HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

amirrajan

423 karma · joined September 22, 2012

Indie Game Developer. Creator of The Ensign, A Noble Circle, and #1 iOS Game: A Dark Room. :wq

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/amirrajan; my proof: https://keybase.io/amirrajan/sigs/vTvNvCPeqjQN_n88TcbRK5Q0OtHsP3n0zIo1-Q66KaI ]

submissionscomments
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
Loved it. Thanks for sharing. Survivorship bias is a problem imho.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
Mildly Interesting RTS looks pretty good to be honest. Have you downloaded it? It's surprisingly a lot of fun. Solid review score too.

Oh and totally give A Dark Room a shot. You may find it pretty okay.

PS: I'm totally gonna frame this comment thread. I'm big fan Braid and The Witness. You? Not so much :-)

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
>there's got to be interesting, useful knowledge in there for other game dev and future generations.

There is, but "the few ruined it for the many". Some who got access to that information tried to "growth hack" their way to a successful app. They started name dropping me to Apple as if they knew me. This isn't a very nice thing to do.

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
I'm really really happy that ADR gave you some (hopefully) great moments during your commute. Seeing thing comment means the world to me (it really, truly does).

If you get a chance, download A Noble Circle and play it with your child. You may find that you can connect over it's ridiculous story and crazy gameplay. I'd love any feedback you may have about it.

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
You’d be surprised at how many variations exist out there. Source: app developer who has had 300k downloads of his Android port and has dealt with death threats from people trying to run his game on a device that has the processing power of a toaster.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
The entire write up was me explicitly stating that it was dumb and that there was an immense amount of luck involved.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
During my free time I did a good amount of contract work with small companies. They loved what they did and it was energizing. But what they love working on isn’t what I love working on which is in essence: “artistic, evocative experiences”. Yes I’ve invested in a closet full of turtle neck sweaters while I continue my search for my “magnum opus”.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
It works great on the devices I’ve tested on. Which is like 4 out of the 15,000 possible OS+Device+Carrier combinations.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
>questionable decisions

That’s an understatement.

>His only hit was porting someone else’s game

Yep. He’s a hack job for sure. There is no way he’ll be successful in future stuff tbh.

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
Not courageous. Really stupid.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
+1. This guy took a huge risk and is an idiot. He got stupid lucky.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
That sucks. I’d spend more time on the Android version. But there is a really high piracy rate. Buy a Samsung Galaxy S8, it was tested on there.

Both Michael and I appreciate the hat tip you gave us by buying it. Email me and I’ll glady refund your $0.99.

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
This comment made my day. Thank you :-)

I should have written it after my morning coffee.

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
Mad props to you. Email me and we’ll exchange war stories.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: From Sabbatical Year to $800k
I give you my Armchair Expert of the Year Award. Congrats :-)

Must be nice to live in a world without having to give Apple 30%, insurance premiums, taxes, and royalties/partnership splits.

Take this comment in good spirit. We all make mistakes. Nothing but love for you. Go build awesome things. Hire a CPA for all the math related stuff.

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
Legally, they have every right to do this. This clone doesn't bother me because it's free and looks like it doesn't monetize on ads either (they just PhoneGap'ed the game and made it playable on touch devices). There is a serious gray area now with regards to ADR's trademark and brand (and developers taking advantage of the open source version/brand for personal gain).

EDIT: welp. it looks like he has ads.... :-(

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
It was definitely soul crushing the first 100 times. The UK is particularly critical. I've gotten used to seeing "dull, rubbish, pretentious, scam" from UK reviews. Still stings just a little bit though.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
All the nice reviews do indeed raise spirits. The most wonderful moments are when I get an email from a kid that is now inspired to get into programming and start building games. So yes, thank you for the kinds words! :fistbump:
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
We thought about it, but the moment you do that, the game is marked as "offers in-app purchases". At initial glance (if you don't take the time to actually look at what purchases are available), you're left thinking that it's "yet another game that'll present a pay wall when I'm about to finish it".
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
Tough call. I get a small taste of what he went through. You start to question the value of the game when you get reviews like this (but 10x worse for a top free game):

>Garbage ★ by XxlCraiglxX - Version 1.6 - Jun 13, 2014

>It's so nice to have this hive-mind community full of hipsters and morons raving about the worst goddamn games. Same thing happened with Angry Birds and Flappy Birds. You people are disgusting. Horrible unwashed masses of brainless consumers. Hey morons, take a step back and really consider the piece of crap you rated 5 stars. No, really, just take a moment.

The entire experience has been a roller coaster. Every time ADR hits a top spot, I dream about a future where I don't have to work a 9-5. But then it drops, and those dreams are taken away. That being said, 50k a day would definitely bring me to that goal quickly (just not the case for me).

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
>Based on... what?

Okay. Let me make sure sure everything is crystal clear:

- I found the game online via a tweet.

- Viewed source and saw's Michael's contact information.

- Emailed him and asked him if I could do a for-pay rendition of it on iOS and that I'd split profits with him.

- He agreed.

- I built it with his oversight/input.

- He get's a 50% royalty on all sales.

- And now? Well, Michael and I get to deal with ADR clones that just wrap the original via PhoneGap.

- And what do the clone say when we try to report them to Apple? "hey! it's open source!"

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
We didn't want to break the immersion. ADR simply wants to be that game you pay for one time up front and enjoy (hopefully). No strings attached. We simply request that you gift the game to someone else if you like it :-)
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
For the UK, I really have no idea unfortunately.

For the US, I think the age profile are kids in middle school and high school. Just from what I've heard from my friends, the game spread like wild fire through schools. This is my current working theory especially since the game dropped significantly in rank the moment summer started.

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
We wanted to add more to the game, but at some point you have to pull back on your urge to tack on more things. So from that standpoint ADR is done.

If your rank is low, release, and release often. Don't sweat the reviews (use them as a means to gain feedback from the people who've downloaded the game). You can also make your app free for a couple of days which will bring in new eyes (you lose your rank if you do that, so just be aware).

As for being a top ranked app (and in my case, a top ranked app that lives and dies by its reviews), I really can't release a new version unless I add something that significantly increases end user engagement.

For example: v1.5 of the game hit the number one spot, and dropped to #2 18 days later. The moment it dropped I released v1.6 of the game which added developer commentary from me and Michael. We went back to #1 for 2 days after a week long slump. That being said, I compared numbers after the fact and our review conversion rates only increased by ~0.2%.

Full write up here: http://amirrajan.net/a-dark-room/#secondwind

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
No ads. No IAP. We didn't wan't to break the immersion or cripple the gameplay in a way that would encourage someone to buy an IAP.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
Drowning came out ~5 months afterwards. And yes, it's such a nice, poetic experience.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
We made ADR free for two days back when it wasn't doing well. In that two day period we received ~15k downloads (and we weren't even a ranked game at the time).

There is an order of magnitude difference between the downloads rates for premium vs free apps (probably 2x). So it is entirely possible that a top ranked free app gets a ton of downloads a day relative to a top ranked paid app.

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
We've had 630k downloads to date. 30% goes to Apple. Michael and I split the rest. From my half, the IRS gets 45%. So my net so far is $120k.

Now, given that we're no where near the #1 spot, we're averaging about $1,000 a day. But that figure is dropping too. ADR is a depreciating asset with a life span of two years I'd say (making this assumption based on what I've seen with other paid apps and their rank history).

amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
This is false. Of course Michael is benefitting from the sales and the work he put in.
amirrajan··on A Dark Room: The Best-Selling Game That No One Can Explain
Michael issued me a license, and he gets a 50% royalty. It would have been extremely sleezy of me if I profited from this without including Michael. Even if it were entirely legal.

Additionally, I didn't write the game in JavaScript. So none of the original source was used. I used a snapshot Michael gave me as a reference and rewrote the entire thing from scratch in RubyMotion.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →