HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

amscanne

2,031 karma · joined July 30, 2010

submissionscomments
amscanne··on 20k federal workers take "buyout" so far, official says
That would be a separate issue, those are not the terms of a buy-out package initiated after the acquisition, but rather wanting to enforce the terms of their original agreements (because Musk terminated them).
amscanne··on In my life, I've witnessed three elite salespeople at work
Yeah, but it’s “your realtor” through that transaction, unless they are fired. Regardless, most successful realtors have repeat clients, for buying and selling (even if it’s years between transactions).
amscanne··on In my life, I've witnessed three elite salespeople at work
My archetype of a good sales person is the successful realtor. Realtors tend to “eat what they can kill”, so you can see the skills power law clearly. They are selling themselves more than houses, but there’s a lot to learn from that.

Some people love their realtors, although they do very little for their outlandish commissions. They do however, guide you through the process and give you transactional advice. Like any sales person, they generally have an interest in the transaction closing but they are only trusted if they come off as acting in your interest. That trust can ultimately help the transaction close — this is the line that I think good sales people walk.

amscanne··on Tesla confirms delivery of 495,570 EVs, way below its own guidance
And how many people who threatened to “move to Canada” did so? I don’t doubt that Elon’s antics will have an impact, but in my experience the actions people take may be different when the rubber meets the road. Your friends may be less idealistic (or changed by the world) in a few years, and some concerns may be weighed differently.

I don’t think there’s a valid universal “hybrids are better” conclusion; it all depends on your specific needs and what you value. A single car for a single person is different than a family with multiple cars. For an electric car, Tesla still makes a compelling product (and while competitors in the US are getting much better, notably Hyundia/Kia, Tesla still feels like the market leader).

amscanne··on Microsoft Confirms Password Deletion for 1B Users
You’re loosely describing a CSRF vulnerability, which do occur but people try to design against them and mitigate them. For example, actions that mutate often require POST (which won’t be triggered by a link), cookies may be marked strict (and not sent from frames or following links), etc.
amscanne··on Man ran 700 miles to make 'insanely impressive' art on GPS fitness app
Why do you say this? I used to live right in the center of the stick figure, and regularly did the loop up around Christie Pits or down around Trinity Bellwoods. Those streets are great for running, not boring at all.
amscanne··on The Billionaire Is The Threat, not the Solution
Looking at inflation-adjusted dollars or even fraction-of-GDP, Biden has spent more on stimulus and new investment programs than the entirety of the New Deal. So what gives? Maybe it’s not a capital problem.
amscanne··on The Billionaire Is The Threat, not the Solution
You should share the secret of how to “correctly invest”, because the point of the parent comment was that it’s not about the capital
amscanne··on We can now fix McDonald's ice cream machines
I don’t think the surprise was based on the head of the executive, rather it was based on the DOJ taking a stance in favor of exemptions.

I just get tired of the idea that the president/executive completely colors every single government action. Let’s stop pretending that every election will completely rewrite the MO and agendas for every agency.

The comment I replied to was based on exactly those kinds of assumptions (“couldn’t possibly imagine this happening under Trump”) and was wrong. Now you’re just doing a no-true-Scotsman (“oh, it only happened because he wasn’t paying attention”).

I’ve personally seen no evidence that right-to-repair is a partisan issue in the way you’ve suggested, and I’ve seen plenty of evidence that the cronyism charges you’re levying are also not limited to a single party. You can hate the guy for lots of reasons, but the idea that Trump is uniquely capable of being bought on this issue seems very strange to me.

amscanne··on We can now fix McDonald's ice cream machines
Prepare to have your mind blown: https://www.techdirt.com/2018/07/11/shocker-dojs-computer-cr...
amscanne··on Ilya Sutskever's SSI Inc raises $1B
Cost of living is extremely high in Tel Aviv, but the rest is true.
amscanne··on Home Assistant Presence Simulation
That’s totally different from needing to reboot.
amscanne··on Home Assistant Presence Simulation
It’s not stable if you need to reboot daily.
amscanne··on Judges rule Big Tech's free ride on Section 230 is over
Not at all. It’s merely a question of whether social networks are shielded from liability for their recommendations, recognizing that what they choose to show you is a form of free expression that may have consequences — not an attempt to control that expression.
amscanne··on Canadian Tire Money
Strange, I was not far from there. I can imagine it being accepted at St. Jacob’s, but I suspect that it was a rather special case. I certainly can’t recall any restaurants in Waterloo taking Canadian Tire money. Then again, I never asked. Thanks for humoring me!
amscanne··on Canadian Tire Money
> but it was accepted in many other places like farmer's markets and independent restaurants

Where were you in Canada? I definitely didn’t have the same experience (in the GTA). Lots of Canadian Tire money circulation and regular trips there in my house, but it was not a thing beyond Canadian Tire.

amscanne··on One Million Checkboxes
Such a strange reflection of ourselves that I had the exact same intent and methodology as you.

I’m sure that we were not alone, and there were many of us appeasing the goblins in our brains yelling for order, diligently checking boxes row by row (or some other orderly pattern). If I had landed on the page with every box checked, I would have felt a sense of doneness and left it in that perfect state. It’s so hard to empathize with all these maniacs here who would destroy that beauty just to write “boobs” ;)

amscanne··on We improved the performance of a userspace TCP stack in Go
I don’t think copy/pasting the same response everywhere is better.

IIRC, CloudRun has multiple modes of operation (fully-managed and in a K8s cluster) and different sandboxes for the fully-managed environment (VM-based and gVisor-based). Like everything, performance depends a lot of the specifics — for example, the network depends a lot more on the network path (e.g. are you using a VPC connector?) than it does the specific sandbox or network stack (i.e. if you want to push 40gbps, spin up a dedicated GCE instance.) Similarly, the lack of a persistent disk is a design choice for multiple reasons — if you need a lot of non-tmpfs disk or persistent state, CloudRun might not be the right place for the service.

It sounds like you personally had a bad experience or hit a sharp edge, which sucks and I empathize — but I think you can just be concrete about that rather than projecting with system call times (I’d be happy to give you the reason gen1 sandbox would be slow for a typical heavy python app doing 20,000 stats on startup — and it’s real but not really system calls or anything you’re pointing at,… either way you could just turn on gen2 or use other products, e.g. GCE containers, GKE autopilot, etc.).

I’m not sure what’s wrong with advice re: optimizing for a serverless platform (like global variables). I don’t really think it would be sensible to recompute/rebuild application state on any serverless platform on any provider.

amscanne··on We improved the performance of a userspace TCP stack in Go
A decent while ago, I was the original author of that performance guide. I tried to lay out the set of performance trade-offs in an objective and realistic way. It is shocking to me that you’re spending so much time commenting on a few figures from there, ostensibly w/o reading it.

System call overhead does matter, but it’s not the ultimate measure of anything. If it were, gVisor with the KVM platform would be faster than native containers (looking at the runsc-kvm data point which you’ve ignored for an unknown reason). But it is obviously more complex than that alone. For example, let’s click down and ask — how is it even possible to be faster? The default docker seccomp profile itself installs an eBPF filter that slows system calls by 20x! (And this path does not apply within the guest context.) On that basis, should you start shouting that everyone should stop using Docker because of the system call overhead? I would hope not, because looking at any one figure in isolation is dumb — consider the overall application and architecture. Containers themselves have a cost (higher context switch time due to cgroup accounting, costs to devirtualize namespaces in many system calls, etc.) but it’s obviously worth it in most cases.

The redis case is called out as a worst case — the application itself does very little beyond dispatching I/O, so almost everything manifests as overhead. But if you’re doing something that has 20% overhead, you need hard security boundaries, and fine-grained multi-tenancy can lower costs by 80% it might make perfect sense. If something doesn’t work for you because your trade-offs are different, just don’t use it!

amscanne··on API Shouldn't Redirect HTTP to HTTPS
It’s preventing the theft of the API key. The attack can, at most, replay that specific request (which you could also mitigate with a nonce and expiration).
amscanne··on API Shouldn't Redirect HTTP to HTTPS
Have the authentication header effectively be a signed hash of relevant headers and the full URL, rather than a simple bearer token?
amscanne··on Hurl, the Exceptional Language
Ah got it. I think there’s such a strong convention there, that it would be exceedingly rare to see in pratice. It’s probably allowed just for compat reasons at this point — but I think your point is don’t make that mistake in the first place, not that Go is filled with flagrant violations of the convention.
amscanne··on Hurl, the Exceptional Language
> I'm looking at you, Go.

I’m so confused by this. Unless you use a dot import, isn’t this just bar.*?

amscanne··on Microsoft CTO: Thoughts on OpenAI (2019)
It's funny that people only seem to remember the successes. Seemingly dominant giants fall all the time. Kodak, Nortel, Blockbuster, Blackberry, ...
amscanne··on The French aristocrat who understood evolution 100 years before Darwin
None of that makes sense or works without the idea that traits are the result of continuous random mutations, which is a very non-obvious idea (and very controversial considering the orthodoxy of divine creation — humans were created by god, so what do you mean they are changing?).
amscanne··on XZ backdoor: "It's RCE, not auth bypass, and gated/unreplayable."
It’s true that there’s a precise set of circumstances that would be different for the RCE (the lack of a PAM dance prior, same process group & session, no allocation of a pseudo-terminal, etc.). My point was merely that I don’t think they are commonly encoded in rule sets or detection systems.

It’s certainly possible, but my guess is sshd is likely to have a lot of open policy. I’m really curious if someone knows different and there are hard detection for those things. (Either way, I bet there will be in the future!)

amscanne··on XZ backdoor: "It's RCE, not auth bypass, and gated/unreplayable."
There is no ‘system()’ syscall, and fork/exec would be extremely common for opensshd — it’s what it does to spawn new shells which go on to do anything.

I’m not arguing with the point, but this is a great place to hide — very difficult to have meaningful detection rules even for a sophisticated sysadmin.

amscanne··on U.S. is said to open criminal inquiry into Boeing
The failure here is that the door was not reinspected after the bolts had been removed to “open” it. A reinspection would be required if had been “removed”, and I’d bet that wings are always inspected for proper construction and installation (because there’s no way to “open” the wings).

I don’t believe the parent comment is saying the design is poor, it’s about the process during assembly and maintenance.

amscanne··on The FCC Is Taking Steps to Wind Down the Affordable Connectivity Program
A salesmen selling door-to-door for Verizon said the same thing to me. “You have kids, so you qualify.” I just told him that was not right, but kudos to you for filing a complaint with the FCC.
amscanne··on ICJ orders Israel to prevent genocide in Gaza, stops short of ordering ceasefire
I don’t live in Gaza, nor do any of the Palestinians that I’ve known. I don’t think it’s fair to assume that the opinion sample is going to be representative for many reasons.

An interesting current data point for me is that the overwhelming majority of Palestinians support the actions of Hamas on October 7th specifically. If someone “just wants freedom” but doesn’t support the slaughter and kidnap of innocent Israeli citizens, they would actually be in the minority — so I don’t think your characterization is broadly correct. This isn’t even considering other historical events and opportunities for independent statehood.

← PreviousPage 2 of 23Next →