HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

amznthrowaway5

314 karma · joined December 18, 2019

submissionscomments
amznthrowaway5··on 5 years of leetcode with no progress. I'm giving up
Yeah talent matters a lot and only a small percentage of the population is cut out for intellectually demanding activities like leetcode or any type of programming. People on forums like these are usually living in a bubble, you shouldn't take advice from them. Try to find something else you are good at.
amznthrowaway5··on How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley
Exactly, these comments would result in bans if they were about black people instead of south asians.
amznthrowaway5··on How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley
> Read it again. That’s precisely what happened, followed by clicking the person’s profile to move on to fundamentally shaming the person rather than the problematic idea.

If this was about the groups in his profile, it wouldn't be acceptable. The only reason his comment is acceptable is because he is picking on an easy target.

amznthrowaway5··on How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley
Or black people, any criticism of black people would be met with outrage. So much hypocrisy.
amznthrowaway5··on Researchers looking for mRNA were ridiculed by colleagues
The evaluation of programmers isn't nearly as objective as the evaluation of athletes, and I'm not convinced modafinil and amphetamines have a statistically significant advantage (how much does programming ability even matter for getting ahead anywhere?), let alone a ludicrous one. On the other hand, the advantage from steroids is ludicrous on multiple factors including stamina, recovery, strength etc. The advantage from cheating and lying in the science game is also very high in my experience, although difficult to measure.
amznthrowaway5··on Researchers looking for mRNA were ridiculed by colleagues
At the top level in all competitive sports almost everyone in on banned PEDs, they are simply too advantageous. Even the women take testosterone.
amznthrowaway5··on Researchers looking for mRNA were ridiculed by colleagues
The people using the dishonest tactics will tend to win out, same reason almost everyone in sports uses steroids. Being dishonest is just far, far too advantageous, which is why the "selling yourself" game is disgusting to many.
amznthrowaway5··on Robinhood Play Store listing went from 329K reviews to 180K in few hours
But the giant hedge funds and billionaires aren't corrupt at all and we should all just believe them?

Get real, most economic theory is all nonsense to cover for corruption and insider trading. Everyone can see how bad the economic inequality is getting, greed is mainly from the rich side, not from the so-called "conspiracy theorists"

amznthrowaway5··on We don't need data scientists, we need data engineers
The "scientists" are often far less valuable or have outright negative contribution.
amznthrowaway5··on Prestige in US Today
This is my experience with more sr members at multiple "faang" as well, there is a lot of cheating especially at more senior "engineering" levels, a lot of these people realistically wouldn't cut it as tech support.

I don't understand how these people sleep at night.

amznthrowaway5··on How to Get Promoted
In my experience taking credit for others' work is far more important than doing good work or taking credit for your own work.
amznthrowaway5··on How to Get Promoted
Why would someone "deserve" to be left behind for not boasting about their performance? If people are doing good work, they should be rewarded appropriately.
amznthrowaway5··on David Graeber has died
Can you go into more detail? Because Graeber's post seems quite convincing, and DeLong fails to coherently reply to the accusations.

Graeber went into detail about why DeLong was impossible to ignore, including DeLong apparently creating a twitter bot to attack Graeber (!!).

amznthrowaway5··on Unpopular Opinion – Data Scientists Should Be More End-to-End
Why do you suspect this experience is so rare and unrepresentative, as opposed to yours? It is a company wide problem in the cases I've seen, the scientist positions are not even expected to have junior software engineer level competence in things like programming.
amznthrowaway5··on Unpopular Opinion – Data Scientists Should Be More End-to-End
"In fact, most data science and ML engineers are quite skilled in systems engineering, because you have to do so much work with GPU hardware issues, underlying scientific package management, efficient data transportation, etc."

This does not align with my experience working with many data/applied scientists at very large companies. A lot of them cannot even write basic code or use git commands. The engineers who are capable are often silo'd away from the scientists, and the organizations struggle to produce any real value.

amznthrowaway5··on Dear Google Cloud: Your Deprecation Policy Is Killing You
If you have an understanding of the product, it is not difficult to come up with a convincing story.

MS pay is actually competitive for external hires, although internal raises aren't usually very high.

amznthrowaway5··on The Case Against OOP Is Wildly Overstated
IQ points less or more? I assume you mean OOP requires 10-15 IQ points less, but it is very hard to do OOP correctly so I don't think that's true.
amznthrowaway5··on Physical attractiveness bias in the legal system (2017)
But how strong is the effect? It's not just a binary judgement. People can heavily bias based on features that are borderline irrelevant. Also, you may end up hurting a lot of innocent people by generalizing too much based on some feature that is not causally associated with the actual crime, even if it predicts well overall.

Are you comfortable applying this same bayesian logic to other factors like race?

amznthrowaway5··on Elite Disillusionment
I've worked on beloved products and I also disagree. These orgs are full of cutthroat psychopathic politicians much more than people who care about the products. They often run on their monopoly status and fail to create any new value.
amznthrowaway5··on The Illustrated Guide to a PhD
Lots of people get these degrees simply for the status aspect. I take meaningful Github OSS contributions much more seriously than PhDs, given all the garbage I have seen in academia. I don't understand how that can be called anecdotal when you can pick up any scientific journal and see that most of the papers are usually trash.
amznthrowaway5··on The Illustrated Guide to a PhD
Well my point was meant to be that it is not a good indicator. I don't know if they fail as much as non-phds, but there are just so many better signals than the PhD itself to go off of, a PhD by itself is not impressive.

And it's well known that if you are smart and start working out of undergrad instead of getting a phd you usually end up significantly ahead in terms of earnings and on the corporate ladder.

amznthrowaway5··on The Illustrated Guide to a PhD
My point was a PhD alone should not be taken as an indicator of skill, it is a very weak signal at best and is no substitute for good evidence of ability. Showing that most who are extremely successful have a PhD does not prove that having a PhD itself is a good indicator of ability, even a small amount of real evidence will override that information. This is why things like basic leetcode interviews are so important, "phds" will often fail these.
amznthrowaway5··on The Illustrated Guide to a PhD
> But it is important to remember what you are doing. In a PhD you should be pushing the boundary of knowledge. As a programmer in a company, you should be solving problems to generate value for your customer and your company.

You don't need to get a phd to push the boundaries of knowledge, and often people who get phds aren't actually doing that. PhD is just a fake status indicator like an MBA.

A lot of work that generates real value is also pushing the boundaries of science. Good scientific work often has real world impact.

I noticed you used "programmer" to refer to the person working in a company, but programming is also an essential skill for pushing the boundaries in just about any field now. Many "scientists" are not capable of it and look upon it as grunt work, which says a lot about their true competence.

amznthrowaway5··on The Illustrated Guide to a PhD
Meaningless spam, advertises as a guide to PhD and gives a few meme images. Academia is very political, I saw senior folk looking down on writing actual code while glorifying corruption and the publishing of fraudulent or meaningless papers. These are closer to the realities you have to deal with getting a "PhD", even in computer science.
amznthrowaway5··on Hiring Without Whiteboards
Leetcode implies all of those, and just like in mathematics competitions, being able to solve these problems implies a high level of ability.
amznthrowaway5··on The Four Quadrants of Conformism
Banning discussion of fraught topics doesn't just affect the discussion about the fraught topics themselves, it also leads to biased and often meaningless discussion of every single other topic where the fraught stuff is an important factor. To have a meaningful discussion you need to be able to challenge base assumptions, you cannot do that here.
amznthrowaway5··on Ask HN: Is all of FAANG like this?
Eventually the accumulated sweatshop tech debt and incompetent management with no technical understanding result in teams not being able to accomplish anything, and situations like the one OP and his team are stuck in.
amznthrowaway5··on Ask HN: Is all of FAANG like this?
Getting special bonuses is more about being part of an inner circle than being a "top performer" or inventing critical algorithms for s3. Yes, the people truly behind a lot of the important stuff are standard engineers making within band compensation (possibly out of band only due to stock appreciation).
amznthrowaway5··on Ask HN: Is all of FAANG like this?
I've seen bonuses like this at Amazon. You forgot the detail where some clown who has been taking credit with no technical understanding of the project gets the bonus while the people who delivered the actual value are ignored.
amznthrowaway5··on Design Docs at Google
The perception m0zg outlined still seems correct. The system encourages deceptive reporting of metrics. If you can take credit for improving things with metrics, while causing far more damage in the process or making no real contributions, you will still get promoted.
← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →