studied Anthropology for my undergrad degree[0], but even still I disagree with this article's premise. Don't take "you should be focusing on HCI and culture" and conflate that with "you shouldn't study CS". This is a stronger case for the argument that social scientists should be taking CS courses (and vice versa) than it is for anything else.

In STEM fields I sometimes find people who condescendingly talk about social sciences and humanities students because their job prospects seem (and indeed are) grim. It's rarer that someone in one of those fields derisively fires back with crap about how shallow a CS (or related) education is, but it happens as it has here. It's not just unproductive; it's toxic. People instinctively respond by digging deeper into the trenches and preparing defensive, even offensive responses in retaliation for what seem like attacks on their intellectual passions. These posts polarize us and discourage us from engaging with people from other fields for fear that we're in for yet another flame war.

We should all be talking about how we can enrich our discourses with wisdom from other fields, not taking pot shots from our respective camps about how much better ours is than the other's. There's a lot that Computer Science can do for other fields, and a lot that other fields can do for CS.

0: to be fair, I double-majored, but I associate personally more closely with Anthropology at the moment (although for credibility's sake, I'm studying CS now).

alialkhatib··on 5 (Inexpensive) Ways to Buy a More Productive Life.
I wouldn't actually recommend getting the kind of whiteboard marker pictured in the article. They're generic and easily mixed up in the sea of crappy markers you're trying to get away from in the first place, so you'll inevitably spend a few minutes at the end of every meeting scribbling a line on the whiteboard with each marker in the room to make sure you're taking your marker (because ostensibly yours is the one that writes well). Not to mention that losing the cap is frustrating.

I got a whiteboard marker with a "retractable tip" and I really recommend it. It basically looks like a slightly blown up pen, fits in most of the same places (e.g. in your bag), and fits in your hand a little better (ie more like a real pen).

I know it seems trivial, but those pens were a real game changer for me. And yes, I know how sad that sounds now.

edit: I thought about not linking to an item since it'd look like I was trying to sell them, but the item the author linked to was a single dry erase marker (for close to $20, currently), which is either hilarious or outrageous depending on your sense of humor. I got some Expo markers[0]. Cheaper, more pens, more colors (although if you want just black pens I think there's a cheaper 3-pack out there).

0: http://www.amazon.com/Expo-Retractable-Markers-Fashion-17516...

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →