HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

altcognito

2,890 karma · joined July 11, 2011

submissionscomments
altcognito··on Claude discovers a novel enzyme system with CRISPR-like repeats
You can't have your cake and eat it too.

Fundamentally the problem with living forever goes beyond billionaires. People get stuck in their ways of thinking, the mindset of living forever is completely different. Why should I even listen to someone who only lives a mere 40 years? What is a suitable punishment for someone that lives forever? How does it change murder?

Philosophically, living forever may be corrupt by nature.

The only way to tear down tiers of society is for some of those tiers to literally die off.

altcognito··on Claude discovers a novel enzyme system with CRISPR-like repeats
Probably should have left off the kids, but lets start with just distrusting anybody who wants to live forever. At the level of influence billionaires have, it is downright dangerous.

For everyone else confused: Think of all the people throughout history we would prefer would not have lived forever. Then multiple that by A LOT. Then consider how greedy and sociopathic most of the billionaire class is already.

Now, we could spend time getting distracted by childless. I don't think it matters.

altcognito··on GPT-6 Sol and Luna
I keep repeating this too.

The history of the self driving car is apt to repeat as well. I remember thinking "2015, 2018 maybe at the latest." But as 2015 (and 2018) came and went, expectations were tempered.

We will see shortened development cycles, and maybe even orders of magnitude shorter development cycles.

But hard problems remain hard (there are only so many chips, materials research and biology are difficult problems). Manufacturing remains a choke point.

I'm more concerned that the absolute worst persons on the planet are in charge of many of these technologies. If those that are in charge are more concerned about allocating resources and power in their favor, the more dismal the future of all humanity will be (including for those in charge, but they can't see that due to self-interest bias)

altcognito··on Apple has added persistent 'ads' to iOS, and it's driving users crazy
I mean sure but reality is pesky. Most ads buys are targeted. Once a company has accepted putting ads in, difficult to know when they've started allowing information gathering. Technically it is already the case that companies sell targeting information before they accept ads even.
altcognito··on Strands Harness
Agreed, especially since the more frontier models are able to accomplish in a vacuum, the more people will trust them. That being said, tool use is still really important for pulling in the right information.
altcognito··on People hooked on vapes try a new way to quit: cigarettes
It needs influencers!
altcognito··on GPT-6 Sol and Luna
I would describe it as "fidelity" and "verbosity" (or just amount of token generation to complete the task, sometimes that works out to scratch space, or literally how large the "solution" is).

If you have something that needs to be done right, might be a bit complicated, up the model size.

You can see this in the pelicans. Big model pelicans are pretty accurate by default. Up the reasoning and only more so, but with more detail. For Astra, it is 105 lines for low, 250 lines for max reasoning.

Small model pelicans will lack the fidelity of a large model. Bits will be out of place etc. For luna, it's 90 lines for low, 150 lines for xhigh.

Additionally the amount of time taken is increased for the larger models. Luna takes 11 seconds on low, and 1:33 for xhigh. Astra is 33 seconds on low, 4 minutes on max.

And naturally, there is the cost. There's some overlap in functionality between luna xhigh and Astra low in the sense that luna really can do quite a suitable job for some tasks. But there are just some tasks that just don't make sense for Luna, even at high reasoning.

The other thing to remember is that sometimes high fidelity isn't ideal. It can lead to overdesigning. My recommendation is to commit early, commit often, and review everything you do, which we've all been doing since before LLMs right?

altcognito··on OpenAI is about to eat Jev's lunch – Arcturus Labs
Keeping people looped into your product is pretty important, but yeah, there's not clean way currently to separate "structured" outputs from the token stream and to start using a different billing structure there. And I also appreciate that they aren't going to be keen on gving free or near free output either, so gotta figure that.
altcognito··on Apple has added persistent 'ads' to iOS, and it's driving users crazy
Can't have ads and tell me you're privacy focused.
altcognito··on OpenAI is well positioned to fast-follow Jev
I don't see it fundamentally any different than knowing when to use a tool. Is this tool like RAG an important enough corner case to train for it? I dunno.

LLMs already shell out and write code to solve certain problems. This is just a special case of that.

altcognito··on AI Has No Wisdom and Neither Will You
Yeah, it's not just over-engineering, it is just that generic systems that look like everything else usually don't solve a business problem, but I think I would be less dismissive of its world model in general.

LLMs are not a "random walk", they take in information and they explore the space according to the way they've been instructed.

altcognito··on AI Has No Wisdom and Neither Will You
You should definitely try it if you haven't already. Most of the models are deeply familiar with domain specific areas in ways that most of us aren't. In fact, I would say the problem is generally the opposite. If model size and effort is is high, it will over architect what an app needs. I find myself reigning in a giant email notification system with subscriptions and "channels" and other such nonsense when sometimes you just want a simple one off.
altcognito··on How OpenAI Used Its Own LLMs to Design Its Jalapeño Chip
Something we can all agree with is we need more foundries and green power.
altcognito··on Bend – A language that blocks AI mistakes via proof, on CPU and GPU
Thanks for your time.

I tried the demo, and I ask it modify the game (hitting the w button immediately proceeds to the flag) and it doesn't do it but does something else. Is that the desired outcome? I think the desired outcome would be "What you're asking for doesn't make sense given the rule."

altcognito··on T. Rex Had a Body Temperature of 97°F
They compared against crocodilian teeth and those teeth were at a different temperature. Crocodilian teeth are known to be at a similar temperature to their environment because they are known to be cold blooded.

It is correct to say that we don't know they were warm blooded, just that their body temps were likely the given observed temperature.

altcognito··on AWS says it can't restore some data from mideast facilities struck by Iran
I was unaware that Amazon even sold single AZ S3. 20% discount. Doesn't seem worth it. By the time I commit to purchasing S3 space, it has to be important data.

I get that S3 is convenient and reasonably performant, but it is not cheap at all.

altcognito··on ImpactGate: A merge gate that scores the structural decay AI adds
Isn't this just static code analysis? We have tools for this.
altcognito··on OpenAI expands ChatGPT ads with Sponsored Agents
So you can pay $8 a month and see ads while using the already pared down offering.

I think pushing back with cancellations is the only way forward.

altcognito··on Big AI sets out its terms for regulatory capture
> I think they're saying America ended up positioning itself as the loser because they framed things as a zero-sum game.

I didn't bother responding earlier, and I'm not sure why I'm responding now because I don't think "because they framed things as a zero-sum game." explains anything, and it sounds like something that sounded like a retort but offered without any evidence means nothing.

altcognito··on Introducing System One Models and Jev
If it is so cheap, why such a limited release?
altcognito··on Cartesian – AI 3D Modeling for Design
> CAD is only half of the design process

I'm not a mechanical engineer but I would be surprised if it was even 30% of the process. Materials, manufacturability, durability, fitting into other requirements. Some of those things can be part of the CAD design, but there's so much more.

Not to say that CAD isn't a big chunk!

altcognito··on Big AI sets out its terms for regulatory capture
No, that is exactly what you were getting at:

> China played the smart long game and took advantage of America's...

Zero sum games imply that if there is a winner, there has to be a loser. That one country takes advantage of another.

altcognito··on Big AI sets out its terms for regulatory capture
China deliberately adopted western style market institutions. They joined the WTO. No, they aren't a fully westernized market, but they are closer to a competitive marketplace than the state dictating all of what will or will not be built.

I'm confused, what has America and the west lost the plot on? You would have preferred the west to exploit China more?

This framing of a zero sum game is counterproductive.

altcognito··on Defining AI Psychosis. Part 2: "Prolific AI Psychosis"
> Is it that psychiatrists in general could maybe use this label, but you know this one is doing it wrong? Otherwise, who is allowed to use the term?

I specifically take issue with the weak standard used.

> Doesn't it kinda inspire you at least a little to reflect on your understanding of the particular term? Or should we understand that to be faultless here?

Is there a way to read this that isn't insulting? Do I need to reflect on my understanding until it matches yours?

> In general, the definition we need to have here is that psychosis is always extreme and violent and pretty much matching the cultural trope we have for it? And anything less is incorrect usage? Is that why you disagree in explicit terms?

Never said any of that. It's a medical term and carries weight. Core symptoms are hallucinations and delusions. Here, delusions is not "my corporate product is better than your corporate product", it is not a strongly held belief that isn't real. We don't call belief in God psychosis. (some do, but that's beside the point)

altcognito··on Defining AI Psychosis. Part 2: "Prolific AI Psychosis"
Also a luddite is not thought of as a danger to others. The label of psychosis implies otherwise. Luddite extends beyond AI

Whataboutism is a plague.

That said, calling folks luddites is an annoyance.

altcognito··on Defining AI Psychosis. Part 2: "Prolific AI Psychosis"
A bad business decision is not psychosis. Misjudging the value provided by a product is not psychosis.
altcognito··on Defining AI Psychosis. Part 2: "Prolific AI Psychosis"
As someone else point out, the term is stigmatizing, psychosis is a very strong term, and as I very much noted, already being misused and abused.
altcognito··on Defining AI Psychosis. Part 2: "Prolific AI Psychosis"
I did dig into that after I read it. Even more depressing honestly. He should know better than to throw around labels.
altcognito··on Defining AI Psychosis. Part 2: "Prolific AI Psychosis"
People really need an entire article to justify labeling someone as having a mental illness because in their opinion, the their coworker isn't contributing meaninfully, or potentially making things worse.

FTA: > Prolific AI psychosis occurs when a person generates a large quantity of AI output without significantly increasing the real value of their work.

Guy, we used to just call this a bad coworker.

I'm pretty sure that the "psychosis" will be abused by folks that just don't like AI. You already see it everywhere.

altcognito··on Building a Wall Lamp from Scratch
Yeah, I was really impressed with the style of the project but got a little triggered by the extruded aluminum. "I don't want to pay a lot" -- proceeds to use engineered metals. And while it is convenient, it is softer and more likely to bend out of shape than just regular wood.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →