HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

almatabata

410 karma · joined September 28, 2023

submissionscomments
almatabata··on We’re receiving about 3,000 reports/hour
> I am very okay with not seeing CSAM, but your argument doesn’t hold water.

By this you mean that its very easy to define a clear set of rules for moderation?

almatabata··on Tesla has the highest fatal accident rate of all auto brands, study finds
The study seems to contradict this: "When broken out by size, small cars have the highest fatal accident rate while midsize and full-size cars are both below average."

And later in the study, “When two small cars collide the forces are equalized and both vehicles tend to hold up well. But if a compact hatchback and a full-size pickup truck try to occupy the same space at the same time, the smaller car always loses.”

almatabata··on Tesla has the highest fatal accident rate of all auto brands, study finds
You can add more parameters.

Whats the temperament of the driver. Certain brands attract hot heads who will drive recklessly. I was kind of expecting more sports cars in the top 5. 2/5 is still a good score.

Given the amount of SUVs as well, no matter how safe you make a small car, if an SUV rams you, it is just not going to end well for the smaller.

almatabata··on A Student's Guide to Writing with ChatGPT
They have the political power to do this: https://smex.org/algeria-another-year-another-exam-shutdown/
almatabata··on A Student's Guide to Writing with ChatGPT
I remember seeing a paper (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4274624/) that talked about how physical writing helps kids learn to read later. Typing on a keyboard did not have the same effect.

I expect the same will happen with math and numbers. To be fair you said primarily so you did not imply to do completely away with the paper. I am not certain though that we can do completely away with at least some pain. All the skills I acquired usually came with both frustration and joy.

I am all for trying new methods to see if we can do something better. I have no proof either way though that going 90% excel would help more people learn math. People will run both experiments and we will see how it turns out in 20 years.

almatabata··on Procrastination and the fear of not being good enough
One thing that helped me was accepting that it is not that I might fail but that I will fail initially.

I will produce bad articles because to become good you have to start with your current skill level which probably sucks if you are average. To become good you have to write. Nothing beats actually doing it. But knowing that everyone published something stupid at some point helps me accept that I will also go through that process as well. Everyone failed, everyone will fail and it is fine to fail.

And no matter how good you become you will still fail from time to time. You never graduate from it. Look at the famous movie directors, writers and journalists. Are all their works great? Is each of their work always better than the previous ones? Of course not. Some works will be amazing and insightful, some might be mediocre. Even the very best will have their ups and downs, so why not you?

Each time I publish a post I already accept it might be subpar.

almatabata··on Judge: Zuckerberg not liable for social media harm to children
> Pretty much every business runs psychological experiments on their customers. That's what the ad industry is, that's why retailers run sales to gather pricing data, that's what A/B testing is for.

Sure but there are differences between the psychological experiments. I would argue that running a sale is benign compared to manipulating words in social media post to see how it influences your mood. What effect will that have on people with already fragile psyches?

I understand its legal whatever facebook has done but still I think that there should be restrictions on the kind of psychological tests you can run like this. Unless I overestimate the effect these studies have.

> Clearly, people value killing foreigners > making money > discovering new knowledge.

Killing foreigners is mostly a way to maintain or gain influence so I would say its more: power > making money > discovering new. The killing foreigners part is just a means to an end.

almatabata··on Boycott men? South Korea's 4B movement gains traction in the U.S.
I will believe it when we get an actual impact in the relationship statistics. Right now its post election craziness where people post to vent their frustration. If that will have an impact in a year is to be seen. But honestly I doubt many women would voluntarily give up having a fulfilling relationship with a man they love.
almatabata··on Judge: Zuckerberg not liable for social media harm to children
Remember when facebook got caught running psychological experiments on its users? (https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jul/02/facebook-...)

I do not trust myself with identifying when companies tweak the algorithm to mess with my psyche. How can I trust myself with identifying with my own kids except when it becomes really obvious in the content or in their behavior?

> Do we blame car manufacturers for young people driving and killing themselves or others?

Cars had no seat belts, had no crumple zone, would crush the driver when the engine got pushed in. We literally put more and more requirements on cars to make them as safe as reasonably possible.

If social media has negative effects why would we not legislate these companies in such a way as to reduce the negatives?

You can argue there is no negative effect if you want. But if they have negatives effects then don't we need to rein them in?

almatabata··on Why systemd is a problem for embedded Linux
At a company I worked at they explicitly told us they will do anything to avoid upgrading the hardware from 1GB to 4GB because it increases costs. They would rather we optimize the software to use less RAM than upgrade the hardware.

I remember arguing as well with people about 0.10$ components. They told me it was a no go, not even a point of bringing it up. Sometimes even a 0.01$ is a big deal.

almatabata··on Rivian's chief software officer says in-car buttons are 'an anomaly'
Will it work if the company stops supporting it after 6 years or goes bankrupt? (https://www.businessinsider.com/fisker-owners-describe-chaos...)

This obsession with replacing robust proven solutions with brittle technological toys will never cease to amaze me.

I expect the true reason lies in the fact that they can charge a recurring fee for the AI assistant but not for the buttons. I also wonder about the impact on the car battery. There is no way a call to a backend uses less energy than a car button or a touchscreen.

almatabata··on Microsoft just delayed Recall again
Their security track record does not really help. I will never trust them again after they refused to tell their customer about a workaround because they wanted that juicy DoD contract (https://www.propublica.org/article/microsoft-solarwinds-gold...).

Why would I trust that company with my data?

almatabata··on Google CEO says more than a quarter of the company's new code is created by AI
I think twitter is an outlier because people hated the employees already for various reasons.

For example they thought that twitter had a bloated workforce because of videos like this (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=buF4hB5_rFs).

And a lot of people heavily disagreed with how they handled moderation. You can take things like the hunter Biden laptop suppression or in the funny category you had the getting banned for saying learn to code (https://reason.com/2019/03/11/learn-to-code-twitter-harassme...).

Take random company without controversies and you will find less vitriol about them getting fired.

almatabata··on EV battery prices to fall by nearly 50 pct and near ICE parity by 2026
Would love to read those studies if you have a link. I keep hearing say that in theory EVs should cost less but then you read things like Tesla having very high insurance costs.

When I search online I see a lot of back and forth. Some claim EVs breakdown more other say ICE (https://www.consumerreports.org/cars/car-reliability-owner-s..., https://thedriven.io/2024/03/13/the-data-is-in-evs-far-less-...).

It does feel like who makes the car says more about the reliability than EV or ICE at this point.

almatabata··on Qualcomm cancels Snapdragon Dev Kit, refunds all orders
Genuinely curious how they could not get a linux version running. If they can release a working android version for their other SoCs, what stops them from releasing a working Linux distro?

I know they have tons of proprietary blobs but I suspect they could still just deliver a linux ISO with all the binaries included.

It just smells like someone at Qualcomm did not see the value and cut the budget to the bone. I had my fears around long term software support of those chips. This news makes me even less confident that I trust them to support these chips long term.

almatabata··on It's Time to Stop Taking Sam Altman at His Word
Funnily I came across an interview from around 5 years ago where he straight up admitted that he had no clue how to generate a return on investment back then (see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TzcJlKg2Rc0&t=1920s)

"We have no current plans to make revenue."

"We have no idea how we may one day generate revenue."

"We have made a soft promise to investors that once we've built a general intelligence system, basically we will ask it to figure out a way to generate an investment return for you."

The fact he has no clue how to generate revenue with an AGI without asking it, shows his lack of imagination.

almatabata··on Some Go web dev notes
> Go is a language that I started learning years ago, but did't change dramatically.

A lot of people underrate that quality I feel. C had that quality but pushed it to neurotic levels where it would change so slowly even when it needed to do it faster. Other language in contrast change too fast and try to do too many things at once.

You do not often get credit for providing boring, stable programs that work. I hope they continue to do it this way and do not get seduced into overloading the language.

We have a lot of fast moving languages already, so having one that moves slowly increases potential choice.

almatabata··on Hacking Kia: Remotely Controlling Cars with Just a License Plate
If it only impacted automakers they might do it. However if you apply this standard to cars you will have to apply it to a lot of other sectors. After all why stop at car makers. Why should other appliances not get the same treatment like IoT as well? A lot of other companies would hate to have this standard applied to them hence they lobby against it as well.
almatabata··on Will A.I. Be a Bust? A Wall Street Skeptic Rings the Alarm
It can take responsibility for production code and get fired when it produces sub-standard work?
almatabata··on "Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit a female hostage (2020)
I do not have access to first hand accounts nor detailed records that would allow me to to make such an analysis. I only have access to stories that look irrational from the outside.

I would like to see more rigorous study of it. If they find its nonsense fine. We can move on to something else. They might find something else entirely.

almatabata··on Breaking Down OnlyFans' Economics
Aren't some of the interactions on OF private chats? Kind of like sexting and caming? Let us say you limit it all to one on one private interactions, it still causes the same issues you mention.
almatabata··on "Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit a female hostage (2020)
Well you have many examples of man and women who display this seemingly irrational behavior. Saying its not real leaves the question why the victims side with the perpetrator in those scenarios.
almatabata··on "Stockholm Syndrome" was invented by police to discredit a female hostage (2020)
> It's the kind of idea that is captivating from a literary perspective but doesn't actually make any sense if you think about it

As far as I understand we have no evidence either way that the phenomena has a basis in reality or not. I think we should maybe hold off on the quick judgements and check a bit more before that.

People can behave irrationally.

almatabata··on Breaking Down OnlyFans' Economics
> Any healthy society would ban all OF type content immediately on national security threat grounds

By this logic we should ban all extra marital relationships as well. Add to that mandatory DNA tests for all kids just in case.

People will do things in private that they do not want known. No amount of legislation will fix it.

almatabata··on Breaking Down OnlyFans' Economics
It does not. These companies do not even work in the same problem space. Amazon works in retail, cloud, book publishing, etc. Microsoft maintains their own cloud as well and a complete operating system.

At least compare it to companies with similar businesses. I would argue twitch seems closer. I think they had over 1000 employees. You would have a better point with that comparison if you would want to make that argument.

almatabata··on Breaking Down OnlyFans' Economics
> Would you not have a relationship with someone you like and likes you back?

For a lot of men the knowledge of the OF carrier kills the attraction that they had. Just like some women lose attraction when they learn that you subscribe to OF content.

almatabata··on X can proceed to trial in case against Media Matters after Texas judge ruling
> One District Court judge ruled against a similar suit: https://reason.com/volokh/2024/08/26/judge-preliminarily-blo...

Thanks for the link. The lawsuit looks slightly different to me. They blocked a CID request where they got a request for a bunch of data about their operations. The requester did not manage to make a good case as to why that request had merit and therefore should not get counted as abusive.

The X lawsuit directly alleges that media matters tried to cause financial harm. It looks like X simply made a better argument as to why they had a good case against Media Matters.

> As far as I know, Media Matters never represented that n% of major advertisers' ads were shown next to racist content, just that some ads were, and that seems undisputed.

I had understood it like this as well. Musk alleges that they got the example through contrived means and that they did it purely to hurt X financially.

I do not think he will win but I do think the case merits examination.

almatabata··on X can proceed to trial in case against Media Matters after Texas judge ruling
"maliciously fabricated side-by-side images of various advertisers’ posts on Plaintiff’s social media platform X depicted next to neo-Nazi or 2 other extremist content, and portrayed these designed images as if they were what the average user experiences on the X platform. Plaintiff asserts that Defendants proceeded with this course of action in an effort to publicly portray X as a social media platform dominated by neo-Nazism and anti-Semitism, and thereby alienate major advertisers, publishers, and users away from the X platform, intending to harm it."

It depends on how you read fabricated. I have no legal background so I have no idea exactly how to interpret it. Does it mean that they made it up? Or does it mean that they use roundabout ways to achieve it that a normal user would never do but then imply this happens very regularly?

I think they probably mean the second one for it to make sense to me. In that context I can see the argument making some kind of sense. I do not know if they will win but I can see why the judge allowed it to go to actual court.

almatabata··on Retiring from the Rust for Linux Project – Wedson Almeida Filho
> If there was such a commitment to Rust, why not pull funding and cut a check to Redox?

You have an existent product line running on Linux. It looks like a no brainer to just get rust into Linux so you do not have to rewrite all your userspace code to work on Redox. You can keep your own drivers as well. You can gradually migrate piece by piece.

It looks simpler to fork the existing code base than support a brand new unproven OS where you do not even know if it will perform the same as your current one. The amount of investment looks smaller with the fork but maybe I miss something.

almatabata··on We're living under a flawed Constitution. Let's start over. Rewrite it
He does not make a very good case as to why we need to rewrite it completely and not simply update it. A lot of the principles still hold up to this day. Why make a completely new document if the basics still work. New does not necessarily mean better.

Honestly in this case I will take an old and tested constitution over a brand new one where we have to re-examine and find all the corner cases all over again.

← PreviousPage 2 of 10Next →