HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

allthenews

233 karma · joined January 30, 2018

submissionscomments
allthenews··on Riot, Blizzard, Twitch and others are teaming up to fight toxic gaming behavior
>And honestly, the fact you think this "ultimately caters to a tiny fraction of gamers while worsening the experience for the majority" tells me you're part of the problem; you're probably often toxic to other players (even if you don't notice it), get your account muted/locked out/whatever, and then think that you did nothing wrong and everyone's in the same boat as you.

Sorry for having the wrong opinion, but personal attacks are uncalled for.

Ironic.

So, to illustrate my point, would you prefer that heavy handed mods step in to censor you according to their definition of toxicity, or would you rather have the freedom to continue this discussion to possibly reach some resolution?

I prefer to put faith in peoples' ability to resolve conflict without vague rules regarding inconsistent notions of toxicity, especially in the context of gaming, where I can leave and join another game more or less any time.

allthenews··on Riot, Blizzard, Twitch and others are teaming up to fight toxic gaming behavior
I was going to agree that forcing was a less than ideal word choice, hence my edit, but it occurs to me that we've invested time and money into these games, only to have rules potentially changed on the whim of developers. They're not exactly going to issue refunds to suddenly unhappy players.

Moreover, when these developers have access to the minds of hundreds of millions of people, including children, there is a degree of cultural forcing involved. These developers' ideas of right and wrong are potentially influencing society, and this is something that non gamers have little control over.

At the very least, journalists have a responsibility to recognize that toxicity is not universal. One could argue that there is potential for priming young people toward obscenity laws and nanny statism, when they are conditioned to look toward authority for resolution of all problems.

Farfetched, perhaps, but I personally believe that people need to learn to deal with such problems on their own, because external solutions are not always available or enforceable. This could easily have unforseen consequences.

allthenews··on Riot, Blizzard, Twitch and others are teaming up to fight toxic gaming behavior
I'd really rather not have video game designers and video game journalists dictating their versions morality to me.

I'll bet this will turn into the usual identity politics nightmare that ultimately caters to a tiny fraction of gamers while worsening the experience for the majority. If this were such a massive problem, millions of people wouldn't be spending billions of dollars and hundreds millions of man hours playing these games.

This is about politics, not gaming experience.

allthenews··on The stability implications of the US nukes' burst-height compensating super-fuze
GP claimed civilization would be unable to rise again, implying thousands of years of knowledge would disappear.

Wikipedia is available for download and requires less than 15GB of space[1]. This is an unprecedented density of self documenting data, containing thousands of years of advancements in science, mathematics, philosophy, arts.

Consider how many people live in or visit dwellings that are tens or hundreds of miles from large population centers, and how many of these dwellings have emergency gasoline generators and working computers.

Now, presuming that most of the destruction happens in major cities, and the rest of the earth generally remains livable, there will still remain millions of people, and if just a small sampling of competent technically minded people survive, there will be billions of abandoned, unused, solid state devices, and millions of generators to power them, ripe for picking. What are the odds that not a single competent survivor will have backed up a copy of wikipedia to be able share with other survivors in the decades after catastrophe?

When a single human can hold in his hand all of the science and mathematics necessary to derive the technologies upon which modern civilization is based, rebuilding is easily within the realm of possibility. Not to mention, artifacts of modern technology will remain as examples for engineering and even use with sufficient technical knowledge.

Further, I encourage all of you to download and keep a copy of wikipedia for this very, however farfetched, purpose.

[1]https://www.google.com/amp/s/lifehacker.com/how-to-download-...

allthenews··on Zuckerberg Has No Way Out of Facebook's Quagmire
That doesn't justify the fact that data was harvested for what amounts to targeted propaganda.

And this isn't some kind of whataboutism. Attention needs to be drawn to these abuses of private data, regardless of where they occur or whether they are technically legal.

allthenews··on The stability implications of the US nukes' burst-height compensating super-fuze
>Here is some food for thought though, about the potential for our civilization to fall; it will not rise again. We’ve accessed far too much petrochemical wealth and burned it, and the same is true of coal, and metal resources...exploit

This is nonsense, for a number of reasons.

