2,068 karma · joined September 29, 2009
Web front-end specialist looking for a job with an ethically-aligned company
http://eleven-twelve.net
http://github.com/alxndr
http://drwxrxrx.bsky.social
email: YWx4bmRyK2huQGdtYWlsLmNvbQo=
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/alxndr; my proof: https://keybase.io/alxndr/sigs/B-vRl0kOw2kpqag-RlOReucueGiSJi-u5Ef4CTQ_TkI ]As for "police routinely pull video ... to establish fault" -- this is just one example, but recently in DC there was a bike-and-car crash in which a surveillance video proved the cyclist was not at fault, but the police refused to even look at it: http://greatergreaterwashington.org/post/19284/it-must-have-...
I have been paying attention in a city for a while. I have seen the situation you describe, but it's rare in my experience, even with SF supposedly full of reckless fixie-riders. Dangerous driving is far more common in my experience.
My common-sense understanding of the difference is that a cyclist can more readily hear what is happening near an intersection, has fewer visual obstacles to see what is near an intersection, and is often already moving slower than a car. That makes me feel that a cyclist rolling through a stop sign is far less dangerous than a car doing the same.
My experience has been in SF/Oakland/Berkeley.
Anyway, the reason I added that link in the earlier comment was to illustrate my frustration with the "all cyclists break laws all the time, they need to be safer like cars" fable -- the article links to a study that found that by 1996, only 1% of cars stopped at the stop sign being observed. Of course there are cyclists who break laws, but there are far more drivers who break laws, and they are the more dangerous offenders.
http://www.cyclelicio.us/2013/stop-sign-compliance-temecula-...
However, in places with vehicles going differing speeds, I would put the onus of safety on the faster vehicles.
And then look at the resulting injuries.
http://bicycleuniverse.info/transpo/almanac-safety.html
Some recent headlines about how NYPD handles car-and-bike collisions:
"Another Cyclist Killed at East Harlem Intersection, NYPD Again Blames Victim"
"Motorist Havoc: Two Dead, Five Hurt, Kids in Critical Condition, No Charges"
"Cleared in Traffic Court, Hit-and-Run Killer Still Employed at NYC DOT"
"Leroy Comrie Bill Would Force NYPD to Report to Council on Hit-and-Runs"
"Hynes: No Charges for Curb-Jumper Who Blew Red and Killed Pedestrian"
"NYPD: Pedestrian Killed Himself by Running Into Stopped Police Cruiser"
"Cyclist’s Brother Says NYPD Closed Investigation Into Unsolved Death"
"Immune From Prosecution, Curb-Jumping NYC Motorists Claim More Victims"
"Irvin Gitlitz, 83, Was First of Two Pedestrian Fatalities Wednesday" (which notes, "The truck involved in the crash that killed Irvin Gitlitz did not have required crossover mirrors. The driver was not summonsed," and for the second fatality, "No summonses were issued")
...and those headlines are just going back to April of this year. http://www.streetsblog.org/category/issues-campaigns/nypd-cr...
Quite the opposite, in fact. In NYC, drivers are seldom cited at all even when a cyclist or pedestrian has been killed. Here's the link I have on hand, but there are more http://www.streetsblog.org/2012/08/03/nypd-7371-pedestrians-...
However, in this constructed situation, it seems to me that the driver is being more unsafe by driving that fast.
You've seen cars stop on the east coast?!? Not me...
Maybe you shouldn't be driving.
This is completely untrue, at least in NYC.
"Historically, nearly half of motorists who kill a New York City pedestrian or cyclist do not receive so much as a citation for careless driving."
http://www.streetsblog.org/2012/08/03/nypd-7371-pedestrians-...
This is untrue.
"The coming of the railways in the 1830s killed off the stage-coach trade; almost all rural roads reverted to low-level local use. Cyclists were the first group in a generation to use roads and were the first to push for high-quality sealed surfaces and were the first to lobby for national funding and leadership for roads. Without cyclists, motorists wouldn't have hit the ground running when it came to places to drive this new form of transport."
I wonder how much this rings true for anyone currently at Google.
"Viewport argument key "http://www1.staging.mcdonalds.com/gtw/displayimage.do?image_... not recognized and ignored."
Or worse: requiring the spaces. Or maybe they want dashes.