HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

amedvednikov

1,578 karma · joined November 15, 2016

submissionscomments
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Exactly. The amount of nitpicking is ridiculous.

There's an entire article half of which is about a single checker bug that has already been fixed.

Or claims like "it uses official system api (libc), therefore you can't say it doesn't have dependencies".

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
> I read this argument in the issue too. How is that remotely relevant?

How is that remotely irrelevant?

What kind of behavior do you expect?

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
How's the first link an attack for asking simple questions?

(By the way there's not a single question there.)

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
vpm has been restarted, I'll move it to another server soon, this one is too busy
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Yes, that's also the vibe I got.
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Agree to disagree. An author saying that proves the bias and the attack angle.
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Because these articles are meant to stay for years.

People will keep linking to them and say "didn't you see? V uses shell to do http requests! what a joke"

This most recent article by an anonymous author had all of the issues fixed within several days, but it wasn't updated, it'll stay like this forever, as planned.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
So people calling me a fraud and a scammer are not attacking me?
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Integer overflow works as expected, like in C.
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
The post is unnecessarily hostile. Created by a new anonymous account, with the goal of attacking V and "not recommending to use it". Also with referencing the notorious ridiculous "V is vaporware" articles, it's pretty clear what the goal of the author was.

It'd take 10 minutes to submit github issues, instead they spent a month on this.

Null is only allowed in unsafe code.

Overwriting of len was never fixed, because it was never an issue in the first place. The author made it up. It's always worked like in Go.

Included libraries, you mean the json library that's part of vlib. So each Go program that uses net.http also has library dependencies by this logic.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
All the issues in the post have already been fixed.

What's wrong with the division by zero issue? It works just like in Go?

What about the openssl issue? The user didn't install the library on Windows, as was documented.

By the way, we're going to embed openssl to avoid this problem.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
> frustration from dealing with low effort snipes/trolls

That's exactly what it is :)

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Interesting. I have always felt the opposite. It's always been stable for me, that's why I rewrote V in V so early.

We also have thousands of tests.

Do you have any examples?

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Only I can ban, and I haven't banned anyone in 2 years. You can read my comments here about the attacks.

There's actual valid criticism and feedback like in https://github.com/vlang/v/discussions/7610

But there's also trolling, harassment, and completely baseless attacks.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Sure:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19086589

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
This user is not a member of the V team, and never contributed to the V project.

He enjoys language development and submits his feedback and ideas, discusses other ideas etc.

I do not work as a big censor and read every single of the thousands of messages, and I do not have time to do it.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
I'm sorry but that makes completely no sense. "Why didn't you release software without any bugs?"

That's not how the world works. And it's open source, where hundreds of contributors help you find and fix these bugs. That's the whole point.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
So can you list the "false claims about language capabilities" here?
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Thank you for the support!
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
You have a very strange definition of a lie. There's a working example. Anyone can run it and inspect it, it's all open source.

Autofree hasn't been a priority because of how unexpectedly well the GC is performing with V, but it will be finished.

All this is clearly stated on the website.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
1. Windows/Linux/macOS/Android/iOS/pi/WASM/*BSD/Haiku/SerenityOS

2. For stuff like i++ expressions, V allows them. Some stuff gets translated to adapted V code. Some (~2% of the syntax) will result in an error. Those will be fixed this year.

3. Memory safe, bounds checking, C ABI.

4. Ridiculously easy. The main reason it was created (was using Go before). Just run `C.foo(1,2,3)`. Use C2V to generate V wrappers.

5. Only system threads for now.

6. Same as with C. Need export "C".

7. Very stable, at least for me. Never had a crash/segfault.

8. Hard to pick. Fast compilation, hot code reloading, nice clean sum types, clean json serialization and ORM (mysql,sqlite,postgres).

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
There are indeed lots of examples in the top directory `examples/`.

Also there's a big link on vlang.io, top menu.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Thanks!

This is how GitHub started to support V:

https://github.com/github/linguist/pull/4564

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Without any evidence? Really? Here's the account I was talking about: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=vlang1dot0

Everything else can be found in the "V is scam" articles. There will be a big article by me covering all that.

"Immature" != "not ready for production".

Regarding that immaturity comment, here's a good summary by someone else from this thread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31945442

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Yeah that's true. And searching for it in chats is a pain. Lots of youtube.com?v= links instead...
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
A 0.3 language feature that is marked as "not ready for production" on the website have bugs. How unexpected.
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Can you please list here the huge promises that could never be kept?

1. 2. 3.

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
Is "I think it is something that should be ignored until it dies into obscurity" different from "I think it should die"?
amedvednikov··on V 0.3
There are 0 false claims about language capabilities on the website or in the docs.

If you can link one, that'd be great, and it'll be fixed. I've spent a lot of time verifying all claims are valid.

For example there was the "functions are pure by default except IO" which caused lots of criticism and memes. I simply changed the wording to a more verbose but correct phrase. So we do admit shortcomings and not make up excuses "for each of them"

We do not delete criticisms, we actually welcome them and any kind of feedback:

https://github.com/vlang/v/discussions/7610

amedvednikov··on V 0.3
It does work, and there's a 1.5 year old working demo:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gmB8ea8uLsM

0 GC is used.

None of the people who ever donated or are still donating felt they were being scammed. They often write about this here on HN.

← PreviousPage 6 of 26Next →