776 karma · joined May 1, 2019
Isn't that making the same point I made: local knowledge matters.
Work is just work. I get to see my kids more. I have more time. That is going to trump anything work related.
Watching the movie Slackers (2002) recently was eye opening. You'd think this weird conspiracy thing was recent, but Slackers shows it predated the mass adoption of the internet.
I find it hard to imagine where this ends.
Can't have free speech because too many voters are conspiracy nuts. Can't ban content because free speech.
The level of ignorance has to be seen to be believed, on sites like 4chan.
Education can clear this impasse, but is it too late?
What is more useful? A factory that makes shoes for your population or a vault of gold? Gold has a role, but factories are king. This is why the USA is so, so screwed in handing over manufacturing to China. Americans usually criticize China by stating that they will stop consuming and what will China do? Nuts.
I'd encourage banks to lend into productive industries by taxing land, not labour (and properly tax externalities like pollution) , capturing publicly created location value and allowing wealth creators to retain more (all?) of the value they create.
---
Replying to the sibling comment as yet again after typing "rent seeking" => "you're submitting too fast". Surprise!
---
I think we should tax things that have an opportunity cost or externality.
If you keep gold in a vault, assuming there is enough for industrial production (if not you have a lot of gold!), then please continue to do so. It doesn't impact me.
If you hold land I and others cannot use it. You did not create it, society should be compensated via a tax, as the land itself has value due to society at large. A square plot in the middle of nowhere is worth considerably less than a square plot in NY.
If you dump sewage into a river or burn lots of coal, you are also damaging the common wealth.
Not trying in case we accidentally inhibit a few rich financiers from become even more rich, where the prize of extricating ourselves from what is fast becoming a nightmare mess is left untouched, is a mistake.
This is the board voting the board gets a pay rise.
Rational, even, when considered within an utterly flawed framework.
That's the scale of the challenge to dig yourselves out of.
The execs getting the bonus know regulators won't come after them.
The execs getting the bonus know the media won't name and shame them.
The execs getting the bonus know that nobody in their social circle will shun them.
The execs getting the bonus don't even think this is wrong, as the main aim is to grab what you can when you can, and if it's immoral, well someone should change the rules.
Yes laws need changing, but laws are set by culture, ultimately.
This is a deep, deep cultural problem that is killing the USA, and I've yet to see it acknowledged anywhere in the mainstream.
It does not represent Adam Smith, who disliked rentiers:
> “As soon as the land of any country has all become private property, the landlords, like all other men, love to reap where they never sowed and demand a rent even for its natural produce.”
They do not make their prospectus visible. If you do not subscribe you cannot even read their principals. In any case writing one thing down and doing another is very common. The Economist is obsessed with financialisation and cheer-led the utter mess the UK and USA are in for decades.
Obviously it's up to each person if they continue to read it. I dispute it's quality, I think it's neoliberal propaganda and nothing more.
I agree, it holds rentier activity on par with wealth creation, which Adam Smith would never have done.
https://www.prosper.org.au/geoists-in-history/adam-smith-on-...
It is massively incompatible.
Who works on this software? Who wants to go to an interview with "workflow and usability lead on service now, 5 years" on their CV!
The analysis from a journal that purports to be about economics should have come in the build up to the crisis, not when the first huge cracks appear in the damn, having spent the prior decade shouting "put more water in".
Adam Smith, whom they model themselves after, was against rentier activity, The Economist is not.
The UK is presently embroiled in negotiating all kinds of trade agreements as part of Brexit, and none of the countries will be signing a reciprocal "free trade" agreement between the two, it's a pipe dream.
In addition, Smith would have been appalled at the UK running a huge deficit ad-infinitum, selling off land to pay for it, and generally making very little. The Economist has very little to do with classic liberals. What The Economist supports now is lunacy, and we've seen in the response to Covid in the UK and the USA that both countries are on their knees.
Again: I find it slavishly neo-liberal.
I used to read The Economist, then in the build up to 2008 when according to them all the growth was actual real growth, the system was fine, and banks knew what they were doing.
I no longer read it.