408 karma · joined December 12, 2010
[ my public key: https://keybase.io/anacrolix; my proof: https://keybase.io/anacrolix/sigs/kUK6TgSm1j2aqELh40B8-WDAv4EeekY8_Us1cbSkS_U ]
I'm simplifying: Stallman told us that free software was the only way. ESR said open source was the way with business in mind.
We've ended up with businesses taking advantage of open source. The slew of licence changes to not compete, having special paid versions, and generally shitting on the open source community.
The only thing free, is the labour companies are exploiting.
If this is actually a common use case, I can resurrect it into a usable form for the public if there's interest or funding. https://github.com/anacrolix/torrent
However there is a built-in hole punching mechanism in BitTorrent where peers ask for a third peer to assist in hole punching.
It's implemented in my client. It was very painful to implement. I think someone privately funded the feature which was very nice.
Not much support for port forwarding.
IPv6 definitely works.
Download order is handled by providing readers directly into torrent data and using that for prioritization. So basically request what you need when you need it. No arbitrary list of algorithms.
I don't do much port forwarding, it's too fiddly. I think I provide upnp out of the box and few other variants that were contributed.
I also have all the DHT extensions, like mutable torrents and get/put etc.
Large torrents do pop up occasionally, but it's been a long time since someone found a performance issue there but it used to happen every few months. Lots of optimisation.
GitHub.com/anacrolix/torrent
My algorithm did favour the best peers (both upload and download) but a few years ago switched to a "seeded" ordering to prevent bad behaviour clients dumping or starving new peers.
The garbage uploaders are not an issue. You can isolate peers to pieces and remove them with certainty, or use a technique called smartban which uncovers bad peers very quickly.