First, you ignore that smaller, shallow deposits of petroleum still exist all over the world, in more than enough quantity to support a developing civilization if it were to be reduced to, say, less than 1/10th of its current size.

Second, existing stores of substances necessary to civilization will not simply evaporate. Metals, plastics, and other raw materials will be recoverable and recyclable.

Third, while there may be a couple hundred years or so of dark ages, I think it is extremely unlikely for any substantial amount of our current scientific progress to be eradicated. Unless we cover every mile of civilized earth with bombardment, I imagine it is guaranteed that there will be survivors with minimal technical knowledge required to operate computers and harvest various data that will inevitably be left on servers in random locations. All it takes is a handful of hackers to spread knowledge of operation and recovery. Not to mention books and magazines will likely still exist.

I think you underestimate the resilience that modern technology can offer over decades in terms of recovery after a global catastrophe. A laptop, a generator, and a copy of wikipedia will get you far in preserving enough scientific and technical knowledge. Civilization at this point is hard to permanently wipe out.

allthenews··on Researchers Learned to Use Facebook ‘Likes’ to Sway Your Thinking
>I'd qualify myself as fitting in the norm of young CS students

I say this in total seriousness, and with no ill intent: based on a number of CS twenty-something males that I've met in the Valley and Seattle over the last couple years, an unusual interest in lingerie is not necessarily that inaccurate of a prediction...

Which doesn't entirely surprise me anymore. Competent, self taught hackers tend to represent the upper tail of intelligence, and it seems to me that having such interests from a young age correlates with a number of unusual and perhaps less than socially acceptable interests. Which would probably be influenced by a lifetime of trouble "fitting in", something I suspect is a disproportionately familiar experience to many of us on HN.

allthenews··on FTC Probing Facebook for Use of Personal Data, Source Says
>There is of course, some effect but it's relatively minor for the middle class

This was my only point, because low and middle class markets and income are continuous spectra, and displacement at the base puts pressure on the rest of the continuum. People don't typically end up homeless because of a couple percent increase in rent, they find a way to pay it. Now, the exact quantitative effect on pricing throughout the market is something that neither of us can likely provide.

>Your analysis leaves out a bunch of realities...outside these areas.

And what happens when these areas fill up and start to influence surrounding neighborhoods? What about the increased strain on infrastructure, including roads, schools, police, fire, etc, especially by those who do not pay taxes?

What about the effect on markets cause by middle income flight post spillover, when these growing low income neighborhoods bring with them crime and other undesirable activity?

No amount of arguing over left out "realities" changes the simple fact that more people create increased local demand in housing starved locales, which puts upward pressure on all markets, although of course the derivative of income pressure vs population decreases with increasing housing prices.

>People tend to get the best they can afford

"Best" is highly subjective and dependent entirely on market rates. People will pay more for less if the whole market is inflated by pressure from below.

To be clear, I am not interested in blaming immigrants, legal or otherwise, for any of societies problems. I am simply arguing that more people>increased demand>higher price.

allthenews··on FTC Probing Facebook for Use of Personal Data, Source Says
Any influx of residents puts pressure on local and regional housing markets. Extra pressure on even low income rentals has an appreciating effect on the rest of the housing chain, because on the short term housing supply is inelastic, and space in desirable areas is relatively finite.
allthenews··on Facebook suspended the account of whistleblower who exposed Cambridge Analytica
Sure, if by matured, you mean that zuck has refined his ability to harvest and use personal data without any sort of qualms.

What Facebook has become is technically brilliant, but the "dumb fuck" attitude shows no signs of having lessened.

allthenews··on 50M Facebook profiles harvested for Cambridge Analytica in major data breach
>So with that said, why do you believe that it's unethical to call out Trump and by extension CA's actions

Nothing in that wall of text justifies your twisting of my words.

>I don't think that we're exaggerating here calling it a data breach...And while I'll admit the term data breach is a bit of a stretch

If you weren't in such a desperate rush to misconstrue my argument, perhaps you would be able to maintain consistency in your own.

Once again, I am speaking of the ethics of exaggeration and selective accountability in journalism. My point is not that it is unethical to call attention to this misuse of data, but that the post title likely deliberately misleading because of enablers like yourself, who selectively turn a blind eye to such embellishment at any mention of Trump or the GOP.

allthenews··on China to bar people with bad 'social credit' from planes, trains
>The implication of "black people commit more crimes" is that there is something about being black that involves a degree of criminality

It sounds like you are the racist here.

allthenews··on 50M Facebook profiles harvested for Cambridge Analytica in major data breach
From my post, again:

>But it is unethical to exaggerate and hold only part of the political system accountable

Please consider what I wrote in sum. Partisanship and exaggeration are antithetical to trust.

allthenews··on 50M Facebook profiles harvested for Cambridge Analytica in major data breach
So, in your opinion, this justifies the false headline of the article, and is reason to turn a blind eye to the same potential data abuse when committed by the other party?

>They are all the same” isn’t just cynical and useless. It’s also wrong.

Please do not put words in my mouth. All I am asking for is journalistic integrity. Media in the U.S. has proven repeatedly to be partisan, which, to a rational person, makes it very difficult to separate fact from propaganda. This article is a case in my point.

Unethical politicking is not an excuse for spread of misinformation.

allthenews··on 50M Facebook profiles harvested for Cambridge Analytica in major data breach
Sure. But it is unethical to exaggerate and hold only part of the political system accountable for shady or illegal practices.

This is part of a consistent pattern. Our media has become as hopelessly partisan as our unfortunate two party system, and unethical behavior on one front does not justify the same on another in response.

allthenews··on In Praise of ADHD
So, are we witnessing a modern form of selection pressure? Are genes related to ADHD favorable for not only coping with, but taking advantage of increasing availability of information in our modern age?
allthenews··on 50M Facebook profiles harvested for Cambridge Analytica in major data breach
Let's be realistic here. This headline is nothing but partisanship. The only reason this is exaggerated as a "data breech" is because of the connection to the Trump campaign.

The real scandal is that such data is so easily harvested and freely available.

I'd be interested in seeing how much of facebook's data repository was used in targeted political ads by all parties. Including Russian agitators who have been shown playing both sides.

allthenews··on China to bar people with bad 'social credit' from planes, trains
You equate driving cars and living on superfund sites with consuming illicit substances and wilfully committing violent acts, and then have the audacity to call someone else's contribution juvenile?

Does personal responsibility exist in your ivory tower?

What sort of convoluted logic could possibly drive you to equate necessities of life, or constraints of circumstance, with such antisocial choices? We're talking about smoking marijuana and stealing expensive clothing, after all, not theft of food for subsistence.

Why is it that any time race is brought up, any argument that even has the potential to cast minorities in negative light is immediately shouted down with any sort of logic or reason thrown out the window? What about objectivity?

We cannot shout down potential truths simply because they have unpleasant implications.

allthenews··on China to bar people with bad 'social credit' from planes, trains
>It has been shown time and time again that black Americans are disproportionately arrested and sentenced.

And you also conveniently ignore that blacks disproportionately commit crimes, especially violent crimes.

Such discussions cannot be productive until we are willing to admit to both sides of the problem.

I do not deny that there are inequities in our justice system. However, disproportionate police presence in low income communities is not a symptom of racist targeting. The blackness of these individuals is incidental to the fact that low income communities have higher rates of all types of crime, especially violent offenses, and in any other context it would be obviously prudent to assign additional police forces to target high crime areas.

But this discussion has far surpassed the boundaries of what is acceptable on HN, and I will not comment in this thread further.

allthenews··on China to bar people with bad 'social credit' from planes, trains
>from who gets more police attention, arrests, charges, plea deals and how heavy the sentences are

None of this detracts from the fact that these laws are ultimately relatively clear in their restrictions, compared to China's social score.

Theft is theft. Drug possession is drug possession. Had these "unfairly" targeted individuals followed the law, they would not be subject to its penalties.

Sure, I recognize that very few of us are perfectly law abiding citizens. But I have trouble with the notion that heavier police presence, and heavier sentencing for repeat offenders, are somehow unfair phenomena, and these alleged transgressions far too often are lumped together with actual institutional inequity.

In other words, one must not conflate subjectivity in sentencing and policing with some kind of ingrained, institutional caste system, so long as laws are followed as written. If you wish to stay out of the felon caste, do not break obvious laws, like those regarding drug possession. If you do not agree with such laws, work to change them.

allthenews··on Surprising Creativity: Anecdotes from Evolutionary Computation
This parallels much of mathematics. Many formulations, even in physics, admit so called trivial solutions which amount conceptually to zero.
allthenews··on Ancient DNA Is Rewriting Human and Neanderthal History
What? This isn't about privilege, this is about fashion, and white guilt is increasingly in.
allthenews··on Saudi Arabia cyber attack goal was chemical plant explosion; experts fear retry
Why isn't it SOP to isolate safety critical components from the web?

Is this just incompetence/cost savings, or is there some other legitimate reason for building this vulnerability into so much of our global infrastructure?

allthenews··on Ancient DNA Is Rewriting Human and Neanderthal History
What you are seeing is simply a reflection of what is socially acceptable.
allthenews··on A New Backdoor Around the Fourth Amendment: The CLOUD Act
Is this inevitable? In the age of Big Data, can we realistically do anything to stop the progressive intrusion of surveillance onto our privacy?

Particularly when a single secret datacenter is enough to circumvent any law or amendment, what can we realistically do, short of going off the grid? Can we make our own?

allthenews··on Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hours Prior Notice
I am not a security researcher, and I do not speak for the person you are replying to, but I do believe that Intel's documented history of unethical, anticompetitive practices against AMD, for example, deliberate compiler handicapping for non Intel CPUs[1], is enough evidence to establish at least some suspicion regarding these results, especially considering the short warning given to AMD before public disclosure.

I also wonder, what is the purpose of such white hat operations if vulnerabilities are disclosed publicly without anywhere near adequate time for a fix? Isn't SOP to give more time before going public?

1.https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_C%2B%2B_Compiler#Criti...

allthenews··on Security Researchers Publish Ryzen Flaws, Gave AMD 24 Hours Prior Notice
I wonder if this is could be Intel up to its old tricks again.
allthenews··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
The problem is not that the topics themselves are toxic, but that only one point of view is identified as such. I only mention these "flamebait" topics as examples, not to discuss them or choose a side.

Gamergate

Gender Equality/Equity

Affirmative Action

White Privilege

The various subjects in James Damore's recent memo [note, he was fired for honest, sourced feedback that was explicitly requested of him]

Politics in general (especially anything remotely pro-Trump or pro-Republican)

If you pay attention to dynamics on reddit, for example, certain sides tend to be stifled, regardless of any potential merits. I am not choosing sides, just offering examples where certain opinions are immediately identified by communities as toxic, and no discussion is even attempted.

Hell, there is a growing movement among feminists, at least a vocal minority online, which claims that our modern concept of masculinity is "toxic."

The very word is turning into a catch all for "opinions I don't like," which seems to happen any time one attempts to censor information.

Finally, consider this: if the topics I've brought up are so clearly, as you claimed, not merely "differences in opinion," then why do they attract such heated discussions, with contributors on both sides, even on HN?

allthenews··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
You don't seem to understand that terms like "toxic" are as arbitrary and subject to abuse as the word "obscene".

In fact, I'm not even sure as to what you're getting at. Are you seriously suggesting that what is toxic is somehow universal?

It does not bother you that dozens of serious contemporary, controversial topics, with severe consequences for our society, are regularly censored on websites like reddit under the guise of so called toxicity?

You aren't bothered by such vague conceptions of offensiveness being used by corporate giants to push their narrative at the expense of others? Of the danger of self-censoring group think on community moderated boards?

allthenews··on Reddit and the Struggle to Detoxify the Internet
I detest this smug mentality, that so called trolling is trivial to identify and differentiate from legitimate, but unpopular opinion.

I feel strongly about it because it creates opportunity for censors, both in the form of moderators and communities themselves, to stifle debate under the guise of "detoxification." This kind of communal policing is ground zero for the echo chamber phenomenon.

We live in a reality where there will always be those who abuse platforms of communication for nefarious purposes. We also live in a reality where we are able to temper our own outrage, and we must if we wish to maintain healthy, open dialogue.

Offense is taken, not given.

← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →