HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

alialkhatib

175 karma · joined March 14, 2012

computer scientist; previously anthropologist

https://ali-alkhatib.com

submissionscomments
alialkhatib··on Gmail API
Hypothetically, wouldn't really aggressive archiving accomplish the same task?

Have a 0-email inbox, and if you get something that you can't address immediately (but you can take care of later in the day), then you leave it in the inbox. In the meantime, anything you can act on in some way gets acted upon and then archived. By the end of the day you would ideally have just that email in your inbox (and even in a realistic world you might have a few tasks lingering in your inbox, but few enough that you can glance and see that "task" still there). Check your email at the end of the day and act on the things you needed to postpone for whatever reason (as well as pruning emails loitering in the inbox).

This requires, as previously said, really aggressive archiving, but since there's no difference between inbox and all-mail as far as I know (unless you use it as a search operator e.g. "from:friend@university.edu label:inbox"), it wouldn't be that big a cost (except that you would have to remember to archive or go through later and archive stuff).

I had been doing this somewhat organically for a while - tagging emails that didn't get filtered automatically and archiving them when there was nothing more for me to do with them - but when I disabled all of my filters (a misguided experiment I don't recommend anyone attempt) I stopped.

alialkhatib··on Browse formulae – All packages available via the Homebrew package manager
A description would be great (especially when you run into ambiguously named projects or projects with similar names), but I'd also like to see something like download metrics and maybe even comments. The Sublime Text package manager [0] does a reasonably good job of this (sans comments, which leads me to think maybe it's a bad idea), which helps identify old & abandoned projects.

0: https://sublime.wbond.net/

alialkhatib··on An Important Tech Job That Doesn't Exist
Coming from an academic perspective, my knee-jerk reaction to this post is "Awesome, we definitely need this", but after some thought I really don't see this as a necessary job (at least, not for most startups in most areas). I'll try to explain my more ruminative thinking: 

Since the article actually specifies behavioral research, I think my background in anthropology and the social sciences might be helpful here. My research for the past ~year has been on the culture of Quantified Self, but I'm also coming from a background of Human-Computer Interaction and I'm going to study HCI at Stanford (sooner or) later this year.

What I generally call "behavioral" research is just too specific to be applicable without an academician him/herself to parse, abstract, and apply this stuff. Worse, you would be hard-pressed to find an anthropologist (or I suspect any other social scientist) who would be able, let alone willing, to make any predictions about the future, even in their own niche. My thesis's discussion section looks at the future of QS culture as it relates to mainstream culture, but I'm not willing to make any predictions at all. The most brazen thing I'm willing to do is highlight some of my observations and follow where those observations might lead. I immediately underscore that these are total unknowns, and that we should all just keenly watch QS culture for how these issues will play out.

That kind of non-committal culture (at least in the social sciences) is favored in academia because it's incredibly difficult to correctly guess or predict the future, especially when humans are the subject of research (and especially when they're aware of the prediction you're making, because they so often seem to want to prove you wrong). You want your research to stand the test of time, and making predictions that don't bear out undercuts your credibility.

So you won't read any journal articles in sociology or anthropology that definitively tell you what you should make your next startup about, and any interpretation between the lines you read will invariably be contentious. For all of my research, I wouldn't bet my lunch on any particular prediction.

Instead, it makes much more sense to have a UI/UX specialist whose job includes knowing the research and academic consensus on stuff. Maybe they should keep their ear to the ground to hear for any trends or new paradigms in user interface design, but whether this person can even shoehorn that stuff into real-world business endeavors is questionable.

All that being said, I think I agree with the idea that a startup should be cognizant of research in the area they're trying to break into. But that sounds (to me, anyway) like I'm advocating that in the process of doing a business plan and analyzing competitors someone should do a cursory search for existing literature on this topic to make sure there are no land mines in the field. If someone wanted to get into medical informatics but had no idea about HIPAA-compliance and the complications that injects, I would steer clear.

alialkhatib··on Stop the Slow Lane
I don't think this is the right approach. I realize that the principle is fundamentally the same with SOPA protests (depriving users of content to highlight the danger of this passing), but there's a more salient argument that you could make here if you really wanted.

Why not implement a loading bar that actually progressed slowly and then put a brief explanation underneath the loading bar describing the FCC "slow lane" and how it would negatively impact users?

To add insult to injury, give the user 3 options:

- pay the site owner to access the "fast lane" to your content

- send an email (to FCC chair? maybe a representative?) to voice their anger

- get used to waiting; that'll be the new norm if nobody prevents this, right?

The first option would be incredibly controversial, but would underscore how objectionable the "Slow Lane" idea even is. If anyone is stubborn enough to pay, you could funnel that money into the EFF or some other relevant organization.

The point is that just throwing people a loading screen (especially without a good explanation) will leave the user confused. Once the content loads they'll probably forget about that loading screen anyway (at least on a conscious level), so don't wait until afterward to explain what just happened.

As an aside, there was a comment that users will wait for a website that's sufficiently highly trafficked, but I don't think that's true. I remember some Google presentation[0] where an engineer explained that virtually any extra loading time was enough to discourage users from returning. Maybe that's just with search or other highly interactive sites (rather than reading a blog, for example), but I wouldn't want to test that hypothesis with any site I cared about and managed.

0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Il4swGfTOSM - The "impact of slow sites" comes up early on.

alialkhatib··on Mail Pilot App
Agreed. $20 is also kind of steep for an app whose current version only has 2.5 stars in the app store (and 3.0 across all versions). It sounds like it crashes a lot and is missing some seemingly basic features.
alialkhatib··on Show HN: Amazon Instant, weekend project
That's a really interesting idea; tracking prices and potentially giving a Buy/Wait indicator would be really cool.

CamelCamelCamel[0] actually does some price tracking, but I'm not very familiar with what they do with it (with regard to giving advice on whether to buy or not). You might be able to grab some information from them on products via an API or scraper. I'm not seeing an API, nor do I see anything about using their data for other stuff, but I suppose it goes without saying that a really aggressive scraper wouldn't be welcome.

0: http://camelcamelcamel.com/

alialkhatib··on Show HN: Intelligent Domain Name Generator
Checked my personal domain... $9.00

Checked the same domain sans a hyphen... $23.06

Someone squatted on it to sell it for a markup, asked for something like $150, I laughed at him over the phone. Joke's on me, I guess.

alialkhatib··on Show HN: Amazon Instant, weekend project
I get the impression that if this wasn't calling on a third-party API (ie if you were indexing the product listings yourself) you'd be able to give more "instant" results, but this is a cool take on search on Amazon (although obviously inspired by Google and other instant search features). I also imagine Amazon would blacklist you for harvesting their product listing, although since you're still giving them referrals maybe they wouldn't. I guess if you called it "aggressive caching" you might get away with it, heh.

While you're re-thinking product search, why not consider higher-resolution/larger thumbnails, a few more products per "page", etc...? I'm not advocating a Pinterest clone or anything like that, but the initial load (10 items in 2 rows) looks a little... dated and spartan.

As said before, cool short-term project. Would be interesting to see a few more features built into this, especially if it made your search "competitive" with Amazon's implementation.

alialkhatib··on The Limits of the Digital Humanities
It's interesting reading this from a background in Anthropology, having experienced some of the challenges the article describes. In particular, the perspective that people need to know how to code (Ramsay), and the backlash it evoked was something I've experienced on numerous occasions. I'm interested in digital cultures and quantitative methods, but Anthropology largely abandoned quantitative stuff in the 70s and now it seems like anyone who mentions statistics and quantitative methods non-sarcastically gets shunted into other fields (e.g. Sociology, Informatics, CS).

I didn't whither away in Anthro, but now I'm leaving the field because, essentially, my methodology and skill set align me more closely with a CS program than with an Anthro program. That my research interests are in line with cultural Anthropology is secondary; methods determined my field, which when you think about it is kind of bizarre.

Dan Jurafsky (at Stanford) and I had a brief conversation about this and seemed to come from a similar experience. He described himself as a linguist and seemed to feel that that's where he is intellectually, but the field of Linguistics sees him as more of a computer scientist because of his tools and so he's got an appointment in CS.

I liken Anthropology in digital cultures to being an anthropologist of some South American culture; there are languages, customs, and mindsets that you need to learn - and indeed be fluent in - before you can even claim to be an expert. Anything less and you're seriously limiting yourself. There will be people who study digital cultures who can't code, eschew quantitative stuff (including "Big Data" et. al), and generally stick to orthodox convention. Their expertise will someday be limited by not being able to "speak the language" both literally and figuratively (ie having an emic understanding of the culture they're studying).

I don't think "someday" is today. Maybe that's because my undergrad advisor is an Anthropologist with no programming background, yet unequivocally one of the leading researchers in digital cultures. I think there's still enough basic stuff that we need to figure out to orient ourselves with digital cultures that people have to be able to code and bring domain-specialized skills to the field. Or maybe we're so far along that getting entrenched in digital culture has become abstracted from being savvy to the point of being a programmer.

The article ends on the prescription to critique technology in the spirit of "intellectual responsibility", but I get the feeling that it doesn't see the "identity crisis" described earlier as the very critique the article calls for. Hacking away at each other, intellectual vying for control of the digital humanities are ultimately advocating for what the field ought to be. This is what we (social scientists and humanists) badly need.

If the digital humanities can't coalesce into something meaningful (and perhaps soon), people like me will ultimately go into CS and related fields where we'll learn the tools we need to become fluent in the technical skills, rather than hone qualitative skills and study sociocultural theory. If that continues to happen, the digital humanities could lose an entire generation and ultimately fail to keep Anthropology and the Humanities modern and relevant. I don't know what will happen to these disciplines if they get left behind.

/rant.

alialkhatib··on Female Co-Founder position for a dating app
I have some serious questions:

- Did you have another person proofread this for you?

- Why should she relocate to Pune, India? Why shouldn't you relocate?

- How did you come to the conclusion that the world lacks dating apps?

- How are you flexible on the skill-set you need from a cofounder but not on the name of the app?

You're trying to get someone with a Masters (or PhD) in Psychology. She's got good prospects wherever she already lives. I don't see an appreciation for that in this post calling for a woman cofounder, especially given the finder's fee, which I would describe as "nominal".

I'm not saying all of this just to put you down; if you're going down the entrepreneurial path, you're going to be seeking investment from VCs and others who will judge you critically. This isn't a learning exercise for them - it's their wealth, and they want to grow it. They're not inclined to cut you slack and ignore your oversights (e.g. "nulcear"), no matter how trivial. Certainly they'll expect compelling answers to the big questions (including but not limited to the ones I asked at the outset).

alialkhatib··on StackOverflow closed my question, that's why we exist
That reads like a question I'd see on Quora. It's open-ended, has virtually no right or wrong answer, and calls for people to evangelize their favorites and perhaps even their own blogs (I realize this sentence might sound like an unequivocal criticism of Quora, which was not intended).

On cursory glance, a similar question actually is on Quora: http://www.quora.com/Computer-Programming/What-are-the-best-...

alialkhatib··on Hacker Koan
At greater risk of exposing my misinterpretation of it than jat850, my understanding was that his domain knowledge allows him to solve the problem directly rather than fumbling around with generic solutions (perhaps solving it accidentally). Some quality of the action affects the outcome, even though the approach is pretty much the same.

Some problems with my router call for a simple power cycle; others call for a power cycle with ~30 seconds unplugged from power. Someone without much knowledge of the router might do the same thing as me (power cycle), and it might even occasionally work (if s/he unplugs it, goes to make lunch, and comes back), but my domain knowledge enables me to solve the problem more consistently (seemingly magically).

alialkhatib··on Python 3.3.5 has been released
That'd be nice, but since CPython is supposed to serve as a reference implementation (and not necessarily be the bleeding edge of speed) I don't hold much hope of performance improvements becoming a top priority (except to make Python3 more compelling than Python 2.x strictly on performance criteria, which they've largely accomplished if I understand correctly).
alialkhatib··on [dead]
Fun. Sad that I got a combination that sounded like a project I actually worked on.

Aside: I'm not getting an error message upon entering the same app name multiple times. Am I stuffing the ballot box, or is the error message (e.g. "we've already got that one") not written yet?

alialkhatib··on Featured dataset cannot be downloaded
There are mediums (pun not intended) where you can make the equivalent of a blog post without much effort (Medium, Quora, I'm sure there are others). And link-bait is more about the marketing used to get people to click on the link (e.g. editorializing), isn't it?

I don't want to get into semantics, so let's consider this a minor detail, because the more important matter is that you're editorializing. HN has a pretty clear (and helpful) set of guidelines on posting: http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

>If you want to add initial commentary on the link, write a blog post about it and submit that instead.

I'm not trying to harangue you or anything; you make a good point but it's hamstrung by a length-limited title section.

alialkhatib··on Featured dataset cannot be downloaded
Those clauses seem contradictory. You have a very clear (and in my opinion on point) critique of what you're presenting us, but you don't have the inclination to write a blog post? You even wrote your own top-level comment providing some context. That would have made a sufficient blog post right there.

(A great blog post might have compared bad vs good cases, or provided some suggestions on improving, or even looked more broadly at whether this was an outlier of badly structured/provided data or just the norm)

The whole "Try (downloading|accessing) this..." strikes me as the same kind of title as Upworthy's "You'll never believe this..." in that it seems vaguely like link-baiting. I'm a little too curious not to click just to see what the dataset is about.

alialkhatib··on The Fat Doctor Problem
I agree with sssilver in his disagreement, but there's a nuanced logical flaw here that's not even being addressed.

sssilver brings up that someone who has experienced failure in x isn't necessarily a poor source of advice in x. Similarly, just because someone was successful in x doesn't mean that they have any clue what they did right.

A more defensible bit of advice would be to evaluate someone's credibility before taking their advice, but I can't think of a more obvious truism.

alialkhatib··on Show HN: Musi
To be honest it comes off as (at least a little) arrogant in my opinion. It's one thing if I read something along the lines of "This kid is 17 and he's trying to change the music industry" [posted by someone else] because that would be a third party endorsement of your ambition/drive, as well as highlighting your age. It's another if you're boasting about it yourself.

Then again, I'm in my mid-20s so maybe I'm just grumpy that I wasn't as motivated or directed at 17 as you are :)

alialkhatib··on Introduction to python
What constitutes a "beginner" in your introduction? You describe Python as "Multiparadigm" but don't explain what that means, which leads me to think that your intended audience is familiar with some programming paradigms, including OOP, and presumably others. But you go on to teach some pretty basic syntax.

I bring this up to encourage you to think about your audience, and frame your guide for a more specific group. If your quintessential beginner is someone who has never coded before and probably shies away from math, your number-heavy intro will probably turn them off, and the "python" > "java" reference won't land. If, on the other hand, you expect people to know Java and Perl (or at least be familiar enough with it that you can make those jokes), then do you really need to explain the logic of how Python does arithmetic?

I apologize if this comes off as kind of harsh; there are so many players in the field trying to teach people how to code, some very good in their attempts, so it really raises the bar for new entrants.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4